You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Palace vs Swansea Carabao Cup Match Thread
November 16 2026 6.52am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Palace vs Swansea Carabao Cup Match Thread


Page 11 of 11 << First< 7 8 9 10 11
ThatPetrolRelation Flag Ottawa 31 Aug 18 3.38pm

Originally posted by Hrolf The Ganger

Not better enough for me.
The simple fact is that the board have decided that we aren't spending money and when that happens, you risk going backwards. It was obvious that what we have up front is not good enough and our back four cannot withstand injuries.
We were lucky against Fulham, poor against Liverpool and dire against Watford. If Wilf is injured for a long period again, we are in trouble. Let's hope our new signings shine.

Palace has been spending a lot, that is a simple fact.
[Link]

I don't think anyone thinks we should be spending like a top 6 team. We spent massively to stay up, but I'm glad they're being careful instead of throwing 20M after Ings or someone similar.

The squad is better than last year.
Guaita > Cavalieri
Kouyaté < RLC (but RLC only started 21 games for us)
Ayew > Sako (close but Sako is a sick note)
Meyer = Cabaye (okay the jury is still out, but it looks good)
AWB > TFM
Pape > Jach
Johnny W > Rakip

And most importantly, we didn't sell any of our top players --which is what dooms most mid-table team to relegation.

Lastly, we locked up Roy and we locked up Zaha, losing either would have made us immediate relegation fodder.

 

Yellow Card - User has been warned of conduct on the messageboards Hrolf The Ganger Flag 31 Aug 18 4.31pm

Originally posted by ThatPetrolRelation

Palace has been spending a lot, that is a simple fact.
[Link]

I don't think anyone thinks we should be spending like a top 6 team. We spent massively to stay up, but I'm glad they're being careful instead of throwing 20M after Ings or someone similar.

The squad is better than last year.
Guaita > Cavalieri
Kouyaté < RLC (but RLC only started 21 games for us)
Ayew > Sako (close but Sako is a sick note)
Meyer = Cabaye (okay the jury is still out, but it looks good)
AWB > TFM
Pape > Jach
Johnny W > Rakip

And most importantly, we didn't sell any of our top players --which is what dooms most mid-table team to relegation.

Lastly, we locked up Roy and we locked up Zaha, losing either would have made us immediate relegation fodder.


I'm not sure I agree. I don't see how the squad is better than last year. Meyer looks good but we have lost Cabaye and I see no improvement elsewhere.
We have lost RLC and Sako and replaced them with uninspiring players. Our strike force is injured, unproven or totally out of form and we have done little to improve that. Our defence is seriously lacking if Tomkins or Sakho are injured which is very likely to happen.

Our last two windows have consisted of signings players who were clearly not good enough or risky and cheap.

Not impressed.

 

ThatPetrolRelation Flag Ottawa 31 Aug 18 7.48pm

Originally posted by Hrolf The Ganger


I'm not sure I agree. I don't see how the squad is better than last year. Meyer looks good but we have lost Cabaye and I see no improvement elsewhere.
We have lost RLC and Sako and replaced them with uninspiring players. Our strike force is injured, unproven or totally out of form and we have done little to improve that. Our defence is seriously lacking if Tomkins or Sakho are injured which is very likely to happen.

Our last two windows have consisted of signings players who were clearly not good enough or risky and cheap.

Not impressed.

Spending our way to relegation makes no sense to me. Not all players pay off, but we seem to do better than most.

I would have loved to keep RLC, but he still had as many invisible games as great ones (If he sits on the bench this year and doesn't play for ENG, I'm hopeful we can get him later). His defensive game certainly needed work, and I rate Kouyaté for that.

I love Cabaye, but he was down to 60 useful minutes per match, and would probably be less mobile this season. Mayer MAY be a brilliant replacement. Cabaye had 1 assist in 31 appearances last year. Meyer equaled that in 15 minutes of play. I'm hopeful.

And Sako? He's a nice guy, but did nothing apart from one good stretch for Roy (and then got injured for the 36th time). 5 Prem goals to Ayew's 17, and 4 years younger, that HAS to be considered an upgrade.

And you seemed to forget we were sweating on Hennessey's health all last season. Now we have Guiata, who may grab the shirt when given a chance.

We're Palace, we aren't going to have £20M players at every position and £100M sitting on the bench.
I'm impressed with the squad that is getting better without panic buys or risking financial ruin.

 

kenners46 Flag sydenham village 31 Aug 18 10.00pm

Originally posted by ThatPetrolRelation

Palace has been spending a lot, that is a simple fact.
[Link]

If that is an up to date valuation then we are only spending/losing 20 million a year on transfers

 

NickinOX Flag Sailing country. 01 Sep 18 1.38am

Originally posted by kenners46

Originally posted by ThatPetrolRelation

Palace has been spending a lot, that is a simple fact.
[Link]

If that is an up to date valuation then we are only spending/losing 20 million a year on transfers

126m net spend since June 2014 is an average of 31.5m per year.

That’s a shed load on top of wages for a club our size.

 


If you come to a fork in the road, take it.

michaelpearce Flag grays 03 Sep 18 7.07am

Originally posted by Hrolf The Ganger

I'm not interested in the Micky Mouse French league.
Where it matters, his clubs have been relegated.

Do try not to be so patronising, especially when comparing apples with oranges.

wrong is wrong you said every team not his last 2 teams,
doesnt matter which league he played in,I worked for 3 company's that went under does that make me a bad worker no just poor company's i choose to work for,then stayed employed for 32 years at one company proctor and gamble

so if you dont like being told your wrong dont make incorrect statements then try and justify how more wrong you can be

 

Page 11 of 11 << First< 7 8 9 10 11

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Palace vs Swansea Carabao Cup Match Thread