You are here: Home > Message Board > Football Talk > The Duckenfield/Mackrell Verdicts
November 22 2026 7.33pm

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

The Duckenfield/Mackrell Verdicts


Page 3 of 3 << First< 1 2 3
thegreatlardino Flag crawley/selsey 28 Nov 19 7.44pm

I did read the last hilsborough report, being of an age where I was treated like crap by the police, and was a copper at the time which seriously pissed me off, it was the system that failed the fans, duckenfield was out of his depth but I couldnt see him ever being found guilty of manslaughter, the police on scene made a decision which killed 96 fans which they have to live with, when you are faced with a situation like this decisions are made some, hindsight is a great skill to have

Edited by thegreatlardino (28 Nov 2019 7.46pm)

 


Sometimes I set out for Ludlow
Sometimes I end up in Chepstow

Phil’s Barber Flag Crowborough 28 Nov 19 10.00pm

Totally the right decision and long overdue.

 

dreamwaverider Flag London 29 Nov 19 8.10am

So many failed systems over the years. The authorities attitude towards football and its hooligans then. Stadia design to control hooliganism the biggest disaster by miles being the fencing. Policing with limited experience. Decision making, what would be the outcome of crushing if the gates weren’t opened? When witnessing potential disaster, probably hard not to release the gates. Failure to have gates in the fencing unbelievable. Acknowledgement by the football authorities that we were fencing in ‘animalas’ not people so why bother with gates in the fencing. But by far the biggest failure in this tragic story is the legal system. 30 years? .......30 years? That is the biggest failure. We are now in different times. So much has been learnt and changed since.
We now have a blame culture and literally hundreds of regulatory departments set up over the past 30 years to help avoid risk, accidents and so forth. Health and safety being the biggest relevant to this.
Political correctness, snowflakes, mamba pambies, we are oh so different now than we were then. And the attitude that someone has to be blamed is a today culture that wasn’t the same 30 years ago.
To blame Ducksworth in light of change for criminal negligence would be absurd and thankfully hasn’t happened......yet.
In that era, going on a kop was risky and dangerous every game. Going on the Homesdale was dodgy enough.
This wasn’t t the first Liverpool ‘hooligan’ fan tragedy. And it certainly wasn’t football’s only disaster.
Stadia, policing,seating, no fences, far less hooliganism. We have moved on , things have improved immeasurably. That is the genuine outcome. Those poor victims lives have led to today’s new world. An improvement for the masses. To blame and single out one man from 30 years ago is totally wrong and although our ludicrous legal system took 30 years so far which in my world would be illegal, well it finally got there yet without any attempt to console the sufferers by helping them understand that their losses were part of the creation of the improved new world of mass spectator live sport

 

Badger11 Flag Beckenham 29 Nov 19 8.27am

Originally posted by dreamwaverider

So many failed systems over the years. The authorities attitude towards football and its hooligans then. Stadia design to control hooliganism the biggest disaster by miles being the fencing. Policing with limited experience. Decision making, what would be the outcome of crushing if the gates weren’t opened? When witnessing potential disaster, probably hard not to release the gates. Failure to have gates in the fencing unbelievable. Acknowledgement by the football authorities that we were fencing in ‘animalas’ not people so why bother with gates in the fencing. But by far the biggest failure in this tragic story is the legal system. 30 years? .......30 years? That is the biggest failure. We are now in different times. So much has been learnt and changed since.
We now have a blame culture and literally hundreds of regulatory departments set up over the past 30 years to help avoid risk, accidents and so forth. Health and safety being the biggest relevant to this.
Political correctness, snowflakes, mamba pambies, we are oh so different now than we were then. And the attitude that someone has to be blamed is a today culture that wasn’t the same 30 years ago.
To blame Ducksworth in light of change for criminal negligence would be absurd and thankfully hasn’t happened......yet.
In that era, going on a kop was risky and dangerous every game. Going on the Homesdale was dodgy enough.
This wasn’t t the first Liverpool ‘hooligan’ fan tragedy. And it certainly wasn’t football’s only disaster.
Stadia, policing,seating, no fences, far less hooliganism. We have moved on , things have improved immeasurably. That is the genuine outcome. Those poor victims lives have led to today’s new world. An improvement for the masses. To blame and single out one man from 30 years ago is totally wrong and although our ludicrous legal system took 30 years so far which in my world would be illegal, well it finally got there yet without any attempt to console the sufferers by helping them understand that their losses were part of the creation of the improved new world of mass spectator live sport

Good post the people that should have been in the dock were the authorities.

We have seen with Grenfall that the authorities blame the people on the ground who are faced with incredibly difficult instant decisions whilst they take years to produce reports and review the actions of those on the ground in minutia.

As with Grenfall the real failing happen a long time before the fatal day. Who allowed those situations to develop who ignored the complaints and whistle-blowers, who was making money etc....

 


One more point

braunstoneagle Flag the middle of bumf*** nowhere... 29 Nov 19 8.24pm

i watched the cctv video posted earlier in the thread & it proves nothing really...at the end of the whatever way you feel its just a tragedy that 96 people lost their lives at a football game.

much like almost 2000 other palace fans, last time i was on a terrace was p’boro away and my partner was scared as there was the wave movement at times and she was feeling uncomfortable. luckily i could assure her it was safe as i know the stand wasn't over crowded.

for whatever reason that day the liverpool fans didn't have that luxury.

 


‘Football isn’t instant coffee. You have to work at it. You must grow the bean, grind it.’ Ian Holloway


Page 3 of 3 << First< 1 2 3

You are here: Home > Message Board > Football Talk > The Duckenfield/Mackrell Verdicts