You are here: Home > Message Board > Football Talk > Another "Hand of God"
November 22 2026 8.03pm

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Another "Hand of God"


kenbarr Flag Jackson Heights, Queens, New York ... 13 Jan 18 7.48pm

Shades of Maradona. Yet another handball goal is given, this time for Watford versus Southampton. An absolutely blatant handball yet neither referee Roger East or the AR see it and Southampton lose 2points as a result. It is no longer a matter of if VAR comes but when due to extremely poor officiating like this. I watched video of the match and East was consistently behind the play and out of position. My question is where are the assessors? Why aren't the match officials being held to the highest possible standards in a league that claims to be the best in the world?

 


Divorced...And LOVING it!
VJRAM Rev.
CPFC since Boxing Day 1989 CPFC 2-2 CFC
Gregg Berhalter, US International & USMNT Head Coach
Jill Ellis, England International & Retired USWNT Head Coach
Trevor Francis, International PRAT

Spiderman Flag Horsham 13 Jan 18 8.24pm

Originally posted by kenbarr

Shades of Maradona. Yet another handball goal is given, this time for Watford versus Southampton. An absolutely blatant handball yet neither referee Roger East or the AR see it and Southampton lose 2points as a result. It is no longer a matter of if VAR comes but when due to extremely poor officiating like this. I watched video of the match and East was consistently behind the play and out of position. My question is where are the assessors? Why aren't the match officials being held to the highest possible standards in a league that claims to be the best in the world?

Well said. Only seen pictures so far how linesman didn't see it is staggering and Southampton players booked for arguing. One picture in Daily Mail shows the linesman with the most arrogant look on his face as player protests...this sums officials up I am afraid

 

chateauferret Flag 14 Jan 18 2.51pm

Seen that on MoTD and an absolutely outrageous piece of refereeing which renders yet another PL result unreliable.

No problem with Saints dropping points though

 


============
The Ferret
============

MKCPFC Flag Spain/MK 18 Jan 18 11.14am

Shame they didn't have VAR because that clears everything up . Oh hang on ....

 

sxp55 Flag South Norwood 18 Jan 18 11.23am

has he been charged? seems like it's just being ignored!?

 


@sxp55555

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 18 Jan 18 11.25am

Originally posted by sxp55

has he been charged? seems like it's just being ignored!?

Just enquiring as to what "Charge" you are thinking of.

 

lefty27 Flag ipswich 18 Jan 18 11.31am

Is diving not deceiving a match official in order to gain an advantage?
Surely punching the ball in the goal is just that!

 

topcat Flag Holmesdale / Surbiton 18 Jan 18 12.32pm

Originally posted by Willo

Just enquiringly as to what "Charge" you are thinking of.

I think misconduct although Henry got away with it against Ireland so I can't see anything happening unless there is (or has been) a rule change.

 


It's 106 miles to Chicago, we got a full tank of gas, half a pack of cigarettes, it's dark... and we're wearing sunglasses.

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 18 Jan 18 12.37pm

Originally posted by lefty27

Is diving not deceiving a match official in order to gain an advantage?
Surely punching the ball in the goal is just that!

I've seen it argued that whilst both Doucoure and Henry handled it was an "Instinctive" reaction and in the case of Doucoure it was mentioned that it could have been an action to prevent his head from being damaged by the keeper.

This is what Dermot Gallagher though of the Doucoure incident :

" I believe,(The referee) is the victim here because he has no chance whatsoever. If you look where the player's head is, he moves his head forward… and the only person who can clearly see that that is handball is the goalkeeper. When you look at it sideways on, when you see the head go forward you cannot be sure at that distance whether he has headed it or not. The only person who knows is the player himself and obviously the goalkeeper "

Graham Poll thought differently and felt that the referee should have spotted the incident.

Edited by Willo (18 Jan 2018 12.49pm)

 

DutchEagleJohan Flag Vlissingen, Netherlands 18 Jan 18 12.48pm

Maybe a percentage of say 98 percent should do and we need a committee of a hundred members. This example to me is very very obvious deceiving and I would think anyone arguing differently has either another agenda or is biassed.
Then I think Willian dived yesterday too. To me the ref was spot on but on the Beeb they all disagree with me so seems I am on my own on that one.

Originally posted by Willo

I've seen it argued that whilst both Doucoure and Henry handled it was an "Instinctive" reaction and in the case of Doucoure it was mentioned that it could have been an action to prevent his head from being damaged by the keeper.

This is what Dermot Gallagher though of the Doucoure incident :

" I believe,(The referee) is the victim here because he has no chance whatsoever. If you look where the player's head is, he moves his head forward… and the only person who can clearly see that that is handball is the goalkeeper. When you look at it sideways on, when you see the head go forward you cannot be sure at that distance whether he has headed it or not. The only person who knows is the player himself and obviously the goalkeeper "

Graham Poll thought differently and felt that the referee should have spooted the incident.

Edited by Willo (18 Jan 2018 12.45pm)


 

chateauferret Flag 18 Jan 18 1.42pm

Originally posted by DutchEagleJohan

Maybe a percentage of say 98 percent should do and we need a committee of a hundred members. This example to me is very very obvious deceiving and I would think anyone arguing differently has either another agenda or is biassed.
Then I think Willian dived yesterday too. To me the ref was spot on but on the Beeb they all disagree with me so seems I am on my own on that one.


Chelsea were diving like submarines yesterday so it's not surprising the ref started throwing the book at them. He didn't exactly take any s*** from Morata either. Pity they didn't get knocked out, they would have deserved it, the cheating tossers.

If they hadn't tried such a blatant dive (Pedro I think?) in the first place Willian might have got more sympathy. I think he was definitely looking for it but if he'd tried to stay upright he'd either have scored or got a pen.

Edited by chateauferret (18 Jan 2018 1.55pm)

 


============
The Ferret
============

DutchEagleJohan Flag Vlissingen, Netherlands 18 Jan 18 2.13pm

I think the tackle is not on his leg but well ahead of it. Then he trails his leg to make the contact. We need to get away from the idea that: going down looking for it is acceptable. I get rather angry when commentators say: there was contact, yes and..... since when is contact synonym for fouling?

Originally posted by chateauferret

Chelsea were diving like submarines yesterday so it's not surprising the ref started throwing the book at them. He didn't exactly take any s*** from Morata either. Pity they didn't get knocked out, they would have deserved it, the cheating tossers.

If they hadn't tried such a blatant dive (Pedro I think?) in the first place Willian might have got more sympathy. I think he was definitely looking for it but if he'd tried to stay upright he'd either have scored or got a pen.

Edited by chateauferret (18 Jan 2018 1.55pm)


 

Stuk Flag Top half 18 Jan 18 2.49pm

I didn't think it was a penalty at the time, and I didn't after any of the replays either. A studio full of strikers was hardly impartial input either.

Only bad thing is that Chelsea now have 2 players banned, and they've got Brighton on Saturday.

 


Optimistic as ever

sxp55 Flag South Norwood 18 Jan 18 2.55pm

Originally posted by topcat

I think misconduct although Henry got away with it against Ireland so I can't see anything happening unless there is (or has been) a rule change.

yeah this was what i was wondering about. he's cheated, thought this would be a ban of some sort.

 


@sxp55555

kenbarr Flag Jackson Heights, Queens, New York ... 18 Jan 18 3.00pm

I figured Sweet Fanny Adams would produce an almooty cick up (don't you love Constable Crabtree) & they came through again. I don't know who has the worst replay system, MLB, NFL, NBA, NHL or FA?

 


Divorced...And LOVING it!
VJRAM Rev.
CPFC since Boxing Day 1989 CPFC 2-2 CFC
Gregg Berhalter, US International & USMNT Head Coach
Jill Ellis, England International & Retired USWNT Head Coach
Trevor Francis, International PRAT

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 18 Jan 18 4.07pm

Originally posted by DutchEagleJohan

I think the tackle is not on his leg but well ahead of it. Then he trails his leg to make the contact. We need to get away from the idea that: going down looking for it is acceptable. I get rather angry when commentators say: there was contact, yes and..... since when is contact synonym for fouling?


Indeed.

There is contact all over the pitch but not every contact is a foul.

 

kenbarr Flag Jackson Heights, Queens, New York ... 28 Jan 18 2.32am

[Link]


Alan Pardew commenting on the use of VAR in the Liverpool 2-3 WBA cup tie The points he raises are those made by many others. Taking three minutes to make a decision is two minutes too long. The flow of the match was ruined. This is the danger of VAR, that officials will rely on it too much and the tempo of the game will be lost. Eventually, it may come to pass that we won't know if a goal is really a goal, just like in the NFL a catch is not a catch if one guy sitting in an office building on Park Avenue, NYC says it isn't. This is not the way forward and if this is the best they can do, junk it.

 


Divorced...And LOVING it!
VJRAM Rev.
CPFC since Boxing Day 1989 CPFC 2-2 CFC
Gregg Berhalter, US International & USMNT Head Coach
Jill Ellis, England International & Retired USWNT Head Coach
Trevor Francis, International PRAT

Pierre Flag Purley 28 Jan 18 3.30pm

Originally posted by kenbarr

[Link]


Alan Pardew commenting on the use of VAR in the Liverpool 2-3 WBA cup tie The points he raises are those made by many others. Taking three minutes to make a decision is two minutes too long. The flow of the match was ruined. This is the danger of VAR, that officials will rely on it too much and the tempo of the game will be lost. Eventually, it may come to pass that we won't know if a goal is really a goal, just like in the NFL a catch is not a catch if one guy sitting in an office building on Park Avenue, NYC says it isn't. This is not the way forward and if this is the best they can do, junk it.

Football VAR needs to look at Rugby where the referee refers decisions he wants clarifying to a video referee. They look at footage from different cameras and angles and makes decision for the referee on the field.
Rugby also show these on the screens in the ground so supporters there are kept involved.
This would help speed up the process and stop the delay for supporters where nothing happens for them!

Also the FA must act to stop players surrounding, harassing and pressurising officials in order to try and influence or overturn decisions.

 

DutchEagleJohan Flag Vlissingen, Netherlands 29 Jan 18 6.15pm

Wise words. It needs some time and evolution. The fact that it on occasions disrupts the flow of the game does not mean VAR in itself is the problem. Many things disrupts the flow of the game, excessive fouling (Huddersfield or Bournemouth at home), feigning Injury, time wasting. Yet we all accept that this is part of the game. Of course 3 mins is way too long, but VAR needs to be used more intensively not disregarded as useless.

Originally posted by Pierre

Football VAR needs to look at Rugby where the referee refers decisions he wants clarifying to a video referee. They look at footage from different cameras and angles and makes decision for the referee on the field.
Rugby also show these on the screens in the ground so supporters there are kept involved.
This would help speed up the process and stop the delay for supporters where nothing happens for them!

Also the FA must act to stop players surrounding, harassing and pressurising officials in order to try and influence or overturn decisions.

 


You are here: Home > Message Board > Football Talk > Another "Hand of God"