You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Jimmy Mac
November 16 2026 6.11am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Jimmy Mac


Page 3 of 3 << First< 1 2 3
Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 09 Apr 19 9.23am

Originally posted by MonsterMunch

While I take your point, in my opinion and I dont wish to do Jimmy a dis-service as we enter our 7th season in the premier league I want more than a trier in our starting eleven. Just because Shelvey is out of favour at Newcastle doesnt mean a great deal. Hes also a local lad so who's to say he would not thrive in our environment. Anyway someone of his ilk would be nice.

Shelvey is an Essex boy and I have seen his brother George play as a striker for Barking.Not that local to Selhurst Park !

 

Straightbackup Flag Crystal Palace 09 Apr 19 9.56am

Spot on, agree with every word of that. Schlupp is a woeful footballer, but he must have some serious dirt on Roy when he keeps getting a game.

Originally posted by Maine Eagle

Seeing as you mentioned me....

Roy may not be doing it deliberately but he is on a stitch up of Meyer, there is no other explanation.

The whole team, the whole performance was crap first half. Meyer had some neat touches, and on one occasion he harried and won the ball back well, and launched an attack.

He was playing much, much better than Schlupp.

Second half things opened up and while I will admit MacArthur actually affected the game when it became a but more stretched, but this is EXACTLY when Meyer should have been out there.

Once again though Roy stitches him up and hooks him at half time (he never makes subs at half time), like starting him in physical away games.

Max Meyer was one of the most highly touted young prospects to come out of Germany in years. Please dont expect me to believe he has become a sh&t player overnight. Hodgson has a lot to answer for destroying the guy's confidence and not letting him get into any kind of rhythm here.

The way Hodgson has managed him has been nothing short of very, VERY poor. You can say all you like that he hasnt taken his chances but any player coming from a foreign league, especially one who isnt the strongest physically, needs a proper run of games and some stability.

Roy hasnt got a clue how to bed in new signings, except ones on loan that we cannot buy anyway, they start every week.

Kouyate should be starting for one.

Mark my words, Meyer will leave Palace behind and go on to become a very high class and highly regarded player in the game. He is too good for the way Hodgson sets us up, it completely doesn't play to any of his strengths.

So why the F did we sign him?

 


'Impulse' advert- Advertising campaign whose slogan is expected to change in the light of Rajiv Gandhi's assassination: 'If someone you don't know suddenly offers you flowers- run like f***!'

HKOwen Flag Hong Kong 11 Apr 19 1.59am

What Shelvey has that is positive is a great range of accurate passing.

Discipline another issue but on his day a game changer

 


Responsibility Deficit Disorder is a medical condition. Symptoms include inability to be corrected when wrong, false sense of superiority, desire to share personal info no else cares about, general hubris. It's a medical issue rather than pure arrogance.

thai-eagle Flag chiang mai 11 Apr 19 5.26am

Would like someone like Mooy (Huddersfield) or Shelvey in Our midfield!

 

EddieMac Flag 11 Apr 19 8.56am

Originally posted by Maine Eagle

Seeing as you mentioned me....

Roy may not be doing it deliberately but he is on a stitch up of Meyer, there is no other explanation.

The whole team, the whole performance was crap first half. Meyer had some neat touches, and on one occasion he harried and won the ball back well, and launched an attack.

He was playing much, much better than Schlupp.

Second half things opened up and while I will admit MacArthur actually affected the game when it became a but more stretched, but this is EXACTLY when Meyer should have been out there.

Once again though Roy stitches him up and hooks him at half time (he never makes subs at half time), like starting him in physical away games.

Max Meyer was one of the most highly touted young prospects to come out of Germany in years. Please dont expect me to believe he has become a sh&t player overnight. Hodgson has a lot to answer for destroying the guy's confidence and not letting him get into any kind of rhythm here.

The way Hodgson has managed him has been nothing short of very, VERY poor. You can say all you like that he hasnt taken his chances but any player coming from a foreign league, especially one who isnt the strongest physically, needs a proper run of games and some stability.

Roy hasnt got a clue how to bed in new signings, except ones on loan that we cannot buy anyway, they start every week.

Kouyate should be starting for one.

Mark my words, Meyer will leave Palace behind and go on to become a very high class and highly regarded player in the game. He is too good for the way Hodgson sets us up, it completely doesn't play to any of his strengths.

So why the F did we sign him?

There is no doubting that Meyer is a good player but he has had a year with absolutely no improvement. We will be doing well if we can cash in on him this summer. There are certain players suited to certain leagues and Unfortunately Max is not suited the PL. The football is too fast and manic for him so everything just passes him by.He is also too lightweight for centre mid and we havn't got the luxury of shoving him into a number 10 role. (which would still fail)

Just think of the all the world class players who have come to England and looked awful. That doesn't mean they are bad players. Horses for courses.

I had high hopes and am gutted that it hasn't worked out for him but his day's in England are numbered. We just need to move on and sign somebody else.

 

slubglurge Flag welling 12 Apr 19 9.21am

Originally posted by Willo

Shelvey is an Essex boy and I have seen his brother George play as a striker for Barking.Not that local to Selhurst Park !

Shelvey is also ex Charlton so may not fancy Selhurst

 

ChrisGC Flag Wantage 12 Apr 19 10.15am

Jimmy Mac has been great for us, everyone loves a guts and thunder player even if the technical brilliance is lacking.

I don't think playing him and Luka is necessary, one or the other for me.

Anyone on here saying Shelvey is a good player instantly puts their opinion in the bin as far as I'm concerned. He's a fat, ill disciplined, glory ball merchant of the first order. Utter s***e and not fit to lace JM's boots, even if I do agree that JM isn't the greatest.

 

HKOwen Flag Hong Kong 12 Apr 19 4.24pm

Perhaps if you ever meet Shelvey you'll tell him so..............then again, probably not

Originally posted by ChrisGC

Jimmy Mac has been great for us, everyone loves a guts and thunder player even if the technical brilliance is lacking.

I don't think playing him and Luka is necessary, one or the other for me.

Anyone on here saying Shelvey is a good player instantly puts their opinion in the bin as far as I'm concerned. He's a fat, ill disciplined, glory ball merchant of the first order. Utter s***e and not fit to lace JM's boots, even if I do agree that JM isn't the greatest.

 


Responsibility Deficit Disorder is a medical condition. Symptoms include inability to be corrected when wrong, false sense of superiority, desire to share personal info no else cares about, general hubris. It's a medical issue rather than pure arrogance.

jeeagles Flag 12 Apr 19 4.47pm

I'm not sure the debate should be Jimmy Mac of Mayer.
It's more why is Schlupp on the pitch?

 

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 12 Apr 19 5.53pm

Originally posted by jeeagles

I'm not sure the debate should be Jimmy Mac of Mayer.
It's more why is Schlupp on the pitch?

In my humble estimation, Schlupp has outperformed Meyer in that he has chipped in with goals, is more of a goal threat and provides a balance down the left.

I am not advocating that Schlupp has played with great aplomb but he has been better than Meyer who has been very disappointing.Just my opinion and of course there are those who will have a totally different viewpoint.

 

TomThePalaceFanatic Flag 12 Apr 19 6.16pm

McArthur is a great option but shouldn't be in the starting line up if we're looking at that mystical progression.

We haven't seen enough of the Luka-Kouyate-Meyer combo.

Luka and Kouyate's physicality would allow us the luxury of playing Meyer, who has shown on many occasions that he keeps the ball better than anyone in our squad and can be incisive and break the lines.

It's fanciful to say but I believe a more progressive manager would unlock Meyer's potential.

 

PatrickA Flag London 12 Apr 19 7.43pm

Mcarthur has been one of our best purchases since we’ve been in the Premier League.
He’s played attacking midfield under Pardew, box to box at time under all managers, and on occasions on the right and left of midfield for Hodgson.
He never appears to complain about his role in the team and is pretty consistent.
I think some fans take him for granted.
He’s clearly a Roy favourite and has been preferred over the likes of Puncheon, Kouyate and Meyer in Roy’s time at the club.
Having said all this , personally I would like to see more of Meyer.
We need to give him a run in the side to see what he can do.
It’s not fair to assess a player on a stop/ start basis and I would like Meyer to play in the remaining games this season.
However, I feel Roy will tend to go for the safe option so don’t expect this to happen.

 

pssguy Flag 12 Apr 19 8.55pm

Originally posted by PatrickA


Having said all this , personally I would like to see more of Meyer.
We need to give him a run in the side to see what he can do.

Kinda off-topic, but if anyone should get a run in team it is Woods to see if we can move Dann on this summer whilst he still has some value

 

Rachid Rachid Rachid Flag 12 Apr 19 10.14pm

Originally posted by PatrickA

Mcarthur has been one of our best purchases since we’ve been in the Premier League.
He’s played attacking midfield under Pardew, box to box at time under all managers, and on occasions on the right and left of midfield for Hodgson.
He never appears to complain about his role in the team and is pretty consistent.
I think some fans take him for granted.
He’s clearly a Roy favourite and has been preferred over the likes of Puncheon, Kouyate and Meyer in Roy’s time at the club.
Having said all this , personally I would like to see more of Meyer.
We need to give him a run in the side to see what he can do.
It’s not fair to assess a player on a stop/ start basis and I would like Meyer to play in the remaining games this season.
However, I feel Roy will tend to go for the safe option so don’t expect this to happen.

IMO McArthur has been our best player over the last five years Wilf excepted. Pleased Meyer was given a chance against Huddersfield but his performance lacked intensity and courage whereas McAthur will show for the ball in any area of the pitch and (most times) find a pass. Given how far forward Meyer has played he should be doing more than looking tidy.

 

Kant Flag exeter 12 Apr 19 11.07pm

Originally posted by Willo

In my humble estimation, Schlupp has outperformed Meyer in that he has chipped in with goals, is more of a goal threat and provides a balance down the left.

I humbly concur.

 

ChrisGC Flag Wantage 13 Apr 19 12.33am

Originally posted by HKOwen

Perhaps if you ever meet Shelvey you'll tell him so..............then again, probably not

Absolutely would LOVE that opportunity and would take full advantage, pikey c***.

 

Page 3 of 3 << First< 1 2 3

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Jimmy Mac