You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Back from the game
November 16 2026 6.52am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Back from the game


kevlee Flag born Wandsworth emigrated to Lanc... 21 Oct 18 8.42pm

Typical Palace. Hold out til the 86 minute and then lose.
1. Wilfred clearly not 100% but still the centre point and only threat from us.
2. As usual he was targeted.
3. It was a penalty - and was right in from of us.
4. I knew Luka was going hit it down the middle, and he did. A s*** penalty.
5. Schlupp was poor, so was Luka. Sakho playing like a lunatic didn't help.
6. Wayne played well. "Wales No 1" chant went down well.
7. I did think we were going to hold out get a point which would have been a good result IMO. But at the end of the day typical Palace, miss a penalty and end up losing.

 


Following Palace since 25 Feb 1978

Ali_Campbell Flag New Addington 21 Oct 18 8.56pm

Personally I thought that was the best wilf has been for weeks. Hennessy has been really good this season, he is like a new man. He can’t be at fault for the goals. We defended well and looked dangerous on the counter.

We just need more up top. Hopefully Wickham can give us something. Plus, if we are playing for a draw, defensive change should have been done on 75 to keep things tighter.

 

FairweatherEagle Flag London 21 Oct 18 10.45pm

Well it seems this match had polarised opinion more than any other. I did not see it but there's now a Roy out brigade forming at the same time there's a load of people who seem to think it's the best we've played in a while.

 

aquickgame2 Flag Beni = summer,Caribbean = winter 21 Oct 18 10.57pm

Been back a short time now.
Thought we played well..best in the last 3/4 games.
Wilf also played his best game since the Watford comment.
We bossed the first half,missed the pen then they got on top for the first time in the game.Nicked a couple of goals,game over.

The ground was like a morgue,never heard Goodison that quiet before.

 

antipodeagle Flag Wellington 22 Oct 18 10.43am

Originally posted by aquickgame2

Been back a short time now.
Thought we played well..best in the last 3/4 games.
Wilf also played his best game since the Watford comment.
We bossed the first half,missed the pen then they got on top for the first time in the game.Nicked a couple of goals,game over.

The ground was like a morgue,never heard Goodison that quiet before.

I would agree with all of that. The difference was their bench. They were able to bring on three very good attacking players and they changed the game. Our attacking replacement has had one game against a non-league team in the last two years.

I thought Kouyate was a positive for us and gave us a bit more size and steel in the middle of the park.

 

thai-eagle Flag chiang mai 22 Oct 18 11.45am

Think this team with Meyer in for Schlupp will start the game vs. Arsenal! And maybe Ayew for Andros....

 

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 22 Oct 18 11.56am

Originally posted by antipodeagle

I would agree with all of that. The difference was their bench. They were able to bring on three very good attacking players and they changed the game. Our attacking replacement has had one game against a non-league team in the last two years.

I thought Kouyate was a positive for us and gave us a bit more size and steel in the middle of the park.

I totally agree.

He is 6ft 4in and filled in at centre-half for W.Ham when they had injuries.
I believe the way forward is to play him with Milivojevic to give us that defensive solidity in midfield allowing the more attacking players to be given a freer reign.Perhaps this will improve our goalscoring.

Edited by Willo (22 Oct 2018 1.34pm)

 

RyWa Flag Beckenham 22 Oct 18 12.05pm

I agree with the comments above.

He may not be the most technically gifted, but Kouyate was good yesterday, he must've won atleast 75% of aerial duels he went in for which i was impressed with.

I think with the holding 3 of himself, Luka & Jimmy and then Meyer to replace Schlupp, its a team that can potentially have a good season (once we get through these next 4 games, which will no doubt cause some sort of meltdown on here in the mean time).

Whatever happens, theres still 87 points to play for, we probably only need a third of those to be safe again for another year (im trying to be optimistic)

Edited by RyWa (22 Oct 2018 12.08pm)

 

Maine Eagle Flag USA 22 Oct 18 12.20pm

Originally posted by thai-eagle

Think this team with Meyer in for Schlupp will start the game vs. Arsenal! And maybe Ayew for Andros....

Meyer and Schlupp don’t play the same position.

Meyer will come in for Kouyate no doubt as Roy can’t seem to drop MacArthur or Luka.

Ayew or Kaikai could play where useless Schlupp does.

 


Trump lost. Badly. Hahahahahahaha.

MARKY Flag coulsdon 22 Oct 18 12.20pm

What stood out for me watching the game on the box was Schlupp was poor and Andros Townsend has lost his pace he really struggles to beat his man and has become really ineffective which is a worry

 

Maine Eagle Flag USA 22 Oct 18 12.38pm

Originally posted by MARKY

What stood out for me watching the game on the box was Schlupp was poor and Andros Townsend has lost his pace he really struggles to beat his man and has become really ineffective which is a worry

Hate to say it but one of the big reasons we are so poor without Zaha is Andros is not much of a threat anymore.

With the defensive attention Zaha gets it should open things up for the other players. When those other players are Schlupp, an out of form or possibly finished Andros and MacArthur (tries hard but he is not an attacking midfielder) we are struggling.

 


Trump lost. Badly. Hahahahahahaha.

benmccarthy Flag Kent 22 Oct 18 1.26pm

They had game changers on the bench we had Puncheon. Enough said.

 

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 22 Oct 18 1.39pm

Originally posted by RyWa

I agree with the comments above.

He may not be the most technically gifted, but Kouyate was good yesterday, he must've won atleast 75% of aerial duels he went in for which i was impressed with.

I think with the holding 3 of himself, Luka & Jimmy and then Meyer to replace Schlupp, its a team that can potentially have a good season (once we get through these next 4 games, which will no doubt cause some sort of meltdown on here in the mean time).

Whatever happens, theres still 87 points to play for, we probably only need a third of those to be safe again for another year (im trying to be optimistic)

Edited by RyWa (22 Oct 2018 12.08pm)

On the assumption that we lose the next 4 games, which is highly likely, we will have 7 pts after 13 games.
Last season we had 8 pts after 13 games but at this stage last season we hadn't lost 7 on the bounce after the 13 games.

 

Maine Eagle Flag USA 22 Oct 18 2.45pm

Originally posted by Willo

On the assumption that we lose the next 4 games, which is highly likely, we will have 7 pts after 13 games.
Last season we had 8 pts after 13 games but at this stage last season we hadn't lost 7 on the bounce after the 13 games.

The comparisons to last season are a bit much.

It was the worst start for any team in the history of professional football. It’s an outlier.

Compare this year to previous seasons but not last year as that is a total one off.

 


Trump lost. Badly. Hahahahahahaha.

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 22 Oct 18 3.06pm

Originally posted by Maine Eagle

The comparisons to last season are a bit much.

It was the worst start for any team in the history of professional football. It’s an outlier.

Compare this year to previous seasons but not last year as that is a total one off.

Of course 0 pts after 7 games was the worst start but as I mentioned, after 13 games we might have less points than after 13 games last season.In our 13th game last season we won 2-1 beating Stoke - not sure we will win our 13th game this season !

Who knows what affect losing 7 on the bounce will have on us, if indeed this sorry state of affairs is the reality ? In effect this will be 0 pts from 7 games - sounds familiar ?

 

JohnB Flag 22 Oct 18 3.20pm

I thought Hennessey, AWB, Tomkins & Zaha were very good.

Sakho seems to be a complete liability, when he first got here he was playing confident passes to feet and doing the right things. Now he seems to be dwelling on the ball, trying ridiculous back heels and the amount of times he played a complete hospital ball to Luka was insane. He made Luka look awful by playing such horrific passes that he had no choice but to just lump it somewhere with no control.

We are clearly crying out for someone with some composure in the team which is why I find it so astounding that Meyer has barely featured.

Schlupp was poor yesterday, he's athletic but that's about where it seems to end. Their second goal came from him trying to beat four players and kicking it at them each time, it bobbling back to him and then trying the same thing until he eventually lost it and they scored.

Zaha is completely isolated and has no help.

Townsend is a player that you can normally count on to run and run and will have a streak of games where he looks world class then goes back to normal, we just don't seem to have had that streak for about 2 years though.

I love McArthur but he just seems to be running around like a headless chicken at the moment.

We need to go back to 4-5-1 and we desperately need a fit striker.

If we had a fit first team I would play

.........Hennessey

AWB...Tomkins....Sakho...PVA

.......Kouyate...Luka
...........Meyer
Townsend/Ayew...........Zaha
...........Benteke

 

EagleinSF Flag San Fransisco 22 Oct 18 3.28pm

Watching it on the box, I thought that Kouyate looked good. TBH I was thinking that with his aerial ability, and the way he gets stuck in he may be a good target man. I'd be tempted to play him up top against Arsenal who don't have the best back line.

Just a thought...

 

The Dolphin Flag 23 Oct 18 8.11am

Originally posted by JohnB

I thought Hennessey, AWB, Tomkins & Zaha were very good.

Sakho seems to be a complete liability, when he first got here he was playing confident passes to feet and doing the right things. Now he seems to be dwelling on the ball, trying ridiculous back heels and the amount of times he played a complete hospital ball to Luka was insane. He made Luka look awful by playing such horrific passes that he had no choice but to just lump it somewhere with no control.

We are clearly crying out for someone with some composure in the team which is why I find it so astounding that Meyer has barely featured.

Schlupp was poor yesterday, he's athletic but that's about where it seems to end. Their second goal came from him trying to beat four players and kicking it at them each time, it bobbling back to him and then trying the same thing until he eventually lost it and they scored.

Zaha is completely isolated and has no help.

Townsend is a player that you can normally count on to run and run and will have a streak of games where he looks world class then goes back to normal, we just don't seem to have had that streak for about 2 years though.

I love McArthur but he just seems to be running around like a headless chicken at the moment.

We need to go back to 4-5-1 and we desperately need a fit striker.

If we had a fit first team I would play

.........Hennessey

AWB...Tomkins....Sakho...PVA

.......Kouyate...Luka
...........Meyer
Townsend/Ayew...........Zaha
...........Benteke

Top post but would have a fit Wickham instead of Benteke.
I never thought I would write it but I am so looking forward to Wickham being fit again and hopefully getting a run of games!

 


You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Back from the game