This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
Allison , Venables , Coppell , Pulis , Allardyce ~
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
Croydonlad sydenham 24 Apr 17 1.02am |
|
|
Yep , early days but for me Big Sam is up there with the best Palace bosses of the past 40 odd years Yes Pulis is in there , because yes Pulis was great for us and would have been going forward Sam is a tactical no nonsense genius , I hope we have him for many years
|
timbob 24 Apr 17 4.39am |
|
|
Sure is n we need a few songs for him too !!
Coyp
R.I.P dear Staffie
|
sa_eagle Just outside Cape Town 24 Apr 17 6.45am |
|
|
I was really anti Allardyce, I didn't want him and thought he was wrong for us.
I was wrong and I've stopped calling him Fat Sam, he's most definitely Big Sam and has my respect now.
He's a class above Pardew or Pulis!
Cynic or realist? It's a fine line!
|
Eewires Guildford 24 Apr 17 7.35am |
|
|
Malcolm Allison was larger than life & great fun, but his league record was poor. 2 relegations and couldn't get us out of the old 3rd division. Bert Head has more right to be in that list than Allison.
Agree about the others though.
|
johnmcormick8 Brundish 24 Apr 17 7.46am |
|
|
Dam right Bert Head was a manager, I know there is a lot love Allison, but to me he has more in common with Pardew. Originally posted by Eewires
Malcolm Allison was larger than life & great fun, but his league record was poor. 2 relegations and couldn't get us out of the old 3rd division. Bert Head has more right to be in that list than Allison.
Agree about the others though.
|
MKCPFC Spain/MK 24 Apr 17 9.16am |
|
Originally posted by sa_eagle
I was really anti Allardyce, I didn't want him and thought he was wrong for us.
I was wrong and I've stopped calling him Fat Sam, he's most definitely Big Sam and has my respect now.
He's a class above Pardew or Pulis!
Well done fella, there are quite a few more who should be as honest as you and give genuine respect to Big Sam now.
|
pssguy 24 Apr 17 4.42pm |
|
Originally posted by Croydonlad
Yep , early days but for me Big Sam is up there with the best Palace bosses of the past 40 odd years Yes Pulis is in there , because yes Pulis was great for us and would have been going forward Sam is a tactical no nonsense genius , I hope we have him for many years
Allison! He took us down 2 divisions. Probably worst
|
Ray in Houston Houston 24 Apr 17 4.45pm |
|
Originally posted by johnmcormick8
Dam right Bert Head was a manager, I know there is a lot love Allison, but to me he has more in common with Pardew.
Allison used to bang the birds Pardew only dreamed about.
We don't do possession; we do defense and attack. Everything else is just wa**ing with a football.
|
kenbarr Jackson Heights, Queens, New York ... 25 Apr 17 6.08am |
|
|
Coppell is still the best post-WWII Palace manager. Big Sam is showing great promise based on the turn-around he has led but would have to manage a few more years here and build on what has happened, making us a top of the table premier league side to surpass Sir Steve's status.
Edited by kenbarr (25 Apr 2017 6.09am)
Divorced...And LOVING it! VJRAM Rev. CPFC since Boxing Day 1989 CPFC 2-2 CFC Gregg Berhalter, US International & USMNT Head Coach Jill Ellis, England International & Retired USWNT Head Coach Trevor Francis, International PRAT
|
Croydonlad sydenham 25 Apr 17 6.38am |
|
|
Some weird answers here re Allison
Either that or peoples memory isnt that great
|
Holmesdale 1989 25 Apr 17 8.57am |
|
|
Pardew was 10 minutes at Wembley away from being on that list, loooool
|
jamiemartin721 Reading 25 Apr 17 1.12pm |
|
|
All fairness to Pulis, he and Allardyce are two of the longest serving and most tactically astute managers you will find in the game.
They achieve year in, year out, with much smaller clubs and much less spending than say the so called 'best managers' - and have never really been given the chance to 'do their thing at the top level' - despite having incredible records.
Its similar to what impressed me about Freedman at Palace, he achieved well above expectations with next to nothing in resources (and I think if he'd stayed we'd have won the Championship).
For all the praise that Eddie Howe gets, its important to remember that these two English managers have been there and done that and continue to achieve impressive finishes with 'relegation fodder'.
Pochettino is also exceptionally talented.
"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug" [Link]
|
jamiemartin721 Reading 25 Apr 17 1.15pm |
|
Originally posted by kenbarr
Coppell is still the best post-WWII Palace manager. Big Sam is showing great promise based on the turn-around he has led but would have to manage a few more years here and build on what has happened, making us a top of the table premier league side to surpass Sir Steve's status.
Edited by kenbarr (25 Apr 2017 6.09am)
Had Pardew won the FA cup and not been in charge at the start of the season, he'd probably have eclipsed Sir Steve. Its easy to forget how much of an impressive impact Pardew had, and if he'd have had that over one season, rather than two, he might well have had us in Europe.
staggering to think about. I think that Sir Steve gets to keep the crown against all comers though for the number of times he's 'been there' for the Palace.
"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug" [Link]
|
Croydonlad sydenham 25 Apr 17 7.41pm |
|
|
No , even then he still wouldnt have made this list
|
Croydonlad sydenham 25 Apr 17 7.47pm |
|
|
Thanks for the replies
Coppell probably wins it as he was consistent and all there But for me the football that Venables brought in the late 70's and 80 was beautiful Allison , yeah not great statistically , but he is responsible even TODAY for the re branding of Palace and raising the profile of the club to a different level He changed our name from the Glaziers to the Eagles And got in kit designers that were before their time And did completely master Leeds , Sunderland and Chelsea AWAY , when they were all doing magnificently
|
crystal-purley Purley 25 Apr 17 8.11pm |
|
|
ison did for the club as opposed to the team cannot be ignored and he also signed Venables and Graham who then took Allison's structure and made the club what it is today. For those reasons alone AND the team of the 80's which big Mal set up he deserves to be in there. Sir Steve yes agreed although some of the football not so. Pullis yes he kept us up and Colin the following season showed how good Pullis was. Pardew took an almost relegated side and didn't just keep them up but top half too and if not for Mark would have won the cup. Sadly his ego almost keeps him out of the best ever. Doog is not mentioned so far? Saved us from the third and then built a decent side/squad that got us promoted the next season. And now the joker. Dowie took us from nowhere to promotion just by getting the players a bit fitter and turning AJ into the gem he became but then brought in a lot of dross which got us relegated the next season.
Enjoying getting up later and not having someone who knows better than me (apart from the missus of course).
|
Croydonlad sydenham 25 Apr 17 9.19pm |
|
|
Good points made above but Freedman and Dowie dont belong in this company Dowie did do unreal things though considering how average the squad was apart from Johnson
|
pssguy 25 Apr 17 9.59pm |
|
Originally posted by Croydonlad
Allison , yeah not great statistically did completely master Leeds , Sunderland and Chelsea AWAY , when they were all doing magnificently
Well Sunderland and Chelsea were 2nd Div teams. That win at Leeds though was as dominant a giant killing as I've seen
|
Painter Croydon 26 Apr 17 12.50pm |
|
Originally posted by Croydonlad
Thanks for the replies
Coppell probably wins it as he was consistent and all there But for me the football that Venables brought in the late 70's and 80 was beautiful Allison , yeah not great statistically , but he is responsible even TODAY for the re branding of Palace and raising the profile of the club to a different level He changed our name from the Glaziers to the Eagles And got in kit designers that were before their time And did completely master Leeds , Sunderland and Chelsea AWAY , when they were all doing magnificently
Your view on Allison is strange? You think he is great because he changed our name and kit, whilst getting us relegated twice. Even Mullery didn't manage that.
|
Glazier#1 26 Apr 17 1.03pm |
|
|
I has to be said that Allison's double bagging of Venables and Ian Evans from QPR was one hell of a coup as far as the future of Palace went. What foresight! So, although the stats provide one reading of'Big Mal', the profile and investment in the club's future means that, for me, he has to be in the mix, even though not the best of the lot.
Sir Steve and Bert Head are the ones, for sure.
|