You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Penalty takers - Who is our best ever?
November 16 2026 6.11am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Penalty takers - Who is our best ever?


Page 2 of 2 << First< 1 2
Cucking Funt Flag Clapham on the Back 09 Apr 19 12.03pm

Benteke. Especially when we play Bournemouth.

 


Wife beating may be socially acceptable in Sheffield, but it is a different matter in Cheltenham

Pete53 Flag Hassocks 10 Apr 19 1.55pm

Originally posted by n wales eagles

John Sewell got to be my number one Think it was 1970 on a cold manchester night when John stepped up to steer one under Alex Stepney to earn us a point Certainly warmed me up Got to go matrons just come in with my porridge

Not that particular one, but I recall Sewell scoring from the spot in a home match where the ball seemed to casually roll over the line. If the keeper hadn't gone the wrong way he could have had a cup of tea and brushed his hair and still saved it.

 

Pete53 Flag Hassocks 10 Apr 19 1.58pm

Originally posted by Eltham Eagle

I can't remember being more confident than I am in Luka when we get a spot kick. But is he our best ever?

Who could be the contenders
Dave Madden - Scored against Blackburn and we got promoted. Can't remember another!

Ian Wright - I was only a youngster at the time but I think he could tuck them away. However, both him and Brighty were responsible for the 997 missed in the game against Brighton!

Andy Johnson - Won more than he scored and holds the record for most in a season. But I feel he did miss a few and was never 100% confident

Glenn Murray - Terrible penalty taker. About a 50/50 chance. But better than Benteke!

Luka - Missed against City (we would have been the first to beat them that season) and also against Everton. But apart from those 2, magnificent finishing, especially when setting the record straight at Man City this season.

But for me the best was Jedi. I don't remember him taking that many but I certainly don't remember him missing one. The one away at West Ham particularly nice when guaranteeing us Premier League status.

Would love Luka to beat AJs record this season. Great player and captain.

My memory of 2012-2013 season is that Murray was pretty reliable with his first penalty in a match, but did sometimes miss when a second one was awarded.

 

ARGILE OLD GEEZER Flag PORTIMAO 11 Apr 19 9.39am

Originally posted by Pete53

Not that particular one, but I recall Sewell scoring from the spot in a home match where the ball seemed to casually roll over the line. If the keeper hadn't gone the wrong way he could have had a cup of tea and brushed his hair and still saved it.

I am not to sure, but i think he had a 100% record from the spot, there was also some talk/gossip that he could hit either post 10 out 10 in practice.

 

monkey Flag Sittingbourne,but made in Bromley 11 Apr 19 10.57am

Originally posted by Cucking Funt

Benteke. Especially when we play Bournemouth.

We need a worst ever penalty thread.

Actually maybe not, Puncheon v spurs, close thread

 

PZ Eagle Flag Penzance 11 Apr 19 11.55am

Not the best penalty taker ever but Alfie Noakes didn't mess about. It Was in the era of the heavier balls and he used to take a long run and just belt it as hard as he could. If he did miss wide of the posts about three feet off the ground the fans behind the goal
had to dive out of the way pretty smartish.

Edited by PZ Eagle (11 Apr 2019 11.56am)

 


Conjunctivitis.com - A site for sore eyes.

Superwag Flag Westoning, Bedfordshire 11 Apr 19 12.41pm

For Me - Ronnie Allen in the 60's. Best Penalty taker I've ever seen, but Luka comes very close.

 


Beckenham born; Palace for life (since 195.

trapperjohn Flag Horsham 11 Apr 19 1.30pm

Originally posted by RyWa

I think it has to be between Luka or AJ, statistically across their careers (Not just Palace), AJ has scored 22 out of 26 pens, missing 4.
Luka has scored 19 out of 22, missing 3.
Both are great records, and its hard to call a clear favourite.. Interestingly, AJ never missed a Premier League penalty, though he did miss two in the same game for Everton in a European game off the back of not scoring for 6 months.
Just shows its down hill once you leave the Palace

Edited by RyWa (08 Apr 2019 2.51pm)

It may be my memory playing tricks, but didn't AJ miss one in a televised game v Charlton in the Premier. The same game where we lost to a last minute breakaway goal and (I think) Danny Granville went AWOL

 


I got vision, and the rest of the world wears bifocals.

monkey Flag Sittingbourne,but made in Bromley 11 Apr 19 1.55pm

Not palace, but Ray Stewart, the old West Ham right back was one of the best, he used to hit it so hard, even if a keeper got to it, it would probably take them into the net with the ball

 

ARGILE OLD GEEZER Flag PORTIMAO 15 Apr 19 3.23pm

Originally posted by Superwag

For Me - Ronnie Allen in the 60's. Best Penalty taker I've ever seen, but Luka comes very close.

I don't know about his penalties, gut he was my favorite player in those days, he came to us late in his career, but still a terrific player to my very young eyes.

 

Teddy Eagle Flag 15 Apr 19 3.27pm

Originally posted by monkey

We need a worst ever penalty thread.

Actually maybe not, Puncheon v spurs, close thread

One major contender was Peter Taylor who took one, I think it was against Millwall, which almost went for a throw in.

 

peterg Flag Anerley 15 Apr 19 5.08pm

Originally posted by ARGILE OLD GEEZER

I don't know about his penalties, gut he was my favorite player in those days, he came to us late in his career, but still a terrific player to my very young eyes.

I remember Ronnie Allen used to live near us in South Norwood. There was a bonfire on some waste ground in Warminster Road one Guy Fawkes night and I saw him there with his children.

 


The right place at the right time

Rachid Rachid Rachid Flag 15 Apr 19 9.06pm

Originally posted by trapperjohn

It may be my memory playing tricks, but didn't AJ miss one in a televised game v Charlton in the Premier. The same game where we lost to a last minute breakaway goal and (I think) Danny Granville went AWOL

December 2004 saved by Dean Kiely. Last minute winner scored by Dennis Rommedahl.

 

Paul67 Flag 15 Apr 19 9.21pm

Originally posted by monkey

We need a worst ever penalty thread.

Actually maybe not, Puncheon v spurs, close thread

John Pemberton v Brighton
Zohar v Saints

 

vic rouse Flag basingstoke 15 Apr 19 9.43pm

Originally posted by Superwag

For Me - Ronnie Allen in the 60's. Best Penalty taker I've ever seen, but Luka comes very close.

I remember Ronnie Allen scoring a penalty against Mansfield in the cup in the last minutes to equalise . We lost replay 7-2

 

edskan Flag 15 Apr 19 9.55pm

As someone mentioned before - Dean Gordon.Loved watching that guy play and his penalties were always slammed in.

 

RyWa Flag Beckenham 16 Apr 19 10.25am

Originally posted by trapperjohn

It may be my memory playing tricks, but didn't AJ miss one in a televised game v Charlton in the Premier. The same game where we lost to a last minute breakaway goal and (I think) Danny Granville went AWOL

You're correct, Dennis Rommedahl scored the winner. I remember the disappointment.
It appears Wiki needs updating on that front.

 

Pigglelet Flag Deepest Darkest Sussex 16 Apr 19 3.59pm

I had every confidence Dean Gordon would score whenever he stepped up to take a penalty. If there hadn't been a net, I think the ball would still be travelling now.

I can only remember seeing Ronnie Allen take a penalty just once for us and it's the only time I have ever witnessed a missed penalty being cheered by supporters of the same side as the penalty taker. Ronnie blazed the ball over the bar and the crowd erupted. Well I suppose we were already beating Torquay 7-2 at the time.

 


"Better to keep your mouth shut and appear stupid than to open it and remove all doubt."
Mark Twain.

Page 2 of 2 << First< 1 2

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Penalty takers - Who is our best ever?