You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > top 5 palace goalkeepers
November 16 2026 7.42am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

top 5 palace goalkeepers


Page 3 of 3 << First< 1 2 3
monkey Flag Sittingbourne,but made in Bromley 26 Jan 18 4.09pm

Nigel Martyn
Julian Speroni
John Burridge
Gabor Kiraly
Paul Hammond

Quite often a keeper is only as good as the defence in front of him, I’ve always had Nigel Martyn as my all time number 1, but he did have the benefit of having the superb Andy Thorn and Eric The Ninja in front of him for a time, Jules hasn’t had that luxury and has had some clowns in front of him, but has still single handedly kept us in games and won us points in the past despite the handicap, but then I suppose Nige wasn’t always that lucky either.

Paul Hammond made my list simply because he was the keeper when I first started going and when you’re a kid you like everyone John Jackson was just before my time

 

Pompyeagle Flag Gosport Hants 26 Jan 18 4.36pm

Early / mid sixties Tony Millington Welsh international I believe (Welsh GoalKeeper I'll get my coat)

 

YT Flag Oxford 26 Jan 18 4.39pm

Originally posted by kenbarr

After going down 1, Nigel Martyn was shown a straight red card by referee David Elleray for a foul outside the box. However, with the score knotted at one after a Bright shot creeped over the line, the Dons Terry Phelan handled a Mark Bright shot on the line, which resulted in his sending off on the "Maradona" rule. The resulting penalty was converted by Andy Gray to give Palace a 2-1 lead. Then Wimbledon lost another man to a second bookable offence and Palace widened its lead to 3-1 before NBC's pundit Robbie Earle pulled one back with a free header that Salako could only watch. With time running down, the Don's super-sub, Alan Cork (dad of Jack) had a dead cert equaliser saved by the quick right arm of Salako, earning chants of "England's Number 1" from the Selhurst faithful. The fixture ended 3-2 to Palace, repeating the fireworks of the previous year's home fixture, also won by Palace 4-3.

I can’t remember which of the 2 Wimbledon games it was, but at one of them John Fashanu (somewhat inexplicably in my view) got loads of “stick” from the crowd as a response to his brother having just come out as gay (or was he revealed as gay? I can’t exactly remember). It wasn’t very pleasant, I’m afraid.

Anyway:
1) our best goalie in my time as a fan was John Jackson
2) my Dad took my sister and me to Stamford Bridge on Boxing Day 1970 (year needs to be checked) when Dave Webb played the whole match in goal. As I recall it, Steve Sherwood was endeavouring to get to the game but didn’t make it in time.
3) my sister only ever went to one other football match. I can’t check the year at the moment, but it was Palace v Charlton and Jerry Murphy scored

 


Palace since 19 August 1972. Palace 1 (Tony Taylor) Liverpool 1 (Emlyn Hughes)

saveloy Flag carmarthen 26 Jan 18 4.59pm

Originally posted by MabbsWasKing

For me
1 Jackson
2 Martyn
3 Barron
4 Kiraly
5 Speroni

Before anyone jumps down my throat over Barron. I know that he was part of the deal where we lost Kenny but he did have a couple of great seasons and was Player Of The Year in 82. He also sat on the England bench a few times when at Rangers.

Interesting thing is, although I can’t comment on Jacko joining as before my time, all the others looked dreadful for their first half dozen games or so....including Nige!

Thought Barron was awful,are you sure he was on the bench for England?

 

kenbarr Flag Jackson Heights, Queens, New York ... 26 Jan 18 5.09pm

Originally posted by YT

I can’t remember which of the 2 Wimbledon games it was, but at one of them John Fashanu (somewhat inexplicably in my view) got loads of stick from the crowd as a response to his brother having just come out as gay (or was he revealed as gay. I can’t exactly remember). It wasn’t very pleasant, I’m afraid.

Anyway:
1) our best goalie in my time as a fan was John Jackson
2) my Dad took my sister and me to Stamford Bridge on Boxing Day 1970 (year needs to be checked) when Dave Webb played the whole match in goal. As I recall it, Steve Sherwood was endeavouring to get to the game but didn’t make it in time.
3) my sister only ever went to one other football match. I can’t check the year at the moment, but it was Palace v Charlton and Jerry Murphy scored

That was the 4-3 classic played in October 1990. It was broadcast the next day on ITV as "The London Match" and Brian Moore called it one of the great matches of the season. The build-up was dominated by the pundits saying it would boring with a comment made that only the physios would get a workout. John Fashanu got tremendous and in my view unfair stick for his brother Justin coming out as gay. I think the wolf whistles and other nonsense led to his creating an absolute cracker of a goal, a chip from the right top of the 18 over and across a stranded Nigel Martyn and into the left side netting. It was a see-saw match, with Wimbledon opening the scoring through Stuart Magee only for Geoff Thomas to equalise with a trademark power header Andy Gray scored the third for Palace from a very intelligent knock-down header by Mark Bright, who scored the winning fourth goal (why isn't he a manager?). John Humphrey also scored in that match from a rebound. Stuart Magee added a second and The Dons third before the final whistle. For a YouTube highlights video, go to:

[Link]

All seven goals were really of the highest quality, both in build up and finishing. When the Eagles and the Dons got together, plenty of really good football was played. Take that, Jeff Powell, you footballing illiterate!

Edited by kenbarr (26 Jan 2018 5.49pm)

 


Divorced...And LOVING it!
VJRAM Rev.
CPFC since Boxing Day 1989 CPFC 2-2 CFC
Gregg Berhalter, US International & USMNT Head Coach
Jill Ellis, England International & Retired USWNT Head Coach
Trevor Francis, International PRAT

YT Flag Oxford 26 Jan 18 5.29pm

Originally posted by kenbarr

That was the 4-3 classic played in October 1990. It was broadcast the next day on ITV as "The London Match" and Brian Moore called it one of the great matches of the season. The build-up was dominated by the pundits saying it would boring with a comment made that only the physios would get a workout. John Fashanu got tremendous and in my view unfair stick for his brother Justin coming out as gay. I think the wold whistles and other nonsense led to his creating an absolute cracker of a goal, a chip from the right top of the 18 over and across a stranded Nigel Martyn and into the left side netting. It was a see-saw match, with Wimbledon opening the scoring through Stuart Magee only for Geoff Thomas to equalise with a trademark power header Andy Gray scored the third for Palace from a very intelligent knock-down header by Mark Bright, who scored the winning fourth goal (why isn't he a manager?). John Humphrey also scored in that match from a rebound. Stuart Magee added a second and The Dons third before the final whistle. For a YouTube highlights video, go to:

[Link]

All seven goals were really of the highest quality, both in build up and finishing. When the Eagles and the Dons got together, plenty of really good football was played. Take that, Jeff Powell, you footballing illiterate!

Happy memories (re the 4-3). Unfortunately, there was a lot worse than wolf-whistles aimed at Fash. But I have to say that he took it all and - as you say - it seemed to spur him on.

 


Palace since 19 August 1972. Palace 1 (Tony Taylor) Liverpool 1 (Emlyn Hughes)

kenbarr Flag Jackson Heights, Queens, New York ... 26 Jan 18 5.52pm

Originally posted by YT

Happy memories (re the 4-3). Unfortunately, there was a lot worse than wolf-whistles aimed at Fash. But I have to say that he took it all and - as you say - it seemed to spur him on.

You're absolutely right. I've managed to block out the really nasty stuff. I remember escorting a few of our more "intelligent supporters" out of the Arthur Wait and The Croydon Advertiser terrace (Whitehorse) for making really high class remarks. As Pink Floyd once observed, "No dark scarcasm in the classroom..."

 


Divorced...And LOVING it!
VJRAM Rev.
CPFC since Boxing Day 1989 CPFC 2-2 CFC
Gregg Berhalter, US International & USMNT Head Coach
Jill Ellis, England International & Retired USWNT Head Coach
Trevor Francis, International PRAT

pssguy Flag 26 Jan 18 6.04pm

I think Martyn just edges it over Jackson on athleticism

It was not just us that hold him in high regard

Leeds
"On 10 April 2006, he was voted as part of Leeds United's greatest team being the only player from after the Revie era to be part of the team.[5]"

Everton
"David Moyes said that he would miss Martyn as he was his "greatest ever signing".

As I stated above, in 1970 when Jackson was in his prime, Ramsey did not even rate hism in his top 6 English goalies (though he was mistaken)

 

Crystal_Clear Flag Belfast 26 Jan 18 6.38pm

My experience only goes as back as far as John Burridge as a youngster.

But in that time, I would echo the sentiments about Matt Clarke. He was class, and such a shame his career was cut short by injury.

I think Chris Day was one of the poorer keepers I saw at Selhurst.

 

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 26 Jan 18 6.51pm

Originally posted by Crystal_Clear

My experience only goes as back as far as John Burridge as a youngster.

But in that time, I would echo the sentiments about Matt Clarke. He was class, and such a shame his career was cut short by injury.

I think Chris Day was one of the poorer keepers I saw at Selhurst.

Chris Day is goalkeeping coach at Stevenage.

 

ARGILE OLD GEEZER Flag PORTIMAO 26 Jan 18 7.24pm

Originally posted by Bud

I thought it was Norman hunter Jacko had ago at but it was a long time ago now. it was him that did Craven he was one dirty B.

The whole Leeds team were, every one of them, coached by Don Revie

 

ARGILE OLD GEEZER Flag PORTIMAO 26 Jan 18 7.36pm

Originally posted by Uphill

There is little point in comparing keepers of John Jackson's era with modern keepers.

In those days, the goalmouth was often a bog, the ball was heavier and keepers were fair game for the bustling all-arms and elbows barging tactics of contemporary centre forwards. They got little protection from referees and had to be courageous (it was often said at the time that all keepers must be mad)

I have watched videos of Jackson when he moved on to Leyton Orient and still wonder at the almost miraculous stops and saves he made. I also had the pleasure of watching Vic Rouse when he was capped for Wales in the old third division south.

Jackson and Johnny Byrne remain our best Palace players. It is a shame they were from a now far gone era (like me!)[/quote

Yeah, me too, its a shame that almost no records remain from those days, i bit with Jacko, but nothing of Byrne.
Well, at least we did get to see them and remember them

 

johnmcormick8 Flag Brundish 26 Jan 18 7.49pm

Quite Right Jacko would have dealt with muller

Originally posted by glazedallover

England did not have a couple of better keepers at the time of ‘Jacko’. If Sir Alf had picked him instead of bonetti for the 1970 world cup as number two to Banks, we would not have lost to West Germany, and that little s*** Gerd Mueller would have been smashed all over the penalty area!

 

charliehub Flag newforest 26 Jan 18 8.01pm

John Jackson. Absolutely No.1. Then Nigel M. After that it doesn't matter too much. But John McCormick - the big guy! - is that you? Sorry if slightly off topic, but big John and Roger Hynd in front of Jacko...that was good.

 

johnmcormick8 Flag Brundish 26 Jan 18 8.09pm

Sadly Big John passed away last year. A much loved husband,father grandfather. I use his name to honour him and the Glazers because,as boy of 10 standing on the Homesdale,along John Swell Colin Taylor,John Jackson,Roger Hynd and the all rest from 69-74 And taught me what was to be a man.

Originally posted by charliehub

John Jackson. Absolutely No.1. Then Nigel M. After that it doesn't matter too much. But John McCormick - the big guy! - is that you? Sorry if slightly off topic, but big John and Roger Hynd in front of Jacko...that was good.

 

YT Flag Oxford 26 Jan 18 8.54pm

Originally posted by Crystal_Clear

My experience only goes as back as far as John Burridge as a youngster.

But in that time, I would echo the sentiments about Matt Clarke. He was class, and such a shame his career was cut short by injury.

I think Chris Day was one of the poorer keepers I saw at Selhurst.

So you’ve been watching Palace since the 1940s then!

 


Palace since 19 August 1972. Palace 1 (Tony Taylor) Liverpool 1 (Emlyn Hughes)

Vaibow Flag vancouver/croydon 27 Jan 18 3.38am

My Era, has to be:

1.Martyn
2.Speroni
3.Kiarly
4.Clarke (shame about the injury)
5. Nash

 


This was once a quality forum....

ta11berg Flag birmingham 27 Jan 18 7.19am

The first match I saw was one of Bill Glazers last before transferring to Coventry. He made a huge impression on me,seemed like superman,always in flight somewhere over his defence. Of course Jacko came in to a cool reception(follow that) but soon became a massive hero,often singlehandedly keeping us in the game. These 2 keepers will always be my favorites,Kiraly and Speroni both deserve a place up there. Afraid I missed the Martyn years completely so not judging him

 

aashman12 Flag 27 Jan 18 8.32am

Originally posted by Frickin Saweet

1. Martin
2. Speroni
3. Kiraly (almost put him second)

It's really then a case of the best of the rest in my time of watching Palace. Hmmm

4. Perry Suckling
5. Jimmy Glass

Jimmy glass????

 

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 27 Jan 18 8.38am

Originally posted by aashman12

Jimmy glass????

I don't recall Jimmy Glass ever playing for our first team.

He is best remembered for coming up for a corner in the dying embers of the game and scoring for Carlisle to keep them in the league.

 

Page 3 of 3 << First< 1 2 3

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > top 5 palace goalkeepers