You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > what went wrong
November 16 2026 9.11am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

what went wrong


nairb75 Flag Baltimore 14 Aug 17 2.31pm

decided to frustrate myself and rewatch the lowlights.

couple of thoughts:

*dann should have buried his chance. you can't miss that.
*1st goal was disgusting. who was at fault? everyone except WH.
*2nd goal. even more disturbing than the 1st. WH rightly angry. no one marked. just awful.
*breakaway saved by F-M: terrible giveaway. WH would have conceded. no doubt.
*3rd goal: me and 10 random fellows from the street could have defended that better. and i'm not in too good of shape.
* WZ: seemed as the attacking gameplan was to just pass the ball to him and hope he makes something happen. if you're playing possession football, then maybe pass it around and get better looks. or create opps for benteke. no idea what they were trying to accomplish.

watching the goals, WH actually can't be blamed for any of it. maybe he had the best game. i'm not his biggest supporter but i don't see what else he could have done.

 

chateauferret Flag 14 Aug 17 7.10pm

Originally posted by nairb75

decided to frustrate myself and rewatch the lowlights.

couple of thoughts:

*dann should have buried his chance. you can't miss that.

*3rd goal: me and 10 random fellows from the street could have defended that better. and i'm not in too good of shape.

You would have needed ten of them? A couple of drunks plus my cat should have sufficed.

 


============
The Ferret
============

crystal-purley Flag Purley 14 Aug 17 8.47pm

Originally posted by nairb75

decided to frustrate myself and rewatch the lowlights.

couple of thoughts:

*dann should have buried his chance. you can't miss that.
*1st goal was disgusting. who was at fault? everyone except WH.
*2nd goal. even more disturbing than the 1st. WH rightly angry. no one marked. just awful.
*breakaway saved by F-M: terrible giveaway. WH would have conceded. no doubt.
*3rd goal: me and 10 random fellows from the street could have defended that better. and i'm not in too good of shape.
* WZ: seemed as the attacking gameplan was to just pass the ball to him and hope he makes something happen. if you're playing possession football, then maybe pass it around and get better looks. or create opps for benteke. no idea what they were trying to accomplish.

watching the goals, WH actually can't be blamed for any of it. maybe he had the best game. i'm not his biggest supporter but i don't see what else he could have done.


They attacked us (often physically) and didn't let us settle
We played out from the back but then played it back to Wayne giving them a throw in
We looked at times like we did under Pards when we were at our least fit
Half the team didn't seem to know the basics
We had no midfield
The ref allowed us to be kicked off the park
FdB had no idea

 


Enjoying getting up later and not having someone who knows better than me (apart from the missus of course).

JRW2 Flag Dulwich 14 Aug 17 8.47pm

What went wrong?

I'm a simpleton when it comes to football tactics and formations (no, that's not false modesty, it's the truth). But it did strike me that if our players could have passed to each other, we would have fared rather better. Yes, I know Huddersfield were pressing us very hard, but the reason why players are in the Premiership is that even under pressure they can still pass to a team-mate - at least sometimes, and not just from the goalie to an unmarked defender. Is this what all the posters have in mind who say our players aren't skilful enough to play FdB's system? Is that what it comes down to - can't pass?

 

Pigglelet Flag Deepest Darkest Sussex 14 Aug 17 8.54pm

Originally posted by JRW2

What went wrong?

I'm a simpleton when it comes to football tactics and formations (no, that's not false modesty, it's the truth). But it did strike me that if our players could have passed to each other, we would have fared rather better. Yes, I know Huddersfield were pressing us very hard, but the reason why players are in the Premiership is that even under pressure they can still pass to a team-mate - at least sometimes, and not just from the goalie to an unmarked defender. Is this what all the posters have in mind who say our players aren't skilful enough to play FdB's system? Is that what it comes down to - can't pass?

I can't remember watching a Palace team that could pass accurately: it just doesn't seem to be our thing. Maybe the so-called team of the 80s possibly, but perhaps that's my memory playing tricks.

 


"Better to keep your mouth shut and appear stupid than to open it and remove all doubt."
Mark Twain.

MKCPFC Flag Spain/MK 14 Aug 17 8.56pm

Originally posted by chateauferret

You would have needed ten of them? A couple of drunks plus my cat should have sufficed.

Make out your cat is Dutch and Frank may pay you a couple of million for him.

 

Crystal_Clear Flag Belfast 14 Aug 17 9.10pm

I couldn't bring myself to watch the footage from the game, but spoke to dad tonight who went to the pre-season friendly against Schalke.

He said the our play was so slow, and that the new style just exposed those that had poor control, and infact one of those was Benteke but we simply have no other option.

Unless we spend alot of money then this simply won't work.

 

Painter Flag Croydon 14 Aug 17 9.23pm

Originally posted by Crystal_Clear

I couldn't bring myself to watch the footage from the game, but spoke to dad tonight who went to the pre-season friendly against Schalke.

He said the our play was so slow, and that the new style just exposed those that had poor control, and infact one of those was Benteke but we simply have no other option.

Unless we spend alot of money then this simply won't work.

We are spending a lot of money every week on wages to players that cant even control a football under pressure. So spending money doesn't work, we are paying out averagely £50k a week each to players, who cant pass comfortably.
God knows where it went wrong to end up in this situation?

 

You What Flag se25 14 Aug 17 9.42pm

Originally posted by Painter

We are spending a lot of money every week on wages to players that cant even control a football under pressure. So spending money doesn't work, we are paying out averagely £50k a week each to players, who cant pass comfortably.
God knows where it went wrong to end up in this situation?

It's called being in the Premier League, overpaying anyone that plays for you!!!

 

ripleyeagle Flag Ripley Surrey 14 Aug 17 10.18pm

Originally posted by Crystal_Clear

I couldn't bring myself to watch the footage from the game, but spoke to dad tonight who went to the pre-season friendly against Schalke.

He said the our play was so slow, and that the new style just exposed those that had poor control, and infact one of those was Benteke but we simply have no other option.

Unless we spend alot of money then this simply won't work.


Your dad was right,we need to stop kidding ourselves that we have a good squad of players.If we intend to change our style of play to a more possession style we need a complete root and branch change of personnel to achieve it.
This is why any manager who likes to play in that style shies away from coming to us i.e Pelegrino,De Silva and Eddie Howe before them.If we are not prepared to do this we should have appointed Sean Dyce.

 

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 14 Aug 17 10.36pm

Originally posted by ripleyeagle


Your dad was right,we need to stop kidding ourselves that we have a good squad of players.If we intend to change our style of play to a more possession style we need a complete root and branch change of personnel to achieve it.
This is why any manager who likes to play in that style shies away from coming to us i.e Pelegrino,De Silva and Eddie Howe before them.If we are not prepared to do this we should have appointed Sean Dyce.

Parish (wrongly IMO) didn't show much interest in Silva and Pellegrino wanted the Southampton job more. Frank probably did as well. Who wouldn't? Parish quickly announced Frank 24 hours before Southampton officially announced Pellegrino.

My opinion then was both clubs hired the wrong man, only it was Southampton's call, and will damage them less.

Looks as though Frank intended to play 3-4-3 at whichever club, ideally Southampton, but 'This year it's Crystal Palace' is what he said.

Good luck to him. Hopefully it works or he realises it won't and variations of 4-5-1 etc or maybe 3-5-2 will.

Edited by Rudi Hedman (14 Aug 2017 10.37pm)

 


COYP

nairb75 Flag Baltimore 15 Aug 17 1.23pm

Originally posted by JRW2

What went wrong?

I'm a simpleton when it comes to football tactics and formations (no, that's not false modesty, it's the truth). But it did strike me that if our players could have passed to each other, we would have fared rather better. Yes, I know Huddersfield were pressing us very hard, but the reason why players are in the Premiership is that even under pressure they can still pass to a team-mate - at least sometimes, and not just from the goalie to an unmarked defender. Is this what all the posters have in mind who say our players aren't skilful enough to play FdB's system? Is that what it comes down to - can't pass?

they were pressing hard, making the passing difficult. BUT, that doesn't explain the defensive lapses, on set pieces no less. just awful. luka's mistakes.

when they had 2 or 3 defenders pushing on wilf, where was the help? he was on an island. i just don't understand a plan where you have one guy who is supposed to do it all. surely others were available for a pass. surely townsend and some of the others can work through huddersfield's defense.

just awful. if FDB stubbornly clings to this, he's not going to make it to november.

 

Brentmiester_General Flag Front line in the battle against t... 15 Aug 17 2.24pm

Originally posted by nairb75

decided to frustrate myself and rewatch the lowlights.

couple of thoughts:

*dann should have buried his chance. you can't miss that.
*1st goal was disgusting. who was at fault? everyone except WH.
*2nd goal. even more disturbing than the 1st. WH rightly angry. no one marked. just awful.
*breakaway saved by F-M: terrible giveaway. WH would have conceded. no doubt.
*3rd goal: me and 10 random fellows from the street could have defended that better. and i'm not in too good of shape.
* WZ: seemed as the attacking gameplan was to just pass the ball to him and hope he makes something happen. if you're playing possession football, then maybe pass it around and get better looks. or create opps for benteke. no idea what they were trying to accomplish.

watching the goals, WH actually can't be blamed for any of it. maybe he had the best game. i'm not his biggest supporter but i don't see what else he could have done.

No mention of the attacker who missed an even more glaring open goal? Or the the striker who is world renowned for being deadly with his head missing from about 8 yards with the keeper stranded?
You are right though, Dann should have buried that but he is a centre half.

 


"We love you Palace, we f@cking hate Man U, We love you Palace, we hate the brighton too, We love you Palace we play in red 'n' blue, so f@ck you, and you ...

Tommyp151211 Flag 15 Aug 17 2.55pm

Personally, I don't think we played as badly as some are suggesting.

We created some clear cut chances which on another day would have gone in. That's quite encouraging for day one of the new system in The Premier League. I think Wagner was correct in stating that the score was not a true reflection of the game. Ultimately, a couple of defensive errors cost us the game.

I've been impressed with FDB since his arrival. I think he comes across very well in his interviews and he's been very vocal on his admiration for the supporters.

The only major thing I think he's got wrong so far is buying into the 'he's one of our own' philosophy regarding Jason Puncheon and making him captain, presumably thinking that's what the fans want to see. If everyone is fit then he shouldn't be in the team and I suspect he won't be when other players return.

We have signed 6 better players than what he already had since January without selling anyone important and with the promise of a few more to come the team and system will get better in time.

Some of the knee jerk reactions are ridiculous. It's the only way the club is going to progress and the ambition ought to be respected and admired by the fans.

Cheers.
Tommy.

 

nairb75 Flag Baltimore 15 Aug 17 2.56pm

Originally posted by Tommyp151211

Personally, I don't think we played as badly as some are suggesting.

We created some clear cut chances which on another day would have gone in. That's quite encouraging for day one of the new system in The Premier League. I think Wagner was correct in stating that the score was not a true reflection of the game. Ultimately, a couple of defensive errors cost us the game.

I've been impressed with FDB since his arrival. I think he comes across very well in his interviews and he's been very vocal on his admiration for the supporters.

The only major thing I think he's got wrong so far is buying into the 'he's one of our own' philosophy regarding Jason Puncheon and making him captain, presumably thinking that's what the fans want to see. If everyone is fit then he shouldn't be in the team and I suspect he won't be when other players return.

We have signed 6 better players than what he already had since January without selling anyone important and with the promise of a few more to come the team and system will get better in time.

Some of the knee jerk reactions are ridiculous. It's the only way the club is going to progress and the ambition ought to be respected and admired by the fans.

Cheers.
Tommy.

wasn't meant to be an exhaustive list. feel free to add to the discussion.

 

slubglurge Flag welling 15 Aug 17 3.27pm

1st goal. Oldest trick in the book the near post corner, something that Frank being Dutch has never seen in his life. 2nd goal the ball worked far too easily on our right and Riedwalde just stood there and gave Mounie a training ground header. 3rd PVA went missing on our left all the time in the world to pick out Mounie who wasnt closed down quick enough. Dreadful defending for all 3 the remedy? SAKHO

 

jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 15 Aug 17 3.42pm

Originally posted by nairb75

decided to frustrate myself and rewatch the lowlights.

couple of thoughts:

*dann should have buried his chance. you can't miss that.

>> CB on the half volley - Shame it dropped to him of all people. Not really known for his accurate shooting.

Originally posted by nairb75
*1st goal was disgusting. who was at fault? everyone except WH.

Nope Hennessey must be the only keeper I've seen that when the ball is going over him from the byline, doesn't track back across his goal. He should have been moving across the goal to his far post when that ball goes over him.

Originally posted by nairb75
*2nd goal. even more disturbing than the 1st. WH rightly angry. no one marked. just awful.

Pretty much, of course their Keeper saved a very similar one from Benetekkers, but in fairness the defence was s**t.

Originally posted by nairb75
*breakaway saved by F-M: terrible giveaway. WH would have conceded. no doubt.

Scott Dann f**ked up. Magnificent recovery tackle.

Originally posted by nairb75
*3rd goal: me and 10 random fellows from the street could have defended that better. and i'm not in too good of shape.

I think using the term defence in relation to that is generous, I'd expect better from a team of 10 strikers.

Originally posted by nairb75
* WZ: seemed as the attacking gameplan was to just pass the ball to him and hope he makes something happen. if you're playing possession football, then maybe pass it around and get better looks. or create opps for benteke. no idea what they were trying to accomplish.

Clearly getting no protection from the referee, and as soon as Huddersfield realised that, they were constantly fouling him (and as a result he's injured). When he lays the ball off, it seems no one is coming in to the box behind him. But clearly played on with a serious knock if he's out for four weeks.

Originally posted by nairb75
watching the goals, WH actually can't be blamed for any of it. maybe he had the best game. i'm not his biggest supporter but i don't see what else he could have done.

Well except for his constant adherence to trying to always play out from the back putting the defence under pressure, the failure to track across his goal for the 1st one, several spooned goal kicks out into touch, a dropped ball etc.

I don't dislike Hennessey, I just think he isn't good enough to be more than the back up guy.

 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]


You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > what went wrong