You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Squad depth/back up choices.
November 16 2026 7.07am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Squad depth/back up choices.


Page 2 of 2 << First< 1 2
YT Flag Oxford 10 Aug 18 6.48am

Originally posted by Ginger Pubic Wig

I agree about flexibility, and I agree our back ups would beat the team that played for us when we came up. I was really concerned going into the window as so many players appeared to be ending their contracts, and I also thought Roy might retire. But he didn't, we kept Wilf, and we appeared to use common sense in the transfer market.

A neat little summary of the close season

 


Palace since 19 August 1972. Palace 1 (Tony Taylor) Liverpool 1 (Emlyn Hughes)

TheBigToePunt Flag 10 Aug 18 1.24pm

There is so much talk these days of ‘squad depth’, but nobody talks about ‘squad hierarchy’, which is as important, if not more so.

The idea that we could have two distinct XIs at the club, both capable of winning any given Premier League game, is not only unlikely, but ultimately counter-productive. If you are a good enough player to do that then you will want to be first choice, and if you can’t be then you’ll become demoralised, dis-incentivised and grumpy. That will then spread to others in the squad, and where there was unity of purpose there will instead be divisions.

Back when Mourinho first rocked up at Chelsea, and was the brightest manager around, he immediately made it clear that for the reasons listed above he didn’t ever want more than 24 players to work with in his squad. Guardiola moved out several established big names as soon as he moved in to Man City, as he knew he didn’t want high-calibre experienced winners at the club if they weren’t going to be first choice picks. Ferguson used to make sure his squads were, as far as possible, split into three equal age bands. Eight very good youngsters who are hungry and pushing to play but won’t expect to be first choice yet, eight in their prime who you rely on the most, and eight elder heads who can do a job when needed and pass on their experience to the rest.

When I look at our squad, it’s the blend that interests me, not whether we have uniform quality and experience across the 25.

 

Yellow Card - User has been warned of conduct on the messageboards Tez Flag Epsom 10 Aug 18 4.08pm

Originally posted by mileend

interesting - I was sceptical about our depth but isn't that back up team above quite a bit better than the first Premier League team we put out in our current run in the top flight - as posted elsewhere recently it was:

2013/14 Premiership v Tottenham H L 0-1
Julian Speroni
Joel Ward
Daniel Gabbidon
Dean Moxey
Damien Delaney
Kagisho Dikgacoi
Owen Garvan
Mile Jedinak
Stephen Dobbie
Dwight Gayle
Aaron Wilbraham

When you see that team on paper you realise the debt we owe to Speroni, Delaney, Ward and Jedinak for carrying the rest of that s***e to survival!

 

Direwolf Flag Lincoln 10 Aug 18 5.37pm

I see from Roy's press conference that Williams and Wickham are both injured again from training. I guess we can only see them as possibly available rather than ever as alternative options?

Edited by Direwolf (10 Aug 2018 5.38pm)

 

Maine Eagle Flag USA 10 Aug 18 7.01pm

Originally posted by mileend

interesting - I was sceptical about our depth but isn't that back up team above quite a bit better than the first Premier League team we put out in our current run in the top flight - as posted elsewhere recently it was:

2013/14 Premiership v Tottenham H L 0-1
Julian Speroni
Joel Ward
Daniel Gabbidon
Dean Moxey
Damien Delaney
Kagisho Dikgacoi
Owen Garvan
Mile Jedinak
Stephen Dobbie
Dwight Gayle
Aaron Wilbraham

Good shout, some serious garbage was out on that pitch just a few years ago.

Kouyate will play ahead of Jimmy Mac when a more physical and taller presence is needed in the middle of the park.

The days of bringing CY Lee on to change the game are over. That is good as he didnt change many games for the better.

Our bench is now the best it has ever looked in recent times.

 


Trump lost. Badly. Hahahahahahaha.

Petereagle Flag Brockley 11 Aug 18 10.32am

Originally posted by Ginger Pubic Wig

I jotted down my b team based on the players at our disposal being fully fit, to see how we look.

BACK UPS:

          Hennessey

Ward    Dann    Kelly     Schlupp

Punch  Riedewald      McArthur Kaikai

Wickham        Sorloth


AGAINST A STARTING 11 OF:

Zaha    Benteke Townsend

Kouyate     Luka    Meyer

PVA      Sakho   Tomkins    AWB

            Guaita

In short, we lack a decent quick player to carry the ball forward if Wilf is missing. Maybe PVA could/would be pushed forward and Schlupp goes to left back.

But actually I think our squad is okay for a club of our stature.

Hopefully AWB's rise has made the club realise that we also have some talent coming through. (hopefully some talent IS coming through!)

I think that is just about spot on. The real difference is in the strength of the back up squad. There is beginning to be strength in depth even if 5 players won’t be there. Two of them (Meyer and Ayew) are likely to be in the starting 11 as soon as their fitness improves enough?

[Link]

 

Petereagle Flag Brockley 11 Aug 18 10.33am

Originally posted by Petereagle

I think that is just about spot on. The real difference is in the strength of the back up squad. There is beginning to be strength in depth even if 5 players won’t be there. Two of them (Meyer and Ayew) are likely to be in the starting 11 as soon as their fitness improves enough?

[Link]

PS I don’t think Meyer will start or even be on the bench as he didn’t really have a preseason

 

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 11 Aug 18 11.24am

Originally posted by Petereagle

PS I don’t think Meyer will start or even be on the bench as he didn’t really have a preseason

Certainly won't start.
He hasn't played a game since April.

From a personal perspective I will be more than happy with a draw but I appreciate that this is going to be some challenge.

Edited by Willo (11 Aug 2018 11.29am)

 

Petereagle Flag Brockley 11 Aug 18 12.50pm

Originally posted by Willo

Certainly won't start.
He hasn't played a game since April.

From a personal perspective I will be more than happy with a draw but I appreciate that this is going to be some challenge.

Edited by Willo (11 Aug 2018 11.29am)

An away draw against a money bags team wd be a good result, tho it could be that we are playing Fulham before all these players really jell. In which case we might scrape a win

 

Page 2 of 2 << First< 1 2

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Squad depth/back up choices.