This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
So who's getting worried?
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
Willo South coast - west of Brighton. 28 Jan 18 11.32am |
|
|
There has been a certain degree of criticism about our transfer activity in this 'Window'.
We are now 27 days into the 'Window' there are 20 PL clubs and I think there have only been 20-25 signings by PL clubs and quite a few are 'Loans' and not significant signings in terms of profile.
We don't leave our transfer activity to the end by design. The whole process can be highly convoluted and frustrating with so many factors entering an ever complex equation and negotiations can be drawn out for weeks and even months.
|
alaneagle1 Dunstable,Bedfordshire.England 28 Jan 18 11.39am |
|
Originally posted by Willo
There has been a certain degree of criticism about our transfer activity in this 'Window'.
We are now 27 days into the 'Window' there are 20 PL clubs and I think there have only been 20-25 signings by PL clubs and quite a few are 'Loans' and not significant signings in terms of profile.
We don't leave our transfer activity to the end by design. The whole process can be highly convoluted and frustrating with so many factors entering an ever complex equation and negotiations can be drawn out for weeks and even months.
Agreed Willo 20 signings. By Liverpool,Leicester,Huddersfield,Everton,Chelsea,Burnley,Stoke,Brighton,Man Utd,Arsenal,newcastle,Burnley,West Ham,Southampton and last but not least Crystal Palace.
Palace 13th 2017/18.
|
Mwncisee Middlesbrough 28 Jan 18 11.41am |
|
Originally posted by Willo
There has been a certain degree of criticism about our transfer activity in this 'Window'.
We are now 27 days into the 'Window' there are 20 PL clubs and I think there have only been 20-25 signings by PL clubs and quite a few are 'Loans' and not significant signings in terms of profile.
We don't leave our transfer activity to the end by design. The whole process can be highly convoluted and frustrating with so many factors entering an ever complex equation and negotiations can be drawn out for weeks and even months.
Agree with this. It's easy for us all to get nervous and bemoan what we do as that is where all our focus is on. However, if you look at othe clubs in the lower half of the table I've not seen the likes of Swansea, West Brom, Stoke, Huddersfield, Newcastle or Bournemouth be able to make any significant signings yet. I'm sure their fans are also bemoaning their lack of activity in the window.
|
hastingseagle67 28 Jan 18 12.44pm |
|
|
The problem is with the power held by the players and agents. It is easy to go out and buy the likes of Jach early in the window because nobody else is really in for them. If we were to go out and buy 5 unheard of players and do all our business before deadline day, Palace fans would lose their sh*t. When talking about the better known names like Dembele for example, we may well have offered a decent contract, but there is no way that his agent is going to let him sign it until the last minute in case a better offer comes along. This is where the natural pecking order comes into play. If Chelsea or Liverpool and probably even West Ham and Leicester decides they wanted Dembele, we would probably miss out on him, so that’s when you hope that you have had discussions with the next player on the list, and that if West Ham have pinched Dembele you hope that Leicester don’t pinch your next target. Eventually you will sign someone though and it will probably be someone that Brighton or Huddersfield were hoping to get.. I hear people saying , well just go out and pay big money to secure him, but personally I still think that the agent would advise his player to hang on until the last minute.
has resisted writing a single post on the Ross McCormack thread !!!
|
Eaglecoops CR3 28 Jan 18 12.50pm |
|
Originally posted by hastingseagle67
The problem is with the power held by the players and agents. It is easy to go out and buy the likes of Jach early in the window because nobody else is really in for them. If we were to go out and buy 5 unheard of players and do all our business before deadline day, Palace fans would lose their sh*t. When talking about the better known names like Dembele for example, we may well have offered a decent contract, but there is no way that his agent is going to let him sign it until the last minute in case a better offer comes along. This is where the natural pecking order comes into play. If Chelsea or Liverpool and probably even West Ham and Leicester decides they wanted Dembele, we would probably miss out on him, so that’s when you hope that you have had discussions with the next player on the list, and that if West Ham have pinched Dembele you hope that Leicester don’t pinch your next target. Eventually you will sign someone though and it will probably be someone that Brighton or Huddersfield were hoping to get.. I hear people saying , well just go out and pay big money to secure him, but personally I still think that the agent would advise his player to hang on until the last minute.
I was actually hoping we would buy more unknowns like Jach, primarily because that's where the value is in transfers and secondly, as you rightly say, there is very little competition for them. Yes, a marque signing would be lovely, but at what cost and would they actually be that much better than a hidden gem from abroad or the lower leagues? We are relying on Dougie to find us these gems and I'm rather suprised he hasn't unearthed at least one forward as of yet.
|
Lyons550 Shirley 28 Jan 18 5.50pm |
|
|
Sometimes you get players that people follow others opinion on rather than make a balanced opinion of their own based on the players actual performances. Mutch is one of these...rarely had a bad game...rarely turned possession over unlike others but he would always be a squad player...sometimes a club and a player dont 'fit'
The Voice of Reason In An Otherwise Mediocre World
|
Kant exeter 28 Jan 18 6.01pm |
|
|
Unless those who are criticising our transfer dealings are happy to see us pay inflated prices then unfortunately the last minute flurry of activity in the final hours of the window is a commercial inevitability.
While purchasing clubs would all prefer to ‘do their business early’ selling clubs frustrate this by inflating the asking price. You can’t blame them for it, but it then encourages a game of brinkmanship. The usual outcome among reasonable parties is that all sides make compromises to reach a negotiated solution as the clock ticks down. Sometimes a party will act unreasonably, or push their negotiating position too far, and the deal breaks down.
For as long as there is a transfer deadline, commercial realities will dictate that a significant number of deals won’t take place until the eleventh hour.
So don’t criticise SP or the club; we are simply at the mercy of an immutable law of business.
|
Mwncisee Middlesbrough 28 Jan 18 6.21pm |
|
Originally posted by Kant
Unless those who are criticising our transfer dealings are happy to see us pay inflated prices then unfortunately the last minute flurry of activity in the final hours of the window is a commercial inevitability.
While purchasing clubs would all prefer to ‘do their business early’ selling clubs frustrate this by inflating the asking price. You can’t blame them for it, but it then encourages a game of brinkmanship. The usual outcome among reasonable parties is that all sides make compromises to reach a negotiated solution as the clock ticks down. Sometimes a party will act unreasonably, or push their negotiating position too far, and the deal breaks down.
For as long as there is a transfer deadline, commercial realities will dictate that a significant number of deals won’t take place until the eleventh hour.
So don’t criticise SP or the club; we are simply at the mercy of an immutable law of business.
I think this is a very balanced and accurate appraisal of the situation.
May also need to consider that we might be a victim of our own success as we gave done better than we expected with what we gave at the moment compared to where we were after 7 games. Consciously or not that could take to edge off urgency and encourage the leadership to take longer and be a bit more cautious (rightly or wrongly).
With regards to the desperation to sign a keeper this is very muddied at the moment due to it seeming very probable we have signed Guiata but it's a question as to if we pay 8mill Euros to get him for the rest of this season or at the end for free.
|
Tyrelli London 28 Jan 18 9.04pm |
|
|
From Sky
PALACE IN FOR BARNES
Sky Sports News understands Crystal Palace are considering a move for Burnley striker Ashley Barnes
The Eagles have been trying to sign first-choice target Khouma Babacar but are yet to reach an agreement with Fiorentina.
Roy Hodgson has between £10m and £12m to spend on a striker this month and they are down to their final two options of the window.
Burnley would be reluctant to sell Barnes, who has 18 months left on his contract. Nevertheless, we are told Palace could approach Burnley in the next 48 hours.
Oh dear ... doesn’t sound great does it (I know media rubbish) but this is how we are being portrait in the media
|
MonsterMunch Cambridge 30 Jan 18 10.51am |
|
|
I really hope we are going to pull a couple of rabbits out the hat. Frustrating to see our rivals being able to get business done. Got a horrible feeling we are going to be getting noting but Parish's stock comments about difficult window, wages are tight, what if the sun doesnt come up etc.
|
Maine Eagle USA 30 Jan 18 2.16pm |
|
|
Parish won’t suddenly change. Look at the Mamadou Sakho transfer fiasco. Unfortunately we also have the Tosun and Niasse fiascos where we actually didn’t get the signing done and then had no time to sort something else out, particularly Niasse which collapsed at the last minute. If you listen to Parish on FYP a couple of weeks ago he says very clearly that he doesn’t believe you can sign strikers except on the last day of the window, other clubs seem to find a way, but not us, as the striker market is very tough, as per Parish. I don’t doubt it is tough, but it’s the same for everyone else also. So here we go again, Parish up to his old tricks, refusing to believe you can get value on a striker except on the last day of the window, and when it all falls through like the Niasse deal, we are left in the lurch once again with only 1 striker.
Trump lost. Badly. Hahahahahahaha.
|
Osvaldo Epsom 30 Jan 18 3.28pm |
|
|
what worries me is that everyone we've been interested in has gone somewhere else and if it carries on tomorrow we will be back to square one! We've always got Benteke! Remember him, the only forward we've got other than Ladapo!
|
Willo South coast - west of Brighton. 30 Jan 18 3.47pm |
|
|
A defeat to W.Ham tonight, no new striker and what is felt by the supporters is a 'Poor Window' and I suspect supporters will be somewhat incandescent with rage.
|
Rudi Hedman Caterham 30 Jan 18 3.56pm |
|
Originally posted by Willo
A defeat to W.Ham tonight, no new striker and what is felt by the supporters is a 'Poor Window' and I suspect supporters will be somewhat incandescent with rage.
If Benteke stays on the floor longer than 2 seconds the camera fixed on Parish is what we'll be seeing. Could be for the rest of the season if the last hour tactic on a position with only one player fails again.
Benteke certainly won't be busting a gut if we fail again, due to lack of competition and safety to keep himself available.
COYP
|
CPFC1965 Warrington 30 Jan 18 3.57pm |
|
|
I envisage no new signings and Hodgson leaving in the summer and being replaced with Freedman.
|
leejaneagles 30 Jan 18 5.23pm |
|
|
Why didn't we get our backup striker in FFS? And I don't mean Murray.
We need a top striker to challenge Benteke or on occasion play with Benteke and a back up striker.
Get ANY striker with a half decent record in the Championship or someone on the bench for other Prem clubs (in the mould of Glen Murray if not Glenn himself) and get that done first week of the Window.
Leave it this late to get the main target. Not the bloody backup.
|
alaneagle1 Dunstable,Bedfordshire.England 30 Jan 18 5.34pm |
|
Originally posted by Willo
A defeat to W.Ham tonight, no new striker and what is felt by the supporters is a 'Poor Window' and I suspect supporters will be somewhat incandescent with rage.
Yes,then on the other hand the current 11 might Win. And Holers will be happy.
Palace 13th 2017/18.
|
Brentmiester_General Front line in the battle against t... 30 Jan 18 6.00pm |
|
|
If that radio show Tweet is to be believed, Parish isn’t happy with Roy’s/Dougie’s shortlist. Perhaps that’s why there’s been no strikers signed yet.
Edited by Brentmiester_General (30 Jan 2018 6.01pm)
"We love you Palace, we f@cking hate Man U, We love you Palace, we hate the brighton too, We love you Palace we play in red 'n' blue, so f@ck you, and you ...
|
MikeCrete Crete 30 Jan 18 6.42pm |
|
Originally posted by Brentmiester_General
If that radio show Tweet is to be believed, Parish isn’t happy with Roy’s/Dougie’s shortlist. Perhaps that’s why there’s been no strikers signed yet.
Edited by Brentmiester_General (30 Jan 2018 6.01pm)
Uhm, let the people who's job is it to get the players in get on with it; too much interference, we hav ebeen down this road before & it generally costs us ££ to replace the manager etc, which leaves less ££ for the transfers. Lessons do ,not seem to have been learnt.
|