You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Roy and subs
November 16 2026 6.52am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Roy and subs


Page 3 of 3 << First< 1 2 3
Casual Flag Orpington 27 Aug 18 8.19pm

Originally posted by ARGILE OLD GEEZER


But Danny Murphy is a Jockey on a crap radio station, R.H. is a manager of Premiership club with years and years of success behind him, i know who i would rather put my trust in.

Murphy wasn’t slagging Roy off, he loves him thinks he’s a great manager , was just explaining how he manages.

 

Booted Eagle Flag Bristol 27 Aug 18 8.22pm

Originally posted by ARGILE OLD GEEZER


But Danny Murphy is a Jockey on a crap radio station, R.H. is a manager of Premiership club with years and years of success behind him, i know who i would rather put my trust in.

Roy was his manager for 3 years or so at Fulham so he probably knows a thing about his tactics.

 


“ [T]here are known knowns; there are things we know that we know.There are known unknowns; that is to say there are things that, we now know we don't know.But there are also unknown unknowns – there are things we do not know we don't know. ”
—United States Secretary of Defense, Donald Rumsfeld

ARGILE OLD GEEZER Flag PORTIMAO 28 Aug 18 7.54am

Originally posted by Booted Eagle

Roy was his manager for 3 years or so at Fulham so he probably knows a thing about his tactics.

I know he was, but it was still a criticism of Roys (subs) tactics.
I do like D.M. actually.

 

laddo Flag london 28 Aug 18 7.58am

I know what you're saying but Joel puts that one away we all say Roy was spot on. Fine margins and all that.

 


laddo

"People say, live fast, die young. I say live fast, die old. That's me, the non-conformist".
David Brent.

Frickin Saweet Flag South Cronx 28 Aug 18 11.20am

Originally posted by ARGILE OLD GEEZER

I was just about to post a very similar response, its looking like a LETS BLAME R.H.thread coz we lost an away game,no mention of the bad luck and ref decisions that went against us. its all roy's fault we have 3 similar strikers, one is off form, one injured still,and one very raw, we also have another option for a striker,but he is not fit yet.
Its as you said Braunstone, some "supporters" just can't wait to blame the club or management for a loss,they don't even think about the rubbish they are writing.

yours and the other poster names you mention are really over the top reactions to what is obviously a common observation made by a lot of fans, pundits and journalists - i.e. that we needed to make changes to influence the game using the players that Roy had declared ready and fit before the match. This is not blame or any sort of attack on the manager - just a bleeding obvious conclusion to what was playing out on the pitch and we've all watched enough matches to see it.

 

Cucking Funt Flag Clapham on the Back 28 Aug 18 11.26am

Originally posted by Frickin Saweet

yours and the other poster names you mention are really over the top reactions to what is obviously a common observation made by a lot of fans, pundits and journalists - i.e. that we needed to make changes to influence the game using the players that Roy had declared ready and fit before the match. This is not blame or any sort of attack on the manager - just a bleeding obvious conclusion to what was playing out on the pitch and we've all watched enough matches to see it.

If the conclusion is indeed as obvious as so many seem to think, then why didn't Hodgson do it?

 


Wife beating may be socially acceptable in Sheffield, but it is a different matter in Cheltenham

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 28 Aug 18 11.48am

Originally posted by Cucking Funt

If the conclusion is indeed as obvious as so many seem to think, then why didn't Hodgson do it?

I sometimes feel these kind of managers give the players on the pitch a chance to keep their place or completely lose it so they have no complaints, grumblings or negative influence in the squad. In a shortish space of time you get the strongest 11 on the pitch selected from a few over 11 players and those unfavoured have very little to complain about, at the cost of a few short term points over a longer term benefit and harmony.

Just a theory, whether obvious or not, or so obvious it’s never mentioned.

Edited by Rudi Hedman (28 Aug 2018 11.51am)

 


COYP

Frickin Saweet Flag South Cronx 28 Aug 18 1.57pm

Originally posted by Cucking Funt

If the conclusion is indeed as obvious as so many seem to think, then why didn't Hodgson do it?

well that's one that only him and perhaps a few people close to him can answer. Danny Murphy gave this thoughts about Roy having his 'winning 11' training together all week for the game ahead making him reluctant to change his formula during a game. Hodgson has said previously that whatever comes off the bench needs to be better than what is already on the pitch. I disagree with that last point to a degree as it's not always about who is best on paper but what is working and I'm of the opinion that if something isn't working then you change it. The best-laid plans of mice and men often go awry, no matter how carefully a project is planned. At those times action is required IMO.

Don't get me wrong I'm very happy he's at Palace and his approach has more positive than negative outcomes, but perhaps this is why Roy is managing at our level club and not Liverpool/England level, the missing ability to have an effective plan B when things aren't going to plan A.

Edited by Frickin Saweet (28 Aug 2018 2.01pm)

 

premier fan Flag BR4 28 Aug 18 2.12pm

Not sure why people are quick to blame Roy.

The team were playing well most of the game and he probably expected a reaction to the goal and not a flukey second goal from them.

I think the Benteke situation is reasonable. He was showing signs of improving and hitting the target and scoring in friendlies but I'm sure he will give the other two strikers a chance on Saturday.

 

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 28 Aug 18 3.34pm

Originally posted by premier fan

Not sure why people are quick to blame Roy.

The team were playing well most of the game and he probably expected a reaction to the goal and not a flukey second goal from them.

I think the Benteke situation is reasonable. He was showing signs of improving and hitting the target and scoring in friendlies but I'm sure he will give the other two strikers a chance on Saturday.

He waited for some kind of competitiveness for 35 minutes in the first half with plenty of complaining of the display between Roy and Ray. They were both fully aware of how bad it was but let it continue for whatever reason. The rigidity last season was another frustration but in the bigger picture Roy delivers. I just think he’d be even better if he was more flexible or introduced these options.

 


COYP

michaelpearce Flag grays 28 Aug 18 5.37pm

why are people being over sensitive over fans saying he needs to use his subs better,

at the moment its just a observation, he does have a history regarding subs, doesn't mean we want him sacked,

the way some on here have acted is like we called for his head, couldn't be further from the truth, we questioned his way regarding subs being introduced in to a match, each manager has there way some fans would like earlier or different changes that's all it is, how many of the ones defending him have not watched in the past and gone why didn't he do that, if you haven't you don't know a lot about the game from watching,

so don't get to bent up on fans asking a simple observation about subs, we all still love him xx

 

est1905 Flag 28 Aug 18 5.44pm

Originally posted by spartakev2

So you don't think he should havd brought subs on earlier, for both this game and liverpool? Motd 'experts' certainly thought so, saying bentekes performance was shocking.

Motd 'experts'? What is it they are actually experts at? It certainly isn't successful management of a football club. Not one of them has made a decent job of coaching/managing. Most of them haven't even had the courage to have a go!

I have known and/or had a beer with a few ex pro footballers over the years and they'll all tell you the same. Watching is nothing like playing and playing is nothing like coaching. In other words ex players a no better qualified in their opinion than anyone else when it comes to coaching.

 

est1905 Flag 28 Aug 18 5.46pm

Originally posted by ARGILE OLD GEEZER


But Danny Murphy is a Jockey on a crap radio station, R.H. is a manager of Premiership club with years and years of success behind him, i know who i would rather put my trust in.

This.

 

spartakev2 Flag Anerley 28 Aug 18 5.53pm

Originally posted by est1905

Motd 'experts'? What is it they are actually experts at? It certainly isn't successful management of a football club. Not one of them has made a decent job of coaching/managing. Most of them haven't even had the courage to have a go!

I have known and/or had a beer with a few ex pro footballers over the years and they'll all tell you the same. Watching is nothing like playing and playing is nothing like coaching. In other words ex players a no better qualified in their opinion than anyone else when it comes to coaching.

Past players who hsve played at the top level and good pundits, entitled to give their opinion abd it seems to be the same opinion of a lot of fans on here.

And you evaded the question i asked. Did you not think it would have been better to bring subs on earlier?

 

est1905 Flag 29 Aug 18 3.50pm

Originally posted by spartakev2

Past players who hsve played at the top level and good pundits, entitled to give their opinion abd it seems to be the same opinion of a lot of fans on here.

And you evaded the question i asked. Did you not think it would have been better to bring subs on earlier?

I apologise as I did not realise that question was addressed to me specifically.
In answer, me personally, both yes and no. I thought the team we started (with the exception of Meyer) was the strongest we could put out to win the game therefore on that basis making changes for change sake makes no sense. But.... I did change my my mind half way through the second half and feel Meyer's creativity and trickery could have been used to unlock them and would have liked to have seen him come on earlier. Then again only Roy and his staff truly know how fit Meyer is and how much he can be pushed right now so again we come back to thepoint I made before about the manager and his staff being far better qualified to decide whats for the best.

 

Booted Eagle Flag Bristol 29 Aug 18 4.08pm

Originally posted by Frickin Saweet

well that's one that only him and perhaps a few people close to him can answer. Danny Murphy gave this thoughts about Roy having his 'winning 11' training together all week for the game ahead making him reluctant to change his formula during a game. Hodgson has said previously that whatever comes off the bench needs to be better than what is already on the pitch. I disagree with that last point to a degree as it's not always about who is best on paper but what is working and I'm of the opinion that if something isn't working then you change it. The best-laid plans of mice and men often go awry, no matter how carefully a project is planned. At those times action is required IMO.

Don't get me wrong I'm very happy he's at Palace and his approach has more positive than negative outcomes, but perhaps this is why Roy is managing at our level club and not Liverpool/England level, the missing ability to have an effective plan B when things aren't going to plan A.

Edited by Frickin Saweet (28 Aug 2018 2.01pm)

That is a fair point. However if you do bring on a new sub which is unlike his replacement then other players may have to shift formation as well and have to be comfortable doing this. Not sure if Roy likes this and whether we actually have the players to do this ? Also invariably subs who do make an impact don't stay to long as subs, unless at the bigger clubs such as Giroud, the latter day David Fairclough. More are used in case of injury.

 


“ [T]here are known knowns; there are things we know that we know.There are known unknowns; that is to say there are things that, we now know we don't know.But there are also unknown unknowns – there are things we do not know we don't know. ”
—United States Secretary of Defense, Donald Rumsfeld

pssguy Flag 29 Aug 18 4.51pm

Originally posted by premier fan

Not sure why people are quick to blame Roy.

The team were playing well most of the game and he probably expected a reaction to the goal and not a flukey second goal from them.

I think the Benteke situation is reasonable. He was showing signs of improving and hitting the target
and scoring in friendlies but I'm sure he will give the other two strikers a chance on Saturday.

The problem is that his idea of hitting the target is just placing it on goal - where the keeper has a good chance to save

Last week a downward header from the Townsend(?) cross would have been a sure goal. Last year his goal against Leicester should really have been saved and the penalty (the one he scored) was nowhere near the side of goal or struck with power

How and why Wickham got injured again is concerning. If fit, he would now clearly be our Number 1 striker

 

Eaglecoops Flag CR3 29 Aug 18 4.56pm

Originally posted by Booted Eagle

That is a fair point. However if you do bring on a new sub which is unlike his replacement then other players may have to shift formation as well and have to be comfortable doing this. Not sure if Roy likes this and whether we actually have the players to do this ? Also invariably subs who do make an impact don't stay to long as subs, unless at the bigger clubs such as Giroud, the latter day David Fairclough. More are used in case of injury.


In fairness, these are all premier league footballers playing in one of, if not the, toughest league in the world. You would think that in view of this they have the abilty to adapt to a plan B, or come to think of it a plan C,D,E or F if necessary. So throwing a different type of player onto the pitch and adapting your play to pose the opposition a different threat should be second nature to these guys, or am I giving them too much credit?

 

Page 3 of 3 << First< 1 2 3

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Roy and subs