You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Wagner in the summer?
November 16 2026 6.11am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Wagner in the summer?


Page 4 of 4 << First< 1 2 3 4
ex hibitionist Flag Hastings 18 Mar 19 12.24am

too early to be talking post Roy really, but for the season after next a leftfield risky one to consider is Graham Potter from Swansea - he's lost a lot of his best players has no funds and is doing miracles to get Swansea anywhere near where they are by most accounts - when they played us in the Caribou (sic?) he played seven debutants and they played us off the park for half the match, starting off in Sweden is no deterrent either, they're clever so and so's over there generally and didn't he transform Ostersunds? I think he may have real talent.

 

kev64 Flag Cambs 18 Mar 19 6.41am

Whatever happens with Roy, I can see both Wilf and WB heading off to pastures new .. and hopefully tekkers going on a free to China or div 2 which is about all he will get .

I can see next season being a really tough gig and a real possibility of us heading to join Stoke et al to languish in the Championship for several years.

 

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 18 Mar 19 8.08am

Originally posted by ex hibitionist

too early to be talking post Roy really, but for the season after next a leftfield risky one to consider is Graham Potter from Swansea - he's lost a lot of his best players has no funds and is doing miracles to get Swansea anywhere near where they are by most accounts - when they played us in the Caribou (sic?) he played seven debutants and they played us off the park for half the match, starting off in Sweden is no deterrent either, they're clever so and so's over there generally and didn't he transform Ostersunds? I think he may have real talent.

This season Swansea have spent circa £7 Mill on players but brought in circa £45 mill in sales from the likes of Fabianski,Mawson,Fernandez,Bartley,Clucas etc.

In terms of their strike force last season, they have lost the services of Abraham and the Ayew brothers and midfielder Renato Sanches who was on loan has also gone.

Potter took Ostersunds from the 4th tier to the top division of the Swedish league for the first time in their history so did really well over there.


Edited by Willo (18 Mar 2019 8.14am)

 

Ginger Pubic Wig Flag Wickham de L'Ouest 25 Mar 19 6.32am

I am in favour of Roy being our manager next season, but it's not too soon to think about his replacement. There has to be a chance he'll retire in 8 games time.

The conservative choice is Dyche. Personally, I like the cut of Wilder's jib if Sheffield United stay down.

 


If you want to live in a world full of kindness, respect and love, try to show these qualities.

cryrst Flag The garden of England 25 Mar 19 6.44am

Steve clarke from killy is doing a great job
Might be one to look at

 

Midlands Eagle Flag 25 Mar 19 6.47am

Originally posted by Ginger Pubic Wig

The conservative choice is Dyche.

As I have said on quite a few occasions I doubt whether Dyche would come as he's used to having free reign over the footballing side of things which is something that he wouldn't get at Palace

 

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 25 Mar 19 8.16am

Originally posted by cryrst

Steve clarke from killy is doing a great job
Might be one to look at

Yes I agree.
When he took over last season,Kilmarnock were second from bottom in the Scottish PL and they are now in 4th place.

Didn't work out for him at both WBA and Reading but at WBA he did bring in Lukaku on loan, whilst at Reading he signed another player on loan namely Ake and they have both gone on to impress in the PL.

 

leejaneagles Flag 25 Mar 19 10.46am

I feel like it really is Roy's choice if he's here next season.

I think its wishful thinking that Parish would be considering his options and planning for the future because 1. He has always stuck by his Managers and 2. Roy will work with whatever little he has, even if that's no Wilf or AWB.

For point 1, Parish didnt want to get rid of Holloway, gave Pardew far too long and recently gave glowing comments about Roy on his birthday but also said Roy's contract extension is as important as a new signing.

Roy presumably signed a 2 year extension for a reason and constantly bangs on about feeling as fit as he's ever been. I don't see him calling it time and Parish won't force him out.

 

Jacey Flag 25 Mar 19 12.17pm

Poor Wagner became a loser with Huddersfield so I am rather surprised that in some quarters,we want another Wan#er in charge, as our Messiah.

 

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 25 Mar 19 2.12pm

Originally posted by Willo

Yes I agree.
When he took over last season,Kilmarnock were second from bottom in the Scottish PL and they are now in 4th place.

Didn't work out for him at both WBA and Reading but at WBA he did bring in Lukaku on loan, whilst at Reading he signed another player on loan namely Ake and they have both gone on to impress in the PL.

Thanks for bringing this one up because I thought he’s one to keep an eye on, as long as he doesn’t develop his drinking for the worse. Sadly I doubt CPFC would look or even think of looking or having an interest in options out there.

 


COYP

black eagle. Flag south croydon. 26 Mar 19 7.45am

Originally posted by cryrst

Steve clarke from killy is doing a great job
Might be one to look at

Steve Clarke is a great shout,more him than Wagner.

Wagner bought mainly players from abroad and was very very lucky to keep Huddersfield up last season.

 

Eaglecoops Flag CR3 26 Mar 19 8.16am

Originally posted by kev64

Whatever happens with Roy, I can see both Wilf and WB heading off to pastures new .. and hopefully tekkers going on a free to China or div 2 which is about all he will get .

I can see next season being a really tough gig and a real possibility of us heading to join Stoke et al to languish in the Championship for several years.

And what do you base those cheery pearls of wisdom on? 2 players on long contracts who have both expressed their desire to play for our club. If for some reason that is currently unbeknown to us supporters, the club decides they want to sell and they did leave, then that would put £100m plus into our coffers. Hardly a really tough gig if that money was properly reinvested along with other money we will have available next year.

 

taylors lovechild Flag 26 Mar 19 8.20am

Wagner had huge support from Huddersfield fans despite their woes, which probably speaks volumes about him as a manager. I wouldn't be against him if Roy left, but I think we need to be looking at bringing in someone who has a clear long-term plan (like Klopp did at Liverpool) as we are likely to lose some big players in the next two years and the club need to get their replacements right. Given our strong links to France with our French speaking contingent maybe we could look in that direction for someone like Rudi Garcia?

 

TheArmaniCode Flag 26 Mar 19 2.01pm

Don't understand why people are saying Wagner wouldn't do well with us

When he was at Huddersfield he brought in youngsters from abroad and lower league on an extremely small budget. That's exactly what Palace are trying to do now and he'll also have our academy to work with this time. And he might've often played for draws in the Premier League but in the Championship when his players were good enough he went at teams. He'd have more opportunities to do that with our squad.

Would be a risk no doubt so maybe not worth outright sacking Roy for him right now, but defo an option to consider once he leaves imo

 

stuckinbristol Flag In the woodwork. 26 Mar 19 3.19pm

Originally posted by TheArmaniCode

Don't understand why people are saying Wagner wouldn't do well with us

When he was at Huddersfield he brought in youngsters from abroad and lower league on an extremely small budget. That's exactly what Palace are trying to do now and he'll also have our academy to work with this time. And he might've often played for draws in the Premier League but in the Championship when his players were good enough he went at teams. He'd have more opportunities to do that with our squad.

Would be a risk no doubt so maybe not worth outright sacking Roy for him right now, but defo an option to consider once he leaves imo

Really?
Went up with a negative goal difference, and won the play-off final on penalties after a 0-0.

 

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 26 Mar 19 3.32pm

Originally posted by TheArmaniCode

Don't understand why people are saying Wagner wouldn't do well with us

When he was at Huddersfield he brought in youngsters from abroad and lower league on an extremely small budget. That's exactly what Palace are trying to do now and he'll also have our academy to work with this time. And he might've often played for draws in the Premier League but in the Championship when his players were good enough he went at teams. He'd have more opportunities to do that with our squad.

Would be a risk no doubt so maybe not worth outright sacking Roy for him right now, but defo an option to consider once he leaves imo

In 17/18 Huddersfield's net spend was £46 Mill and this season it is £35 Mill.

 

TheArmaniCode Flag 26 Mar 19 5.21pm

Originally posted by stuckinbristol

Really?
Went up with a negative goal difference, and won the play-off final on penalties after a 0-0.

He also won 25 out of 46 games - 15 of which were at home too. He battered the likes of us Bournemouth and Watford last year when he needed results and only 8 home defeats in the Prem too.

Even if his football wasn't great I wouldn't care. We've been playing crap football for years, it's nothing new. We need someone who's gonna get results, particularly at home. He's a young manager who has the capability to learn too, unlike Roy who's a total dinosaur. Like I said, he has his faults, but if he's available at the end of Roy's contract, we should absolutely consider him

Edited by TheArmaniCode (26 Mar 2019 5.22pm)

 

est1905 Flag 26 Mar 19 5.40pm

Originally posted by TheArmaniCode

Don't understand why people are saying Wagner wouldn't do well with us

When he was at Huddersfield he brought in youngsters from abroad and lower league on an extremely small budget. That's exactly what Palace are trying to do now and he'll also have our academy to work with this time. And he might've often played for draws in the Premier League but in the Championship when his players were good enough he went at teams. He'd have more opportunities to do that with our squad.

Would be a risk no doubt so maybe not worth outright sacking Roy for him right now, but defo an option to consider once he leaves imo

Come off it, he turned Huddersfield into a bunch of hatchet men. Lets not pretend they didn't kick, bite, claw and elbow thier way to safety. Fair enough when you will do anything for the points and the quality is just not there you do what you have to do. But this is the reason there will be few tears shed when they go down despite them being a plucky small club that usually wins the hearts of the neutral. They are unattractive to watch and commit way too many fouls. No thanks

 

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 26 Mar 19 6.13pm

Originally posted by est1905

Come off it, he turned Huddersfield into a bunch of hatchet men. Lets not pretend they didn't kick, bite, claw and elbow thier way to safety. Fair enough when you will do anything for the points and the quality is just not there you do what you have to do. But this is the reason there will be few tears shed when they go down despite them being a plucky small club that usually wins the hearts of the neutral. They are unattractive to watch and commit way too many fouls. No thanks

And he signed Puncheon !

 

moffi Flag Bexhill 26 Mar 19 9.57pm

Roy’s doing a great job, he doesn’t get everything right but who does. Anyone who says we don’t play good stuff I dont understand what they’re after. We get it down, play some neat stuff and have good rhythm and ability down the flanks, very much in the palace tradition. There’s good method and positivity to what he’s doing. Not sure we’d get him but I’d like Howe when it’s time.

 

Page 4 of 4 << First< 1 2 3 4

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Wagner in the summer?