You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Palace vs West Brom (Carabao Cup) match thread
November 16 2026 6.51am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Palace vs West Brom (Carabao Cup) match thread


Page 6 of 6 << First< 2 3 4 5 6
Forest Hillbilly Flag in a hidey-hole 26 Sep 18 12.04am

great result. Roy pleased too.

 


I disengage, I turn the page.

MrCParrot Flag Taunton 26 Sep 18 6.53am

Originally posted by Maine Eagle

Mainly I would think this concerns Max Meyer who did well, but not great.

Roy may have thought Schlupp and Sorloth put a good shift in also. I dont see Puncheon being a factor, except outside nightclubs. You never know with Hodgson though, he might be talking about Joel Ward, you just never know.

Ayew did enough in about 6 minutes to tell me he is better than Sorloth up top. That said Sorloth did one thing very well which was lay the ball to Andros with 2 guys around him, which allowed Townsend to get into position to hit that cracking shot.

I doubt he means the goalie but you never know, Guaita looked very assured tonight, albeit against a lacklustre outfit.

Sounds like its all about Meyer then.
Ayew>Sorloth
Hennessey>Guaita
Meyer>Schlupp & Macca

I think its worth a try with Meyer wide left of midfield in RLCs place and Kouyate staying alongside Luka.
I'd like to see if Meyer can play in the centre with Luka at some stage as there is a chance that RLC will come back to Selhurst Park.

Parrot

 


Mr Cadbury's Parrot says "Hello"

YT Flag Oxford 26 Sep 18 8.12am

Originally posted by Willo

Splendid victory.
I suspect not too many would have predicted a 3-0 win for us.
I would be happy with a draw against Blackpool or Burton Albion in the next round !

I’ve speculated in another thread that if Stoke progress, we could draw them away and will therefore have faced in successive away ties all three teams that were relegated from the Prem last season.

 


Palace since 19 August 1972. Palace 1 (Tony Taylor) Liverpool 1 (Emlyn Hughes)

louis01 Flag Llandudno 26 Sep 18 8.32am

Originally posted by Maine Eagle

At least RH gave Meyer 30 mins last weekend, rather than the normal 15.

Meyer is not exactly setting the world on fire here, but I still think he should be starting for us.

I thought he was fantastic last night. Set the tempo of the play. Always in space and free for the ball. Great at closing down and winning back the ball. Quick first touch passing with a football brain far superior to anyone else on the pitch.

I haven't seen the stats but I would bet he touched the ball more than anyone else on the pitch? IMO he has to start for us every game from now on. He is ready.

Edited by louis01 (26 Sep 2018 8.33am)

 


It's all fun and games until someone loses an eye!

Badger11 Flag Beckenham 26 Sep 18 9.04am

Originally posted by louis01

I thought he was fantastic last night. Set the tempo of the play. Always in space and free for the ball. Great at closing down and winning back the ball. Quick first touch passing with a football brain far superior to anyone else on the pitch.

I haven't seen the stats but I would bet he touched the ball more than anyone else on the pitch? IMO he has to start for us every game from now on. He is ready.

Agreed I thought he gave a Cabaye type performance last night. He was the link man constantly busy recycling the ball.

Edited by louis01 (26 Sep 2018 8.33am)

 


One more point

PatrickA Flag London 26 Sep 18 9.53am

That was a good performance and it wouldn’t have flattered us to win 5-0 as a number of chances were missed.
However, it should be borne in mind that WBA were so,poor that even Sorloth looked decent!
It was pleasing to see Townsend score a couple of very good goals and Meyer looked impressive and has a different skill set to the other midfielders.
I’m still not sure exactly how Roy will fit him into the team but I hope he gets the chance sooner rather than later.

 

Painter Flag Croydon 26 Sep 18 10.36am

WBA were very poor in truth. The worrying aspect is Sorloth can’t hold the ball up, every time it was played up to him, it bounced off him like a cat trying to trap a ping pong ball.

 

ouzo Flag Rafina 26 Sep 18 11.42am

Highlights from last night

[Link]

 

Yellow Card - User has been warned of conduct on the messageboards Hrolf The Ganger Flag 26 Sep 18 11.57am

A comfortable win but Sorloth?
What a waste of time. Barely Championship level in my opinion. With Ayew being totally average, I'd play a four man midfield and just have Wilf and Townsend forward. That way we can include Meyer and Kouyate. It couldn't be worse than it is currently.

Edited by Hrolf The Ganger (26 Sep 2018 11.57am)

 

palace chick Flag South Croydon 26 Sep 18 12.19pm

Originally posted by Hrolf The Ganger

A comfortable win but Sorloth?
What a waste of time. Barely Championship level in my opinion. With Ayew being totally average, I'd play a four man midfield and just have Wilf and Townsend forward. That way we can include Meyer and Kouyate. It couldn't be worse than it is currently.

Edited by Hrolf The Ganger (26 Sep 2018 11.57am)

Agree with the four midfield guys with Wilf and Townsend in front of them. Think we may see that on Monday at Bournemouth ?

 

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 26 Sep 18 12.21pm

Originally posted by Hrolf The Ganger

A comfortable win but Sorloth?
What a waste of time. Barely Championship level in my opinion. With Ayew being totally average, I'd play a four man midfield and just have Wilf and Townsend forward. That way we can include Meyer and Kouyate. It couldn't be worse than it is currently.

Edited by Hrolf The Ganger (26 Sep 2018 11.57am)

Ayew never did pre-season training with Swansea and joined us on deadline day.He has not had much chance with us and perhaps he just needs more game time to recover his sharpness.I appreciate that his overall goal scoring record in the PL is not that impressive but he did score 11 PL goals last season in a struggling team.

 

buzzby Flag West Sussex 26 Sep 18 1.48pm

Originally posted by Maine Eagle
At least RH gave Meyer 30 mins last weekend, rather than the normal 15.

Meyer is not exactly setting the world on fire here, but I still think he should be starting for us.

Meyer is quality. he has only had limited game time in the prem.

What do some of you expect. He needs 90 mins game time on a consistent basis.

 


rub a dub dub who's buying the next round in the Pub?

Yellow Card - User has been warned of conduct on the messageboards Hrolf The Ganger Flag 26 Sep 18 2.02pm

Originally posted by Willo

Ayew never did pre-season training with Swansea and joined us on deadline day.He has not had much chance with us and perhaps he just needs more game time to recover his sharpness.I appreciate that his overall goal scoring record in the PL is not that impressive but he did score 11 PL goals last season in a struggling team.

Fair comment but do we want him going forward? He is a cheap option loan player and we must sign better, the sooner the better.

 

Daddyorc Flag Atlantic Highlands, NJ 26 Sep 18 2.06pm

Originally posted by YT

I haven't spotted any comments about the ref - Peter Bankes, I believe.

How was he? A SAFE pair of hands, or did his performance TELLER different story?

Seen better, although to be fair, we managed to get the better of the calls. The Kelly non-call was likely a hand ball that wasn't called (was just outside the penalty area). Also, there was one play where Townsend (ours) was WAY offside, and it wasn't called. Sure it was a deflection to him, but there was no possession, so should have been offside, but wasn't called (he didn't score, but was a great chance).

 

Maine Eagle Flag USA 26 Sep 18 2.22pm

Originally posted by Hrolf The Ganger

A comfortable win but Sorloth?
What a waste of time. Barely Championship level in my opinion. With Ayew being totally average, I'd play a four man midfield and just have Wilf and Townsend forward. That way we can include Meyer and Kouyate. It couldn't be worse than it is currently.

Edited by Hrolf The Ganger (26 Sep 2018 11.57am)

Sorloth looks poor. That said he needs to go out on loan and play regularly for us to really evaluate him. His close control is generally not good enough for hold up play, but every now and then he does something good, like score at Swansea, or play a nice ball to Andros for the first goal last night.

Whoever sanctioned Rakip, Jach, and Sorloth needs to have a long look in the mirror.

I am not gonna write off Ayew just yet though, he is still getting up to speed and he is proven in the Premier League.

Wilf and Andros up top worked pretty well (mainly) in the past, and if it gets Max Meyer on the pitch I am down with it.

Dont forget who our manager is. We only have AWB playing for us now as RH had his hand forced. Same goes for playing 2 wingers up front, although Zaha isnt only a winger anymore I guess.

RH is conservative and old school in many ways - expect Sorloth and Ayew to be in the plans if they are fit and available.

 


Trump lost. Badly. Hahahahahahaha.

BarEagle Flag Monmouth 27 Sep 18 2.50pm

Originally posted by Hrolf The Ganger

A comfortable win but Sorloth?
What a waste of time. Barely Championship level in my opinion. With Ayew being totally average, I'd play a four man midfield and just have Wilf and Townsend forward. That way we can include Meyer and Kouyate. It couldn't be worse than it is currently.

Edited by Hrolf The Ganger (26 Sep 2018 11.57am)

I was at the match. I must advise you he was quality. I was not convinced and thought a loan spell would help. He laid off some balls when he could have shot, he made the correct decision to do so but they had winkle pickers on.

He works hard, looks up and was hungry.

Guitar was very confident and impressive on the crosses; certainly has the edge over Hennessey there.

However, Joel Ward switched from Right back to left central defender and was outstanding. He was my MOM and those around me at the game. Put it this way I would replace Sakho with him atm.

 

BarEagle Flag Monmouth 27 Sep 18 2.51pm

Originally posted by BarEagle

I was at the match. I must advise you he was quality. I was not convinced and thought a loan spell would help. He laid off some balls when he could have shot, he made the correct decision to do so but they had winkle pickers on.

He works hard, looks up and was hungry.

Guitar was very confident and impressive on the crosses; certainly has the edge over Hennessey there.

However, Joel Ward switched from Right back to left central defender and was outstanding. He was my MOM and those around me at the game. Put it this way I would replace Sakho with him atm.

Guaita not guitar

 

Bexley Eagle Flag Bexley Kent 27 Sep 18 4.10pm

Originally posted by BarEagle

I was at the match. I must advise you he was quality. I was not convinced and thought a loan spell would help. He laid off some balls when he could have shot, he made the correct decision to do so but they had winkle pickers on.

He works hard, looks up and was hungry.

Guitar was very confident and impressive on the crosses; certainly has the edge over Hennessey there.

However, Joel Ward switched from Right back to left central defender and was outstanding. He was my MOM and those around me at the game. Put it this way I would replace Sakho with him atm.

Interesting comments on this thread. Joel Ward had a tidy game, however given that we dominated possession and for large parts our defence was redundant, it is hard to judge. Meyer done OK, but wasn’t a stand out as some suggest. He did OK, but then most did OK. I personally liked a lot of what Sorloth contributed. He had a couple of headed chances which were by no means “Benteke sitters” and thumped a shot towards the end which almost decapitated their defender. I think he knows where the back of the net is, but still needs to work on his positioning. His first touch and lay-offs were much improved, albeit not perfect. Ayew looked a threat in his brief outing as well. So we do have options, albeit nothing as a stand out option up front.

I personally would like to go 442 for Bournemouth with Meyer and Macarther playing wide in a narrow 4, with Wilf and Andros up top. I definitely think it’s worth a look.

 

Booted Eagle Flag Bristol 27 Sep 18 5.35pm

Originally posted by Maine Eagle

Sorloth looks poor. That said he needs to go out on loan and play regularly for us to really evaluate him. His close control is generally not good enough for hold up play, but every now and then he does something good, like score at Swansea, or play a nice ball to Andros for the first goal last night.

Whoever sanctioned Rakip, Jach, and Sorloth needs to have a long look in the mirror.

I am not gonna write off Ayew just yet though, he is still getting up to speed and he is proven in the Premier League.

Wilf and Andros up top worked pretty well (mainly) in the past, and if it gets Max Meyer on the pitch I am down with it.

Dont forget who our manager is. We only have AWB playing for us now as RH had his hand forced. Same goes for playing 2 wingers up front, although Zaha isnt only a winger anymore I guess.

RH is conservative and old school in many ways - expect Sorloth and Ayew to be in the plans if they are fit and available.

Hoping that we have new personnel scouting around and consequently a far better Jan window. If Sorloth cannot contribute anything then it definitely doesn't look good. Sorloth looks like his best is hold up/lay off play which he showed on Tues night. Was hoping to see him attack the clear header he had at the back stick a little more in the 1st half. Ayew needs more gametime but may well have the edge at the moment. Meyer has very good close control and his short passing game moving forward is great. Hopefully we can see him threading some longer balls through in the future. Kouyate looked solid as well. Got stuck in and did the basics well. Nice to see Pape given a run out and hoep to see Dann as well soon.

 


“ [T]here are known knowns; there are things we know that we know.There are known unknowns; that is to say there are things that, we now know we don't know.But there are also unknown unknowns – there are things we do not know we don't know. ”
—United States Secretary of Defense, Donald Rumsfeld

traevor Flag 28 Sep 18 12.13am

Originally posted by BarEagle

However, Joel Ward switched from Right back to left central defender and was outstanding. He was my MOM and those around me at the game. Put it this way I would replace Sakho with him atm.

Ward did well in the same role against Swansea as well. Granted it was against weaker oppositions but he might have what it takes to be a decent ball-playing defender.

Edited by traevor (28 Sep 2018 12.14am)

 

Page 6 of 6 << First< 2 3 4 5 6

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Palace vs West Brom (Carabao Cup) match thread