This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
England vs Italy
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
dreamwaverider London 29 Mar 18 6.44am |
|
|
If I was in charge I would i would make VAR the same as tennis where the players call for the camera review. I would give both managers the chance to make 2 appeals per half. The decision would then be made by the techno guys in the stands and the ref would be told the decision. At the moment this just puts more pressure and confusion on the ref. The idea of technology is to take the heat off the pitch so the camera removes any doubt. In this case the decision you are debating is removed from the pitch just like in tennis cricket and rugby.
|
dreamwaverider London 29 Mar 18 6.50am |
|
Originally posted by Willo
I believe there is going to be quite a debate as to what is a "Clear and obvious error".Very subjective.
In terms of the review, the referee would have been advised by the VAR to watch footrage of the incident and reconsider his decision.
Edited by Willo (28 Mar 2018 1.50pm)
But surely if you accidentally trip a player up which is undoubtedly what happened it is still a penalty. If that had been Wilf for Palace we would all have called it.
|
CrazyBadger Ware 29 Mar 18 9.16am |
|
Originally posted by dreamwaverider
If I was in charge I would i would make VAR the same as tennis where the players call for the camera review. I would give both managers the chance to make 2 appeals per half. The decision would then be made by the techno guys in the stands and the ref would be told the decision. At the moment this just puts more pressure and confusion on the ref. The idea of technology is to take the heat off the pitch so the camera removes any doubt. In this case the decision you are debating is removed from the pitch just like in tennis cricket and rugby.
problem is with this is that it is too open for misuse. it's open to be used tactically - for timewasting and to break up the play. Also, what decisions are open for a manager to appeal? i.e. If a ref is playing advantage, can a manager stop that advantage and ask for a review? nice idea, but can't see it working in football.
"It was a Team effort, I guess it took all players working together to lose this one"
|
Painter Croydon 29 Mar 18 10.48am |
|
|
Forget all the VAR nonsense, it deflected how poor England are. They struggled to a draw against a poor Italian side. How that lad from Burnley is playing instead of Dunk from Brighton is a mystery. Watching England play is painful, when you have the likes of Henderson and Dier in midfield, you know it’s going awful. The only bright star is when Sterling or Vardy gets the ball, the rest are just not very good at this level.
|