You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > No longer cut adrift
November 16 2026 8.07am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

No longer cut adrift


Page 2 of 2 << First< 1 2
Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 30 Nov 17 4.22pm

Originally posted by jamiemartin721

A win against West Brom (which isn't outside the realm of reasonable) could see us well placed to escape the drop zone

"Isn't outside the realm of reasonable" but in my humble estimation somewhat unlikely.

 

dg1937 Flag 30 Nov 17 5.37pm

Willo mentioned Shelvey. Listening to Dougie the other week he was very clear that a key consideration for anyone they looked at was 'character'. I agree Shelvey can pick a pass (as he demonstrated when he came on against WBA) but there have been a few episodes in his career that make me think he might fail the character test.

 

KAOS Flag In a tree 30 Nov 17 5.43pm


Originally posted by Willo

Definitely need a keeper on the basis that we only have 2 senior keepers whereas others have a minimum of 3.
And the need for a sriker goes without saying.
A central midfielder who can spray passes about wouldn't go amiss either.

Arguably the 3 most difficult and/or expensive, positions to fill though! We'll be lucky to get 1 of those in Jan never mind 3 ...

 

Ray in Houston Flag Houston 30 Nov 17 6.02pm

Originally posted by dg1937

Willo mentioned Shelvey. Listening to Dougie the other week he was very clear that a key consideration for anyone they looked at was 'character'. I agree Shelvey can pick a pass (as he demonstrated when he came on against WBA) but there have been a few episodes in his career that make me think he might fail the character test.


No thanks on Shelvey, unless he's being given away. He's not notably better than Cabaye or MacArthur (if at all) and would be a incremental upgrade at best, therefore.

As others have said: focus on a keeper and a striker (or two), and take advantage of any bargains that come our way.

 


We don't do possession; we do defense and attack. Everything else is just wa**ing with a football.

DutchEagleJohan Flag Vlissingen, Netherlands 01 Dec 17 5.28pm

You mean he screwed us certainly? By not taking anything from our first two home games against relegation candidates no 1 and 3. Just because he wanted to start a vanity project and underestimated the English game.
And to add insult to injury: now , surprise surprise, no other club is in for him; he might consider the Dutch national team. He can sod off with his useless, aimless, boring, overly controlling, non creating possession s***!


Originally posted by Maine Eagle

Frank wasn’t given a chance, and was the wrong appointment by Parish in the first place, so he got royally screwed.....twice. From what SP said after the last window he knows he made several mistakes. Roy has been vocal about certain positions, so if we don’t spend 25 mil on a keeper and striker I would be amazed. Add in a half decent full back or another winger and he would have splashed some cash there.


 

Maine Eagle Flag USA 01 Dec 17 6.24pm

Originally posted by DutchEagleJohan

You mean he screwed us certainly? By not taking anything from our first two home games against relegation candidates no 1 and 3. Just because he wanted to start a vanity project and underestimated the English game.
And to add insult to injury: now , surprise surprise, no other club is in for him; he might consider the Dutch national team. He can sod off with his useless, aimless, boring, overly controlling, non creating possession s***!


Then why was he hired? An employee takes a job and they do what they think is best to get the job done generally speaking. De Boer played a certain way his whole career, and learnt his trade at Ajax for crying out loud, did we not expect possession football? De Boer didnt help himself in some regards but he should never have been anywhere near managing this club. And once Parish had made that clanger, after we actually put a better display in against Burnley, and should have at least scored one (goal line clearance vs Dann for one) he doesnt even give the guy any semblance of a chance to turn things around, and fires him immediately. Totally calamitous way to run a football club. Parish is more responsible for the De Boer fiasco than De Boer is.

Edited by Maine Eagle (01 Dec 2017 6.25pm)

 


Trump lost. Badly. Hahahahahahaha.

DutchEagleJohan Flag Vlissingen, Netherlands 02 Dec 17 8.32am

I know where he came from, I had a season ticket at Ajax when he started playing there......
But to argue that we knew what to expect is utter nonsense. His whole career , minus a few games at Inter, he has played in and with a 4 men defense, usually with either 3 midfielders and wingers far forward with a striker or at a later stage with a "false" forward winger when the traditional Ajax winger was starting to be unavailable.
His whole attitude and persistence in the 5 men defense was his responsibility and his alone, or do we really think Parish insisted at 5 at the back when hiring him. It may well be worth noticing that the better display at Burnley came after 4 at the back. And behind closed doors I would not be surprised that only happened because of external pressure on the Boer who by then already had managed to loose the dressing room. I am not sure but it does seem likely.

A vanity project and arrogant underestimation of English football.

Originally posted by Maine Eagle

Then why was he hired? An employee takes a job and they do what they think is best to get the job done generally speaking. De Boer played a certain way his whole career, and learnt his trade at Ajax for crying out loud, did we not expect possession football? De Boer didnt help himself in some regards but he should never have been anywhere near managing this club. And once Parish had made that clanger, after we actually put a better display in against Burnley, and should have at least scored one (goal line clearance vs Dann for one) he doesnt even give the guy any semblance of a chance to turn things around, and fires him immediately. Totally calamitous way to run a football club. Parish is more responsible for the De Boer fiasco than De Boer is.

Edited by Maine Eagle (01 Dec 2017 6.25pm)


 

samprior Flag Hamburg 02 Dec 17 9.55am

Originally posted by DutchEagleJohan

I know where he came from, I had a season ticket at Ajax when he started playing there......
But to argue that we knew what to expect is utter nonsense. His whole career , minus a few games at Inter, he has played in and with a 4 men defense, usually with either 3 midfielders and wingers far forward with a striker or at a later stage with a "false" forward winger when the traditional Ajax winger was starting to be unavailable.
His whole attitude and persistence in the 5 men defense was his responsibility and his alone, or do we really think Parish insisted at 5 at the back when hiring him. It may well be worth noticing that the better display at Burnley came after 4 at the back. And behind closed doors I would not be surprised that only happened because of external pressure on the Boer who by then already had managed to loose the dressing room. I am not sure but it does seem likely.

A vanity project and arrogant underestimation of English football.


Totally agree. Spot on. The 3/5/2 5/3/2 or whatever it was, was complete arrogance. He had no real managerial experience with it. Then to continue with it blindly after bad results is just poor management. The switch to 4 at the back against Burnley like you say I feel was only down to external influences.

All in all mistakes were made on both sides (for what it's worth I think Fdb could actually have done ok if he'd gone 433). But I feel a lot more confident now with Roy in charge.

 

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 02 Dec 17 10.02am

In terms of "Not being cut adrift", the gap between ourselves and safety has narrowed and we are in a more healthy situation than we were a few weeks ago.

That said, a loss today and others around us winning and we will once again be in a more parlous position.I might be going out on Saturday night riddled with negativity.

 

thai-eagle Flag chiang mai 02 Dec 17 10.13am

A draw at the Hawthorns and we'll slowly but surely creep out of relegation zone.

 

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 02 Dec 17 10.19am

Originally posted by thai-eagle

A draw at the Hawthorns and we'll slowly but surely creep out of relegation zone.

A draw would be a decent result for us.
Cannot see us winning.
As I have mentioned before, at Pardew's last 5 clubs he hasn't lost his opening match as manager.

 

Spiderman Flag Horsham 02 Dec 17 10.43am

Originally posted by kingdowieonthewall

w.hams next 3 games are great.Can see there GD getting royally mullered.
city / chels & arse!
Swansea / stoke & wba are all in a mix up playing each other next few games so sombodys got to lose out.
as others have mentioned hopefully a greatly improved position by Christmas will warrant a few bob spent.

Agreed. Also I think Huddersfield and the Weed will be hauled in once the lack of squad depth becomes an issue.

 

Page 2 of 2 << First< 1 2

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > No longer cut adrift