You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Tactics v Arsenal
November 16 2026 7.53am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Tactics v Arsenal


Page 2 of 2 << First< 1 2
Rachid Rachid Rachid Flag 29 Dec 17 9.35pm

Sanchez is ultimately why we lost.

Wilshere's a massively overrated sick note who was let off the hook by the ref in the second half.

 

Username Flag Horsham 30 Dec 17 1.12pm

Originally posted by Dangermouse

Thought we stood off too much 1st half. Clearly forward pair were asked to not close down in their half and just drop into shape. We were far more effective when we got in their faces and switched Wilf wider, especially when Sako came on.
Obviously people want Benteke to disobey his manager and chase down defenders in their own half. When chasing the game we had to be more proactive and that's when we closed higher up, but the team were following their managers instructions, clearly.

Spot on. Was frustrating hearing people slag him off when he was clearly following orders. When Arsenal had the ball both he and Wilf dropped in to make it a 4-6-0.

TFM is clearly struggling to pick things up with the system which is why he isn't getting in the team. In fairness to Kelly, it was his challenge which robbed Sanchez of the ball and set up the first goal.

Also agree we looked better when we did get on the front foot, easy to say in hindsight but maybe we should have got at them more from the start. Having said that, we got beaten by two goals that, while we could have cleared earlier, were very well taken and a third that was inch perfect. We also created a number of good opportunities that we should have done better with.

The idea that Tomkins should just have started running towards his own goal when Wilshere had it before the first goal is ridiculous. You set yourself up so the other team have to execute something difficult to get through. In that situation, the pass had to be perfect, most times it carries through to Jules or we cut it out.

It's the same as the second Defoe goal the other week, people moaned that Dann let him shoot, but in reality he got himself into a decent position and forced Defoe wide. He left Defoe with only one option, and it's just unlucky that it was the one time out of twenty it was weighted perfectly and ended up in the back of the net and not row 20 of the Holmesdale.

 


Employee of the month is a good example of how someone can be both a winner and a loser at the same time.

spartakev2 Flag Anerley 30 Dec 17 2.48pm

Originally posted by ex hibitionist

the tactics v Arsenal weren't about selection - we had two different formations each half, once Zaha went back to the right wing and Cheek came off the left back to an advanced central position we were more effective. Schlupp was a different player second half - he is a real athlete and if his ability to burst through the lines and turn defence into attack could be used more regularly he could be handy for us, cos lately he's looked so poor. Wouldn't put the loss down to individual errors either - we were basically outclassed but gave it a good go. Be interesting if Roy v City tries to do what Benitez tried the other night (a formation of 10-0-0) or is more adventurous like we were second half.


We must have been watching a different game. Can't remember wilf playing on the right or RLC playing more central. And schlupp had an absolute nightmare.

 

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 30 Dec 17 3.07pm

Originally posted by Username

Spot on. Was frustrating hearing people slag him off when he was clearly following orders. When Arsenal had the ball both he and Wilf dropped in to make it a 4-6-0.

TFM is clearly struggling to pick things up with the system which is why he isn't getting in the team. In fairness to Kelly, it was his challenge which robbed Sanchez of the ball and set up the first goal.

Also agree we looked better when we did get on the front foot, easy to say in hindsight but maybe we should have got at them more from the start. Having said that, we got beaten by two goals that, while we could have cleared earlier, were very well taken and a third that was inch perfect. We also created a number of good opportunities that we should have done better with.

The idea that Tomkins should just have started running towards his own goal when Wilshere had it before the first goal is ridiculous. You set yourself up so the other team have to execute something difficult to get through. In that situation, the pass had to be perfect, most times it carries through to Jules or we cut it out.

It's the same as the second Defoe goal the other week, people moaned that Dann let him shoot, but in reality he got himself into a decent position and forced Defoe wide. He left Defoe with only one option, and it's just unlucky that it was the one time out of twenty it was weighted perfectly and ended up in the back of the net and not row 20 of the Holmesdale.

Totally disagree.

There was no pressure on the ball when Wilshere was in possession and one of our central defenders should have dropped off but they were caught square with Sanchez in the middle of them.Had this happened the player who dropped off could have cleared the ball.

Edited by Willo (30 Dec 2017 3.08pm)

 

Username Flag Horsham 30 Dec 17 3.54pm

Originally posted by Willo

Totally disagree.

There was no pressure on the ball when Wilshere was in possession and one of our central defenders should have dropped off but they were caught square with Sanchez in the middle of them.Had this happened the player who dropped off could have cleared the ball.

Edited by Willo (30 Dec 2017 3.08pm)

Fair enough. I'd say the problem there was the first part of that sentence, where there was no pressure on the ball.

If one of the centre halves drops deep, then when Sanchez makes the same run it's a simple ball into feet, on the edge of the area?

 


Employee of the month is a good example of how someone can be both a winner and a loser at the same time.

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 30 Dec 17 4.05pm

Originally posted by Username

Fair enough. I'd say the problem there was the first part of that sentence, where there was no pressure on the ball.

If one of the centre halves drops deep, then when Sanchez makes the same run it's a simple ball into feet, on the edge of the area?

Username

If a centre-half had dropped off then the ball through to Sanchez could have been cut off and cleared.Sanchez got between the defenders who were square on, went past them and was able to control the ball before shooting.

 

chateauferret Flag 30 Dec 17 4.10pm

Originally posted by Willo

Username

If a centre-half had dropped off then the ball through to Sanchez could have been cut off and cleared.Sanchez got between the defenders who were square on, went past them and was able to control the ball before shooting.

Someone bought you FIFA 18 for Christmas, did they?

Pretty easy to say this sort of thing from your armchair. In the case you describe there were a number of options open to the Arsenal forwards and the real problem isn't that someone made a mistake or a wrong decision, but more that throughout the game we allowed too much pressure onto ourselves and against a good side when you do that something at some point is bound to give.

 


============
The Ferret
============

Spiderman Flag Horsham 30 Dec 17 4.16pm

Originally posted by boo909


We've already got one world class player that rolls around on the floor and cries whenever he's tackled, not sure I could handle another.

If you are talking about Wilf you are talking out of your a*** How many games have you seen (live at the ground?)Wilf gets hacked to pieces day in day out with very little protection so he is entitled to complain..you wouldn't see any top 6 players with so little protection. I will add that I was very disappointed by Wilf on Thursday when he continued his complaints at half-time and got booked. I thought Michael Oliver handled it well and could have issued a red.
However please dont accuse Wilf of "rolling around and crying"

 

Username Flag Horsham 30 Dec 17 4.18pm

Originally posted by Willo

Username

If a centre-half had dropped off then the ball through to Sanchez could have been cut off and cleared.Sanchez got between the defenders who were square on, went past them and was able to control the ball before shooting.


But a much easier pass into feet would have been available. As it was, the position of the defenders left Wilshere with a much more difficult option.

Perhaps if our midfield had put more pressure on him, the weight of the pass wouldn't have been so good?

It's like how we sit off, keeping shape and let some players shoot from distance. Most of the time, the ball ends up in the upper tier and it's a good strategy. You just have to accept that sometimes the ball is going to end up in the back of the net regardless.

 


Employee of the month is a good example of how someone can be both a winner and a loser at the same time.

chateauferret Flag 30 Dec 17 4.19pm

Originally posted by Spiderman

If you are talking about Wilf you are talking out of your a*** How many games have you seen (live at the ground?)Wilf gets hacked to pieces day in day out with very little protection so he is entitled to complain..you wouldn't see any top 6 players with so little protection. I will add that I was very disappointed by Wilf on Thursday when he continued his complaints at half-time and got booked. I thought Michael Oliver handled it well and could have issued a red.
However please dont accuse Wilf of "rolling around and crying"

Could have issued a red? Not even Madley would send Wilf off for a first offence of dissent!

 


============
The Ferret
============

Username Flag Horsham 30 Dec 17 4.50pm

Originally posted by chateauferret

Could have issued a red? Not even Madley would send Wilf off for a first offence of dissent!

It wasn't a first offence. He was warned, then get booked and then started clapping Oliver.

Plenty of other refs would have sent him off.

Although to be honest, I assumed the comparison was with Cabaye?

 


Employee of the month is a good example of how someone can be both a winner and a loser at the same time.

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 30 Dec 17 4.56pm

Originally posted by chateauferret

Someone bought you FIFA 18 for Christmas, did they?

Pretty easy to say this sort of thing from your armchair. In the case you describe there were a number of options open to the Arsenal forwards and the real problem isn't that someone made a mistake or a wrong decision, but more that throughout the game we allowed too much pressure onto ourselves and against a good side when you do that something at some point is bound to give.

Tactical knowledge gained from qualifications - first time I have mentioned that on here.

 

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 30 Dec 17 5.01pm

Originally posted by Username


But a much easier pass into feet would have been available. As it was, the position of the defenders left Wilshere with a much more difficult option.

Perhaps if our midfield had put more pressure on him, the weight of the pass wouldn't have been so good?

It's like how we sit off, keeping shape and let some players shoot from distance. Most of the time, the ball ends up in the upper tier and it's a good strategy. You just have to accept that sometimes the ball is going to end up in the back of the net regardless.

We will have to agree to disagree on this one about a pass to feet.

Regards your scond point, the position of the defenders gave Wilshere an easy option. They were square and Wilshere just needed to drop the ball in over them to Sanchez who is quicker than the pair of them.

 

Page 2 of 2 << First< 1 2

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Tactics v Arsenal