This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
|
Originally posted by ThatPetrolRelation
It looks like we had a net spend of £41,500,000 last season (some people seem to think we were break even). On BBC Talksport, SP made it sound like the owners were talking about kicking more money in to make some buys, we just don't have the revenue or budget of the big boys. We are about 8th, net in terms of spend, and we sure aren't 8th in revenue. So no wonder we have to tap the brakes. [Link] We've only really sold Bolasie for big money. And I'm glad we've kept Zaha despite interest. I figure FDB is working with a £20-30M Budget, with anything higher needing new investment from the owners. The only market seems to be for Cabaye and Townsend, and I'd rather lose Cabaye if someone will pay £10M for a player who will be 32 in January, so I'm doubtful. And that's not even touching the ever-increasing wage expectations. Hard to do this mid-table business! Good reply but something I still don't get - surely if FFP is about turnover, then more money from shareholders doesn't help if we are up against the buffers on the turnover side of the equation. Unless we can get a shareholder to sponsor the stadium, academy or ladies team for a fortune maybe!
|
|
|
Originally posted by Russ62a
Good reply but something I still don't get - surely if FFP is about turnover, then more money from shareholders doesn't help if we are up against the buffers on the turnover side of the equation. Unless we can get a shareholder to sponsor the stadium, academy or ladies team for a fortune maybe! They are allowed to put money into the club (I don't get all the actual details, but it requires them writing off the extra cash somehow), otherwise the club can only increase spending by a set amount plus non tv revenue. As such, the increase in tv money people go on about does not make a huge difference in terms of where we sit re the cap. The Guardian, I think it was, had a very good explanation of the whole thing last year.
If you come to a fork in the road, take it. |
|
|
Yeah, basically there is a spending cap per team determined by the share of TV money and prize money. Then on top, teams can also spend their other money (sponsorship, money from games days, shirt sales etc). It's been a while since I looked at numbers, but a few years ago Palace had around £20M in other revenue, and other more established mid-table teams had about £40M (this was Everton, Hammers, Villa and Newcastle --so that tells you something right there.) FPP works on a 3-year average, so if you overspend one year (think January) you need to re-balance the books, or face fines (like Bournemouth), or FIFA penalties. The big difference is around selling and buying a player. When you sell a player --say we sold Townsend for £15M-- you book that total revenue for that year. When you buy a player, you spread the cost over the contact (say 5 years.) So if we then bought John Doe for the same price, we would actually only book a cost of £3M per year over 5 years. So it's the amortized cost over 5 years that would show in the books. So it comes down to accounting, but money from player sales gives you much more flexibility. Anyway, long answer to a short question, but there was a good summary of Palace done at Swiss Ramble last year, which covers the financials well without required an accountant's degree:
|
|
|
Originally posted by Nobbybm
That is not what he actually said and is way out of context. To sum up, he said three incoming in an ideal world if we can financially manage it but some may have to go to make room & make it happen. He also mentioned players "you are not going to be using" inferring that a big part of the outgoing situation is to free up wages - it developed into the wider FFP conversation. If you listen to the whole show & join up the Palace bits it's far more positive than a couple of partial quotes. It's here: [Link] I already that that this morning and put the audio on my podcast account. It isn't positive in my opinion.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Russ62a
Something certainly doesn't add up for me with the FFP arguement being put forward by our club. Been in the "big league" all this time and only spent 8m this window. I know it's about wages too but others seem to be doing it just fine People seem to forget we spend £25m of the summer budget back in January. Back then we made £30m of signings and up to £5m in loan fees.
|
|
|
^^ That's the problem.
|
|
|
Originally posted by ThatPetrolRelation
Yeah, basically there is a spending cap per team determined by the share of TV money and prize money. Then on top, teams can also spend their other money (sponsorship, money from games days, shirt sales etc). It's been a while since I looked at numbers, but a few years ago Palace had around £20M in other revenue, and other more established mid-table teams had about £40M (this was Everton, Hammers, Villa and Newcastle --so that tells you something right there.) FPP works on a 3-year average, so if you overspend one year (think January) you need to re-balance the books, or face fines (like Bournemouth), or FIFA penalties. The big difference is around selling and buying a player. When you sell a player --say we sold Townsend for £15M-- you book that total revenue for that year. When you buy a player, you spread the cost over the contact (say 5 years.) So if we then bought John Doe for the same price, we would actually only book a cost of £3M per year over 5 years. So it's the amortized cost over 5 years that would show in the books. So it comes down to accounting, but money from player sales gives you much more flexibility. Anyway, long answer to a short question, but there was a good summary of Palace done at Swiss Ramble last year, which covers the financials well without required an accountant's degree:
If you come to a fork in the road, take it. |
|
|
Originally posted by ThatPetrolRelation
Yeah, basically there is a spending cap per team determined by the share of TV money and prize money. Then on top, teams can also spend their other money (sponsorship, money from games days, shirt sales etc). It's been a while since I looked at numbers, but a few years ago Palace had around £20M in other revenue, and other more established mid-table teams had about £40M (this was Everton, Hammers, Villa and Newcastle --so that tells you something right there.) FPP works on a 3-year average, so if you overspend one year (think January) you need to re-balance the books, or face fines (like Bournemouth), or FIFA penalties. The big difference is around selling and buying a player. When you sell a player --say we sold Townsend for £15M-- you book that total revenue for that year. When you buy a player, you spread the cost over the contact (say 5 years.) So if we then bought John Doe for the same price, we would actually only book a cost of £3M per year over 5 years. So it's the amortized cost over 5 years that would show in the books. So it comes down to accounting, but money from player sales gives you much more flexibility. Anyway, long answer to a short question, but there was a good summary of Palace done at Swiss Ramble last year, which covers the financials well without required an accountant's degree:
So as a guess We probably have less than 20-25M in cash terms on hand to play with. Plus whaterver we can add with sales ?
School, SN.Juniors, SN High, Selhurst. 1st match 1972 CP 2 N. Utd 1. Thank you, John Jackson and Vince Hilair for brightening our darkest days. I moved to the west country in 1983. Always Proud and 'Glad All Over' to be a Palace Fan. |
|
|
Originally posted by majorkaios
So as a guess We probably have less than 20-25M in cash terms on hand to play with. Plus whaterver we can add with sales ?
Well, we signed that extra arm-logo sponsorship, so that's probably another 2M. And the Manbet logo was also I think 6M or something. I am expecting they Budgeted for 30M, plus player sales. They may have to kick in cash to pay for a player then hope they can get it back quickly by selling players before the window shuts. I think the bigger challenge may be that the teams we are competing with for players have sold players and so have a lot they could spend if they wanted too (probably constrained by the wage bill more than the purchase price). Swans and Burnley both have more than 40M burning a hole in their pockets, and the urgently need to bring in replacements. I'm sure the agents of the players we are closing in on are texting all the teams trying to drum up the best deal. Seagulls and Huddersfield probably have it the worst. Newcastle has Benitez and a big-club reputation (but is still pissed they haven't signed any class players), but the other two will be tapped for immediately going back down, so they would be a player's last choice. (Both overpaid for unknown non-prem players, but it looks like Huddersfield did really well with Mooy and Mounie --which could keep them up) These teams know they revenue is going to go way up, so they can spend lots of cash, they just need to convince players to sign!
|
|
|
Originally posted by ThatPetrolRelation
Well, we signed that extra arm-logo sponsorship, so that's probably another 2M. And the Manbet logo was also I think 6M or something. I am expecting they Budgeted for 30M, plus player sales. They may have to kick in cash to pay for a player then hope they can get it back quickly by selling players before the window shuts. I think the bigger challenge may be that the teams we are competing with for players have sold players and so have a lot they could spend if they wanted too (probably constrained by the wage bill more than the purchase price). Swans and Burnley both have more than 40M burning a hole in their pockets, and the urgently need to bring in replacements. I'm sure the agents of the players we are closing in on are texting all the teams trying to drum up the best deal. Seagulls and Huddersfield probably have it the worst. Newcastle has Benitez and a big-club reputation (but is still pissed they haven't signed any class players), but the other two will be tapped for immediately going back down, so they would be a player's last choice. (Both overpaid for unknown non-prem players, but it looks like Huddersfield did really well with Mooy and Mounie --which could keep them up) These teams know they revenue is going to go way up, so they can spend lots of cash, they just need to convince players to sign! Huddersfield have soentv £35.5m so far. Nor bad for a promoted side. ..
|
|
|
Originally posted by Russ62a
Something certainly doesn't add up for me with the FFP arguement being put forward by our club. Been in the "big league" all this time and only spent 8m this window. I know it's about wages too but others seem to be doing it just fine We spent a lot in the January window whilst others did not.
Bring back Brolin |
|
|
Originally posted by spartakev2
Huddersfield have soentv £35.5m so far. Nor bad for a promoted side. .. Yeah, they will get some £60m+ from being in the Prem, so they have a lot of money to spend. Wage cap for prem teams is something like £75m this year (from TV --they can spend other money as they like), and Huddersfield were probably spending less than £10m in the Championship.
|
|
All images and text on this site are copyright © 1999-2025 The Holmesdale Online, unless otherwise stated.
Web Design by Guntrisoft Ltd.