You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Dominic Fifield article in the guardian
November 16 2026 8.34am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Dominic Fifield article in the guardian


Page 2 of 2 << First< 1 2
YT Flag Oxford 12 Sep 17 4.42pm

Originally posted by mike_sc

I think that would be the perfect banner. Pretty expensive if you're paying by the letter mind...

Having said that, Hodgson will be 72 when his contract is up. Hard to plan too far ahead when he's liable to dose off midway through the second half.

Yes I expect at that age he'll be on quite a lot of medication.

 


Palace since 19 August 1972. Palace 1 (Tony Taylor) Liverpool 1 (Emlyn Hughes)

Malcolm Ali's Son Flag 12 Sep 17 4.46pm

Originally posted by est1905

All of your points are based on your own opinion (which is fine) and gossip (which is not) but none of which is fact.
We were not nailed on to be relegated under FdB. The game against Burnley actually suggests the tide is (or was) about to turn in our favour.
Talk of him upsetting the regime/players is just that, talk. The performance Sunday 100% proves that at least the players on the pitch were playing for him. On your final point, in 4 matches time I think most of us would have been breathing a sigh of relief that we didn't sack him as I truly believe it would have started to come good.
The bloke has been treated unforgivably badly. This will do us harm in the future when recruiting a manager that isn't in his 70s and has a choice of other clubs and is talented. Would you want to take a job with someone that may sack you 4 games in? I know I wouldn't

I agree, I reckon hitting the panic button just as Frank got a decent performance out of the team is madness. Why not give him until Christmas? Hello relegation...

 

susmik Flag PLYMOUTH -But Made in Old Coulsdon... 12 Sep 17 4.49pm

Originally posted by budgie2

Well written piece on latest mess we find ourselves in .

There is no hiding from this fiasco, whether or not talk of fans’ protests is followed through on Saturday lunchtime which is a stupid idea in the first place as the fans should get behind the team who it has come to light were subjected to an awful and torrid for time under Frank De Boer which in turn made the players not want to play for him. Some senior club members of staff have come out and said the he was a control freak and he thought he ran the club and did not listen to good advice. This was the case in his last club where he got sacked from. I think if I was one of the players and the manger kept getting the ball in training and started showing off his skills in front of goal every five minutes I too would get p1$$ed off as our players did. His man management by all accounts is nil.

From Dominic Fifields article
"The owners – it is safe to assume the American investors, in particular – cannot contemplate slipping into the Championship. Once De Boer offered no clear plan as to how he would kickstart the team’s season in a meeting with Parish and the sporting director, Dougie Freedman, on the last Monday in August, the writing was on the wall.
The sight of the Dutchman bemoaning his players’ lack of “courage” on the ball in his post-match observations was too much for the owners to accept. One would have hoped the interview process might have highlighted any potential personality clash but clearly something had been lost in translation mid-summer. De Boer had apparently pledged “evolution, not revolution” but his approach suggested otherwise. Parish might argue some of the Dutchman’s tactics were evidence he had been hoodwinked. What so infuriated the board was De Boer’s apparent naivety when it came to the demands of the Premier League, as perverse as that may seem in relation to a man who excelled as a player at Barcelona, earned 112 Holland caps and claimed four Eredivise titles in six seasons as Ajax’s coach. Tony Pulis and Allardyce proved at Palace that the starting basis for any kind of success at a club of this size is a solid defence; be hard to beat first, and build any kind of progressive play from that base. De Boer could point to a fine defensive record in Dutch football but fell back on his principles, his weight of experience as a player and coach, and a favoured tactical game plan: a 3-4-3 forged on possession and patient buildup as if it was lifted from his Ajax days."

It seems pretty obvious to me that De Boer was completely out of his depth which the above proves and it was the best thing that SP could have done was to sack him especially when it seems De Boer had somehow hoodwinked him in the initial interview. I personally think SP should get some praise for acting so quickly on seeing where we were heading. He does not deserve all the flack he is getting as he is trying to put things right and we must all remember that he is not alone in decisions made by the owners he only does things when ALL three agree upom something. He knows as we do he is on a learning curve when it comes to running a football club and he HAS admitted it in the past many times both in the press and when interviewed on TV, radio or on Hol radio so give him a break he is only doing what he can do to make our club get better and it does not warrant us fans and everyone else calling him names etc. Give the guy a break and see how Roy gets to grips with the situation and gets our players playing like we know they can play and changes their mood from "pi$$ed off" to "Pride in a Palace shirt".

I say again a display like a fans protest on Saturday is really uncalled for and will only put the team off their game and quite well make it our 5th loss please remember that when Saturday comes, (plus remember the game is on TV) we do not want the world to see how fickle and stupid Crystal Palace Fans are but instead show them how we have the loudest and most loyal fans as we always have done in the past and spur the team on to get us our first three points on the board!!

 


Supported Palace for over 69 years since the age of 7 and have seen all the ups and downs and will probably see many more ups and downs before I go up to the big football club in the sky.

Goldfiinger Flag Just down the road 13 Sep 17 7.17pm

Good article, found it interesting that he said some players were taking to his methods.

 

chateauferret Flag 13 Sep 17 8.15pm

Originally posted by est1905
Talk of him upsetting the regime/players is just that, talk. The performance Sunday 100% proves that at least the players on the pitch were playing for him. On your final point, in 4 matches time I think most of us would have been breathing a sigh of relief that we didn't sack him as I truly believe it would have started to come good.

Maybe, but we have it from more than one source that he'd already begun to destroy Milivojevic and observations of that player tend to bear this out (together with the fact that he was dropped on Sunday).

 


============
The Ferret
============

Page 2 of 2 << First< 1 2

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Dominic Fifield article in the guardian