You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Player season ratings
November 16 2026 7.07am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Player season ratings


rossboss29 Flag Portsmouth 14 May 18 12.13am

For me

Hennessey 6
Speroni 5

Van aanaholt 7
Schlupp 6
Dann 6
Tomkins 9
Sakho 7
Delaney 4
Fosu Mensah 7
Ward 6
Kelly 6
Wan Bissaka 8

Townsend 6
Zaha 9
Sako 7
Chungy 5
Luka 9
Riedewald 5
MacArthur 7
Cabaye 6
Loftus-Cheek 7

Benteke 4
Sorloth 6

 

sprites Flag Auckland 14 May 18 5.17am

Great topic. Here's mine.

Hennessey 7 (He's actually done pretty well, despite the haters.)

Speroni 6 (Hard to judge. Never let us down though.)

Van aanaholt 8 (A revelation. Hugely impressive, especially in the back end of the season.

Schlupp 6 (Hampered by injured, but looked average to decent.)

Dann 6 (Again, hard to judge but was solid enough.)

Tomkins 8 (Outstanding in the last 10 games or so.)

Sakho 8 (He's been awesome - just seems like he's been slightly off, because of the high standards he set for himself.)

Delaney 4 (Agree - but hard to judge on his game time.)

Fosu Mensah 6 (Never done bad, but equally never massively impressed.)

Ward 6 (Seems fair)

Kelly 6 (Again, seems fair.)

Wan Bissaka 9 (What more could the kid do? Immense.)

Townsend 7 (6 is harsh for Andros. Been involved in a lot of good stuff going forward and works his arse off for the cause.)

Zaha 9 (Easy to forget that he has had a handful of average games for us. But for the most part, vital and excellent.)

Sako 8 (While he was available, he was immense. Goal scoring machine. Shame about the injury.)

Chungy 5 (Hard for the guy to make an impact.)

Luka 9 (Agreed. An absolute machine. Best signing we've made in a while.)

Riedewald 6 (Limited opportunities, never let us down.)

MacArthur 8 (A rock for us. 7 too low. 8 at least.)

Cabaye 7. (Again, 6 too low. He's been decent and kept us ticking over.)

Loftus-Cheek 8 (Been excellent while available.)

Benteke 3 (Unfortunately a season to forget for Tekkers.

Sorloth 5 (Not enough time to really judge.)

 

jimruss Flag Sidcup 14 May 18 7.06am

Hennessey 7
Speroni 5

Van aanaholt 8
Schlupp 6
Dann 6
Tomkins 9
Sakho 8
Delaney 4
Fosu Mensah 6
Ward 6
Kelly 6
Wan Bissaka 8

Townsend 8
Zaha 9
Sako 6
Chungy 5
Luka 9
Riedewald 5
MacArthur 8
Cabaye 7
Loftus-Cheek 8

Benteke 3
Sorloth 5

 

adamnye27 Flag Bracknell 14 May 18 9.10am

spot on there sprites

 

Loz83 Flag Crawley 14 May 18 9.18am

I agree with most of the ratings but 3 for benteke is harsh even though he’s had a shocker , he’s contributed more than Lee, Delaney and reidewald have so a 5 is the minimum he should get for me.

 

Elpis Flag In a pub 14 May 18 3.21pm

Everyone contributed to our survival ,which looked a lost cause back in October . Everyone that played and those who didn't so much who kept those who did on their toes . No voices of discontent , nobody throwing a strop,nobody going awol in games .

Everyone of them to a man pulled for the cause even when out of form so I'm giving everyone an 7 with Wilf mentioned in dispatches .

 


You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Player season ratings