You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Are Economists Worth Listening To?
November 21 2026 10.40pm

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Are Economists Worth Listening To?


Page 2 of 2 << First< 1 2
.TUX. Flag 20 Jul 18 10.14pm

Originally posted by .TUX.

Are Economists Worth Listening To?

The good ones are because they have no agenda, hence why you rarely see them on MSM.


As i've posted recently, the second half of this year will be more than interesting, economically.
I look forward to the many many 'excuses' spouted by those on the MSM who are paid for their 'expertise'.............when the s*** hits the fan.

 


Buy Litecoin.

PalazioVecchio Flag south pole 21 Jul 18 9.24am

as i entered the nightclub, the security staff frisked me to confirm that i was not carrying any hidden swimming pools

 


Kayla did Anfield & Old Trafford

Stirlingsays Flag 21 Jul 18 9.26am

Originally posted by PalazioVecchio

as i entered the nightclub, the security staff frisked me to confirm that i was not carrying any hidden swimming pools

 


'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)

Lyons550 Flag Shirley 23 Jul 18 9.54am

Originally posted by ddjdd

If you want your opinion on any economic matter to be based on a level of knowledge and understanding, then read and digest what economists have to say.

Particularly with things like forecasts, error margins exist and mistakes are made because the world is a chaotic system, and any number of perturbations can occur to throw it off from what was predicted a year ago.

If you disagree with what an economist is saying, don't ask 'are economists worth listening to?', that's ridiculous and helps no one, least of all yourself. Instead look at the assumptions they made in their work etc etc, and challenge the logic behind those.

On the other hand, if you merely want to back up whatever your political opinion is, then just read opinion pieces from your favourite newspaper (These will have varying degrees of bias).

Basically yes they are, and this is another stupid thread.


The point i'm making...is if their 'assumptions' are seemingly more often wrong then correct then NO they're not worth listening to.

The clearly they have no real grasp or clue as to what is going on, other than knowing the drivers and resistors that play a part in ALL capitalist economies...and yet they STILL can't use those to come to any insightful, sensible or meaningful predictions.

So the question i posed in essence was what is the point of them if they're useless at suggesting anything other than a generic...so far from being a stupid thread.

It's akin to a weather presenter suggesting that the Sun will come up tomorrow (based on a known) and that the heat from it will either produce cloud or not.....brilliant!

 


The Voice of Reason In An Otherwise Mediocre World

silvertop Flag Portishead 23 Jul 18 12.44pm

Political science, social science, economic science. None are pure sciences in that they cannot seek to assess physical exactitudes.

While it is possible to identify patterns, individual humans behave in a vast permutation of ways. Take a simple example. Throw a brick at a man. Will he duck, move to the left, to the right, or take it head on? Who knows? He doesn't know. And if you throw more than one, likely a different reaction each time.

Collectively, even if all those individuals behaved as predictable automatons, they don't behave identially to the next individual. There are simply far too many of them to make any accurate empiracle judgement on likely behaviour.

And even if we were a collection of identical clones, behaviour is shaped by external environmental factors which, themselves are unbelievably complex, unpredictable and so inter-related as to undermine the voractiy of most long term predictions.

That said, is it a waste of time? I would say no. Take the meteoroligal example. In this country we have no fewer than 5 major weather systems impacting the weather of our little island. No wonder prediction beyond this afternoon is plagued with uncertainty. Yet the science continues to evolve and improve and the % accuracy increases with time. Likewise, economnic predicters will improve with time, albeit, in % terms, increasing from a low base of very little to not very much.

Still, better than nothing; and certainly better than basing policy on complete guesswork or political dogma.

 

Sportyteacher Flag London 23 Jul 18 5.53pm

Originally posted by Midlands Eagle

The Office for Budget Responsibility reminds me of the Ministry of truth in 1984 as they are continually rewriting history

Much like our Government then with manifesto promises quickly abandoned and policy made up on the hoof....

 

PalazioVecchio Flag south pole 23 Jul 18 7.05pm

the EU has not submitted any audited books , ever.

a totally bunk organisation that would make an economist weep.

having said that, if the EU employed an economist to say that 2+2=7 he would probably be very accommodating.

 


Kayla did Anfield & Old Trafford

.TUX. Flag 23 Jul 18 8.13pm

Originally posted by PalazioVecchio

the EU has not submitted any audited books , ever.

a totally bunk organisation that would make an economist weep.

having said that, if the EU employed an economist to say that 2+2=7 he would probably be very accommodating.

Shhhhhhhhhh.
Apparently it's all about 'a bus'.

 


Buy Litecoin.

Page 2 of 2 << First< 1 2

You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Are Economists Worth Listening To?