You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Youth movement PL myth?
November 16 2026 9.24am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Youth movement PL myth?


nairb75 Flag Baltimore 27 Jun 17 1.19pm

southampton, maybe? what other club successfully brings kids multiple kids through their academy? isn't it all about recruitment at this point?

average manager gets 12-18 months. they can't play kids.

 

chateauferret Flag 27 Jun 17 1.23pm

United? Their younger players looked pretty decent the other week and look at Rashford. Made his England colleagues look even more like donkeys in the last few minutes against Iceland.

Edited by chateauferret (27 Jun 2017 1.24pm)

 


============
The Ferret
============

nairb75 Flag Baltimore 27 Jun 17 1.43pm

i do like rashford and the iceland game is a good example.

however, if manu has only one good player to show for all of their money spent, etc, it's not exactly a high percentage of success. it'd probably be cheaper to just buy mbappe.

 

Dan89 Flag Se25 27 Jun 17 1.56pm

Originally posted by nairb75

southampton, maybe? what other club successfully brings kids multiple kids through their academy? isn't it all about recruitment at this point?

average manager gets 12-18 months. they can't play kids.

Everton, Tottenham

 


Another Damien Diagonal - Total Football

PaddyMcPaddy Flag 27 Jun 17 2.08pm

Originally posted by chateauferret

United? Their younger players looked pretty decent the other week and look at Rashford. Made his England colleagues look even more like donkeys in the last few minutes against Iceland.

Edited by chateauferret (27 Jun 2017 1.24pm)

The Rashford one is a slight myth. He wasn't introduced to the team on purpose. He got a call up to the bench due to injuries then in the warm up the young reserve due to play in front of him got injured so they were forced to play Rashford. He took his chance and hasn't looked back. He wasn't pulling up trees in the youth and the likelihood is had he not had that luck he would be nowhere near the first team and probably at Wigan.

 

PaddyMcPaddy Flag 27 Jun 17 2.10pm

Originally posted by Dan89

Everton, Tottenham

Everton is a great example. They have purchased a number of their youngsters but still give them the opportunity to play.

 

Lyons550 Flag Shirley 27 Jun 17 2.13pm

Originally posted by nairb75

southampton, maybe? what other club successfully brings kids multiple kids through their academy? isn't it all about recruitment at this point?

average manager gets 12-18 months. they can't play kids.

Everton have started to

 


The Voice of Reason In An Otherwise Mediocre World

Midlands Eagle Flag 27 Jun 17 2.14pm

Originally posted by nairb75

i do like rashford and the iceland game is a good example.

however, if manu has only one good player to show for all of their money spent, etc, it's not exactly a high percentage of success. it'd probably be cheaper to just buy mbappe.

Jesse Lingard?

Spurs are claiming that if anyone wants to buy Harry Kane his price is £100m. That wouldn't be a bad return on their youth product

 

Bexley Eagle Flag Bexley Kent 27 Jun 17 3.05pm

Most fans would love for us to have a conveyor belt of young exciting talent coming up from the youth set up. In reality the initial post sums it up. Unless the youngster is outstanding at youth level they will not get their chance as the risk is too great.

I have watched a fair bit of the u21 games over the last few seasons and hand on heart there isn't any players that are anywhere near the first team. I am happy to be proved wrong and I hope FDB can turn this around so we can have one or two players making it through the grades to the first team - as has been the case in the past.

 

GladAllOver27 Flag 28 Jun 17 3.41pm

Originally posted by nairb75

southampton, maybe? what other club successfully brings kids multiple kids through their academy? isn't it all about recruitment at this point?

average manager gets 12-18 months. they can't play kids.

While I agree, we have to produce a route to the first team.

 

nairb75 Flag Baltimore 28 Jun 17 6.23pm

Originally posted by GladAllOver27

While I agree, we have to produce a route to the first team.

i agree but but it's rare in the PL at this point. and i'd say none use the academy as the primary way to build their 1st team.

 

GladAllOver27 Flag 28 Jun 17 6.38pm

Originally posted by nairb75

i agree but but it's rare in the PL at this point. and i'd say none use the academy as the primary way to build their 1st team.

It's about substainabilty. We not a club that can spend 30m on a single player each year. We need to produce academy products, that can be used to save that money for a position or to sell the academy product to improve squad. Although Southampton lose a lot of their players, their general outlay in transfers is like 20m at most, with all the funds recouped.

 

spartakev2 Flag Anerley 28 Jun 17 6.58pm

Isn't one of the good things about frank being manager, tgat he should be able to attract more good youth players to the academy.

 

DutchEagleJohan Flag Vlissingen, Netherlands 28 Jun 17 8.15pm

I refuse to believe that any decent youth set up would be unable to produce players of the level Ward, Kelly, Tompkins let alone Campbell are on. It is not just quality, there is very much a general lack of guts in the game to go with unproven players. And yes, v Gaal proved it at Man U, Koeman at Everton, that is something Dutch coaches will perhaps be a bit more "daring".

Originally posted by Bexley Eagle

Most fans would love for us to have a conveyor belt of young exciting talent coming up from the youth set up. In reality the initial post sums it up. Unless the youngster is outstanding at youth level they will not get their chance as the risk is too great.

I have watched a fair bit of the u21 games over the last few seasons and hand on heart there isn't any players that are anywhere near the first team. I am happy to be proved wrong and I hope FDB can turn this around so we can have one or two players making it through the grades to the first team - as has been the case in the past.


 

Mwncisee Flag Middlesbrough 29 Jun 17 5.02pm

Not just us at Palace who see this issue: [Link]

Interesting to see who gave the most time to youngsters...Sunderland and look what happened to them, yet Southampton, Everton, Man U and Spurs make up the rest of the top 5.

 


You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Youth movement PL myth?