You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Topic
November 16 2026 7.41am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Ref: Palace v Spurs (LOCKED)


auk Flag 21 Feb 18 3.19pm

It's Kevin Friend from Leicester.

His previous Palace matches this season were the defeats at Liverpool and Spurs, then the home draw v. Bournemouth.

 

crystal-purley Flag Purley 21 Feb 18 4.19pm

No friend of ours but he is assessed stringently after each game.

 


Enjoying getting up later and not having someone who knows better than me (apart from the missus of course).

chateauferret Flag 21 Feb 18 6.49pm

Usual comment, which is "FFS".

 


============
The Ferret
============

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 21 Feb 18 7.19pm

Originally posted by crystal-purley

No friend of ours but he is assessed stringently after each game.

As are all 'Select Group' referees.

There is a robust system for measuring their performance. Every decision is scrutinised using the match footage and 'ProZone'. Furthermore there is an assessment of their accuracy and consistency of decision making and their management of the match.Referees also meet every couple of months when match analysis is carried out and rationale for decisions discussed.

I have admiration for the 'Select Group' who have reached the top of their profession.

Edited by Willo (21 Feb 2018 7.21pm)

 

the silurian Flag The garden of England.(not really) 21 Feb 18 8.06pm

Originally posted by Willo

As are all 'Select Group' referees.

There is a robust system for measuring their performance. Every decision is scrutinised using the match footage and 'ProZone'. Furthermore there is an assessment of their accuracy and consistency of decision making and their management of the match.Referees also meet every couple of months when match analysis is carried out and rationale for decisions discussed.


I have admiration for the 'Select Group' who have reached the top of their profession.

Edited by Willo (21 Feb 2018 7.21pm)


Other than Stuart Atwell, has any 'elite' referee ever been penalised for being biased/useless/incompetent/having a diabolical game?? After all most fans, not just Palace fans, see referees making major errors every week, yet we never hear of any sanctions against their incompetence.....even the Mighty 'Mark' admitted to making errors and errors of judgement in the infamous Spurs v Chelsea match where he admitted that he should have sent off a 'few' players and didnt, as it didnt fit his agenda at the time. What happened to him after his 'forensic assessment?? Oh, Nothing!

 

crystal-purley Flag Purley 21 Feb 18 8.55pm

Originally posted by the silurian


Other than Stuart Atwell, has any 'elite' referee ever been penalised for being biased/useless/incompetent/having a diabolical game?? After all most fans, not just Palace fans, see referees making major errors every week, yet we never hear of any sanctions against their incompetence.....even the Mighty 'Mark' admitted to making errors and errors of judgement in the infamous Spurs v Chelsea match where he admitted that he should have sent off a 'few' players and didnt, as it didnt fit his agenda at the time. What happened to him after his 'forensic assessment?? Oh, Nothing!

My Apologies Silurian I shouldn't have tripped the alarm bell. Do as I do and just ignore anything written by the Norwegian dwarf.

 


Enjoying getting up later and not having someone who knows better than me (apart from the missus of course).

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 21 Feb 18 10.05pm

Originally posted by the silurian


Other than Stuart Atwell, has any 'elite' referee ever been penalised for being biased/useless/incompetent/having a diabolical game?? After all most fans, not just Palace fans, see referees making major errors every week, yet we never hear of any sanctions against their incompetence.....even the Mighty 'Mark' admitted to making errors and errors of judgement in the infamous Spurs v Chelsea match where he admitted that he should have sent off a 'few' players and didnt, as it didnt fit his agenda at the time. What happened to him after his 'forensic assessment?? Oh, Nothing!

I totally refute the sentiments expressed.

As soon as I perused "Useless,biased,incompetent, major errors every week..." I rolled my eyes and uttered words of derision.


Grandstanding is alive and well on HOL.

Edited by Willo (21 Feb 2018 10.05pm)

 

chateauferret Flag 21 Feb 18 10.07pm

Originally posted by Willo

I totally refute the sentiments expressed.

As soon as I perused "Useless,biased,incompetent, major errors every week..." I rolled my eyes and uttered words of derision.


Grandstanding is alive and well on HOL.

Edited by Willo (21 Feb 2018 10.05pm)

As do the rest of us when you roll out all that old s***e about referees' performances being "forensically examined", etc. etc. Lest you think I'm "grandstanding", I'll use some good down-to-earth old-fashioned Anglo-Saxon instead: it's f***ing bulls***.

Edited by chateauferret (21 Feb 2018 10.09pm)

 


============
The Ferret
============

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 21 Feb 18 10.16pm

Originally posted by chateauferret

As do the rest of us when you roll out all that old s***e about referees' performances being "forensically examined", etc. etc. Lest you think I'm "grandstanding", I'll use some good down-to-earth old-fashioned Anglo-Saxon instead: it's f***ing bulls***.

Edited by chateauferret (21 Feb 2018 10.09pm)

Yes I state facts about referees performances being "Forensically " examined.

And I am proud of the fact that I can disagree with a viewpoint without recourse to certain terminology.

 

chateauferret Flag 21 Feb 18 10.28pm

If it were not bulls*** then:

- We would not see week after week ghastly mistakes being made by soi-disant "elite group" referees.
- The arch-t*** Clattenburg would not be entrusted with important matches and certainly would not be in the Middle East getting his snout buried as deep as he can in the deepest trough on the planet whilst he sits there laughing at us hearing about his own admissions of ghastly errors in a number of important matches including an FA Cup Final in which we were involved.
- Several men would have been dismissed and suspended this season alone for fouls on Zaha.
- Bakary Sako might be available (or else Zabaleta would also have had a red card).
- Niasse would not have obtained a penalty for Everton against us. Ditto Snodgrass for Hull.
- Most referees would be trusted by fans to give an objective and fair performance in a Premier League game.
- Pep Guardiola would not look such a fool after playing against a referee who was actually prepared to send one of his men off when he deserved it for a change.
- Not even Alan Shearer would be able to accuse Zaha of being a diver.
- The so-called "Diving Panel" would not be required.
- VAR would not be required.
- Huddersfield Town would be bottom.

These things happen because the standard of refereeing is unacceptably poor and because, for all your harping on about "forensic reviews", nothing is ever done about it apart from the sticking plasters that are the VAR trials and the Diving Panel. Those two initiatives don't address the real problems or help clubs that lose out because of s*** decisions, but they do constitute an admission that the referees are doing a s*** job and that the system isn't delivering the level playing field that everyone involved with football should expect as a basic right.


Edited by chateauferret (21 Feb 2018 10.35pm)

 


============
The Ferret
============

auk Flag 21 Feb 18 10.35pm

Historically, we tend not to do well when KF is in the middle.

Since returning to the top flight, our only win with him as match official was a 2-1 triumph over Stoke in what seems like the distant past.

Among ignominious defeats were two v Swansea, one of them being that 4-5 horror show at their place.

Here’s hoping we break the sequence on Sunday.

 

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 21 Feb 18 10.39pm

Originally posted by chateauferret

If it were not bulls*** then:

- We would not see week after week ghastly mistakes being made by soi-disant "elite group" referees.
- The arch-t*** Clattenburg would not be entrusted with important matches and certainly would not be in the Middle East getting his snout buried as deep as he can in the deepest trough on the planet whilst he sits there laughing at us hearing about his own admissions of ghastly errors in a number of important matches including an FA Cup Final in which we were involved.
- Several men would have been dismissed and suspended this season alone for fouls on Zaha.
- Bakary Sako might be available (or else Zabaleta would also have had a red card).
- Niasse would not have obtained a penalty for Everton against us. Ditto Snodgrass for Hull.
- Virtually no referee is trusted by fans to give an objective and fair performance in a Premier League game.
- Pep Guardiola would not look such a fool after playing against a referee who was actually prepared to send one of his men off when he deserved it for a change.
- Not even Alan Shearer would be able to accuse Zaha of being a diver.
- The so-called "Diving Panel" would not be required.
- VAR would not be required.
- Huddersfield Town would be bottom.

These things happen because the standard of refereeing is unacceptably poor and because, for all your harping on about "forensic reviews", nothing is ever done about it apart from the sticking plasters that are the VAR trials and the Diving Panel.


Edited by chateauferret (21 Feb 2018 10.31pm)

Suffice to say a declamatory post which shouts a lot but imparts little.24-carat tosh.

As McEnroe said "You cannot be serious".

Not going to waste my time proving any further 'Oxygen' to such hogwash.

 

chateauferret Flag 21 Feb 18 11.05pm

Originally posted by Willo

Suffice to say a declamatory post which shouts a lot but imparts little.24-carat tosh.

As McEnroe said "You cannot be serious".

Not going to waste my time proving any further 'Oxygen' to such hogwash.

Well, you had the opportunity to point to examples of improvement which had taken place because of your "forensic examination" but failed once again to do so.

You therefore presumably concur that they are either going through the motions or not doing it at all.

 


============
The Ferret
============

HKOwen Flag Hong Kong 21 Feb 18 11.21pm

At least Clattent*** has gone

Refs of course will never get everything right but it can't be assumed that because there is a more formal performance evaluation that the performances are getting better.

The more technology the better IMHO

 


Responsibility Deficit Disorder is a medical condition. Symptoms include inability to be corrected when wrong, false sense of superiority, desire to share personal info no else cares about, general hubris. It's a medical issue rather than pure arrogance.

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 21 Feb 18 11.26pm

Originally posted by chateauferret

Well, you had the opportunity to point to examples of improvement which had taken place because of your "forensic examination" but failed once again to do so.

You therefore presumably concur that they are either going through the motions or not doing it at all.

"Forensic" appraisal of a referee's match performance is all to do with maintaining the high standards set and I can assure you that they are carried out after every game.NOT forgetting the 'Training camps' every 2 months.

I have to say that when "Diving panel" is mentioned without mention of players or the need for such a panel then arguments lose credibilty.And of course the 3 person panel views the footage independently and there has to be a UNANIMOUS decision which recognises the fact there could be differing viewpoints despite seeing the incident numerous times with 'Slow-Mo'.A referee only gets one chance of viewing the incident in real time.

Apropos VAR, it has been recognised worldwide that referees cannot see everything from every angle, hence it's introduction. Clearly some believe that referees should be able to do so.Yet another argument short of any credibility.

Anyway time to go to bed now so Goodnight to one and all.

Edited by Willo (21 Feb 2018 11.30pm)

 

HeathMan Flag Purley 22 Feb 18 12.22am

We must not forget that referees are also evaluated while in action, and are able to respond to the spoken words, both of players, and supporters during matches. "Who's the Scouser in the black" is an assessment sentence I have heard. COYP

 

chateauferret Flag 22 Feb 18 12.24am

Originally posted by Willo

"Forensic" appraisal of a referee's match performance is all to do with maintaining the high standards set and I can assure you

You accuse me of not bringing facts and then expect me to treat "I can assure you" as though it were evidence?

You must have worked in a Government Department's policy letter-writing team for years and years because that's the only place I can think of where that counts as logic.

As for "the high standards set" - ROTFL.

 


============
The Ferret
============

Midlands Eagle Flag 22 Feb 18 6.24am

same old, same old

 


You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Topic