You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Keepers diving?
November 16 2026 6.33am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Keepers diving?


h.smith91 Flag Sanderstead 16 Dec 18 11.07am

The other one... the bad one!

Watching as much as I could of yesterday’s game (due to currently working in Dubai with bang average WiFi). It made me think... has their ever been a case of a keeper diving to win a foul? If it was a dive in the box would it be a penalty or freekick?

What first made me think of it was Schmeichel going down after a feather touch from McArthur I believe in the first half from a cross. The commentators said he was barely touched if at all yet, with keepers getting so much protection in the modern game, it was blown up for a foul. It clearly wasn’t a foul, and my frustration was doubled when minutes later McArthur was booked for diving. That was a harsh decision I feel, even if he was looking for it. Anyway, if the keeper was judged to have dived what would the punishment be (apart from a yellow card)? Similarly when Guaita went down under Vardy’s challenge (which WAS a foul, incidentally) it that was judged as a dive would that have been a pen or freekick?

Thoughts?

 

thai-eagle Flag chiang mai 16 Dec 18 11.55am

It was blatant dive. Watched game on TV live with mate from Leicester - he agreed 100%. But our no 18 did NOT dive...ref got it wrong twice.

 

TheExpatEagle Flag 20 Dec 18 8.36pm

It would be a free kick.

You probably know that not all fouls inside the penalty area result in a penalty. I know the rules have changed a little in the last few years so it isn't a common occurrence.

Free kicks can be awarded inside the box for offences such as a goalkeeper picking up a back pass and simulation by a defending team player.

Here are some free kicks from inside the penalty box. [Link]

 


You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Keepers diving?