You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Have a groan about a loan
November 16 2026 6.33am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Have a groan about a loan


Page 3 of 3 << First< 1 2 3
Midlands Eagle Flag 05 Mar 19 4.02pm

Originally posted by ASCPFC

Batman seems to suit us - I don't believe he will ever be our player though. It seems a shame that no matter how many chances they get - Wickham is going to be injured and Benteke poor.

Yet nothing is mentioned on the Physio Room so are we sure that he's really injured or is it something else

 

ASCPFC Flag Pro-Cathedral/caravan park 05 Mar 19 4.15pm

Originally posted by Midlands Eagle

Yet nothing is mentioned on the Physio Room so are we sure that he's really injured or is it something else

I know there have been rumours but I wouldn't like to speculate. With Wickham, injured seems to be the most likely, unfortunately.

 


Red and Blue Army!

southnorwoodhill Flag 05 Mar 19 7.26pm

Originally posted by Nc412760

£40m for AWB, £60m for Wilf, (£5m for Benteke!) a big summer transfer kitty after owners have taken some out. Should be enough to secure Bats plus others. Love them to stay but realistically this must be in the Chairman's plans.

Crazy. Sell the club's best players? All the goals against Burnley came from the right side: cross across the face of goal which Schlupp turned back, cross to Bats, Wilfs trickery for the third. Crazy talk.

 

braunstoneagle Flag the middle of bumf*** nowhere... 05 Mar 19 9.29pm

i cannot see why people moan about loans...i know yhey are not our players, but more often than notvthey enhance the squad whilst here.

the phrase “biting off your nose to spite your face” springs to mind!

 


‘Football isn’t instant coffee. You have to work at it. You must grow the bean, grind it.’ Ian Holloway


Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 05 Mar 19 9.40pm

Originally posted by Nc412760

£40m for AWB, £60m for Wilf, (£5m for Benteke!) a big summer transfer kitty after owners have taken some out. Should be enough to secure Bats plus others. Love them to stay but realistically this must be in the Chairman's plans.

‘Must be in the chairman’s plans.’ You think, or you hope?

Must? Really?

 


COYP

Maine Eagle Flag USA 06 Mar 19 2.28am

Originally posted by braunstoneagle

i cannot see why people moan about loans...i know yhey are not our players, but more often than notvthey enhance the squad whilst here.

the phrase “biting off your nose to spite your face” springs to mind!

Loans with an option to buy are truly great deals. It’s a win win.

Loans with no option to buy and no realistic prospect represent the most short term thinking possible when running a football club.

It’s time to move on from short term fire fighting and have a proper long term strategy. We shouldn’t need to loan first team players if our recruitment was good enough. We are literally helping rival clubs with improving their players and the value of their players.

Did you notice the giant RLC sized hole in our midfield when we started out this year?

If it increases our chances of not getting relegated then I am all for it, but:

1 - with the squad we have now we should have been nowhere near relegation this year either way.

2 - whilst we give game after game to Batshuayi we are literally making our strikers even worse by denying them game time.

3 - if we are going to cut ties with benteke we need to get the most money possible, that won’t be the case if he is not playing.

As I said above while the spectre of relegation looms we need goals and points, end of story.

Once safety is assured we need to be planning for next year, not building teams and systems around the very members of our squad we can guarantee WONT be here next year.

Edited by Maine Eagle (06 Mar 2019 2.30am)

 


Trump lost. Badly. Hahahahahahaha.

ARGILE OLD GEEZER Flag PORTIMAO 06 Mar 19 7.47am

Originally posted by braunstoneagle

i cannot see why people moan about loans...i know yhey are not our players, but more often than notvthey enhance the squad whilst here.

the phrase “biting off your nose to spite your face” springs to mind!

I think you mean "cutting off your nose" a bit difficult to bite of your own nose haha, just saying.

 

ARGILE OLD GEEZER Flag PORTIMAO 06 Mar 19 8.04am

Originally posted by Maine Eagle

Loans with an option to buy are truly great deals. It’s a win win.

Loans with no option to buy and no realistic prospect represent the most short term thinking possible when running a football club.

It’s time to move on from short term fire fighting and have a proper long term strategy. We shouldn’t need to loan first team players if our recruitment was good enough. We are literally helping rival clubs with improving their players and the value of their players.

Did you notice the giant RLC sized hole in our midfield when we started out this year?

If it increases our chances of not getting relegated then I am all for it, but:

1 - with the squad we have now we should have been nowhere near relegation this year either way.

2 - whilst we give game after game to Batshuayi we are literally making our strikers even worse by denying them game time.

3 - if we are going to cut ties with benteke we need to get the most money possible, that won’t be the case if he is not playing.

As I said above while the spectre of relegation looms we need goals and points, end of story.

Once safety is assured we need to be planning for next year, not building teams and systems around the very members of our squad we can guarantee WONT be here next year.

Edited by Maine Eagle (06 Mar 2019 2.30am)

Can't agree with any of this, RLC helped us to retain our Premiership status last season, Batshuayi probably will this season, or at least push us up the table, what is it, 1M plus for each place ?
What if you don't have the funds to buy a 20M-30M player?
there are two sides to your theory about Playing Benteke, suppose he plays every game from now until the end of the season and doesn't score any goals, that would A/ reduce our league table payments, and B/make his value lower as no one would want him, might even relegate us.

 

DutchEagleJohan Flag Vlissingen, Netherlands 06 Mar 19 9.11am

There is still a cup to win as well. Could be massive for the club and an excellent opportunity to win silverware. Would happily win with a couple of loan players over "our own" players.

Originally posted by Maine Eagle

Loans with an option to buy are truly great deals. It’s a win win.

Loans with no option to buy and no realistic prospect represent the most short term thinking possible when running a football club.

It’s time to move on from short term fire fighting and have a proper long term strategy. We shouldn’t need to loan first team players if our recruitment was good enough. We are literally helping rival clubs with improving their players and the value of their players.

Did you notice the giant RLC sized hole in our midfield when we started out this year?

If it increases our chances of not getting relegated then I am all for it, but:

1 - with the squad we have now we should have been nowhere near relegation this year either way.

2 - whilst we give game after game to Batshuayi we are literally making our strikers even worse by denying them game time.

3 - if we are going to cut ties with benteke we need to get the most money possible, that won’t be the case if he is not playing.

As I said above while the spectre of relegation looms we need goals and points, end of story.

Once safety is assured we need to be planning for next year, not building teams and systems around the very members of our squad we can guarantee WONT be here next year.

Edited by Maine Eagle (06 Mar 2019 2.30am)


 

Maine Eagle Flag USA 06 Mar 19 3.02pm

Originally posted by ARGILE OLD GEEZER

Can't agree with any of this, RLC helped us to retain our Premiership status last season, Batshuayi probably will this season, or at least push us up the table, what is it, 1M plus for each place ?
What if you don't have the funds to buy a 20M-30M player?
there are two sides to your theory about Playing Benteke, suppose he plays every game from now until the end of the season and doesn't score any goals, that would A/ reduce our league table payments, and B/make his value lower as no one would want him, might even relegate us.

As I said, once we are safe, we should play benteke, IF we know we cannot sign Michy permanently.

 


Trump lost. Badly. Hahahahahahaha.

Nc412760 Flag Oxford 06 Mar 19 8.36pm

Originally posted by Midlands Eagle

If Batshuayi does well do you think he would want to stay permanently or is he putting himself in the shop window for a bigger club

I’m hoping he’s had enough loan spells that didn’t go so well to see us as a place to stay at least for a few years. Then again we may just be the shop window he needs. As noted elsewhere, loans with no buy clause aren’t ideal.

 


First game aged 7: 16/12/72 CPFC 5-0 MUFC - Palace for life!!!!!

chris123 Flag hove actually 06 Mar 19 9.30pm

Originally posted by Maine Eagle

As I said, once we are safe, we should play benteke, IF we know we cannot sign Michy permanently.

Michy will want to play with Euro qualifier coming up?

 

Maine Eagle Flag USA 07 Mar 19 3.30am

Originally posted by chris123

Michy will want to play with Euro qualifier coming up?

If he won’t be our player next year I couldn’t care less what he wants.

If there is a chance we want to sign him, can afford him, and Chelsea will sell him, then by all means.

 


Trump lost. Badly. Hahahahahahaha.

dreamwaverider Flag London 07 Mar 19 3.58am

Sadly benteke and CW are over. Apparently we DO have an option to buy Batshuayi. So let’s test our US owners pockets. The squad we now have is supporting this logic. I would also try and buy Ayew then out CB and CW.

 

ARGILE OLD GEEZER Flag PORTIMAO 07 Mar 19 7.40am

Originally posted by Maine Eagle

As I said, once we are safe, we should play benteke, IF we know we cannot sign Michy permanently.

OK, i take your point, but it could still cost us league positions though, each position is worth millions.

 

Eaglecoops Flag CR3 07 Mar 19 8.09am

Originally posted by dreamwaverider

Sadly benteke and CW are over. Apparently we DO have an option to buy Batshuayi. So let’s test our US owners pockets. The squad we now have is supporting this logic. I would also try and buy Ayew then out CB and CW.

Link/source, genuinely interested as I’ve seen no comment on this?

 

chris123 Flag hove actually 07 Mar 19 9.05am

Originally posted by Maine Eagle

If he won’t be our player next year I couldn’t care less what he wants.

If there is a chance we want to sign him, can afford him, and Chelsea will sell him, then by all means.

The qualifiers start this month.

 

Page 3 of 3 << First< 1 2 3

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Have a groan about a loan