You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Dear Frank.....
November 16 2026 9.11am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Dear Frank.....


Page 2 of 2 << First< 1 2
Mr_Gristle Flag In the land of Whelk Eaters 12 Aug 17 7.22pm

Having watched that first half horror show (we looked better second half)......

Ward has to be dropped from the first XI, despite his one brilliant goal saving tackle. Everything else he did was not good enough for this league.

Punch was Punch - one footed, willing, used the ball quite well, quite neat & tidy, woeful with a dead ball. Again, his contribution isn't good enough for this league.

RLC playing in the heart of midfield second half was the best player on the pitch. TFM didn't have a bad game and I still don't know how he caught their guy up for that goal saving tackle in the second half.

Huddersfield were organised, mistake-free and Mounie looked razor-sharp all game. Ref let them get away with murder in the first half, though.

You can blame the system if you want, but individual mistakes lost this game - how many times do we find ourselves saying that?

 


Well I think Simon's head is large; always involved in espionage. (Name that tune)

cpfc1976 Flag Reading 12 Aug 17 7.31pm

In his interview FdB thought we deserved at least a point, frightening, we got what we deserved absolutely nothing. He said he thought we dominated after that 15 minute spell where they scored two and could have had two more. Surely he realises that at 2-0 up they sat back and waited to pick us off on the break. Which they managed very well in scoring a third.

Edited by cpfc1976 (12 Aug 2017 7.32pm)

Edited by cpfc1976 (12 Aug 2017 7.32pm)

 

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 12 Aug 17 7.32pm

Yes mistakes cost games but Ward was targeted because he's not a RWB. Never will be. That contributed to his mistakes. We shouldn't be playing it with players who can't. Ward and Hennessey the stand outs.

Oh and 3-4-3 nearly had us 1-0 down after a few minutes when they played the ball at left back because they were instructed nobody would be there. They should've scored from 10 yards out. We were lucky.

There is currently issues with the system. It cannot be denied. Whether those issues or the system is changed we'll see. But something has to.

 


COYP

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 12 Aug 17 7.35pm

Originally posted by cpfc1976

In his interview FdB thought we deserved at least a point, frightening, we got what we deserved absolutely nothing. He said he thought we dominated after that 15 minute spell where they scored two and could have had two more. Surely he realises that at 2-0 up they sat back and waited to pick us off on the break. Which they managed very well in scoring a third.

Edited by cpfc1976 (12 Aug 2017 7.32pm)

Edited by cpfc1976 (12 Aug 2017 7.32pm)

He has it the wrong way round. Up to 15 minutes we were going at them from all angles with about 7 players going at them. After that they stopped our midfielders turning with the ball and stopped PVA going wide. He went inside every time and it caused real problems. Ward was an obvious target we all predicted.

 


COYP

Uphill Flag Bedford 12 Aug 17 7.39pm

You began to lose me when you announced Puncheon as the captain.
We need creativity in the middle so we can score more goals than we let in.
At this rate we will need to score 4 goals a game to win any points.

 

Part Time James Flag 12 Aug 17 7.41pm

Originally posted by europalace

If you listen to FdBs after match interview, he mentions we created the chances but didn't finish them. HT finished theirs. On another day it will be the other way around as we see in many matches we have played in the PL.

As I commented in the 'embarrassing' thread, the only thing embarrassing today were the so called 'supporters' today booing the new manager after one game. That is appalling and unacceptable, just like spoiled children who want everything without working for anything and expecting instant gratification.

Yeah to be fair I didn't do that. I've reserved my anger for this forum which hopefully isn't as damaging!

I don't need Palace to win or dominate all the time but I do feel concerned that this experiment might back fire. If we had signed a right wing back and maybe a stronger CB but still lost 3-0 I'd be a lot more tolerant. I just think it's a bit short sighted to force the players into a formation that doesn't match their strengths.

 




Part Time James Flag 12 Aug 17 7.44pm

I should add another positive. Restricted view tickets meant I only saw Palace play like sh*te for about 80% of the game!

I'm being jovial, don't gun me down!

 




Dangermouse Flag Hastings 12 Aug 17 8.09pm

Originally posted by europalace

If you listen to FdBs after match interview, he mentions we created the chances but didn't finish them. HT finished theirs. On another day it will be the other way around as we see in many matches we have played in the PL.

As I commented in the 'embarrassing' thread, the only thing embarrassing today were the so called 'supporters' today booing the new manager after one game. That is appalling and unacceptable, just like spoiled children who want everything without working for anything and expecting instant gratification.

Have to agree. Many bleat on how the HF get a mention all the time and bitch that there are other fans you know? Yes the type that turn on new players and managers 35 minutes into their first game. Give up chanting at the first sign of trouble and then bang on about our wonderful atmosphere when we're winning. At least the HF keep singing and jumping all game long.
Yes lots of mistakes were made today and I'm also baffled by some of FdB's decision, but this was our fifth game playing this system against a team that has played a passing game for the past two seasons. It was a game I was really uncomfortable with to be fair because of that reason. Still we go again next week.

Edited by Dangermouse (12 Aug 2017 8.10pm)

 


That's Life
And as funny as it may seem
Some people get their kicks stompin' on a Dream.
KEEP THE FAITH!!!!!

ChewyB Flag Cuxton, Kent 12 Aug 17 8.34pm

Huddersfield wont have another easy game like that all season. I was worried 3 at the back would see us get hammered, due to the calibre of players we have. We cant play like that! We simply cant. Its all about getting points on the board, and a la last season, failed in our "easier" game. Look a little bit of me thinks that we needed this defeat in a strange way. DeBoer now knows this league is ruthless. He also now knows that 3 at the back, with Dann in the middle is bot the way forward. Mensah and Reidwalierd (spelling) did well to keep looking after Dann in my opinion. If we ever did sign Sakho, i dont think even he could play 3. I believe we need a 4 or 5 and if we did we would have a solid looking defense.
For as much as i like Ward, and he should be respected more in my opinion, RW or RWB he is not good enough to operate there. Althoygh maybe forced as i see that Townesend looks like he is off to Leicester.
Puncheon for me needs to go top left, L-C coming in behind in the middle. He looked completly lost out there and didnt look like a capatain marvel we needed when we went 0-1.
Oh and we could have ANYONE in goal today and still would have lost setting up like that.
Come on Mr DeBoer over to you know...

 


Nuff Said...

Bangell Flag Oxford 12 Aug 17 8.39pm

Originally posted by europalace

If you listen to FdBs after match interview, he mentions we created the chances but didn't finish them. HT finished theirs. On another day it will be the other way around as we see in many matches we have played in the PL.

As I commented in the 'embarrassing' thread, the only thing embarrassing today were the so called 'supporters' today booing the new manager after one game. That is appalling and unacceptable, just like spoiled children who want everything without working for anything and expecting instant gratification.

Yes, booing at this stage is ridiculous.

 

hntreagle Flag Croydon 12 Aug 17 8.41pm

Originally posted by chateauferret

Fosu-Mensah and Tomkins definitely better than Ward and Riedewald. At the end of the season last term we had no defence to speak of between Sakho getting injured and Tomkins coming back.

Hennesey
Fosu-Mensah Tomkins Dann van Aanholt
Cabaye Milivojevic Loftus-Cheek
Zaha Townsend
Benteke

What's so hard about that? Why must we keep dabbling in systems that don't suit our players?

FFS.

you think tomkins is better than riedewald? did you watch the same game?

 

Dan89 Flag Se25 12 Aug 17 8.43pm

Dear Deidre (I meant frank)

This formation doesn't work. Try something else. Otherwise you be replaced by mr woy hodgson in Nov.

Thanks
Dan89

 


Another Damien Diagonal - Total Football

azureus Flag sevenoaks 12 Aug 17 9.05pm

Originally posted by europalace

Lots of kiddies posting on here who want instant gratification without supporting a team that is in the process of applying a new way of playing. Maybe I used a wrong word there, 'support'. Booing a manager after one game tells much about the poor quality of support that the club has unfortunately attracted in recent times, many attempting to freeload only when success has been achieved.

Edited by europalace (12 Aug 2017 6.15pm)

As bad as it was to watch at times ,you are spot on

 

merganser Flag 12 Aug 17 9.23pm

Perhaps it was unwise of Frank to signpost his tactical approach so publicly in advance of the season.

H'field knew exactly how we would play and adapted accordingly.

By contrast, no one knew what tactics H'field would adopt. I doubt if anyone had done much research.

 

Mapletree Flag Croydon 12 Aug 17 9.27pm

All we need is Sakho and a right wing back.

Ideally also a striker and a goalie.

Most of the players are good enough to play the system.

Very impressed with Fosu Mensah and with Loftus Cheek.

I have been thinking all along we are biding our time to buy Sakho for a £5m discount. I do wonder if we should just bite the bullet now though.

Similarly with Callum Chambers. Those two would make all the difference. Used to be our left side was weak, now it's the right

 

chateauferret Flag 12 Aug 17 9.37pm

Originally posted by hntreagle

you think tomkins is better than riedewald? did you watch the same game?

Yes. Were you watching Tomkins in the last few games of last season? Riedewald might be better with fewer headless chickens around him but he couldn't settle the defenders down and Tomkins isn't Sakho but he has more of that gravitas.

If you have a wee look at the player ratings thread you'll see that I'm not the only one who thought Riedewald was poor today

Edited by chateauferret (12 Aug 2017 9.42pm)

 


============
The Ferret
============

EaglesEaglesEagles Flag 12 Aug 17 9.48pm

Agree that Puncheon and Ward aren't up to scratch in this team. Ward especially; He rode his luck last season.

You could actually see a lot of the weaknesses in this new formation in the pre-season friendly against Schalke. There were a lot of spaces down the flanks in which the opposition could launch attacks even though we looked ok in that game.

The positives were RLC and TFM. If only we had such quality permanently!
But more than half the teams in this league are better passers than us. I'd certainly put Huddersfield above us after today's display.

To concede three and only have one outstanding chance saved against a promoted team is dire.


 


I ain't got nuthin' funny to say. Sorry.

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 12 Aug 17 9.55pm

Dear Frank,

Put our safety and future before yourself or you can add England to the Italian failure at Inter. We won't stand for it if it goes on for long enough to know it's not going to work.

Good luck. Plenty of time. Just don't be stubborn.

 


COYP

Page 2 of 2 << First< 1 2

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Dear Frank.....