You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Momentum investigation
November 21 2026 11.03pm

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Momentum investigation


Page 2 of 2 << First< 1 2
serial thriller Flag The Promised Land 07 Dec 17 6.46pm

I'm a member of Momentum, and I have to say I think this whole thing's a bloody farce.

The headline is obviously tantalising for our opponents, but look at the details of this story and you'll see it's a storm in a tea cup. The Electoral Commission have said they'd investigate, as they do with almost any non-party organisation involved in the election. Momentum said they'd be happy to take part, having already released their expenses for the election.

The Standard, the Times etc have their story though. Needless to say that when the investigation actually comes back with its findings, they'll report them on the 35th page, but for now they can stamp it on the front page with the usual 'hard-left', 'Trots' etc labels.

It's nearly as ludicrous as this whole 'purge of the moderates' argument that's going on. But that's for another thread me thinks...

 


If punk ever happened I'd be preaching the law, instead of listenin to Lydon lecture BBC4

cryrst Flag The garden of England 07 Dec 17 6.59pm

Originally posted by serial thriller

I'm a member of Momentum, and I have to say I think this whole thing's a bloody farce.

The headline is obviously tantalising for our opponents, but look at the details of this story and you'll see it's a storm in a tea cup. The Electoral Commission have said they'd investigate, as they do with almost any non-party organisation involved in the election. Momentum said they'd be happy to take part, having already released their expenses for the election.

The Standard, the Times etc have their story though. Needless to say that when the investigation actually comes back with its findings, they'll report them on the 35th page, but for now they can stamp it on the front page with the usual 'hard-left', 'Trots' etc labels.

It's nearly as ludicrous as this whole 'purge of the moderates' argument that's going on. But that's for another thread me thinks...

What is momentum's wants going forward then with you being a member and all.
Or is it just stating how wrong the existing party is.
That's the whole problem
No concrete policies, just seems to highlight how bad the incumbents are.
I get students free education
Great in theory total no go financially
Any more?

 

serial thriller Flag The Promised Land 07 Dec 17 7.25pm

Originally posted by cryrst

What is momentum's wants going forward then with you being a member and all.
Or is it just stating how wrong the existing party is.
That's the whole problem
No concrete policies, just seems to highlight how bad the incumbents are.
I get students free education
Great in theory total no go financially
Any more?

Good question!

Momentum was born out of a group in Labour called the CLPD - the Campaign for Labour Party Democracy. It was run mainly by people like John Lansman and Mcdonnell, and it was a sort of protest movement at the top-down reorganisation of the Party by Mandelson.

Instead of party members electing local council nominees and Parliamentary candidates, the decision making was transferred to Whitehall and the NEC. That basically meant you got people like Tristram Hunt being put up in a place like Stoke on Trent, a person with about as much to do with Stoke on Trent as Alan Mullery does with Crystal Palace.

So their first job was to wrestle control back from the beureaucracy and give it back to members. Then, during the election, they were tasked with mobilising new Labour members, which they evidently did with incredible success.

As for policies, Momentum now is a really large organisation, with nearly as many members as the Tories. It took in people from anti-war backgrounds, climate backgrounds, housing, immigration, education...so lack of policy ideas is certainly not an issue!

As for free education not being financially viable, how do you think they manage to do it in Germany then?

 


If punk ever happened I'd be preaching the law, instead of listenin to Lydon lecture BBC4

cryrst Flag The garden of England 07 Dec 17 8.18pm

Originally posted by serial thriller

Good question!

Momentum was born out of a group in Labour called the CLPD - the Campaign for Labour Party Democracy. It was run mainly by people like John Lansman and Mcdonnell, and it was a sort of protest movement at the top-down reorganisation of the Party by Mandelson.

Instead of party members electing local council nominees and Parliamentary candidates, the decision making was transferred to Whitehall and the NEC. That basically meant you got people like Tristram Hunt being put up in a place like Stoke on Trent, a person with about as much to do with Stoke on Trent as Alan Mullery does with Crystal Palace.

So their first job was to wrestle control back from the beureaucracy and give it back to members. Then, during the election, they were tasked with mobilising new Labour members, which they evidently did with incredible success.

As for policies, Momentum now is a really large organisation, with nearly as many members as the Tories. It took in people from anti-war backgrounds, climate backgrounds, housing, immigration, education...so lack of policy ideas is certainly not an issue!

As for free education not being financially viable, how do you think they manage to do it in Germany then?

Firstly education.
I think maybe that needs investigating but maybe that are richer than us bearing in mind they are no 2 or 3 in the world's
( rich list). That may be how they afford it. Alternatively maybe they don't allow any type of course and may limit the ones where a tiny percentage will get a job relavent to the training. IE media etc.
( Not saying it's not learning but hardly a highly 'wanted' qualification) according to what I've seen and heard.
Now on to why momentum started
I see that you disagreed with core labour thought and policy. Seems very hardline without sitting down and meeting with them.
Sort of bullying the core vote into thinking like you then.
Could you not have met them on some middle ground as now you are seen as a problem in my eyes.
I get that local people for local issues but the same rules for most things apply nationally.
What are your basic policies on what you list then.
A house for everyone no matter what you put in.
No more wars EVER.
Stop fossil fuel and all get a treadmill.
Everyone welcome to build this big utopia.
I'm afraid that won't work and I still don't get your mission and why.

 

Page 2 of 2 << First< 1 2

You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Momentum investigation