You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Have we got Worse Scouting network in the prem ?
November 16 2026 8.51am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Have we got Worse Scouting network in the prem ?


Page 2 of 2 << First< 1 2
Dangermouse Flag Hastings 02 Sep 17 11.53am

Most scouting is done on the Internet nowadays anyway. FdB must have excellent contacts and a great knowledge of European players, so I disagree with the assumption. Why we did so badly, I like everyone else don't know?
Maybe uncertainty over the manager had an effect? Maybe we'd have no spare funds right now as we have other things to spend on? Maybe there wasn't a goalkeeper or forward we could get that we felt was value and we weren't prepared to pay over the odds? Maybe everyone overslept? Maybe no one could give a toss and are determined to send us down? Maybe Parish wanted to piss off Croydonlad and Dan89? Last one is more likely as we even got Everton to stitch us up over Niasse.

Ho hum......


Edited by Dangermouse (02 Sep 2017 12.34pm)

 


That's Life
And as funny as it may seem
Some people get their kicks stompin' on a Dream.
KEEP THE FAITH!!!!!

Pierre Flag Purley 02 Sep 17 11.58am

Originally posted by Dan89

I'm a fan mate,that watches prem league and often la liga. I think niasse would be a reasonable signing but how can the likes of Watford and wba get players like krychwioak and Richarlson and our scouting rely on players on England only. If your happy with our scouting please enlighten us why.


Krychowiak was offered to Slaven Bilic first before being picked up by West Brom. Obviously West Ham didn't fancy him!
Palace couldn't have had a look at Krychowiak as it is a only a loan deal from PSG but WBA are having to pay all his £110,000 a week salary.

Richarlson joined Watford from Fluminense they needed to get a work permit for him which was sailing very close to the wind as they had bought him already for £11.5m.
He agreed to go to Watford as they have a Portuguese manager and Gomez a Brazilian goalkeeper. Once again not much use to us if he cant speak a word of English or French!
Watford are owned by Giampaolo Pozzo who owns Udinese. His son Gino runs Watford for him. That's why they have instant Italian connections.
Remember their Championship side in 2013 with 9 loan players from Udinese and Granada Matej Vydra winning player of the season from FFS! Got the loan rules changed after that.
Does that answer your question!
Sometimes players just don't fit your clubs current DNA.
Its certainly has not the greatest transfer network or policy overall by any means over the last 5-6 years.

We also have to remember we do not exactly offer the most salubrious or luxuriant facilities compared with other clubs not many miles from us.
However I do think our own scouting network will continue to improve.
It is all about finding young undiscovered talent signing them early either to the academy or in the squad just like diamond mining!

 

Midlands Eagle Flag 02 Sep 17 12.00pm

Originally posted by Palace in the Blood

<snip>

The fact that we have no 3rd goalkeeper, no backup strikers show to me that something is wrong. Is SP not backing his manager or is his manager not identifying targets?

Something is obviously wrong although none of us know whether the problem is with SP or FdB neither or both.

Many people will guess though and offer their guesses as fact as is the way on HOL

We were certainly linked with quite a few goalkeepers over the period and as many of them were Dutch they would either have been FdB's targets or media speculation and again we don't really know the answer

 

alaneagle1 Flag Dunstable,Bedfordshire.England 02 Sep 17 12.41pm

Originally posted by Midlands Eagle

Something is obviously wrong although none of us know whether the problem is with SP or FdB neither or both.

Many people will guess though and offer their guesses as fact as is the way on HOL

We were certainly linked with quite a few goalkeepers over the period and as many of them were Dutch they would either have been FdB's targets or media speculation and again we don't really know the answer

Unless we are really unlucky (now I've said that we probably will be) there will be no need for a third choice Goaly.
The under 21 lad can do that.
However Centre Forward is risky.


 


Palace 13th 2017/18.

Dan89 Flag Se25 02 Sep 17 6.35pm

Our bad scouting leads to us being so close to fpp. Your telling me that there isn't a better alternative than a mutch or PVA aboard instead of paying extrodianry fees. This is why the scouts let us down. Need a whole restructure.

 


Another Damien Diagonal - Total Football

Goldfiinger Flag Just down the road 02 Sep 17 7.23pm

PVA was signed in the same window as Sakho and Miliov, those two turned out class. But let's forget that and just focus on the ones that weren't complete successes.

As if other clubs dont make mistakes, and every signing is spot on.

Yeah ok.

I'd also argue PVA was a good addition well needed at the time.

Edited by Goldfiinger (02 Sep 2017 7.24pm)

 

Rachid Rachid Rachid Flag 02 Sep 17 8.11pm

Originally posted by Goldfiinger

PVA was signed in the same window as Sakho and Miliov, those two turned out class. But let's forget that and just focus on the ones that weren't complete successes.

As if other clubs dont make mistakes, and every signing is spot on.

Yeah ok.

I'd also argue PVA was a good addition well needed at the time.

Edited by Goldfiinger (02 Sep 2017 7.24pm)

Much was made of the lack of left sided players and pace in the side when we were going down last season. PVA and Schlupp both addressed this. Very selective and short memories among some.

 

Goldfiinger Flag Just down the road 02 Sep 17 8.19pm

Originally posted by Rachid Rachid Rachid

Much was made of the lack of left sided players and pace in the side when we were going down last season. PVA and Schlupp both addressed this. Very selective and short memories among some.

Completely. We blew a hole in the finances to solve the problem and doubled down in case an injury.

Injuries hit so it was lucky as many would argue without both we'd have been found wanting when it mattered most.

Few months on and the board gets pelters for wasting money on PVA. Jokers.


 

Dan89 Flag Se25 02 Sep 17 8.21pm

Originally posted by Rachid Rachid Rachid

Much was made of the lack of left sided players and pace in the side when we were going down last season. PVA and Schlupp both addressed this. Very selective and short memories among some.

I think you missed the point. Yes a left back was needed. Olson joined Swansea for 4.5m. We could of used a foreign loan had our scouts gave us options.

 


Another Damien Diagonal - Total Football

Rachid Rachid Rachid Flag 02 Sep 17 8.41pm

Originally posted by Dan89

I think you missed the point. Yes a left back was needed. Olson joined Swansea for 4.5m. We could of used a foreign loan had our scouts gave us options.

No you missed the point. Wasn't time to mess about with some unknown from Europe who might be ok in the Prem like, dare I say, Riedewald

 

Goldfiinger Flag Just down the road 02 Sep 17 8.48pm

Precisely ^^^^^^

 

Goldfiinger Flag Just down the road 02 Sep 17 8.54pm

It might be foolish of me. But my impression is we've been trying to sign a fairly high standard forward all window but have had a budget of maybe £15m max. Various options for what ever reason didn't pan out.

Maybe knowing they've got Andros, Wilf and Benteke in front of them have put the best options off signing?

Just a hunch but my gut says we've been looking at decent forwards and didn't just want a 'back up'.

Obviously i have no prof of this but all summer we've been linked with fairly decent forwards.

Anyway my gut says the intent was there. Is that good enough? No

 

Kintak11 Flag Vauxhall, London 02 Sep 17 10.06pm

Originally posted by Dan89

Our bad scouting leads to us being so close to fpp. Your telling me that there isn't a better alternative than a mutch or PVA aboard instead of paying extrodianry fees. This is why the scouts let us down. Need a whole restructure.

Agreed.
The original question was: 'Have we got Worse Scouting network in the prem?'

Sadly, five years on there is no evidence that we have a scouting network at all. Hence all the last minute, hopelessly dysfunctional chaos, leaving us horribly exposed in the striker and goalie departments. Amateur night!

 

Dan89 Flag Se25 02 Sep 17 10.21pm

Originally posted by Rachid Rachid Rachid

No you missed the point. Wasn't time to mess about with some unknown from Europe who might be ok in the Prem like, dare I say, Riedewald

Yet again you missed the point. I agree we need a left back but why didn't we buy one of Schlupp or PVA and loan another one from abroad like santon for instance. This what I'm trying say, our scouts aren't given the current manager options from abroad. This is where we are lacking big time.

 


Another Damien Diagonal - Total Football

chris123 Flag hove actually 02 Sep 17 10.36pm

Originally posted by Dan89

Yet again you missed the point. I agree we need a left back but why didn't we buy one of Schlupp or PVA and loan another one from abroad like santon for instance. This what I'm trying say, our scouts aren't given the current manager options from abroad. This is where we are lacking big time.

Have you had a bad day?

 

Rachid Rachid Rachid Flag 02 Sep 17 10.37pm

Originally posted by Dan89

Yet again you missed the point. I agree we need a left back but why didn't we buy one of Schlupp or PVA and loan another one from abroad like santon for instance. This what I'm trying say, our scouts aren't given the current manager options from abroad. This is where we are lacking big time.

We had no left sided players fit and available at all and Sam obviously wanted proven prem players. Keep twisting and arguing if you want but probably best you go back to scouting.

 

Page 2 of 2 << First< 1 2

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Have we got Worse Scouting network in the prem ?