You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Sensible write up on Roy and our season
November 16 2026 6.11am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Sensible write up on Roy and our season


Page 3 of 3 << First< 1 2 3
Cucking Funt Flag Clapham on the Back 12 Apr 19 7.24pm

Originally posted by NEILLO

That truly is a sensible write up and as such probably won't resonate with some on here

I feel the ' home ' pain same as everyone else. I'm a season ticket holder and travel a fair distance to get to Selhurst Park. It hasn't been much fun this season.

A bit more composure in front of goal and we would have had a few more points.

But you have to look at the bigger picture. We have a very good away record that has underpinned our league position.

Agreed. I have absolutely no patience with people calling for his head. He's a quality manager and we're very fortunate to have him.

The naysayers can, frankly, shampoo my crotch.

 


Wife beating may be socially acceptable in Sheffield, but it is a different matter in Cheltenham

NEILLO Flag Shoreham-by-Sea 12 Apr 19 7.25pm

Originally posted by leejaneagles

The hilarious thing is, people asking if there's a middle ground between Roy and Pardew, we already with the extremely underrated Sam Allardyce.

It just shows how much the media can influence fan opinion because we watched with our own eyes, an organised defensive team (like Roy's), with direct effective attacking (Pardew) whilst also getting a tune out of Benteke and being really dangerous from set-pieces.

We just get revisionist history that Sam is boring and just plays long ball and is only suitable for keeping a team in the Premier League. Probably because he is Northern and English.

Big Sam is the best Manager we have ever had and unfortunately, he knows his limitations and knows what he needs in the Transfer Market to be a success and we were too afraid to back him.

I'd have him back in a heart-beat but the Board would have to give him money to finish his vision. He simply would not fail to get us into Europe, if given the required (but still realistic budget). He wouldn't be far off with the Team we have assembled now.

Edited by leejaneagles (12 Apr 2019 9.01am)

That's the BFS that got drummed out of West Ham and Everton for the boring brand of football that he peddles.

As for backing him, we did. And it still wasn't enough.

How do you know that he would only require a '' realistic budget '' And how much would that be then ?Look at how much he paid for Schlupp - are you going to tell me that's been value for money ?

I always thought of him as a money grabbing ego maniac. That's not unique in football I know but he's quite transparent about it.

 


Old, Ungifted and White

Cucking Funt Flag Clapham on the Back 12 Apr 19 7.33pm

Originally posted by NEILLO

That's the BFS that got drummed out of West Ham and Everton for the boring brand of football that he peddles.

As for backing him, we did. And it still wasn't enough.

How do you know that he would only require a '' realistic budget '' And how much would that be then ?Look at how much he paid for Schlupp - are you going to tell me that's been value for money ?

I always thought of him as a money grabbing ego maniac. That's not unique in football I know but he's quite transparent about it.

We stayed up. Was that not enough? Also, I think Schlupp is underrated.

I apologise for the heresy, but I think BFS did a bloody good job.

 


Wife beating may be socially acceptable in Sheffield, but it is a different matter in Cheltenham

NEILLO Flag Shoreham-by-Sea 12 Apr 19 7.44pm

Originally posted by Cucking Funt

We stayed up. Was that not enough? Also, I think Schlupp is underrated.

I apologise for the heresy, but I think BFS did a bloody good job.

My point being that we did back him in the market however the other poster that I was replying to claims that the club were too afraid to back him - hence my '' was that not enough '' remark.

Sam did a decent job while he was at Palace, that's undeniable.

As for Schlupp, yes underrated on here for sure, in fact that's an understatement. I maintain that we overpaid for him though.

Just my perception, but keeping SA happy in the transfer market would not have been easy.

 


Old, Ungifted and White

pssguy Flag 12 Apr 19 8.46pm

The hilarious thing is, people asking if there's a middle ground between Roy and Pardew,

Overall, their records are pretty similar. Av points per game Hodgson 1.24, Pardew 1.21 + a few minutes form an FA Cup win. It seems most people judge them differently based on their personality

I'm abroad as well so get to see most games and there have been some good spells for sure. Looking back on this year, assuming we finish where we are, it wont look too bad. Great win at Man City, something at Old Trafford at last and beating Spurs on way to a decent Cup run

Of course, the narrow losses to Watford and Brighton hurt especially when Hodgson is so rigid on formation and lack of substitutions

 

TomThePalaceFanatic Flag 12 Apr 19 10.20pm

Originally posted by Henry of Peckham

Of course it would ... we've seen mostly $hite live football this season. It's NOT entertaining to watch and NOT what I travel in or want to pay for. If others are content then so be it but I'm not happy.

And this is the crux of it. The majority of us pay good money to watch home games. We go to a few away games.

 

Vaibow Flag vancouver/croydon 13 Apr 19 3.08am

We played fantastic football under pulis, the turnaround from holloway was impressive, he was up there for manager of the season and just missed out.

He took the job after talking with his mate Holloway and a few others and i loved him at the helm. The players he had to work with, and let's be honest, he gave us our best ever finish!

I wanted him to do his thing, get us to be a boring mid table team and the tranfer budget would not have been what it is now, which means he would have over seen investment in the academy and else where.

Parish has shown himself to be a difficult person to work with, fair enough, his business head and ego souring the ways in which football is or has been.

Thing is, parish personally doesn't have the funds to wipe the slate clean and say, ok, 7 seasons in, we owe 45 mil, let's push on - it's, ok, we owe 45 mil, let's not increase that net year, keep treading water.

Fact is, every year the league costs more, clubs spend more, players increase, these debts if you worry about them are only going to add up.

We need to get back to a system where we have a cap on wages, scouts unearth quality, that will make a return on investment and youth is explored.

Benteke should never have been bought, Sakho was desperate measures - after 4 managers and conflicting styles, no wonder.

This is why i say let roy reboot this summer, back him and let him build a squad that suits each other and has a plan b.

 


This was once a quality forum....

cryrst Flag The garden of England 13 Apr 19 6.59am

Plan b has been available since the bench was fit.
Sadly roy doesnt even try it.
Im sure he knows a different style.
Maybe we will see it now we are basically safe.
It would be good if he had a real go for our last two home games.
Might not be too clever against city but against everton and Bournemouth.

 

braunstoneagle Flag the middle of bumf*** nowhere... 13 Apr 19 7.51am

Originally posted by KAOS


Ditto!

Not sure quite what people expect from us! I'll take another season like this, and another, and another ... etc

agreed...some people just dont understand how football works.


 


‘Football isn’t instant coffee. You have to work at it. You must grow the bean, grind it.’ Ian Holloway


braunstoneagle Flag the middle of bumf*** nowhere... 13 Apr 19 7.57am

Originally posted by ChrisGC

Couldn't load the link, but in summary of the facts, if it didn't include:

Plan A or bust.
75th minute like for like subs.
Dropped too many points against s*** teams.
Couldn't finish our dinner.
Terrible at home.
Mid-table by default.

Then it's inaccurate.

ive heard it all now.

 


‘Football isn’t instant coffee. You have to work at it. You must grow the bean, grind it.’ Ian Holloway


CB Flag 13 Apr 19 9.06am

The pros and cons of Roy and our club are pretty clear. I'd agree with the article's view and the people saying the pessimism is partly due to the home record I can't help but wonder if all that s*** about the hf move at the start I'd the season has soured everything - dunno how the majority of fans see it but while it's not really something I think about, when I do it leaves a bad taste and I just feel that has influenced our hone season. Hopefully onwards and upwards next year.

 

palace chick Flag South Croydon 13 Apr 19 9.26am

Think I agree with those that say that if our home form had replicated our away form or switched around then it would be a great season. Staying in this league is paramount getting to see the best teams / players in the world at Selhurst is amazing for this old geezer. Hodgson is a great manager for a team like us and has kept us up again. Just wish as a home fan that some of those results away had been at home? I’m sure we would all be more content with our current position in the league if that had happened? I also feel losing Sakho when we did finished our chances of a Wembley appearance? I read on here that buying him was a desperate measure? For me he is the best central defensive player we have ever had. A semi or cup final appearance plus finishing as a premier team would have been a superb season and we just missed out on this due to losing Sakho when we did in my opinion. Perhaps also losing the way we did to Brighton twice and also Watford didn’t help with our thought process?

 

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 13 Apr 19 9.30am

Originally posted by palace chick

Think I agree with those that say that if our home form had replicated our away form or switched around then it would be a great season. Staying in this league is paramount getting to see the best teams / players in the world at Selhurst is amazing for this old geezer. Hodgson is a great manager for a team like us and has kept us up again. Just wish as a home fan that some of those results away had been at home? I’m sure we would all be more content with our current position in the league if that had happened? I also feel losing Sakho when we did finished our chances of a Wembley appearance? I read on here that buying him was a desperate measure? For me he is the best central defensive player we have ever had. A semi or cup final appearance plus finishing as a premier team would have been a superb season and we just missed out on this due to losing Sakho when we did in my opinion. Perhaps also losing the way we did to Brighton twice and also Watford didn’t help with our thought process?

I agree with the general thrust of these comments.

 

Sherlock II Flag The Big Mango 13 Apr 19 10.14am

Originally posted by Vaibow

This is the situation - Parish couldn't back Roy, as he should have done this summer, to allow him to have two years doing it his way, to fully steady the ship and hand us over a mid table club..

Too many mistakes in the past are still being paid for, literally.

So, whilst Roy is doing a great job considering he is expected to finish 17th with what he has, we are not seeing the best of Roy.

This summer, i really feel we need to give Roy an extension, one year so that summer 2021 is time for a new manager to come in, with a similar vision and ethos to carry on with the club.

Last Jan, Roy was stubborn and was making statements on the pitch with players, showing that we needed signings - he asked and stated we needed up to 7 new bodies in. That never happened, not even close. There are articles out there stating this, any one reading up on us at the time will have seen this.
So, what happens, Parish lays it out to him and a year later, Roy has a different story, playing along with the poor us narrative Parish wants. It's not poor us, it's broke us.

Thing is, i don't think it's fair on Roy as we aren't seeing the best of him, which is why i feel, cash in on AWB, Meyer, spend that cash on 4 players Roy does want, built around Zaha and capable of plan b. Let Roy do his thing and i am confident we reach 40 points quicker next season and quicker again.


Good summary. In 2 seasons Roy has been able to spend just £17.5M, on Kouyate and Sorloth, and allowed to sign Meyer and Guaita on frees. Considering the chronic lack of investment I've no complaint about our relatively safe league position.

 


Originally Sherlock, the Holmesdale Online class Of 2001

bifffabazz Flag Highworth, Wiltshire 13 Apr 19 10.22am

Originally posted by YT
What a stupid article (IMHO)

Your opinion differs to mine as I think the aricle's well written and mostly accurate. But it's all about opinions so yours is as worthy as the next person.

As a ST holder and part-time away fan, I travel with my sons from Wiltshire. My average mileage for home wins is 758 per win while away victories average at 157!

I think that what I and most are feeling is a loss of balance. Yes we've won games but few have been scintillating. We've had so many chances to thrash teams at home but never once have; Newcastle, Burnley, Cardiff, Fulham, West Ham come to mind. Losses to Southampyon, Wolves and Spurs were avoidable. Most lamentable was at home to Chelsea when we didn't get out of first gear.
We have tried at home but clearly are only really capable of smash and grabs which is why we excelled at City, Leicester and Burnley. We ground out wins at Huddersfield, Newcastle and at Wolves we were the better of two poor teams.

Ultimately, as passionate and humble fans, I think we all just hope/expect to win some blue riband matches: Any of the top six plus Brighton and a significant cup result. Barring the City away game, there has not been another banner moment this season and ultimately we feel flat.


I'm certain it's not arrogance from us fans. The 'careful what you wish for' brigade miss the point. Everyone knows these are heady days when compared to our history but reality stems from where you are not where you could be, be that better or worse.

So here's to seeing a banner win or two in the final few games, a stable summer of shrewd transfer business and some good news on the Main Stand development.

Edited by bifffabazz (13 Apr 2019 10.01am)

 


Spirit of 1974

Page 3 of 3 << First< 1 2 3

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Sensible write up on Roy and our season