You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > No Poppy On Shirt?
November 16 2026 8.08am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

No Poppy On Shirt?


Page 2 of 2 << First< 1 2
phillanth Flag London 04 Nov 17 9.36pm

"..his friends in the IRA were allies of the Nazis."

And your evidence for this is?

 

phillanth Flag London 04 Nov 17 9.44pm

Whilst his fellow countrymen were fighting the greatest evil and threat to democracy

Catholics in Northern Ireland did not enjoy democracy. They did not have equal voting right with Unionists were banned the shipyards and the other major employers just like black people in the Southern states of the USA. What democracy were the Indian troops in the British army in World War Two defending?

 

Jimenez Flag SELHURSTPARKCHESTER,DA BRONX 04 Nov 17 9.46pm

Originally posted by phillanth

"..his friends in the IRA were allies of the Nazis."

And your evidence for this is?

Ireland were neutral in the Second World War but a small minority chose to fight for Germany.

 


Pro USA & Israel

Goldfiinger Flag Just down the road 04 Nov 17 9.50pm

Originally posted by Midlands Eagle

In the immortal words of John McEnroe "You cannot be serious"

So disabled people shouldn't have a national day where our footballers wear there symbol and we buy and wear flowers for them?

Only injured/dead soldiers?

Not saying they shouldn't just questioning why others shouldn't as well.

Edited by Goldfiinger (04 Nov 2017 9.53pm)

 

Jimenez Flag SELHURSTPARKCHESTER,DA BRONX 04 Nov 17 10.01pm

Originally posted by Goldfiinger

So disabled people shouldn't have a national day where our footballers wear there symbol and we buy and wear flowers for them?

Only injured/dead soldiers?

Not saying they shouldn't just questioning why others shouldn't as well.

Edited by Goldfiinger (04 Nov 2017 9.53pm)

Well people fought & died for you to say that. Its a free country & if you feel that strongly about this cause maybe start a campaign?

 


Pro USA & Israel

Casual Flag Orpington 04 Nov 17 10.41pm

Originally posted by Goldfiinger

So disabled people shouldn't have a national day where our footballers wear there symbol and we buy and wear flowers for them?

Only injured/dead soldiers?

Not saying they shouldn't just questioning why others shouldn't as well.

Edited by Goldfiinger (04 Nov 2017 9.53pm)

The point is that the servicemen have fought and died for our way of life /safety. The disabled have their Poppy Day, every day by getting the best parking spaces. I am of course joking.

 

Goldfiinger Flag Just down the road 04 Nov 17 11.10pm

Originally posted by Jimenez

Well people fought & died for you to say that. Its a free country & if you feel that strongly about this cause maybe start a campaign?

I completely support Poppy day, for me to say that others in need should be supported in a similar fashion does NOT mean i don't support our armed services or Poppy day.

That's all.

 

palace777 Flag belfast 04 Nov 17 11.16pm

I am a proud Irishman and I wear a poppy to recognise that my grandfather (another proud Irishman) gave his life in 1917 on the Western Front.
I also believe everyone has the right to choose not to wear one without any pressure.
That is what my grandfather fought and died for.

 

Mapletree Flag Croydon 04 Nov 17 11.49pm

Originally posted by richard shaw (og)65

i noticed that daniel sturrridge wasn't wearing a poppy on his shirt at the weekend , he doesn't seem to have been dug out for it like james maclean has.

Edited by richard shaw (og)65 (04 Nov 2017 11.16am)

Odd. He laid a wreath last year.

 

Stirlingsays Flag 04 Nov 17 11.59pm

Originally posted by palace777

I am a proud Irishman and I wear a poppy to recognise that my grandfather (another proud Irishman) gave his life in 1917 on the Western Front.
I also believe everyone has the right to choose not to wear one without any pressure.
That is what my grandfather fought and died for.

Respect to your grandfather.

I also respect this tradition but yes, compulsion is rarely helpful, though I do believe criticism is fair comment.

People have freedom to comment or not to comment.

Edited by Stirlingsays (05 Nov 2017 12.04am)

 


'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)

EagleEssex Flag Essex 05 Nov 17 1.58am

Originally posted by Rachid Rachid Rachid

What is politically correct about remembering the war dead ?

I hear your point, and realise it doesn't fit into the usual PC mould. Furthermore I personally support this charity, so I can be objective.
The reason I described it as politically correct is because of the mass hysteria stirred up by anyone who doesn't want to wear the poppy, ie James McClean, as much as I disagree with his politics, Id be a hypocrite if I didn't agree his treatment by the media waa harsh. Everyone is free to support charities and political causes but it should never be obligatory in sport.
There's one thing however that I think should be respected and that is respect to the national anthem of the country being played in, which is why I vehemently disagree to the "take a knee" trend in the USA right now.

 

Thegamesafoot Flag Somewhere but Nowhere 05 Nov 17 3.06am

Could be worse, could be Croat/Serb living memory war rather than remembering 100 WW1 70 years WW2

 


It's good to keep an opened mind, but not so open that your brains fall out.

Badger11 Flag Beckenham 05 Nov 17 7.54am

Originally posted by phillanth

"..his friends in the IRA were allies of the Nazis."

And your evidence for this is?

I didn't cite evidence because I assumed (wrongly) that it was well known about links between the IRA and the Nazis. I don't want to derail this thread from the original question so this is my fault for mentioning it. A quick look on Wikipedia (below) gives some context although not everyone will accept that as a valid source. There are plenty of other history books and websites so take your pick.

Anyway my bad and I repeat I am fine with people not wearing a poppy it is their choice.

[Link]

 


One more point

YT Flag Oxford 05 Nov 17 8.07am

Just a point about ‘compulsion’. Surely it’s the football club that decides to sport the poppy on its shirts, and if players want to play for their club then that’s the shirt they wear that week. If a player was opposed to gambling, they wouldn’t get a choice about wearing a shirt with a betting firm’s logo in it, would they?

When I see a team wearing the poppy on its shirts I see it as the club making a gesture, not the individual players.

 


Palace since 19 August 1972. Palace 1 (Tony Taylor) Liverpool 1 (Emlyn Hughes)

Midlands Eagle Flag 05 Nov 17 8.28am

Originally posted by EagleEssex

The reason I described it as politically correct is because of the mass hysteria stirred up by anyone who doesn't want to wear the poppy, ie James McClean, as much as I disagree with his politics, Id be a hypocrite if I didn't agree his treatment by the media waa harsh.

It's very sad that he refuses to honour those that died to that he could earn a small fortune from their descendants every week

 

Slimey Toad Flag Karsiyaka, North Cyprus 05 Nov 17 9.12am

Growing up the whole point of poppies was to make a conscious effort to go and pay for one, then wear it. This made it more of a worthwhile and respectful act.

My suggestion to footballers. On Remembrance weekend you are given the choice of a shirt with a poppy and one without. If you want to wear the poppy-emblazoned on you have to donate £ ........ to the Poppy Appeal.

 

Lombardos barber Flag 05 Nov 17 9.20am

Originally posted by Midlands Eagle

It's very sad that he refuses to honour those that died to that he could earn a small fortune from their descendants every week

He honoured our dead who did just that in his statement, and said if the poppy was a symbol of the world wars he would wear one.

I’m serving and I tell you this; if I were from the nationalist community in Derry I wouldn’t wear a poppy either. Look up the Ballymurphy Masacre and Bloody Sunday.

 

crystal-purley Flag Purley 05 Nov 17 9.25am

Originally posted by Jimenez

Ireland were neutral in the Second World War but a small minority chose to fight for Germany.

and a few for the allies. Ireland was also bombed by the Luftwaffe (possibly because they weren't 100% neutral) but as Adolf's half brother Aloysius was living there at the time just the once.

 


Enjoying getting up later and not having someone who knows better than me (apart from the missus of course).

Page 2 of 2 << First< 1 2

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > No Poppy On Shirt?