You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Bemused
November 16 2026 7.41am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Bemused


Page 3 of 3 << First< 1 2 3
Painter Flag Croydon 11 Feb 18 3.53pm

Originally posted by spartakev2

Game was lost after 3rd goal went in. Should have bought rakip on for a run out and given cabaye/macarthur a rest. Nothing to loose.

We haven't a game for 16 days, whats the point in resting them. I think Rakip and Jach arent up to Premier fitness yet, Rakip on the bench as a last resort yesterday.

 

Direwolf Flag Lincoln 11 Feb 18 4.19pm

Originally posted by Rudi Hedman

Not heading the ball that came down from above him after Tomkins connected would prove Mensah is not a centre half for the English leagues. That was truly pathetic and pathetic isn't a word that should describe a CB in this league. Head that ball away and they don't score. Simple as that. A mistake of not doing anything is pretty difficult to forgive and it's arguably lack of ability in, or understanding the role of, a centre back, than a 'mistake.'

Also his defensive work vs Newcastle was poor. Complacency towards his marking and duties vs his marker. Too far away from him and when he went over to meet him in possession it was slow, late and too far away. They scored and created chances from this.

Good in possession for a full back. Not good enough without possession. And he's had a bit of a run in the team too.

Personally I would argue that Tomkins was to blame as he should have headed it away properly in the first place rather than nodding it up in the air.

 

Yellow Card - User has been warned of conduct on the messageboards berlinpalace Flag berlin 11 Feb 18 5.47pm

If he had shuffled the pack for the last ten and we let in another goal or two while everyone was working out who they were marking, then what?
We really should've been back in it after the second one went in and although it might have been tempting to chuck some fresh legs on I'm assuming Roy saw enough to believe we might still claw one or two back.
I suspect we might see a bit more of the other two lads once their English is up to scratch.

 

PZ Eagle Flag Penzance 11 Feb 18 7.09pm

Originally posted by TheExpatEagle

Erm... Unless you can provide proof that I have slated Pardew for making subs then kindly direct your drivel elsewhere.

I understand tactics just fine, maybe you should try to understand tactics yourself because as we saw, leaving things the same resulted in a 3-1 loss. Not to mention the previous 6 games which also resulted in a 4-1 spanking at Arsenal.

If you are getting a beating why not change things around, give someone a run out, try a different idea?

You seem to be more clueless than those you are berating.

What level of football have you played?

When the game is lost why bring on substitutes for the sake of it. All our players should be fit enough to last 90 minutes otherwise they shouldn't be in the team in the first place. Perhaps you should learn some manners instead of accusing other people of posting drivel.

 


Conjunctivitis.com - A site for sore eyes.

Rachid Rachid Rachid Flag 11 Feb 18 7.23pm

Bit puerile arguing about subs when we’re 3 zip down but the number of times we’ve scored (or should have scored) in the dying moments this season suggests Roy knows what he’s doing. Both subs scored against Watford IIRC.

 

michaelpearce Flag grays 11 Feb 18 7.39pm

Originally posted by MonsterMunch

As many have already said I reckon he’s sticking two fingers up to Steve, Dougie & co.

So going by what you are saying is Roy has deliberately lost a game to prove a point, in that case i want him sacked now and get someone in who does things for the club not himself,Or you just making things up because you dont like the people who put there millions in to you club

 

askyourself Flag 11 Feb 18 7.49pm

I think Roy is one of the most professional managers around these days.
He may well have contemplated trying a sub or two but on a bitterly cold day, introducing cold muscles may have been risky.
The best 11 were on the field, if they could last, leave them on.
Thought our new lad, Alexander had an excellent debut. Sakho hopefully will be back for the next one.....
..... perhaps some luck as well.
COYP !

 


We move in the direction of our thoughts.
Just think a little.

MonsterMunch Flag Cambridge 11 Feb 18 7.52pm

Originally posted by michaelpearce

So going by what you are saying is Roy has deliberately lost a game to prove a point, in that case i want him sacked now and get someone in who does things for the club not himself,Or you just making things up because you dont like the people who put there millions in to you club

Not too sure what you are on about. Who’s saying he deliberately tried to lose a game? Are you pissed?

 

01CPFC Flag central coast NSW (The Mariners Mi... 11 Feb 18 8.07pm

Originally posted by Eaglecoops

Can't argue with anything here. Nothing to lose when you are that far behind. Definitely would have tried out Rakip for Cabaye otherwise as a loan signing it is a waste of time (unless of course he is not fit, or not considered good enough) in which case its a bit worrying as to why we took him in the first place.

Exactly what I posted in the Rakip thread,
what was the point of loaning him if there is no option to buy,and he appears to be just a last resort bench sitter.Who approved this ineffective loan.
COYP

 


Where is the Joker shown, I haven't used it ?

michaelpearce Flag grays 11 Feb 18 8.17pm

Originally posted by MonsterMunch

Not too sure what you are on about. Who’s saying he deliberately tried to lose a game? Are you pissed?

your the one who said he didnt make changes to stick two fingers up to upstairs,so its a deliberate act to bring a poor result or dont you read what you right when your pissed

 

MonsterMunch Flag Cambridge 11 Feb 18 8.38pm

Originally posted by michaelpearce

your the one who said he didnt make changes to stick two fingers up to upstairs,so its a deliberate act to bring a poor result or dont you read what you right when your pissed

Yep I was intimating Roy’s a match fixer. You heard here first. I’d have an early night Mike if I were you. You’ve had a shocker.

 

michaelpearce Flag grays 11 Feb 18 8.52pm

Originally posted by MonsterMunch

Yep I was intimating Roy’s a match fixer. You heard here first. I’d have an early night Mike if I were you. You’ve had a shocker.

OK so now your saying he wasnt sticking up his fingers, make up your mind either he was or wasnt or is that to hard for you to work out

 

MonsterMunch Flag Cambridge 11 Feb 18 8.59pm

Originally posted by michaelpearce

OK so now your saying he wasnt sticking up his fingers, make up your mind either he was or wasnt or is that to hard for you to work out

Haha right you are definitely pissed.

So let me get this straight. My assumption that because Roy made no substitutions as a message to the board even at 3-0 down means I believe Roy is trying to throw a premier league game?


 

michaelpearce Flag grays 11 Feb 18 9.22pm

Originally posted by MonsterMunch

Haha right you are definitely pissed.

So let me get this straight. My assumption that because Roy made no substitutions as a message to the board even at 3-0 down means I believe Roy is trying to throw a premier league game?


you was insinuating that he didnt make substitutions as in protest of who we brought or didnt, correct,so was Roy sticking two fingers up or maybe believed we could still get a better result with those on the pitch I go with Roy trusting who he had on the pitch,because its not in his character to do something like that

 

chateauferret Flag 11 Feb 18 9.35pm

Surely anyone who thinks Hodgson makes tactical decisions or substitutions (or non-substitutions) for reasons such as "wanting to make a point to the Board", "being pi**ed off with the transfer window" or "to stick his fingers up at Parish" is greatly underestimating the man.

Hodgson is more than capable of telling the Board what he thinks without jeopardising our chances of winning points and he has far more integrity than a manager who would consider acting in that ridiculous manner.

FFS.

 


============
The Ferret
============

MonsterMunch Flag Cambridge 11 Feb 18 10.02pm

Originally posted by chateauferret

Surely anyone who thinks Hodgson makes tactical decisions or substitutions (or non-substitutions) for reasons such as "wanting to make a point to the Board", "being pi**ed off with the transfer window" or "to stick his fingers up at Parish" is greatly underestimating the man.

Hodgson is more than capable of telling the Board what he thinks without jeopardising our chances of winning points and he has far more integrity than a manager who would consider acting in that ridiculous manner.

FFS.

Like Guardiola naming 5 subs you mean? Don’t be so naive.
I may be way off but there has to be some reason behind Roys refusal to bring on a sub, if only to protect the players on the field he does actually value. It’s very odd, there’s something behind it surely.

Edited by MonsterMunch (11 Feb 2018 10.03pm)

 

Aray Flag South London 12 Feb 18 1.24pm

Originally posted by MonsterMunch

Like Guardiola naming 5 subs you mean? Don’t be so naive.
I may be way off but there has to be some reason behind Roys refusal to bring on a sub, if only to protect the players on the field he does actually value. It’s very odd, there’s something behind it surely.

Edited by MonsterMunch (11 Feb 2018 10.03pm)

It is odd but this is a man who does have some odd managerial ticks. I mean who would have Kane taking corners? In fact who would let Cabaye continue to take any of our dead ball plays...Now dont get me wrong - I think he deserves the freedom of Croydon or summat for his work so far this season but not bringing on Reiderwald for Jimmy Mac or Cabaye made no sense to me.

 

Page 3 of 3 << First< 1 2 3

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Bemused