This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
Fosu-Mensah v Ward
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
glaziermart 21 Nov 17 11.13am |
|
|
Anyone else find it odd that Roy seems to prefer Ward over Fosu-Mensah at right back? I know Fosu-Mensah can play anywhere along the back line and even in midfield, but the only real available position for him in our team is at right back. Apparently Jose Mourinho sees his long term position as replacement for Antonio Valencia at United. I thought he looked the nuts in a couple of games, Burnley away springs to mind and when he came on against West Ham in the second half. Pace and power, with a good ability on the ball. Surely he should be above Ward who i still feel is vulnerable at times, and other teams seem to target that side of the pitch against us
|
chateauferret 21 Nov 17 11.22am |
|
|
Yes, me. I can only think that Fosu-Mensah was brought in with a back three in mind and that Hodgson playing 4 at the back sees Ward as a 4-back-line man and Fosu-Mensah as a wing back. But as you say the latter's versatility should make that no issue.
But WTF do I know?
============ The Ferret ============
|
Hutchyeagle Hove 21 Nov 17 12.40pm |
|
|
Agreed...best full back in the club
|
Palace in the Blood 21 Nov 17 2.45pm |
|
|
Ward is ours and Fosu Mensah is a loan player.
Ward's confidence was destroyed by the experiences with our previous manager. Ward is an EPL quality player and has proved this by his performances over the years. Yes he has made mistakes this year but so have most of the defence.
I agree that he needs competition for his place but so far he has seen off all players we have brought in to challenge. I think FM is a good player and will probably be world class in the future however it won't be for us and Ward is more committed to Palace cause so I hope he is offered a new contract and stays with us
|
Goldfiinger Just down the road 21 Nov 17 5.08pm |
|
Originally posted by chateauferret
Yes, me. I can only think that Fosu-Mensah was brought in with a back three in mind and that Hodgson playing 4 at the back sees Ward as a 4-back-line man and Fosu-Mensah as a wing back. But as you say the latter's versatility should make that no issue.
But WTF do I know?
On the whole I'd say Ward is fine at right back as long as everyone knows there duties.
Start mucking with their mojo and he's the first to get overwhelmed.
That being said Roy is the correct medicine for him.
Im happy wards back playing decent football, hopefully he'll sign an extension and be here next year when we can start bringing wan-bissaka through,
What we kinda know for sure is TFM won't be. Maybe Roy understands the long game...
And yes Wan-bissaka can play right back. He's our future.
|
Casual Orpington 21 Nov 17 7.38pm |
|
|
Agree from what I’ve seen. Could be playing at right or left back.
|
Casual Orpington 21 Nov 17 7.40pm |
|
Originally posted by Palace in the Blood
Ward is ours and Fosu Mensah is a loan player.
Ward's confidence was destroyed by the experiences with our previous manager. Ward is an EPL quality player and has proved this by his performances over the years. Yes he has made mistakes this year but so have most of the defence.
I agree that he needs competition for his place but so far he has seen off all players we have brought in to challenge. I think FM is a good player and will probably be world class in the future however it won't be for us and Ward is more committed to Palace cause so I hope he is offered a new contract and stays with us
I think he’s been offered a new contract and hes chosen to run his one down , until the end of this season, which is when Fosu Mensah goes back, unless he extends his loan.
|
mattteo 21 Nov 17 9.31pm |
|
|
Neither is capable of playing there at high level in my opinion. Fosu Mensah might make a good center back
|
Zebedee Surrey 21 Nov 17 10.34pm |
|
|
Just me who thinks Ward has played very well as a defender and not a wing back. Got an assist at the weekend with a perfect ball. Ward needs some one in front of him who can cover and knows when to. Fosu looks fast and cool headed for me he is a centre back and if he was ours id be saying Dann replacement next year.
|
Welsh Eagle 21 Nov 17 11.21pm |
|
|
Even though Ward"s performances have improved recently it doesn't make up for his poor form for at least 2 years!
I would much prefer Fosu-Mensah playing RB,he is quicker,more comfortable on the ball & a better dribbler which is needed in the modern game.
Ward used to be 1 of my favourite players but I now hope he doesn't sign a new contract & leaves in the summer.Teams target him for a reason & we really need to strengthen the quality in the RB & LB positions either in Jan or the summer.
|
thai-eagle chiang mai 22 Nov 17 2.37am |
|
|
In spite of Ward's precise assist for Wilf (2-1 Everton), he's our weakest link. Too many passes astray, slow, give away free kicks (in dangerous positions) too easy and often out of position. On the other side, seems an awfully nice bloke...
|
Ginger Pubic Wig Wickham de L'Ouest 22 Nov 17 6.31am |
|
|
The Wig's Top Trumps verdict, inauthentically all scores out of 100:
Wardy: Pace: 80 Positional play: 85 Passing: 65 Tackling: 85 Strength: 80 Skill: 65 Being a Palace player*: 100
Brainsy: Pace: 90 Positional play: 78 Passing: 73 Tackling: 85 Strength: 88 Skill: 70 Being a Palace player: 0
...TFM edges it on most metrics but needs to curb his exuberance. I guess Hodgson wants positional discipline, much of which Wardy has gleaned from experience.
*Doesn't Ward's contract expires next summer? If so I'm not convinced his being a Palace player makes sod all difference.
If you want to live in a world full of kindness, respect and love, try to show these qualities.
|
Palace in the Blood 22 Nov 17 12.01pm |
|
|
Yes but I think the reason he was going to run down contract was FDB. With our current position in League we don't know where we will be playing next year so contract offers will probably not be made till later in season. Thus we could lose any of the player who are out of contract in summer if they sign pre-contract agreements after Jan. Personally I think he will be made an offer and stay.
|