You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Player ratings:
November 16 2026 9.11am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Player ratings:


Page 3 of 3 << First< 1 2 3
chateauferret Flag 13 Aug 17 1.14am

Originally posted by Dan89

Probably Because you never been. I see you at anfield then. Oh forget your an armchair fan.

Thinking someone isn't a "proper fan" because circumstances force him to live hundreds or thousands of miles away and never be able physically to get to matches is pretty downright stupid. We have fans all over the world and seeing a performance like that pi**es them off whether they're in the Holmesdale or on the other side of the world. Equally, when Puncheon scored in the FA Cup Final I jumped as high in the air as any of you that were in the stadium.

 


============
The Ferret
============

chateauferret Flag 13 Aug 17 1.16am

Originally posted by Bangell

Wow, those highlights make Dann, Riedewald and Ward look a little pathetic.

De Boer says afterwards that we didn't play well enough 'technical-wise, to do the things that we spoke about.' I think he might soon realise that whatever he tells the defenders to do regarding passing out from the back, they just can't.

I thought he should learn how to park the bus before he throws his players under the damn thing.

 


============
The Ferret
============

Dan1994 Flag Wallington 13 Aug 17 1.20am

Before this gets personal, a holistic, detailed(-ish) rating of the team.

First XI

Hennessey - 5
We definitely an upgrade, but no goals were his fault, and I think he's been unfairly treated in others' ratings. He flapped a bit and didn't look calm when being passed back to; not what we need for a 3-43

Riedewald - 3
Very disappointing for me, didn't make any tackles or interceptions of note. Backed off a lot of challenges and headers, two of which lead to goals. He lost possession a lot, but he had piss all to pass to in front of him.

Dann - 4
Crap, but made a couple of interceptions/tackles. he gave away possession a lot, but, again, had no one to pass to bar lumping up top.

Fosu-Mensah - 6
One of two, maybe 3, players who weren't s*** in my opinion. I thought he made a very good account of himself, and showed a lot more tactical awareness than Dann, who's almost a decade his senior. This lad will be the tits one day, and it showed today. Also, credit for that excellent tackle when Mounie(?) burst through our defence after a Scott Dann cock-up.

Ward - 2
Worst player on the pitch for me. I absolutely love this guy (and it hurts to say it), but it's time we upgrade on him; the warning signs were there last season. He doesn't have the pace or positioning to be a RWB; he also lost possession a lot through poor crossing. Credit for the great tackle when a Huddersfield player got through, though; shows his commitment and why I love the guy.

van Aanholt - 4
Was pretty anonymous throughout the whole game, so don't really have much else to say. I suppose one positive is that I don't remember Huddersfield exploiting that flank a lot. Marked down for the atrocious set pieces - honestly, why the f*** was he taking them...?

Puncheon - 2
Not the worst player on the pitch, because Ward was so terrible. I've said we've needed an upgrade since the beginning of last season. Love the guy to bits, and I do not doubt his captaincy credentials, but he does not have the technical ability anymore for the 1st XI. Lost possession so much and gave zero options for the back 3 to pass to. Admittedly, this is not his position, as he is an attacking midfielder; he never has, or will be, a deep lying playmaker.

Milivojevic - 3
Didn't get stuck in like his normally does, gave away the ball so much and just lumped it up a lot. I don't think de Boer is playing him to his strengths, as I believe he's more of a 'I'm the player, get past me', rather than an N'Golo Kante type DM that de Boer wants.

Zaha - 4
He was very selfish at times today, and, given the performance of the whole team, I don't blame him. However, he didn't even try to link up with Benteke, and when the cross was needed, it wasn't going to the right place - he needed to bring his head up a touch to see where the players in the box are.

Loftus-Cheek - 7
For me, he was our best player - he was quick, powerful and on it. He linked up well with everyone, successfully took on the opposition and provided us with options. I have no clue why Chelsea have let him go on a season long loan, because he is quality and will be an England regular one day.

Benteke - 4
He was very, very, very isolated up top. To be fair, he won most of his aerial duels, but there was no one to pick up that second ball, and we were playing into Huddersfield's hands. Arguably could've done better with his opportunities, but going by shot statistics, that would've been a very good conversion. No one linked up, and he ended up dropping very deep at times.

Subs

Townsend - 6
Worked hard, got in and around the Huddersfield players, which we hadn't done all game. I have absolutely no idea why he didn't start the game; he's one of our best players, both technically and work ethic-wise. He did himself proud today.

Tomkins - 5
To me, this was a very bizarre subsitution, and this rang more alarm bells for me than any other point of the game. Why bring on a defender when we're 2-0 down against a team holding back and looking for the counter? To me, that smacks of a lack of a 'plan B option', which was my main concern about de Boer in the first place. Don't really remember anything he did, so it'd be harsh to slate him. I think he's our most technically gifted CB, and I don't know why de Boer didn't start him.

I tried to give a balanced rating for each player, and I think a lot of it is down to confusion of the system. However, it is clear we are a long, long way off making this system work. I think the question is not whether if we can make it work, but rather how long will it take.

Edited by Dan1994 (13 Aug 2017 1.32am)

 


[Link]

Wilbraham413 Flag 13 Aug 17 2.25am

Originally posted by Dan1994

Before this gets personal, a holistic, detailed(-ish) rating of the team.


Ward - 2

Zaha - 4

Agree with 99% of your ratings.

Except, what does Ward have to do to get a "1"? Because we would have been better with 10 men from the start and Ward on the bench.

Zaha a 4? Granted I'm tired of him flopping and crying for calls all the time, but he was the only player on our team who could have scored a goal today. I'd give him a 5 at least, just on talent.

 


2017 Feb. (Van Aanholt) Palace 1 - 0 Middlesboro
2018 Jan. (Sako) Palace 1 - 0 Burnley
2019 May (Batshuayi, Batshuayi, OG, Van Aanholt, Townsend) Palace 5 - 3 Bournemouth
2020 Feb. (Van Aanholt) Palace 1 - 0 Newcastle

BelfastEagle Flag 13 Aug 17 8.23am

Just watched the motd lowlights....What's happened to Dann he's desperate.

 

eddiqc Flag Tunbridge wells 13 Aug 17 11.58am

Originally posted by palace chick
How can you still believe in the team and manager after being shafted by Huddersfield? 0.3 is the worse defeat of the day in the prem. No team shouldn't be prepared for the first match of a new season - unbelievable!

Because I have faith and I know they're still adapting.

 

Dan89 Flag Se25 13 Aug 17 12.17pm

Originally posted by chateauferret

Thinking someone isn't a "proper fan" because circumstances force him to live hundreds or thousands of miles away and never be able physically to get to matches is pretty downright stupid. We have fans all over the world and seeing a performance like that pi**es them off whether they're in the Holmesdale or on the other side of the world. Equally, when Puncheon scored in the FA Cup Final I jumped as high in the air as any of you that were in the stadium.

I responding to fans who criticised me for leaving after Huddersfield scored the 3rd. When he doesn't even go. Simples.

 


Another Damien Diagonal - Total Football

crystal-purley Flag Purley 13 Aug 17 12.18pm

Originally posted by Part Time James

I agree with some of these. I can also now give my opinion given that someone has helped me recognise which of the new players I thought was dogsh*t!

Going:

Hennessey 4
Fosu Mensah 6
Dann 4
Riedewald 3
Ward 4 - didn't he also prevent a certain goal? Did a lot of crap stuff too though and apparently the first goal was his OG!
Milovojevic 5
Puncheon 4
Van Aanholt 4 (marking him down for those corners)
Loftus-Cheek 6
Benteke 4
Zaha 4 (although largely due to the marking on him, but he looked flimsy)

Townsend 6 - he did as some spark to an almost spent bonfire
Tomkins - I couldn't tell you. I didn't really see him do anything except run onto the pitch. I thought it was a pitch invader.

Didn't realise we had a midfield but I saw a lot of what people hate about Punch with his poor passing.
Some of the pass backs to Wayne were below abysmal.
Agree with most of the points but would also add
FdB 3 - He was down to the standard of most of our managers over the years with a lack of reaction and 433 coming halfway through the second half.
Ward I though had a reasonable game but presumably wasn't in class when 343 was being taught (in common with others)

 


Enjoying getting up later and not having someone who knows better than me (apart from the missus of course).

FinchleyEagle Flag 13 Aug 17 1.16pm

Only Loftus-Cheek looked good today. The worst was Riedewald who looked so far off the pace, and Ward who was played out of position.

But the worst was the manager who is trying too much too fast and without the personnel to do it. We're a counter-attacking team that needs two good wingers.

 


You'll be forever in my family's memories and it was an honor and privilege to play and lead in the red and blue
Yours sincerely
Mile Jedinak

hastingseagle67 Flag 13 Aug 17 4.15pm

Originally posted by kevlee

Punch was better than:
1. henesey
2.dann
3. Luka
2. Ward
4. Riedewald
arguably better than
5. benteke
6. PVA

he got involved far more than these and his contribution was overall better.


Thank God, I'm not the only one who thought that Punch was one of our better players on a day where the team performance really wasn't great. He keeps the ball and tries to make the probing passes through to the front men

 


has resisted writing a single post on the Ross McCormack thread !!!

Dan1994 Flag Wallington 13 Aug 17 6.47pm

Originally posted by Wilbraham413

Agree with 99% of your ratings.

Except, what does Ward have to do to get a "1"? Because we would have been better with 10 men from the start and Ward on the bench.

Zaha a 4? Granted I'm tired of him flopping and crying for calls all the time, but he was the only player on our team who could have scored a goal today. I'd give him a 5 at least, just on talent.

I'll give Ward a bit of credit for a very solid recovery challenge at one point.

I thought Wilf was being very selfish yesterday. He got in positions which would've benefitted a pass to another player. Instead, he kept running with the ball.

 


[Link]

Page 3 of 3 << First< 1 2 3

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Player ratings: