This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
|
Originally posted by Forest Hillbilly
I am an olde duffer. I have met many journalists from 'the papers'. Those who used to hang-about in the Red Lion on Whitehall in the 1980's for a little chat to a politician. There is some kind of kudos on social media about where facts are gleaned. And therefore, how opinions are formed. I think we are all potential victims to 'fake news' and political manipulation. Maybe it's me getting old. opinions welcomed I agree. To avoid being embroiled in a debate about anything emotive, an example that bothers me is that I like to read a lot about fitness and training techniques. I have reached a point where I believe almost nothing I read because there are so many supplement companies that can influence articles to be written in such a way that the reader is pushed towards their products. Ok, I think the same sort of thing about political stories too. I always think "Could the publisher of this story have a vested interest in leading the reader?" and the answer is usually "yes". I tend to read articles that contradict my beliefs, as well as ones that resonate with my beliefs, with a raised eyebrow these days. I think we all should.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Forest Hillbilly
I am an olde duffer. I have met many journalists from 'the papers'. Those who used to hang-about in the Red Lion on Whitehall in the 1980's for a little chat to a politician. There is some kind of kudos on social media about where facts are gleaned. And therefore, how opinions are formed. I think we are all potential victims to 'fake news' and political manipulation. Maybe it's me getting old. opinions welcomed Money is the prime mover of all things. What is rewarded is encouraged. The nature of journalism has changed as fewer and fewer people take their news from printed sources. That being the case the fiscal rewards are to be found in views to an article or website...So the more popular something is the more advertisers wish to use it....or with alternative news the more patrons will pay to support it. So essentially we are back to the tabloid issue but digitally. So like the tabloids have always done simplistic depictions of reality that come with 'per-digested' thinking are offered that mostly parrot back the views of the viewer to ensure they continue to patronise the product. News and views becomes more more of a consumer product than before.....You choose your angle, the news outlet feeds it back to you. When it comes to politics the widening out of information sources means that what is considered 'news' can no longer be contained to a few accepted sources who control the narrative. So the groups that have always existed no longer have to contend with each other and instead can just talk amongst themselves. The result of this is that they each become bolder versions of themselves each convinced in the correctness of their respective visions. Of course 'normies' and those amongst the elderly who don't wish to keep up will continue to use the mainstream outlets and parrot the narratives fed to them but for that demographic that's how it always was.....but their numbers reduce with each passing day. I don't suggest that as a good or bad thing but just as a reality. Edited by Stirlingsays (25 Feb 2019 7.46pm)
'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen) |
|
| .TUX. |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by Forest Hillbilly
I am an olde duffer. I have met many journalists from 'the papers'. Those who used to hang-about in the Red Lion on Whitehall in the 1980's for a little chat to a politician. There is some kind of kudos on social media about where facts are gleaned. And therefore, how opinions are formed. I think we are all potential victims to 'fake news' and political manipulation. Maybe it's me getting old. opinions welcomed 1. Agreed. The internet has opened a whole new world of knowledge to those who wish to learn.
Buy Litecoin. |
|
| W12 25 Feb 19 10.15pm | |
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by PalazioVecchio
the pamphleteers with the dodgy printing presses in the time of Queen Elizabeth the first.
Murdoch's ancestor was swinging from a tree and saw a panther stalking a relaxed monkey, said nothing, monkey got eaten. Murdoch senior guilty of not telling the truth, blood was spilt. does the OP have a model of fair/balanced/honest media that he can draw upon to enlighten us ? How about one where diversity included that of opinion? Also we could do with a lot less opinion and a lot more focus on reporting facts even those facts that might hurt some people’s feelings. We use to trust people to make up their own minds or are people now simply too stupid?
|
|
|
Originally posted by W12
Also we could do with a lot less opinion and a lot more focus on reporting facts even those facts that might hurt some people’s feelings. We use to trust people to make up their own minds or are people now simply too stupid? That's apparently not for the UK it seems. The BBC should at least try to be objective but that battle was lost internally decades ago now. Ages ago I remember reading that one of its top bods wanted to ensure that hirings were looked at for being even politically but that idea was rejected. When it comes to the best solution I don't think there is one. Essentially at the moment the right pay towards a TV corporation that has a left neo liberal bias. The solution is for the right to get its own network and start paying towards that instead. There is plenty of talent on the right in Internet shows.
'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen) |
|
|
Originally posted by Forest Hillbilly
I am an olde duffer. I have met many journalists from 'the papers'. Those who used to hang-about in the Red Lion on Whitehall in the 1980's for a little chat to a politician. There is some kind of kudos on social media about where facts are gleaned. And therefore, how opinions are formed. I think we are all potential victims to 'fake news' and political manipulation. Maybe it's me getting old. opinions welcomed Edited by Bert the Head (25 Feb 2019 11.08pm)
|
|
|
Originally posted by Forest Hillbilly
I am an olde duffer. I have met many journalists from 'the papers'. Those who used to hang-about in the Red Lion on Whitehall in the 1980's for a little chat to a politician. There is some kind of kudos on social media about where facts are gleaned. And therefore, how opinions are formed. I think we are all potential victims to 'fake news' and political manipulation. Maybe it's me getting old. opinions welcomed I stumbled across a webside called Media Bias/Fact check. [Link] The site says that "Media Bias/Fact Check (MBFC News), founded in 2015, is an independent online media outlet. MBFC News is dedicated to educating the public on media bias and deceptive news practices. MBFC News’ aim is to inspire action and a rejection of overtly biased media. We want to return to an era of straight forward news reporting." It rated the Daily Mail under `Questionable Sources', with the following rating: Overall, we rate Daily Mail Questionable due to numerous failed fact checks and poor sourcing of information. Detailed Report The Daily Telegraph: Overall, we rate the The Telegraph Right Biased based on story selection that strongly favors the right and Mixed for factual reporting due to poor sourcing of information and some failed fact checks. The Daily Express Overall, we rate the Daily Express Right Biased based on editorial content and Mixed for factual reporting due to publishing conspiracies & pseudoscience as well as a few failed fact checks.
The left wing Canary Media scored more highly than either the Daily Mail, The Express or the Telegraph: News outlets are meant to be a source of information but they have deteriorated into a disinformation system. I read Flat Earth News a few years ago that describes how the media now is spoon fed by press briefings and lacks the will or resources for proper journalism. I find Media Lens (http://www.medialens.org/) a good site. But it is left of centre and has a very dim view of the mainstream media.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Bert the Head
I stumbled across a webside called Media Bias/Fact check. [Link] The site says that "Media Bias/Fact Check (MBFC News), founded in 2015, is an independent online media outlet. MBFC News is dedicated to educating the public on media bias and deceptive news practices. MBFC News’ aim is to inspire action and a rejection of overtly biased media. We want to return to an era of straight forward news reporting." It rated the Daily Mail under `Questionable Sources', with the following rating: Overall, we rate Daily Mail Questionable due to numerous failed fact checks and poor sourcing of information. Detailed Report The Daily Telegraph: Overall, we rate the The Telegraph Right Biased based on story selection that strongly favors the right and Mixed for factual reporting due to poor sourcing of information and some failed fact checks. The Daily Express Overall, we rate the Daily Express Right Biased based on editorial content and Mixed for factual reporting due to publishing conspiracies & pseudoscience as well as a few failed fact checks.
The left wing Canary Media scored more highly than either the Daily Mail, The Express or the Telegraph: News outlets are meant to be a source of information but they have deteriorated into a disinformation system. I read Flat Earth News a few years ago that describes how the media now is spoon fed by press briefings and lacks the will or resources for proper journalism. I find Media Lens (http://www.medialens.org/) a good site. But it is left of centre and has a very dim view of the mainstream media. And how do we check for lack of bias in the site that is assessing bias in others? Quis custodiet ipsos custodes?
|
|
| W12 26 Feb 19 4.23pm | |
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by palace_in_frogland
And how do we check for lack of bias in the site that is assessing bias in others? Quis custodiet ipsos custodes?
MediaBIasFactCheck.com describes itself as “the most comprehensive media bias resource in the Internet.” The site is owned by Dave Van Zandt from North Carolina, who offers no biographical information about himself aside from the following: “Dave has been freelancing for 25+ years for a variety of print and web mediums (sic), with a focus on media bias and the role of media in politics. Dave is a registered Non-Affiliated voter who values evidence based reporting” and, “Dave Van Zandt obtained a Communications Degree before pursuing a higher degree in the sciences. Dave currently works full time in the health care industry. Dave has spent more than 20 years as an arm chair researcher on media bias and its role in political influence.” WND was unable to locate a single article with Van Zandt’s byline. Ironically, the “fact checker” fails to establish his own credibility by disclosing his qualifications and training in evaluating news sources. Asked for information concerning his expertise in the field of journalism and evaluating news sources, Van Zandt told WND: “I am not a journalist and just a person who is interested in how media bias impacts politics. You will find zero claims of expertise on the website.” Concerning his purported “25+ years” of experience writing for print and web media, he said: “I am not sure why the 25+ years is still on the website. That was removed a year ago when I first started the website. All of the writing I did was small print news zines from the ’90s. I felt that what I wrote in the ’90s is not related to what I am doing today so I removed it. Again, I am not a journalist. I simply have a background in communications and more importantly science where I learned to value evidence over all else. Through this I also became interested in research of all kinds, especially media bias, which is difficult to measure and is subjective to a degree. Read more at [Link]
|
|
| Invalid user 2019 |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by W12
MediaBIasFactCheck.com describes itself as “the most comprehensive media bias resource in the Internet.” The site is owned by Dave Van Zandt from North Carolina, who offers no biographical information about himself aside from the following: “Dave has been freelancing for 25+ years for a variety of print and web mediums (sic), with a focus on media bias and the role of media in politics. Dave is a registered Non-Affiliated voter who values evidence based reporting” and, “Dave Van Zandt obtained a Communications Degree before pursuing a higher degree in the sciences. Dave currently works full time in the health care industry. Dave has spent more than 20 years as an arm chair researcher on media bias and its role in political influence.” WND was unable to locate a single article with Van Zandt’s byline. Ironically, the “fact checker” fails to establish his own credibility by disclosing his qualifications and training in evaluating news sources. Asked for information concerning his expertise in the field of journalism and evaluating news sources, Van Zandt told WND: “I am not a journalist and just a person who is interested in how media bias impacts politics. You will find zero claims of expertise on the website.” Concerning his purported “25+ years” of experience writing for print and web media, he said: “I am not sure why the 25+ years is still on the website. That was removed a year ago when I first started the website. All of the writing I did was small print news zines from the ’90s. I felt that what I wrote in the ’90s is not related to what I am doing today so I removed it. Again, I am not a journalist. I simply have a background in communications and more importantly science where I learned to value evidence over all else. Through this I also became interested in research of all kinds, especially media bias, which is difficult to measure and is subjective to a degree. Read more at [Link] It's perfectly valid to ask 'who checks the fact checkers' and if this guy is just some chump winging it in a basement, it's good that any website would point that out. That said, in the wider conversation about the quality of journalism, lets also add that WND is well known for being a loose on facts fringe, conspiracy theory peddling website in its own right.
|
|
All images and text on this site are copyright © 1999-2025 The Holmesdale Online, unless otherwise stated.
Web Design by Guntrisoft Ltd.