You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > You should go in Jan wilf
November 16 2026 6.51am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

You should go in Jan wilf


Page 3 of 3 << First< 1 2 3
Midlands Eagle Flag 08 Oct 18 1.54pm

Originally posted by MonsterMunch

So by this you are implying that getting rid of Wilf is constructive? Jog on

Try reading what I have posted in this thread instead of selecting soundbites

 

Lyons550 Flag Shirley 08 Oct 18 3.13pm

I'm happy for any player to leave us on high...provided that we have his replacement already in the squad. There's no point selling Wilf for say £80m and then get held to ransom for a below par replacement.

Leicester got it right by signing Demari Gray a season before then offloading Mahrez

 


The Voice of Reason In An Otherwise Mediocre World

eag-les Flag Coulsdon 08 Oct 18 4.17pm

Need to go back to the winning formation of Wilf and Andros up front. Best football I've seen in a long time ....throw in Max for JA....simps!

 


If I agreed with you we'd both be wrong

Pinkfluff1981 Flag 08 Oct 18 8.30pm

Obviously everyone wants to keep zaha. The OP said and I agree free up some funds. Palace can’t afford a decent striker or decent attacking midfielder, we would have to cash in on zaha to create funds. Otherwise all we buy is tosh like Benteke, Ayew, sorloth and Wickham. The jist of the post as I read it was to take a different approach and not rely on one man. Which we do and have done for several years and it’s not doing great. We scrape by every season. Zaha will go this season or end of so why not do it on our terms and be ready for it, rather than end of season or worse January and be left with the palace hierarchy to do transfer business in a panic like we always do and buy the left overs that no other team wants. Exceptions to mila, pva and Meyer of recent years.

Edited by Pinkfluff1981 (08 Oct 2018 8.33pm)

 

Aray Flag South London 08 Oct 18 8.49pm

Originally posted by Midlands Eagle

I can't see that anyone here has made a rubbish suggestion.

Some have made suggestions that you and/or others may disagree with but that doesn't make them "rubbish"

You’re entitled your opinion - I think the OP’s suggestion of selling our best player is a rubbish idea - it’s not as if we have already got ready made replacements in the bag. The January market place is rarely a good one to spring class players. Other clubs would see us coming and pull our pants down. There. A longer form answer but still the same conclusion.

 

Rachid Rachid Rachid Flag 08 Oct 18 9.19pm

My view is that the remainder of the midfield and attack has been so chronically short of quality in the final third that teams really just have to stop Wilf and Wilf only.

 

Midlands Eagle Flag 08 Oct 18 9.49pm

Originally posted by Aray

You’re entitled your opinion - I think the OP’s suggestion of selling our best player is a rubbish idea - it’s not as if we have already got ready made replacements in the bag. The January market place is rarely a good one to spring class players. Other clubs would see us coming and pull our pants down. There. A longer form answer but still the same conclusion.

As you say, you are entitled to your opinion as the OP is entitled to his

 

Vaibow Flag vancouver/croydon 08 Oct 18 10.25pm

Thing is, way things are going i can see Zaha going in the summer.

The hierarchy at palace just isn't changing it's apparent ethos of 'gambling that there will be 3 worse teams than palace and then panic buy if we need too'.

Roy wanted up to 7 faces in January... who did we get, 3 blokes, one finished his loan spell with not so much a performance, one has been shipped out on loan stating he isn't ready and the other hasn't performed in any capacity in 10 months, wether or not t's his fault.

This summer, we had players go, planned or not. Cabaye was replaced in theory with Meyer, who ultimately needs time to grow into that role.

So what about players like Sako, RLC, TFM have they been like for like replaced or upgraded? So far, no.

Our striker last season under performed, so did we get a replacement as plan b or competition - no. Has he returned to scoring ways, no.

Ok, has the club come out with a game plan, a style they want to achieve and have a squad that reflects that? not really...

We are still a frankenstein team with players from Holloway, Pulis, Warnock, Pardew, SA, FDB. Managers that all have very different styles.

The breaks on a new stand should be pumped. The manager needs to be backed and let his squad be seen, utilized and respected.

Get some stability in that.

So, let's say last summer we shipped out Bentekke for 20 mil. Zaha for 45 mil and let's say we still got in Meyer, we spent the loan fee and got RLC - i heard it was 10 million.

Let's also say we bought two strikers, each at around 20 mil (when all factors taken in).

Sure, it be a new look palace, but would we be where we are now? No recognized striker scoring? Players played put of position?

It's all very well having a merc in the garage, but if you're only driving it to Lidle and back once a week, defeats the purpose.

Summer just gone should have been a major over haul for the good of the club as the rot is just continuing.

 


This was once a quality forum....

taylors lovechild Flag 09 Oct 18 8.06am

Originally posted by Vaibow

Thing is, way things are going i can see Zaha going in the summer.

The hierarchy at palace just isn't changing it's apparent ethos of 'gambling that there will be 3 worse teams than palace and then panic buy if we need too'.

Roy wanted up to 7 faces in January... who did we get, 3 blokes, one finished his loan spell with not so much a performance, one has been shipped out on loan stating he isn't ready and the other hasn't performed in any capacity in 10 months, wether or not t's his fault.

This summer, we had players go, planned or not. Cabaye was replaced in theory with Meyer, who ultimately needs time to grow into that role.

So what about players like Sako, RLC, TFM have they been like for like replaced or upgraded? So far, no.

Our striker last season under performed, so did we get a replacement as plan b or competition - no. Has he returned to scoring ways, no.

Ok, has the club come out with a game plan, a style they want to achieve and have a squad that reflects that? not really...

We are still a frankenstein team with players from Holloway, Pulis, Warnock, Pardew, SA, FDB. Managers that all have very different styles.

The breaks on a new stand should be pumped. The manager needs to be backed and let his squad be seen, utilized and respected.

Get some stability in that.

So, let's say last summer we shipped out Bentekke for 20 mil. Zaha for 45 mil and let's say we still got in Meyer, we spent the loan fee and got RLC - i heard it was 10 million.

Let's also say we bought two strikers, each at around 20 mil (when all factors taken in).

Sure, it be a new look palace, but would we be where we are now? No recognized striker scoring? Players played put of position?

It's all very well having a merc in the garage, but if you're only driving it to Lidle and back once a week, defeats the purpose.

Summer just gone should have been a major over haul for the good of the club as the rot is just continuing.

If we'd been offered £20m for Bentenke I think we might have taken it. If we'd sold Zaha for 45m the fans would have burned the ground down.

It's possible what you say is true, but it's also possible neither of the strikers would score and RLC would put his back out again and we wouldn't have the three goals and an assist that Wilf has already racked up (and the points that go with that).

 

Bangell Flag Oxford 09 Oct 18 9.33am

This thread is like inviting another man to sleep with your wife

 

HeathMan Flag Purley 09 Oct 18 12.06pm

A very interesting thread. Some posters have confirmed that Palace are (sadly) recognised as a one player team (wins are rare without Wilf), and a stop Wilf stop Palace culture is coming into existence. Watching Palace play the level of ball control and passing (sometimes it seems that the forward pass is too rarely used effectively) is a joy to watch. There are also concerns about not scoring (could a six nil win lead to many palace supporters scoring after the match?). One young Palace Player (AWB) broke into the first team last season. He has peers (Alexander-Arnold at Liverpool and the 21 yo Leicester player called up be Mr Southgate). We had an injury crisis last year at the back, could this years crisis at the front be used to the benefit of young player waiting their chance?

 

HeathMan Flag Purley 09 Oct 18 12.09pm

Perhaps a couple of wins with Wilf not starting and leading quality from the bench at 50 minutes could give worry to 19 managers and joy to Palace People?

 

southnorwoodhill Flag 09 Oct 18 12.23pm

Originally posted by Vaibow

The hierarchy at palace just isn't changing it's apparent ethos of 'gambling that there will be 3 worse teams than palace and then panic buy if we need too'.

Summer just gone should have been a major over haul for the good of the club as the rot is just continuing.

I have the impression that Parish is a bit of a chancer. It's been more of the same for a few seasons now, I can't imagine any major overhaul occurring. Not solving the striker crisis really sums up the club at the moment.

 

Aray Flag South London 09 Oct 18 1.00pm

Originally posted by Bangell

This thread is like inviting another man to sleep with your wife

To continue the analogy...nailed it

 

cryrst Flag The garden of England 09 Oct 18 9.24pm

Originally posted by Bangell

This thread is like inviting another man to sleep with your wife

Theres a thread on general for that

 

Vaibow Flag vancouver/croydon 10 Oct 18 1.40am

Originally posted by southnorwoodhill

I have the impression that Parish is a bit of a chancer. It's been more of the same for a few seasons now, I can't imagine any major overhaul occurring. Not solving the striker crisis really sums up the club at the moment.

Spot on, nothing is going to change as it's making the directors money.

 


This was once a quality forum....

Page 3 of 3 << First< 1 2 3

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > You should go in Jan wilf