You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Palace v Southampton Match Thread
November 16 2026 6.51am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Palace v Southampton Match Thread


Page 17 of 17 << First< 13 14 15 16 17
palace chick Flag South Croydon 02 Sep 18 10.22am

Three players stand out for me as underperforming/not good enough for the first 11 from yesterday and they were Benteke, Townsend and Schlupp. Our problem then is who plays in place of them? I still have our best 11 including Loftus-Cheek and Cabaye and of course the missing Zaha. I’m confused as to why new players purchased still aren’t up to speed to be starters from our first game onwards. We are now 5 games in and playing a weaker 11 in our league matches then we had playing for us last season? Even though I said Townsend, he would be in my top 11 playing up front alongside Zaha. Perhaps Ayew? The big center forward doesn’t seem to work for us with Roy’s way of playing/players we have so we need to go back to a stronger midfield as McArthur and Luka need quality help In midfield?

 

spartakev2 Flag Anerley 02 Sep 18 10.41am

Originally posted by palace chick

Three players stand out for me as underperforming/not good enough for the first 11 from yesterday and they were Benteke, Townsend and Schlupp. Our problem then is who plays in place of them? I still have our best 11 including Loftus-Cheek and Cabaye and of course the missing Zaha. I’m confused as to why new players purchased still aren’t up to speed to be starters from our first game onwards. We are now 5 games in and playing a weaker 11 in our league matches then we had playing for us last season? Even though I said Townsend, he would be in my top 11 playing up front alongside Zaha. Perhaps Ayew? The big center forward doesn’t seem to work for us with Roy’s way of playing/players we have so we need to go back to a stronger midfield as McArthur and Luka need quality help In midfield?

Townsend for me is the most overated player in the team. Seems to have lost his pace, almost always cuts inside, making him very predictable and in his position should score more goals. Yes he runs around a lot and chases back, but rarely does he actually get a tackle in - watch the two Watford goals. With Benteke not looking like he'll ever score a goal, we need other players to step up and no one is. Which is why we rely so heavily on Zaha, without him we just don't look like scoring. I agree with others that Meyer and kayoute should be starting. If they don't start against Huddersfield, I really will be p****d off.

 

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 02 Sep 18 10.48am

Originally posted by spartakev2

Townsend for me is the most overated player in the team. Seems to have lost his pace, almost always cuts inside, making him very predictable and in his position should score more goals. Yes he runs around a lot and chases back, but rarely does he actually get a tackle in - watch the two Watford goals. With Benteke not looking like he'll ever score a goal, we need other players to step up and no one is. Which is why we rely so heavily on Zaha, without him we just don't look like scoring. I agree with others that Meyer and kayoute should be starting. If they don't start against Huddersfield, I really will be p****d off.

This is exactly what I was stating on HOL a couple of weeks ago.For me, he has been disappointing and perhaps his performances have not been criticised as much as all the focus is on Benteke and the continuance of his abject displays.

 

jeeagles Flag 02 Sep 18 1.19pm

Thought the blame lies with Hodgson yesterday. He's got us well drilled but he's an avarage manager at this level.

Last season, Cabaye, RLC and Zaha would have carried us through that game. With the exception of Schlupp the rest of the players gave a good account of themselves but just weren't up to it.

Benteke seemed to be pressing more than usual but there's only so many times you can say he's unfortunate to miss.

Schlupp just seemed like he wasn't paying any attention. We should have dragged him off the pitch at the earliest opportunity. It was like we only had 10 men on the pitch.

Some positives. The new signings all played well. I'd like to see Zaha go back on the wing and keep Ayew up front.

 

StrangerThing Flag Brisbane 03 Sep 18 4.58am

Terrible first half. The midfield just didn't work, simply not enough creativity amongst Schlupp, Luka, JMac and Andros.
Second half was better and got even better when the subs came on.

 

Eaglecoops Flag CR3 03 Sep 18 11.25am

If Roy wants to persist with 4-4-2 in Zahas absence then Townsend should play up front with Ayew (as he did end of last season with Zaha), the midfield should then be Milivojevic in front of the back 4 and Meyer, Kouyate and McArthur in the midfield. Kouyate and Meyer will allow Milivojevic to play more like he did last year when Cabaye was in the side.

 

Page 17 of 17 << First< 13 14 15 16 17

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Palace v Southampton Match Thread