You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Cabaye
November 16 2026 7.42am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Cabaye


Page 3 of 3 << First< 1 2 3
Seagles Flag Croydon 12 Feb 18 1.00pm

Originally posted by Trollo

His pass accuracy in terms of % might be impressive but stats can be misleading.

I recall the Cabaye of old at Newcastle and admired his ability. Im afraid the passing of time has blunted his effectiveness when playing over 90 mins and I suspect that in the main our supporters will conclude that he hasn't lived up to expectations.

A recent post mentioned that he only had the fitness to last 30 mins - I can understand where this is coming from and I did mention that he would be useful coming off the bench in the last 20 mins against flagging opposition.At the moment Hodgson has no option but to start Cabaye.

Yes I was discussing Cabaye on my allotment this morning with Fred who grows the best runner beans in Brighton & he said, Cabaye can`t kick with his left foot, he can`t head the ball, he can`t tackle & he doesn`t score many goals. Apart from that he`s all right.

MKCPFC, is that you? Lol!

Edited by Seagles (12 Feb 2018 10.43pm)

 

JtCpfc Flag 12 Feb 18 1.01pm

Originally posted by Eaglecoops

Agreed, you actually notice more when he's not in the team and you realise then how much we need him.

Precisely this.

 

The_postman Flag Forest Row 12 Feb 18 1.09pm


Cabaye is most effective when the opposition has the ball. His defensive stats are impressive with 2.5 interceptions per game (ranked 2nd in the league behind James Tompkins) and 2.1 tackles per game. He may not be the play maker that many expected/hoped him to be but his contribution as a defensive midfield player is undeniable.

 

Uphill Flag Bedford 12 Feb 18 1.33pm

According to the Times weekly stats, Cabaye has the second highest number of interceptions in the PL.

We all note his average to poor corner kicks (Puncheon was even worse) so maybe it is time for a change.

However, despite his drawbacks he is still the only reliable passer of the ball we have.
Unfortunately this is not saying much!
Comparisons with Jedinak are hilarious - his 'passing' was generally in the air.

I have always advocated a new midfield general along the lines of a Mata or Fabrigas - but we all know this type is the rarest of gold dust. Ben Watson would have been an improvement but he has gone to Forest. Jonjo Shelvey, despite having a short fuse, was at his best against United and would be valuable to us. Perhaps Dougie has someone in mind in the summer ...

 

cpfc1976 Flag Reading 12 Feb 18 1.46pm

Originally posted by Uphill

According to the Times weekly stats, Cabaye has the second highest number of interceptions in the PL.

We all note his average to poor corner kicks (Puncheon was even worse) so maybe it is time for a change.

However, despite his drawbacks he is still the only reliable passer of the ball we have.
Unfortunately this is not saying much!
Comparisons with Jedinak are hilarious - his 'passing' was generally in the air.

I have always advocated a new midfield general along the lines of a Mata or Fabrigas - but we all know this type is the rarest of gold dust. Ben Watson would have been an improvement but he has gone to Forest. Jonjo Shelvey, despite having a short fuse, was at his best against United and would be valuable to us. Perhaps Dougie has someone in mind in the summer ...

Don’t agree that Ben Watson would have improved us. He went from Watford to Forest for a reason. But agree we need someone in there, Amadou? Or a modern day equivilent of Michael Hughes even better.

 

JtCpfc Flag 12 Feb 18 1.47pm

Originally posted by Uphill

According to the Times weekly stats, Cabaye has the second highest number of interceptions in the PL.

We all note his average to poor corner kicks (Puncheon was even worse) so maybe it is time for a change.

However, despite his drawbacks he is still the only reliable passer of the ball we have.
Unfortunately this is not saying much!
Comparisons with Jedinak are hilarious - his 'passing' was generally in the air.

I have always advocated a new midfield general along the lines of a Mata or Fabrigas - but we all know this type is the rarest of gold dust. Ben Watson would have been an improvement but he has gone to Forest. Jonjo Shelvey, despite having a short fuse, was at his best against United and would be valuable to us. Perhaps Dougie has someone in mind in the summer ...

Am I reading this right?

Have you just said that Ben Watson would be an improvement on Yohan Cabaye?

I must be seriously missing something, that wouldn't even cross my mind as a question let alone actually thinking it. Please someone agree with me here or I might just go into meltdown.

 

Lyons550 Flag Shirley 12 Feb 18 2.11pm

Originally posted by mattteo

IF he is getting slower in his old days, he would benefit from playing in a more more backwards position, in front of the defense, like Pirlo played in his old days. Pick up the balls and distribute them instead of defenders sending long balls without purpose.

But for that he'd need a box-to-box midfielder, if not 2, slightly in front of him, like Pirlo had Vidal and Pogba. And Milivojevic just can't cut it. I'm not saying I want him to be Vidal or Pogba level, but he's no box-to-box. In fact, Milivojevic and Cabaye are pretty much the same type of "brain" player in midfield. If they can play together and if they need a faster player next to them in midfield or if they can't play together ans 2 faster player are required there remains to be seen.

There are plenty of cheap box-to-box options out there: Onazi (Trabzonspor, formerly Lazio), Alex Song (free), Jonathan de Guzman (Eintracht), Kozielo (Koln), Wakaso (Alaves), Andrea Poli (Bologna, formerly Milan).


s*** at deadball situations...often hits the first man on corners...and cant even bend a free kick over a wall!!!

 


The Voice of Reason In An Otherwise Mediocre World

Aray Flag South London 12 Feb 18 2.12pm

Originally posted by JtCpfc

Am I reading this right?

Have you just said that Ben Watson would be an improvement on Yohan Cabaye?

I must be seriously missing something, that wouldn't even cross my mind as a question let alone actually thinking it. Please someone agree with me here or I might just go into meltdown.

I agree with you. I thought it was a very sensible post until that bizarre claim - I'm afraid Uphill lost the plot slightly there. Back on topic - Cabaye is our key midfield player. Not only for the unsung (and clearly unnoticed) defensive work but also for his passing. Someone take the ball off him next time there's a corner or freekick.

 

chateauferret Flag 12 Feb 18 5.27pm

Originally posted by Aray

I agree with you. I thought it was a very sensible post until that bizarre claim - I'm afraid Uphill lost the plot slightly there. Back on topic - Cabaye is our key midfield player. Not only for the unsung (and clearly unnoticed) defensive work but also for his passing. Someone take the ball off him next time there's a corner or freekick.

Milivojevic is best at dead balls and Milivojevic is also captain. Am I missing something here?

 


============
The Ferret
============

sprites Flag Auckland 13 Feb 18 1.54am

The guy's quality. Much better with him than without him, imo.

 

n wales eagles Flag llandudno 13 Feb 18 9.30am

At goodison should certainly have scored or at least hit target following their poor backpass but to be fair had two reasonable shots .Rest of game took poor corners and chased Rooney around albeit a yard behind him

 

steven_t92 Flag Orpington 13 Feb 18 9.36am

You can see his class but unfortunately his form has steadily disappeared. He floats a lovely cross field pass, whereas Luka strikes it when he does the same.

I've never quite understood where the HF got the line "scoring goals for fun" for Cabaye's song. He has barely ever scored for us, we had a similar situation with Chamakh....

 

SeagullHunter Flag Reading 13 Feb 18 9.37am

Originally posted by n wales eagles

At goodison should certainly have scored or at least hit target following their poor backpass but to be fair had two reasonable shots .Rest of game took poor corners and chased Rooney around albeit a yard behind him

Are you sure? I feel like even the best in the game would have struggled to find the net from that, it was a half chance at best with the ball spinning at pace and 40 yards from goal, which he almost miraculously put away.

Easily the most unsung hero in our team. Most interceptions in our squad by quite some way (PL Statistics) and also one of the few players in the squad with the ability to pick the ball of the back four and switch play or start attacks ACCURATELY. I think he is sorely missed when not in the team, and if we don't have a replacement lined up, would be ludicrous to let him go for free.

Surely worth another year, especially when big clubs are sniffing around, highlighting his quality and importance. I wonder what people who can't see Yohan's importance think of the rest of our top 5/6 players

 


Dont let Cabaye go

MabbsWasKing Flag 13 Feb 18 10.50am

We are a much better team with him in it. Generally he picks up the loose balls won centrally by our defence whilst he is facing our goal, gets the ball under control quickly and on to someone facing the right way, often Luca. When he isn’t playing these balls that we have won often go straight back to the opposition.

Facing the opposition goal he is a great passer and retainer of possession. Disappointed with his shooting, not that he gets many decent opportunities as he plays much further back than he used to at Newcastle. Currently his dead ball delivery is appalling and he should not be taking them.

For me one of our best players.

 

n wales eagles Flag llandudno 13 Feb 18 11.48am

Originally posted by SeagullHunter

Positive how the hell was the ball spinning it was a gentle pass to say the least any thoughts of why he was yards behind Rooney all afternoon .Sure he can do a good job for us but not on corners .

Are you sure? I feel like even the best in the game would have struggled to find the net from that, it was a half chance at best with the ball spinning at pace and 40 yards from goal, which he almost miraculously put away.

Easily the most unsung hero in our team. Most interceptions in our squad by quite some way (PL Statistics) and also one of the few players in the squad with the ability to pick the ball of the back four and switch play or start attacks ACCURATELY. I think he is sorely missed when not in the team, and if we don't have a replacement lined up, would be ludicrous to let him go for free.

Surely worth another year, especially when big clubs are sniffing around, highlighting his quality and importance. I wonder what people who can't see Yohan's importance think of the rest of our top 5/6 players

 

Brentmiester_General Flag Front line in the battle against t... 13 Feb 18 11.55am

Originally posted by SeagullHunter

Are you sure? I feel like even the best in the game would have struggled to find the net from that, it was a half chance at best with the ball spinning at pace and 40 yards from goal, which he almost miraculously put away.

Easily the most unsung hero in our team. Most interceptions in our squad by quite some way (PL Statistics) and also one of the few players in the squad with the ability to pick the ball of the back four and switch play or start attacks ACCURATELY. I think he is sorely missed when not in the team, and if we don't have a replacement lined up, would be ludicrous to let him go for free.

Surely worth another year, especially when big clubs are sniffing around, highlighting his quality and importance. I wonder what people who can't see Yohan's importance think of the rest of our top 5/6 players

Wasn’t really a half chance was it. It was an open goal. If he can’t hit the target with that then he needs more practice.

 


"We love you Palace, we f@cking hate Man U, We love you Palace, we hate the brighton too, We love you Palace we play in red 'n' blue, so f@ck you, and you ...

Page 3 of 3 << First< 1 2 3

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Cabaye