You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Palace vs Southampton Match Thread
November 16 2026 7.53am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Palace vs Southampton Match Thread


Page 23 of 23 << First< 19 20 21 22 23
kenbarr Flag Jackson Heights, Queens, New York ... 03 Jan 18 11.51pm

The general rule of thumb when it comes to offside is the benefit of the doubt should go to the offense. I guess the pundits for something to justify their pay checks.

 


Divorced...And LOVING it!
VJRAM Rev.
CPFC since Boxing Day 1989 CPFC 2-2 CFC
Gregg Berhalter, US International & USMNT Head Coach
Jill Ellis, England International & Retired USWNT Head Coach
Trevor Francis, International PRAT

dp Flag Tunbridge Wells 04 Jan 18 1.07am

Originally posted by kenbarr

The general rule of thumb when it comes to offside is the benefit of the doubt should go to the offense. I guess the pundits for something to justify their pay checks.

Yes. Even if Benteke might have been marginally closer to the goal than the defender, it can hardly be called a mistake. The ref called it as he saw it, nobody has said he 100% was wrong, just that the call might have gone the other way.

Our turn to enjoy a bit of luck.

 

Ray in Houston Flag Houston 04 Jan 18 3.40pm

Originally posted by steeleye20

I think Tekkers is very fractionally offside for a moment but how do you synchronise that with the moment at which the ball is kicked.

When he heads it he is not in front of a defender so nothing there.

Why, as an official, give anything marginal or unsure?

Because they are human beings under pressure having to give instant decisions.

My idea of a good official would be one who just doesn't give penalties.

Then we can rediscover football?


I watched the replay of the match last night (at least the last 30 minutes which I missed in real time). He was offside for the 1st goal by a fraction, but enough to be seen on the TV. It was enough for a replay official to have chalked that one off, I think.

 


We don't do possession; we do defense and attack. Everything else is just wa**ing with a football.

kenbarr Flag Jackson Heights, Queens, New York ... 04 Jan 18 6.41pm

Originally posted by Ray in Houston


I watched the replay of the match last night (at least the last 30 minutes which I missed in real time). He was offside for the 1st goal by a fraction, but enough to be seen on the TV. It was enough for a replay official to have chalked that one off, I think.

This is why VAR should over-rule only if the evidence is clear. What we don't want is what the NFL has got right now with then is a catch not a catch. We're getting decisions made by a replay official that are taking points off the board for decisions that are based on frame by frame scrutiny. If the video evidence isn't conclusive, and judging by the opinions expressed in this thread it isn't, the original ruling should stand.

 


Divorced...And LOVING it!
VJRAM Rev.
CPFC since Boxing Day 1989 CPFC 2-2 CFC
Gregg Berhalter, US International & USMNT Head Coach
Jill Ellis, England International & Retired USWNT Head Coach
Trevor Francis, International PRAT

dg1937 Flag 04 Jan 18 6.48pm

A bit like in cricket where they have 'umpire's call'. The umpire is only over-ruled if his decision was clearly wrong, if it was only slightly 'wrong' then the umpire's decision stands. Benteke was definitely not clearly offside so the goal would have stood if the cricket system was used.

 

Southampton_Eagle Flag At the after party 04 Jan 18 7.09pm

Not a game for the purist, there's drainage issues at St Mary's which has caused havoc with the pitch, I saw the drainage blokes go in yesterday when I went back to retrieve my keys that went flying un-noticed celebrating Luka's goal. Add to the hoolie that was blowing, the conditions were not conducive to a free flowing game.

Fair play to the players for fighting, well done the Palace fans who were immense as normal & boo to the usual suspects on this thread who believe a match lasts twenty five minutes

 

greenbrook_ Flag Croydon 04 Jan 18 9.34pm

My review of the game, including my player ratings and MOTM, is now available. Listen here: [Link]

 


I run the e-Crystal Palace YouTube channel. Like and Subscribe here: [Link]

Username Flag Horsham 05 Jan 18 9.18am

Originally posted by kenbarr

This is why VAR should over-rule only if the evidence is clear. What we don't want is what the NFL has got right now with then is a catch not a catch. We're getting decisions made by a replay official that are taking points off the board for decisions that are based on frame by frame scrutiny. If the video evidence isn't conclusive, and judging by the opinions expressed in this thread it isn't, the original ruling should stand.

That is technically what is supposed to happen in NFL, except the people doing the reviews seem to have forgotten that crucial bit, especially in recent weeks.

Similarly in rugby and rugby league, the TMO can really only influence a decision based on what he is asked.

If Union, if the referee thinks it's a try, he can ask 'is there any reason I can't award the try', in which case only something clear and obvious can overturn it. If he asks 'Try yes or no' then there needs to be much clearer evidence it WAS scored.

In rugby league the referee tells the TMO what decision he has on the field and again, only clear evidence to the contrary changes the call.

 


Employee of the month is a good example of how someone can be both a winner and a loser at the same time.

BuckinghamshireEagle Flag 05 Jan 18 10.33am

My understanding on this for football is that the video referee will review the footage and refer it back to the referee if he thinks there is a case to overturn a decision. The referee will then look at the footage on a monitor and make a final decision.
It seems to be a more drawn out process, but leaves the final decision with the referee.

Edited by BuckinghamshireEagle (05 Jan 2018 10.34am)

 

Gary St.Andrews Flag Kenley 06 Jan 18 8.15am

Did a proper job on Southampton, or should I call them the ultimate feeder club? Second half there was only one winner and 2-1 flattered the Saints...

 

Page 23 of 23 << First< 19 20 21 22 23

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Palace vs Southampton Match Thread