You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Best Palace Centre Half Over Last 40 Odd Years
November 16 2026 9.36am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Best Palace Centre Half Over Last 40 Odd Years


Page 3 of 3 << First< 1 2 3
palace chick Flag South Croydon 28 Apr 17 10.10pm

Sakho would hold his own / would be class in any of the top sides throughout Europe - don't think we have ever had a centra half that could do that? From his short time here and I've supported Palace since 68, he is the best I've seen for us.

 

Harry Beever Flag Newbury 28 Apr 17 10.13pm

Originally posted by SurreyEagle16

I know he only played a handful of games (similar to Sakho I think)...but Matthew Upson on loan in the early 2000's was quality. I think he was coming back from injury and Arsenal wanted to get him game time...I remember him being immense in the few games he played.

Nod to Herman the German from our 98 prem season as well.

Do you mean Hreidarsson from Iceland? Always had a soft spot for him but apparently he was relegated from the premiership with a record 5 different clubs.

 

Wisbech Eagle Flag Truro Cornwall 28 Apr 17 10.48pm

I have seen just about every player mentioned in this thread and saw Jimmy Cannon play many times. None of them though come close to Sakho in my opinion. He is a class above. He seems to be able to see things earlier and make the interventions just that little bit more effectively. Truly world class and a joy to watch, which is unusual for a defender. He is also a natural leader who organises and encourages. On top of that he appears to be a genuinely nice man. I don't know how many of you saw the way he treated the little lad who was the "mascot" he was leading out on Wednesday but he was lovely with him. Chatting away, explaining things, guiding him and general making sure he had a great experience. If we can get him, and it is of course a big "if", then he would be a wonderful addition to the squad. I think he really appreciates the reception and appreciation he has been shown. I think he feels at home and that matters.

 


For the avoidance of doubt any comments in response to a previous post are directed to its ideas and not at any, or all, posters personally.

monkey Flag Sittingbourne,but made in Bromley 28 Apr 17 10.51pm

Originally posted by Warlingham Boy

Has to be Billy Gilbert for me.

This fella knows what he's talking about!!!

 

hastingseagle67 Flag 28 Apr 17 10.54pm

Probably wouldn't make many peoples top defender list cos he didn't play that many games for us, but Steve wicks was the best I've seen in a Palace shirt.

 


has resisted writing a single post on the Ross McCormack thread !!!

Glazier#1 Flag 29 Apr 17 7.09am

Originally posted by Wisbech Eagle

World class. You said it. It's a pleasure to watch him for all the qualities you have noted, Wis.

For pure class, although in a different position, only Lombardo comes close in my opinion and even then, not that close.

I have seen just about every player mentioned in this thread and saw Jimmy Cannon play many times. None of them though come close to Sakho in my opinion. He is a class above. He seems to be able to see things earlier and make the interventions just that little bit more effectively. Truly world class and a joy to watch, which is unusual for a defender. He is also a natural leader who organises and encourages. On top of that he appears to be a genuinely nice man. I don't know how many of you saw the way he treated the little lad who was the "mascot" he was leading out on Wednesday but he was lovely with him. Chatting away, explaining things, guiding him and general making sure he had a great experience. If we can get him, and it is of course a big "if", then he would be a wonderful addition to the squad. I think he really appreciates the reception and appreciation he has been shown. I think he feels at home and that matters.

Edited by Glazier#1 (29 Apr 2017 7.09am)

 

Hampsterite Flag Godalming 29 Apr 17 7.36am

Always remember, in the few games he played for us, Paul Warhorse being a class player. Although I can't remember if he played CB.

 


Nigeeeeeeeeeeel, bloody legend!

Hampsterite Flag Godalming 29 Apr 17 7.37am

Originally posted by Hampsterite

Always remember, in the few games he played for us, Paul Warhorse being a class player. Although I can't remember if he played CB.

Sorry Paul Warhorse

 


Nigeeeeeeeeeeel, bloody legend!

Hampsterite Flag Godalming 29 Apr 17 7.38am

Originally posted by Hampsterite

Sorry Paul Warhorse

Spell check !!!

 


Nigeeeeeeeeeeel, bloody legend!

Croydonlad Flag sydenham 30 Apr 17 4.16am

Originally posted by palace chick

Sakho would hold his own / would be class in any of the top sides throughout Europe - don't think we have ever had a centra half that could do that? From his short time here and I've supported Palace since 68, he is the best I've seen for us.

100 % agree , and Ive watched since '67

 

johnmcormick8 Flag Brundish 30 Apr 17 6.32am

its a thread, game of opinions. My most vivid memory of Gerry was from a night match against Blackpool. One of their defenders had fouled Gerry after a run down the wing. Gerry got up decked the chap with solid punch. I think the ref gave a free kick but that was all.

Originally posted by GerryQueen10

Yep a great time when all the defenders were called John! Loved his goal when we beat Sheffield united 5-1.
Have to pick Jim Cannon just ahead of him though.

 

General Flag 30 Apr 17 1.15pm

Gonzalo Sorondo was pretty classy.
Gareth Southgate palace lad and my dad said he'd play for England.. I laughed .. I was wrong!
Craig Moore again wow so cool on ball.

But damn Sakho takes the biscuit with flicks back heels and chests back to the GK in 85th minute I love it.

 

dougster Flag 30 Apr 17 8.12pm

Craig Moore was quality.

I think Fan Zhiyi is definitely up there as one of my personal favourites. He was class and massively under rated.

But no one gets close to Mama Sakho.

Dean Austin anyone?

 

Page 3 of 3 << First< 1 2 3

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Best Palace Centre Half Over Last 40 Odd Years