You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > My take on things.
November 16 2026 8.22am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

My take on things.


Page 2 of 2 << First< 1 2
Lyons550 Flag Shirley 25 Oct 17 5.55pm

Originally posted by Booted Eagle

Good post but I don't buy into last nights horrorshow at the back being down to not playing together. In this cup we have beaten Ipswich and Huddersfield and we were no way near the shower last night. Every round barring maybe the quarters onwards where there is a sniff of a Wembley appearance and trophy we would see major changes. Lack of leadership at the back cost us. Need a strong leader at the back. I'm sure Jedi use to play in these games in the past. Damo could of been a possibility, giving him the armband instead of Punch ?Also this dross gone in Jan idea unfortunately won't happen. Mutch may well go, he didn't in the summer, but he wasn't even in the side last night. Not just him but these type of players may well sink us, that is the worry from last night.

Edited by Booted Eagle (25 Oct 2017 1.44pm)

Each of those games had a higher percentage of 1st teamers in it...last night just had RLC and TFM

 


The Voice of Reason In An Otherwise Mediocre World

Plaistow Eagle Flag 25 Oct 17 6.51pm

Originally posted by Dangermouse

I understand the sentiment, but exactly who's vision should he be following then? Surely all of us would follow our vision, rightly or wrongly. SP screwed up, but I'd rather he screwed up his way rather than do it trying to pander to other people's ideas and vision.
Dyche was never in for the job as far as I know and why do people think he would have wanted it?
I'm more pissed off that SP didn't address the keeper and forward issue. These were fixable and obvious problems and to ignore them was negligent.


Great post Danger Mouse - IMO incapsulates the predicrement we are in.

Simple example is if you are Riedewald - you were bought in by FDB from Ajax on the premise we were going to play a certain style - then 5 games in the Guy you signed for gets his marching orders.

You are 21 years of age - plying your trade for the first time outside your native country and your reason for making that decision has just been given the "Spanish Archer" - how would you feel.

It must have a detrimental affect on your mindset and confidence.

Given our attrition rate of Managers there are numerous examples of this across the squad.

This is where Parish and the board must take some responsibility IMO Dyche was there for the signing at the end of last season - he was the right man for the job and if the right offer was made he would have taken it.

But no Parish decides he wants to play a more expansive style - which is totally not conducive with the personnel or resources of the squad.

Then exerbates that by not making funds available or backing FDB in the transfer market to recruit players to play in that style.

Then he confounds it all by signing Sakho - saying something along the lines of we as fans have been "pushing" him to signing Sakho so he has.

Don't get me wrong I think Mama is/will prove to be a great sigining and we all love him after the impact he had last season - I think in fact he should be Captain.

But the point is he was a Parish signing - not FDB, so not a backing of FDB in the transfer market and the style of football that Parish bought FDB to play.

Look to play the sort of football Parrish bought in FDB to play cost''s millions - realistically only the top half a dozen sides in the Prem have the financial clout to achieve it.

For the rest of the Prem it's about being solid at the back, being energetic and hitting teams on the break.

This is what we were so good at, at the backend of last season - we had the players and resources to suit this style and still have.

This is where we need to focus..

IMO - where we are is due to Parish's vanity and egotisticalness for which he/we did/do not have either the player or financial resources to deliver.

In simple terms he tried to bite off more than he can chew and now we're suffering the consequences.

All that said I think Roy will get it right, get the most out of the squad, with some additions in January and we will stay up.

But the lesson is be careful what you wish for, do not lose sight of your identity and what got you there.

COYP

 

Dangermouse Flag Hastings 25 Oct 17 8.08pm

As I stated earlier, we would all do it OUR way, so criticising him for that is pointless IMO. If anyone on here is even disagreed with the pouting starts and heels are dug in over their opinions. So practically everyone has an ego and wants to be proved right, why would Parish be any different.
Honestly, I'm not trying to defend or justify any of his decisions, but I don't understand slating someone for doing what they believe is right for the club they actually own. If you can prove, he's done it on purpose and is deliberately trying to destroy the club then that's a different scenario.

 


That's Life
And as funny as it may seem
Some people get their kicks stompin' on a Dream.
KEEP THE FAITH!!!!!

mrfantasy Flag maidstone 25 Oct 17 8.27pm

Originally posted by Gidge

People have suggested that the likes of Pulis and Big Sam left us because of Parish and the general set up at the club but I don't buy that. Pulis is proven to be a nasty piece of work and Big Sam??? Well, one day we'll find out why he left.

Don't hold your breath. If we just had a bit of honesty from Parish things may be easier to stomach? In the mean time we must assume that managers find it impossible to work with the bloke. Freedman, Hollaway, Pulis and Allardyce all quit and we can only guess the reasons. I wonder how long Roy will last before he's had enough?

 

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 25 Oct 17 11.25pm

Originally posted by Frickin Saweet

kind of to my point, if we start doing due diligence on managers before it's an absolute necessity and our hand is forced, then we'll know more about them and make a more informed decision rather than ill-thought-out panic buys

All the successful managers have been decided because they are clearly the best available. When Parish dithered and signed Frank in secrecy it was an immense disaster. I pray for logic to be priority.

 


COYP

Page 2 of 2 << First< 1 2

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > My take on things.