This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
|
Originally posted by thai-eagle
the more these stupid comments from similar stupid morons, it will keep coming. Don't comment, don't bother - just don't give them any attention!! Interesting strategy, a 'turn the other cheek' approach. But is there any evidence this actually works and do you envisage any difficulty in persuading black footballers that it is in their interest to adopt your strategy whenever they are racially abused?
"Deviance is a freedom enjoyed in a city of lightly engaged strangers" |
|
|
Originally posted by soulboy
Interesting strategy, a 'turn the other cheek' approach. It isn't really turning the other cheek but denying morons any publicity and leaving it up to his peers to tell them what they think of them. One idiot makes a racist comment on Twitter that would probably not have been seen by anybody but because people have made a big song and dance about it this one idiot has now become an internet celebrity or whatever the opposite is and he will probably not be punished as he's an anonymous coward
|
|
|
Originally posted by Midlands Eagle
Except that many of these half wits operate under the cloak of anonymity You are crediting this person with half a wit, Midlands? That's far too generous a rating.
Palace since 19 August 1972. Palace 1 (Tony Taylor) Liverpool 1 (Emlyn Hughes) |
|
|
Originally posted by Midlands Eagle
It isn't really turning the other cheek but denying morons any publicity and leaving it up to his peers to tell them what they think of them. One idiot makes a racist comment on Twitter that would probably not have been seen by anybody but because people have made a big song and dance about it this one idiot has now become an internet celebrity or whatever the opposite is and he will probably not be punished as he's an anonymous coward Interesting. But what of the contrary view that "silence is not inaction. It is doing something: silence is acquiescence. Whenever you acquiesce to injustice, you are contributing to it"
"Deviance is a freedom enjoyed in a city of lightly engaged strangers" |
|
|
Originally posted by Vaibow
From my globe trotting experience, every race, nation, culture has its racists. It's part of that tribal, primal instinct - just as they have thieves, murderers, rapists and other vile things which are not going anywhere, sadly. Racism will never disappear but that doesn't mean we accept it - a bloke in the stands shouts out abuse - telling me no one around him can do anything? Sure, some people are afraid to step in? A system needs to be in place where it can be reported, safely, quickly and anon so that the law of the land can be applied. There is such a system, in this country, where you might get one moron because hundreds of them was either 30 years ago or, ‘that’s so 30 years ago.’ Montenegro are still where we were 30-40 years ago unfortunately. It won’t change asap. I agree on your first paragraph. Humans aren’t all nice and mobs and herd mentality does exist. Edited by Rudi Hedman (07 Apr 2019 7.45pm)
COYP |
|
|
Originally posted by Rudi Hedman
There is such a system, in this country, where you might get one moron because hundreds of them was either 30 years ago or, ‘that’s so 30 years ago.’ Montenegro are still where we were 30-40 years ago unfortunately. It won’t change asap. Sorry Rudi, but whereas I generally admire the quality of your posts (even if I don't always agree with them) you've lost me with this one. Probably me missing the point.
Palace since 19 August 1972. Palace 1 (Tony Taylor) Liverpool 1 (Emlyn Hughes) |
|
|
Originally posted by YT
Sorry Rudi, but whereas I generally admire the quality of your posts (even if I don't always agree with them) you've lost me with this one. Probably me missing the point. I was responding to vaibow saying, ‘A system needs to be in place where it can be reported, safely, quickly and anon so that the law of the land can be applied.’
COYP |
|
|
Originally posted by Rudi Hedman
I was responding to vaibow saying, ‘A system needs to be in place where it can be reported, safely, quickly and anon so that the law of the land can be applied.’ Yes I gathered that from the bold font. I just couldn't understand what you posted. Anyway, don't worry. It's me. I'll move on. No need to reply again, my old mucker.
Palace since 19 August 1972. Palace 1 (Tony Taylor) Liverpool 1 (Emlyn Hughes) |
|
|
Originally posted by daven
To make racist remarks illegal is perhaps correct. But it doesn't stop the way that racists think, and they still voice their views when amongst like minded people or even worse try to convert others. hate speech. if a bloke wants to be racist i his own home, so be it.... educated people that hear will make their own mind up and slowly, but surely, racism will recede.
This was once a quality forum.... |
|
|
Originally posted by YT
Yes I gathered that from the bold font. I just couldn't understand what you posted. Anyway, don't worry. It's me. I'll move on. No need to reply again, my old mucker. i was confused too.
This was once a quality forum.... |
|
|
Originally posted by dreamwaverider
Alternatively, the ref could take the players off informing the police he would only bring them back on once the thugs had been removed. And don’t try to claim there aren’t enough police. And if they are not removed the game would be abandoned. Imagine what a pain that would be for the straight fans and us TV fans.
Which thugs exactly? How can you be sure you are punishing the right people? People lie, people make mistakes.... How many times are you going to be stopping a game? When a game is underway and we get some chanting that a player or players find offensive and the players are removed.....the idea that 'thugs' can be quickly identified is a bit fanciful. It's wishful thinking. So you identify correctly or incorrectly Jimbob and his mate and throw them out.....You restart the game.....Then you get someone else or a group shouting something.....What are you going to do?....Stop the game again? Go through the same procedure? What if one team is losing a game heavily and this becomes a method of abandoning the game? The reality is that as soon as it's made clear that there is a way that a result can be determined then you are going to get dishonest actors. People have used their free time and paid a lot of money for tickets to see a football match. Abusive fans are far more effectively dealt with by camera footage after the game when there is time to effectively put together an accurate picture of who did what.....Action taken is then fair and appropriate.
'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen) |
|
|
Originally posted by dreamwaverider
If it kicks off ina big way at a stadium like in Monte negro, I would walk off. If say Rose had walked ( and I’m sure he would have been followed by some of his team mates) besides the fact it would have caused major international news, it would have ruined the night for all the spectators present. I don't think the players should be the ones to make the decision to walk off the pitch. You say be strong but they are already strong. You have to be thick skinned to say the least to play ninety minutes with fans hurling abuse at you. Imagine a scenario where a team is 1—0 down and fans abuse a player. He walks off, it would, as you say, be big news. Then after the game people start saying he only walked because he wasn't playing well or the team were losing or he's soft, not cut out for the pressure of the game. You start to put immense pressure on an already victimised player and leave him exposed to more scrutiny and people questioning his judgement in walking off. Now he has all that to deal with on top of the abuse. There will always be those that blame the players for the abuse they receive. Also your asking the victim to stand up for themselves, again, as no one else will stick their neck out. When there is racial abuse the manager should speak to the referee, the referee should be the one to stop the game. If the abuse continues and the referee does nothing, then the manager should pull all his players off the pitch so not to pressurise players into thinking its all on them to disappoint an entire stadium of fans, who probably wouldn't know fully what was going on until they got home and saw how it was reported.. Right now we have an England manager saying that he would support his players walking off. That for me is passing the buck. He should make that decision.
"You can lead a horse to water but a pencil must be lead" Stan Laurel |
|
| Invalid user 2019 |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by blackheatheagle
If i am not mistaken Balotelli & Eto`o tried to walk away from the pitch due to consistent racial abuse from opponent fans. Yes, it became headline but life went on after. Although i would not stress any player who give this decision, this should not be official methodology as it overwrites main rule of the game which confirms that `referee` is the ruler on the pitch. Any action should be taken and reported by him. I don`t think stopping or abandoning the game would be an issue. There are various of practice for this. If you throw items to pitch, club is fined but game continues but if it consistently happens, referee has all rights to walk off and / or abandon. It is not feasible to stop the game whenever someone here monkey sounds for sure but if it starts ruling the atmosphere, there is no issue to do so. It is not different than consistently throwing items to the pitch. I tend to agree. Walking off the pitch is the easy way out and doesn't solve anything. People blurt this b0llocks out because they want to have an impact on the individual. Instead, take out the frustration on the goal mouth, and as you say let the ref deal with it. It's a very connected age. People can point out d!ckheads reeling off racial slurs, or better still film them when they're doing it, so it's undeniable. It's very much a minority pursuit, and fans, players and officials can work together to kick it out. It's not a god given right to attend a football game and crap all over eveyone elses enjoyment of it. They can enjoy their ban in front of Sky Sports at home, while the rest of us enjoy the match in person.
|
|
|
Originally posted by dollardays
I tend to agree. Walking off the pitch is the easy way out and doesn't solve anything. People blurt this b0llocks out because they want to have an impact on the individual. Instead, take out the frustration on the goal mouth, and as you say let the ref deal with it. It's a very connected age. People can point out d!ckheads reeling off racial slurs, or better still film them when they're doing it, so it's undeniable. It's very much a minority pursuit, and fans, players and officials can work together to kick it out. It's not a god given right to attend a football game and crap all over eveyone elses enjoyment of it. They can enjoy their ban in front of Sky Sports at home, while the rest of us enjoy the match in person. Is the perception that this is a recent phenomenon or has it always been there but not reported?
|
|
All images and text on this site are copyright © 1999-2025 The Holmesdale Online, unless otherwise stated.
Web Design by Guntrisoft Ltd.