You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Hennessey or Guaita v Cardiff?
November 16 2026 6.32am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Hennessey or Guaita v Cardiff?


Page 3 of 3 << First< 1 2 3
Eaglecoops Flag CR3 27 Dec 18 2.15pm

Hennessey should have to wait his chance now. Guaita has looked assured and pulled off a couple of memorable saves. He deserves the no1 jersey for the time being

 

PZ Eagle Flag Penzance 27 Dec 18 3.03pm

Originally posted by Eaglecoops

Hennessey should have to wait his chance now. Guaita has looked assured and pulled off a couple of memorable saves. He deserves the no1 jersey for the time being

By that logic if AWB or Wilf miss a game through injury and Ward or Ayew/Sorloth replaced them and had good games you would leave AWB and Wilf on the bench to await their chances would you??

 


Conjunctivitis.com - A site for sore eyes.

Eaglecoops Flag CR3 27 Dec 18 4.17pm

Originally posted by PZ Eagle

By that logic if AWB or Wilf miss a game through injury and Ward or Ayew/Sorloth replaced them and had good games you would leave AWB and Wilf on the bench to await their chances would you??

Do you just post facetiously because you can or because you just like being unnecessarily obtuse?

I believe both keepers are of similar ability and the current incumbent deserves to stay in goal. Not sure why you felt it necessary to liken that to players who are clearly not of similar ability.

 

bifffabazz Flag Highworth, Wiltshire 27 Dec 18 4.40pm

Originally posted by Eaglecoops

Do you just post facetiously because you can or because you just like being unnecessarily obtuse?

I believe both keepers are of similar ability and the current incumbent deserves to stay in goal. Not sure why you felt it necessary to liken that to players who are clearly not of similar ability.

Hear hear. PZ clearly likes to spoil for a fight.
Hennessy is not in Zaha's league so the point that the replacement deserves his chance is more than reasonable. It's the way of the world except for the very elite few.

Edited by bifffabazz (27 Dec 2018 4.41pm)

 


Spirit of 1974

premier fan Flag BR4 27 Dec 18 5.13pm

Originally posted by PZ Eagle

By that logic if AWB or Wilf miss a game through injury and Ward or Ayew/Sorloth replaced them and had good games you would leave AWB and Wilf on the bench to await their chances would you??

Don't be daft!

 

Maine Eagle Flag USA 27 Dec 18 5.19pm

Originally posted by PZ Eagle

By that logic if AWB or Wilf miss a game through injury and Ward or Ayew/Sorloth replaced them and had good games you would leave AWB and Wilf on the bench to await their chances would you??

Ho ho ho. Gave me a right old chuckle here.

Comparing Hennessey to Zaha and AWB, potentially our 2 best players.

That is not so much apples to oranges as apples to typewriters.

Guaita is in now it seems, PZ, so you better accept it.

 


Trump lost. Badly. Hahahahahahaha.

PZ Eagle Flag Penzance 27 Dec 18 5.20pm

Originally posted by Eaglecoops

Do you just post facetiously because you can or because you just like being unnecessarily obtuse?

I believe both keepers are of similar ability and the current incumbent deserves to stay in goal. Not sure why you felt it necessary to liken that to players who are clearly not of similar ability.

Ward has been a good servant to Palace and would not let us down, to say that he is of lesser ability than AWB is not true, because he has a wealth of experience.that AWB has not yet acquired. If you are of the opinion that both our keepers are of similar ability then why should the one who misses out through injury not be given his place back as would be the case with an outfield player. I will concede your point regarding Wilf.

 


Conjunctivitis.com - A site for sore eyes.

Terry Vegetables Flag Forest Hill 27 Dec 18 5.23pm

Originally posted by PZ Eagle

By that logic if AWB or Wilf miss a game through injury and Ward or Ayew/Sorloth replaced them and had good games you would leave AWB and Wilf on the bench to await their chances would you??

Err? So what other logic are you meant to go by. Keep em in the team if they're playing s***e ??

 


catford kid, caught up supporting "team of the 80s" in the 70s..
1st actual Match - PALACE 1-1 LEEDS (Sat 13 Nov 1982)

Maine Eagle Flag USA 27 Dec 18 5.29pm

Originally posted by PZ Eagle

Ward has been a good servant to Palace and would not let us down, to say that he is of lesser ability than AWB is not true, because he has a wealth of experience.that AWB has not yet acquired. If you are of the opinion that both our keepers are of similar ability then why should the one who misses out through injury not be given his place back as would be the case with an outfield player. I will concede your point regarding Wilf.

Did you honestly just say that with a straight face?

Joel Ward is of the same ability as a footballer as AWB?

Mate you are off your rocker.

 


Trump lost. Badly. Hahahahahahaha.

PZ Eagle Flag Penzance 27 Dec 18 5.35pm

Originally posted by Maine Eagle

Ho ho ho. Gave me a right old chuckle here.

Comparing Hennessey to Zaha and AWB, potentially our 2 best players.

That is not so much apples to oranges as apples to typewriters.

Guaita is in now it seems, PZ, so you better accept it.

And Eaglecorps calls me facetious! Compared to you I am an amateur in that field. Where did I compare Hennessey to Wilf and AWB who are both outfield players. If you want to be that stupid I could tun it around and say that Hennessey is a class above Wilf and AWB because they don't play in goal.

VG may have made a couple of good saves but he messed up gainst Leics and almost cost us a goal plus, although KDBs cross was flukey he made no effort to save it from going in.

 


Conjunctivitis.com - A site for sore eyes.

Casual Flag Orpington 27 Dec 18 5.47pm

Originally posted by PZ Eagle

And Eaglecorps calls me facetious! Compared to you I am an amateur in that field. Where did I compare Hennessey to Wilf and AWB who are both outfield players. If you want to be that stupid I could tun it around and say that Hennessey is a class above Wilf and AWB because they don't play in goal.

VG may have made a couple of good saves but he messed up gainst Leics and almost cost us a goal plus, although KDBs cross was flukey he made no effort to save it from going in.


‘Messed up against Leicester ‘, when he kept a clean sheet on his premier league debut ??

 

PZ Eagle Flag Penzance 27 Dec 18 5.59pm

Originally posted by Casual


‘Messed up against Leicester ‘, when he kept a clean sheet on his premier league debut ??

Do you actually read what is written. I said he almost cost a goal because he did mess up by getting caught out by Vardy instead of clearing the ball. If Kevin Friend had been the ref the foul might not have been given.

 


Conjunctivitis.com - A site for sore eyes.

Casual Flag Orpington 27 Dec 18 6.08pm

Originally posted by PZ Eagle

Do you actually read what is written. I said he almost cost a goal because he did mess up by getting caught out by Vardy instead of clearing the ball. If Kevin Friend had been the ref the foul might not have been given.

Kevin Friend wasn’t the ref, the foul was given. The only way the forward could get the ball was to foul the keeper, which he did.
Clean sheet. The end.

 

Yellow Card - User has been warned of conduct on the messageboards robdave2k Flag 27 Dec 18 6.27pm

Originally posted by PZ Eagle

Do you actually read what is written. I said he almost cost a goal because he did mess up by getting caught out by Vardy instead of clearing the ball. If Kevin Friend had been the ref the foul might not have been given.


And Maradona handled it.

If anything the best thing that could have happened to him. Removes any complacency. .

As for your other comment

"KDBs cross was flukey he made no effort to save it from going in"

The only way any keeper would have stopped that would have been by

A. Being at the back of the goal, leaving the entire front post open for a player of KDB's quality to hit.

B. Being 15ft tall.

He started in the right place, it was a fluke. That's the whole point of a fluke - it's a freak event.

To me he looks a better keeper - more self assured and he's come in from a standing start with 2 clean sheets. WH has improved no doubt, but VG has the tools and the pedigree on his side and to me he also looks like a much cleaner "taker" of the ball. Shots into the body stick to him.

 

Maine Eagle Flag USA 27 Dec 18 7.13pm

Originally posted by PZ Eagle

Do you actually read what is written. I said he almost cost a goal because he did mess up by getting caught out by Vardy instead of clearing the ball. If Kevin Friend had been the ref the foul might not have been given.

So?

Guaita is a better keeper, and will now be our number 1.

Get over it.

 


Trump lost. Badly. Hahahahahahaha.

Maine Eagle Flag USA 27 Dec 18 7.14pm

Originally posted by Maine Eagle

Did you honestly just say that with a straight face?

Joel Ward is of the same ability as a footballer as AWB?

Mate you are off your rocker.

Hmmmm no reply here, PZ?

What a surprise.

Hard to justify a crazy point of view not based in reality isn’t it.

 


Trump lost. Badly. Hahahahahahaha.

cryrst Flag The garden of England 27 Dec 18 8.07pm

Originally posted by PZ Eagle

Do you actually read what is written. I said he almost cost a goal because he did mess up by getting caught out by Vardy instead of clearing the ball. If Kevin Friend had been the ref the foul might not have been given.

Far from me to know a players mind it seemed vardy accepted the decision and walked away.
He wouldnt have if he really beleived he didnt foul VG
Leicester didnt surround the ref and give him stick at the end so there is great milaege in it being the correct decision.
As for VG and his footwork he played in a lot slower league and is realising he doesnt get the time on the ball.
Also he does use both feet.
The defence do look solid with him behind and play 5 yards further forwards as well.
For now hes the man between the sticks for me.

 

Page 3 of 3 << First< 1 2 3

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Hennessey or Guaita v Cardiff?