You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > FA Cup
November 16 2026 7.53am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

FA Cup


Page 2 of 2 << First< 1 2
boo909 Flag Figeac 02 Jan 18 4.38pm

Originally posted by Ray in Houston


The Palace - Brighton rivalry is about as organic as it gets; having been generated by the fans themselves and not due to any media hype or simple geographic proximity.

If it wasn't, it would've died years ago.

When I first started supporting Palace in the eighties absolutely noone cared about Brighton, Millwall and Charlton were always our main rivals. I'm mainly taking issue with Park Road's "years ago" statement, which is untrue in my experience. The rivalry has mainly been fueled/manufactured by Brighton fans desperate to give their team a bit of depth and history, I mean they even changed their nickname to try and get us to notice them.

Maybe it's just the period I grew up in but I'll always think of Millwall as our main rivals.

Anyway happy new year Ray, always like your posts.

Edited by boo909 (02 Jan 2018 4.48pm)

palace-millwall_3553655k_trans_NvBQzQNjv4BqLZ1bJd-I99VgiaPxe-UMcAxA3pkpuDgkan6Ll2HG7jQ.jpg Attachment: palace-millwall_3553655k_trans_NvBQzQNjv4BqLZ1bJd-I99VgiaPxe-UMcAxA3pkpuDgkan6Ll2HG7jQ.jpg (41.64Kb)

 


Bangell - If Camus wrote The Myth of Sisyphus today, it would be about Jason Puncheon eternally trying and failing to pass with his right foot.

KAOS Flag In a tree 02 Jan 18 5.03pm

Disagree totally. I started supporting Palace in the early 80's and we hated Brighton then. We sang anti Brighton songs all the time. It kicked off when we played them etc etc.

It's only when Millwall came up again mid-ish 80's that we reignited our 'local' rivalry!

Charlton was always lively in the 80's too and fuelled further by the ground share but to dismiss BHA as rivals in the 80's is inaccurate to say the least!

 

alaneagle1 Flag Dunstable,Bedfordshire.England 02 Jan 18 5.12pm

December 6th 1976 at Stamford Bridge was where the Brighton Rivalry started.

 


Palace 13th 2017/18.

boo909 Flag Figeac 02 Jan 18 5.20pm

Originally posted by alaneagle1

December 6th 1976 at Stamford Bridge was where the Brighton Rivalry started.

Yeah Mullery chucking his loose change around. I'm just saying in my experience (must have been mid-eighties as KAOS said) they weren't our main rivals Millwall were and that's always stuck with me, though admittedly I have drunk a lot of booze since those days so my memory could be faulty.

 


Bangell - If Camus wrote The Myth of Sisyphus today, it would be about Jason Puncheon eternally trying and failing to pass with his right foot.

Goldfiinger Flag Just down the road 02 Jan 18 5.29pm

IF we win tonight and get another 3 points on the board then I'd say the team has earned the right to fight for a cup run.

Win tonight and we're well on our way to safety and although our CB should be protected and players rotated I'd still like to think we'd try to win.

 

Park Road Flag 02 Jan 18 5.31pm

Hate the seaweed proper football rivalry
[Link]

 

PA Flag Bedfordshire 02 Jan 18 5.33pm

Be interesting to see which team makes the most changes. I’m going for both teams to make 11 changes each!

 

Goal Machine Flag The Cronx 02 Jan 18 5.46pm

Rest Zaha, Townsend, Cabaye and Luka, they’ve run themselves into the ground recently. Play the rest and try to win and progress.

We’re far too strong to go down this season and will finish about 12th. A cup run will give the last third of the season some excitement

 

Park Road Flag 02 Jan 18 6.02pm

You can go anywhere in the UK and ask any football fan.
Who are Millwall's rivals?
99&#8453; would say West ham without hesitation.

You can go anywhere in bermondsey and they will say the same thing without hesitation.
There are palace who hate Millwall more and there are Charlton who hate palace.
But Brighton are our rivals end of, a unique, proper rivalry that was not manufactured, it was born

 

KAOS Flag In a tree 02 Jan 18 6.05pm

Originally posted by boo909

Yeah Mullery chucking his loose change around. I'm just saying in my experience (must have been mid-eighties as KAOS said) they weren't our main rivals Millwall were and that's always stuck with me, though admittedly I have drunk a lot of booze since those days so my memory could be faulty.

LOL - fair play mate!

My best mate got nicked on Boxing Day against the Weed circa 84/85! Wouldn’t mind but we were only 13/14 lol

Remember Millwall in the AW circa 86/87! Kicked off properly, fans on the pitch, game held up etc! We even tried to run them when we scored but thankfully the police stopped that! Got chased through TH after and had to hide in Prestos or whatever it was called! Very lively! West Ham fan Terry Burns was stabbed to death that evening in Embankment by Millwall who were at the game. There was summat sinister in the air that day ...

 

KAOS Flag In a tree 02 Jan 18 6.11pm

Originally posted by Park Road

You can go anywhere in the UK and ask any football fan.
Who are Millwall's rivals?
99&#8453; would say West ham without hesitation.

You can go anywhere in bermondsey and they will say the same thing without hesitation.
There are palace who hate Millwall more and there are Charlton who hate palace.
But Brighton are our rivals end of, a unique, proper rivalry that was not manufactured, it was born

Agree with most of that. When we play Millwall - these days - it’s a bit of a jolly up for some. There’s no real malice just a local rivalry. That said, when we played them @ the New Den and Ndah took the p1ss they upped the ante! But when I go to Palace / Millwall home or away I end up going with my Wall mates too ... they’re not all scum end of the day!

Charlton are rivals and I hate them. If you were there that day they sent us down at the Valley you’d understand. Weird fans, weird club, weird area!

But for me it’s BHA that pips it! It’s unique and reminds me of the 80’s and what football is all about.

We’re lucky to have 3 very different rivals to choose from based on your own personal experience. Hate them all lol

 

Page 2 of 2 << First< 1 2

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > FA Cup