You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Our shape or formation is wrong
November 16 2026 8.07am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Our shape or formation is wrong


Aray Flag South London 13 Dec 17 6.39am

He's done and is doing a good job making us hard to beat- the points tally since Chelsea is testament to that - but Roy's got to figure out how we get the 4 creative players working more effectively. Wilf is a winger if you aske me while RLC isn't - and surely needs to play off Benteke is we are playing 4 4 2. CB is often too isolated with this setup IMO. Thoughts?

Edited by Aray (13 Dec 2017 6.40am)

 

matthau Flag South Croydon 13 Dec 17 6.59am

Zaha isn’t a striker and needs to go back into the wing.

Although I can understand Roy’s reasons to try him up front

Loftus should play the hole behind Benteke because he isn’t a winger

However I’d go one step further, I’d have it out with android and make him play on the left. He wants to play right wing and cut in. Well that’s only good if he does more infield but he doesn’t. So either play android on left and wild on right (still wilfs best position; right wing) or like before constantly swap them during the games.

And play milo JUST in front of the back four like big Sam did rather than central midfield. He’s a dmc.

Other than that we are a form team and perhaps playing these players in these positions makes us harder to beat, what do I know?

I reckon in two or three weeks time we’ll have two new strikers anyway and a lot will change

 

dannyboy1978 Flag 13 Dec 17 7.19am

We should change positions, leaves teams guessing

 

MKCPFC Flag Spain/MK 13 Dec 17 7.23am

Originally posted by dannyboy1978

We should change positions, leaves teams guessing


Didn't Frank try that? We ended up being the team that was guessing.

 

slubglurge Flag welling 13 Dec 17 8.44am

If hes hell bent on 4 4 2 he should play RLC up front with Benteke. Wilf and Andros on oppodite flanks

 

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 13 Dec 17 9.25am

Agree with the thoughts. It doesn't work enough how it is.

I'd have Andros left and Wilf right 1st half mainly, with maybe a swap 1st half but definitely one late on in the 2nd half, especially at home. Wilf on the left v tired full backs late on definitely works.

I expect there'll be changes when hopefully some signings happen.

 


COYP

Painter Flag Croydon 13 Dec 17 9.42am

Originally posted by Aray

He's done and is doing a good job making us hard to beat- the points tally since Chelsea is testament to that - but Roy's got to figure out how we get the 4 creative players working more effectively. Wilf is a winger if you aske me while RLC isn't - and surely needs to play off Benteke is we are playing 4 4 2. CB is often too isolated with this setup IMO. Thoughts?

Edited by Aray (13 Dec 2017 6.40am)

Intrigued to why you think the formation is wrong. We are on an unbeaten run of 6 games, Roy and Ray have years of experience and watch the players training, so they know what they can do.
I guess you have no experience in football management, but think you know better.

 

MonsterMunch Flag Cambridge 13 Dec 17 9.51am

Originally posted by Painter

Intrigued to why you think the formation is wrong. We are on an unbeaten run of 6 games, Roy and Ray have years of experience and watch the players training, so they know what they can do.
I guess you have no experience in football management, but think you know better.

Yes I kind of agree. everyone can see that RLC is being wasted out wide, he just doesnt look comfortable there. We are missing creativity through the middle and have the answer imo stuck out on left. And Wilf is WIlf, he's a winger, an exceptional one at that. However as you have pointed out we are 6 unbeaten and he is getting results. Cant really take Roy to task with that. Roy has had a massive impact.

 

silvertop Flag Portishead 13 Dec 17 9.56am

I suspect this is a temporary situation imposed by the existence of only one fit striker in the squad.

If January goes as planned, we will have more options available.

For my part, I would love to see the wingers swapping over and bamboozle the opposition like Zaha and Bolasie used to do under Pardew before the squad was ravaged by injury.

 

Painter Flag Croydon 13 Dec 17 10.19am

Originally posted by MonsterMunch

Yes I kind of agree. everyone can see that RLC is being wasted out wide, he just doesnt look comfortable there. We are missing creativity through the middle and have the answer imo stuck out on left. And Wilf is WIlf, he's a winger, an exceptional one at that. However as you have pointed out we are 6 unbeaten and he is getting results. Cant really take Roy to task with that. Roy has had a massive impact.

RLC is still young in Premier terms and hasn’t played that many games, not convinced he is that creative, more a give and go player and very steady.
Wilf is playing up front, but seems to have a free role to go where he wants, Roy obviously knows he unsettles most teams.
In February we will have more of an idea the formation Roy wants to play with any new signings.

 

Red & Blue Pharaoh Flag South London 13 Dec 17 10.26am

Originally posted by Painter

Intrigued to why you think the formation is wrong. We are on an unbeaten run of 6 games, Roy and Ray have years of experience and watch the players training, so they know what they can do.
I guess you have no experience in football management, but think you know better.


I don't think you need experience in football management to have an opinion on our formation?

Yes, we're on a 6 game unbeaten run, but the performances haven't been particularly good. We didn't have a shot on target last night until the 88th min, Stoke was probably lucky too, as would have been against Bournemouth if we had won on Sat. WBA was a good point, but on paper we should be beating Brighton, and didn't offer anything going forward that night. One real chance if I remember correctly.

These are all teams who are struggling, and on another day the result could have gone the other way - we're not exactly playing them off the park.

RLC struggles to get into the game on the wing, and Wilf struggles to get the ball to feet alongside Benteke - yesterday's goals came from Wilf on the wing.

But onwards & upwards, i'll take picking up points and not playing well... you just worry our luck may change soon if we don't up our level of performance.

 


Meatball Header

si_1967 Flag Surrey 13 Dec 17 10.28am

On yesterday's performance, I'd move Townsend to the bench. We need battlers at the moment especially in the away games, too much of a 'luxury' player for me. I don't think Sako is the answer but he will battle.

 


... what

Aray Flag South London 13 Dec 17 10.32am

Originally posted by Painter

Intrigued to why you think the formation is wrong. We are on an unbeaten run of 6 games, Roy and Ray have years of experience and watch the players training, so they know what they can do.
I guess you have no experience in football management, but think you know better.

I dont THINK I know better. I said - "He's done and is doing a good job making us hard to beat- the points tally since Chelsea is testament to that - but Roy's got to figure out how we get the 4 creative players working more effectively"

Then I offered my opinion of what I can see - a winger not on the wing. a central midfielder/no 10 on the wing. Now maybe that is Roy's deliberate choice to offer some steel in front of Jeff. That is why I asked for thoughts.

This used to be a forum where us Palace fans would debate such matters rather than take pot shots. You sir are an arse. Good day.

 

Deleted11 13 Dec 17 10.44am

I think we need to rotate a bit. Didn't see the game last night, so can't judge Benteke, but he has been improving since he's come back from injury and desperately needs a goal to get him going.
The problem I see is Cabaye, because that is where RLC should be playing. We should start with PVA on the left and have Wilf free to create overloads on either wing. Townsend is basically Puncheon with a bit of pace, but at least when Puncheon first came, he was banging in important goals.
I was really disappointed when we drew with Bournemouth, but am really happy now. I always thought if we could get to 20 games and have around 20 points, we could be ok and it looks like that could be the case.

 

thai-eagle Flag chiang mai 13 Dec 17 10.57am

Like the idea of Luka behind Cabaye, RLC and MacArthur midfield, Zaha & Andros free to roam and never again PVA on right back. But prefer him over Schlupp on left side, the former Leicester player seems to have more or less no idea of what's goin' on out there....

 

Pete53 Flag Hassocks 13 Dec 17 11.44am

I think Roy is still exploring some of his options in terms of getting the best out of the manpower available.

What I have noticed recently is that when we go forward we are using the center of the park as well as the wings. Before it was always the case of looking to get the ball out to the flanks as quickly as possible for Zaha/ Bolasie/Puncheone/Townsend, which did make our play somewhat predictable and one-dimensional.

Also, and I don't think I am deluding myself here, but it seems we are attempting to play a better passing game with improved movement and lay-offs. Unfortunately, our passing isn't always up to scratch, nor our final ball into the area, but there are signs of progress on this front.

 

DutchEagleJohan Flag Vlissingen, Netherlands 13 Dec 17 11.47am

I agree, Towsned can count himself lucky he is getting the amount of starts he gets and can certainly not claim a place on a favored right. His drive inside brings absolutely nothing. Time for giving some time to some youngsters, not necessarily with a start but at least in the squad.

As for central midfield: Cabaye is looking like he is struggling lately, maybe a rotating system with Cabaye, Jimmy Mac and RLC would be a good option

And let's face it: last nights substitutes made us a mess. PVA looked completely out of his depth at the right and it was puzzling why Kelly did not come on when TFM was forced off. Would like to see PVA back at left back though even if he has his defensive issues at least he brings something forward and can not say I have been impressed with Schlupp.

It is not a matter of thinking Roy does not know what he is doing, of course he is grinding out results. yesterday admittedly with luck and undeservedly but we were due a bit of that.

 

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 13 Dec 17 12.13pm

[quote=Red & Blue Pharaoh;3280857]


I don't think you need experience in football management to have an opinion on our formation?

Yes, we're on a 6 game unbeaten run, but the performances haven't been particularly good. We didn't have a shot on target last night until the 88th min, Stoke was probably lucky too, as would have been against Bournemouth if we had won on Sat. WBA was a good point, but on paper we should be beating Brighton, and didn't offer anything going forward that night. One real chance if I remember correctly.

These are all teams who are struggling, and on another day the result could have gone the other way - we're not exactly playing them off the park.

RLC struggles to get into the game on the wing, and Wilf struggles to get the ball to feet alongside Benteke - yesterday's goals came from Wilf on the wing.

But onwards & upwards, i'll take picking up points and not playing well... you just worry our luck may change soon if we don't up our level of performance.


Mine (Rudihedman):

Very good post. Any rose tinted spec wearers cannot deny this.

Edited by Rudi Hedman (13 Dec 2017 12.14pm)

 


COYP


You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Our shape or formation is wrong