You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Fantastic to see the old James mcarthur back
November 16 2026 8.50am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Fantastic to see the old James mcarthur back


Dan89 Flag Se25 23 Aug 17 6.55am

I've been critical of mcarthur, and wanted to sell him numerous times throughout the summer but he finally looks like he recovered from the back spasms that hindered him under bid Sam. 2 fantastic strikes yesterday and would love to see him alongside a midfield of RLC and cabaye. I'm sorry but puncheon was poor again. Side note the Ipswich town fans were a real credit, sung throughout the whole match. Positive going into a massive game against Swansea. Coyp

 


Another Damien Diagonal - Total Football

DANGERCLOSE Flag London 23 Aug 17 7.01am

FdB must drop punch

 

Dan89 Flag Se25 23 Aug 17 7.17am

Originally posted by DANGERCLOSE

FdB must drop punch

Very true

 


Another Damien Diagonal - Total Football

collier row eagle Flag romford essex via another galaxy 23 Aug 17 7.35am

Agree, let's stop this he's " one of our own" bulls***

 

Part Time James Flag 23 Aug 17 7.38am

From about ten minutes onwards last night I was raving about how good Jimmy Mac looked and how it was the JMc of old. A great thing to behold and I can only echo what's been said.

I also thought he was trying to help Lokilo get some confidence after we wentba goal up, giving him the ball a couple of times when he could've gone on himself. No complaints.

 




Dan89 Flag Se25 23 Aug 17 7.39am

Originally posted by collier row eagle

Agree, let's stop this he's " one of our own" bulls***

Yeah one of our scored a hatrick for scumwall. No goals in 15 months definitely not good enough.

 


Another Damien Diagonal - Total Football

Part Time James Flag 23 Aug 17 8.11am

Originally posted by Dan89

Yeah one of our scored a hatrick for scumwall. No goals in 15 months definitely not good enough.

I don't want to cast him off entirely but he shouldn't be a guaranteed starter. I have no issue seeing him in a Palace shirt but he needs to be made to fight for it. And to be fair, a pissed off Punch with a point to prove is quite often a much better Punch.

 




Nobbybm Flag Dartford 23 Aug 17 8.35am

Originally posted by Part Time James

I don't want to cast him off entirely but he shouldn't be a guaranteed starter. I have no issue seeing him in a Palace shirt but he needs to be made to fight for it. And to be fair, a pissed off Punch with a point to prove is quite often a much better Punch.

Ain't that the truth. We were only saying this at the weekend - he's not fighting like he did before & we couldn't fathom whether that's because he's not having to compete for a place or he's just lost that edge he had.

Seems to slow the game down rather than drive it forward like he used to.

 


Will this be five? It's gonna be five! It IS five!

chateauferret Flag 23 Aug 17 12.13pm

Originally posted by Part Time James

I don't want to cast him off entirely but he shouldn't be a guaranteed starter. I have no issue seeing him in a Palace shirt but he needs to be made to fight for it. And to be fair, a pissed off Punch with a point to prove is quite often a much better Punch.

Which is why we nearly won that cup final, of course.

He's definitely too comfortable and complacent. If we aren't selling him we've got enough form players now in that part of the park now that the heavy team are fit again to oust him from the starting lineup. Cabaye, McArthur, Loftus-Cheek.

 


============
The Ferret
============

coulsdoneagle Flag London 23 Aug 17 12.20pm

Originally posted by Dan89

I've been critical of mcarthur, and wanted to sell him numerous times throughout the summer but he finally looks like he recovered from the back spasms that hindered him under bid Sam. 2 fantastic strikes yesterday and would love to see him alongside a midfield of RLC and cabaye. I'm sorry but puncheon was poor again. Side note the Ipswich town fans were a real credit, sung throughout the whole match. Positive going into a massive game against Swansea. Coyp

Fair play to you for holding your hands up and admitting you wanted him sold. Me and you had quite a few arguments about it over the summer but not many posters would admit they were wrong.

Far more would do a Sg Bilko and disappear.

Agree re. Punch 100%

 

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 23 Aug 17 12.34pm

Originally posted by coulsdoneagle

Fair play to you for holding your hands up and admitting you wanted him sold. Me and you had quite a few arguments about it over the summer but not many posters would admit they were wrong.

Far more would do a Sg Bilko and disappear.

Agree re. Punch 100%

Agree on all and I was the same as Coulsdon.

But how much will Parish accept for Jimmy then? -.-'

 


COYP

Barcelona eagle Flag Cubelles 23 Aug 17 12.40pm

Personally, I think Punch is playing way too deep. He could for me play at the top of a diamond or just behind tekkers in no way is he a holding midfielder, neither is Cabaye, the only players who should be near that role are Luka, RLC and as a last option Jimmy Mac.

I would however try to have Punch in the wing back position just to see if since he has gone to a deeper defensive role, he can be useful there in both defence and attack.

I'd try (when fit) and in the league cup 3-5-2

WH/ Speroni

Ward/ Kelly Dann/Tomkins Jairo/Papa

Jimmy Mac Luka RLC

Puncheon/Cabaye

Andros/ Lokilo Wilf/kaikai

Tekkers

It is still a bit square peggish but we are left with a massive gap from our centre midfielders to tekkers, teams find it too easy to defend against us knowing we will most likely utilise the wings. Having a Beardslyesq player in the hole would in my opinion bring the attack together a bit and allow us to play as Every single player in that attack can pass the ball very well.


Edited by Barcelona eagle (23 Aug 2017 12.41pm)

 

BarEagle Flag Monmouth 23 Aug 17 12.48pm

I have been beating the drum about Puncheon for a long, long time. He is a liability with the ball.

 

Part Time James Flag 23 Aug 17 12.57pm

Originally posted by chateauferret

Which is why we nearly won that cup final, of course.

He's definitely too comfortable and complacent. If we aren't selling him we've got enough form players now in that part of the park now that the heavy team are fit again to oust him from the starting lineup. Cabaye, McArthur, Loftus-Cheek.

Absolutely. I had heard he stuck two fingers up at Pardew when he netted that goal, but despite the unprofessional nature of it all (if it even happened), I thought "yes Punch, some f**king passion".

I'd REALLY love for him to find some form. I have nothing against him at all and on principal he can still become a fan's favourite again, but he needs to be managed better, both tactically and his morale/passion.

 




Tommyp151211 Flag 23 Aug 17 1.00pm

An example of how fickle some fans are becoming.

Macurther gets slated for 2/3s of a season, one good game and he's the best thing since sliced bread again and yet wait for the chorus of criticism when he doesn't score twice on Saturday.

 

Croydonlad Flag sydenham 23 Aug 17 4.23pm

A truly great Palace player is JM

 

matthau Flag South Croydon 23 Aug 17 4.45pm

Originally posted by Tommyp151211

An example of how fickle some fans are becoming.

Macurther gets slated for 2/3s of a season, one good game and he's the best thing since sliced bread again and yet wait for the chorus of criticism when he doesn't score twice on Saturday.

fickle or naturally selective. Both puncheon and McArthur haven't been great for a while, But the prior is ALWAYS in the team and doesn't do much at all.

If McArthur has had one classy game, irrespective of opponents, then he should get his turn. Puncheon didn't even shine in pre season as far as I remember.

Its not fickle, its relief that we all can mention a good reason why puncheon can be dropped for least one game, as someone has better form than him.

Edited by matthau (23 Aug 2017 4.46pm)

 

aashman12 Flag 25 Aug 17 7.38am

Originally posted by Dan89

I've been critical of mcarthur, and wanted to sell him numerous times throughout the summer but he finally looks like he recovered from the back spasms that hindered him under bid Sam. 2 fantastic strikes yesterday and would love to see him alongside a midfield of RLC and cabaye. I'm sorry but puncheon was poor again. Side note the Ipswich town fans were a real credit, sung throughout the whole match. Positive going into a massive game against Swansea. Coyp

So does macca start in midfield instead of loftus cheek?

Edited by aashman12 (25 Aug 2017 7.38am)

 


You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Fantastic to see the old James mcarthur back