You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Assess the transfer window
November 16 2026 5.54am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Assess the transfer window


Page 9 of 9 << First< 5 6 7 8 9
roman eagle Flag South London 13 Aug 19 11.01pm

[Link]
Interesting piece about value in the transfer window - moneyball Palace?

 


Audentis fortuna iuvat (Virgil, 19BC)

taylors lovechild Flag 16 Aug 19 2.28pm

This opinion piece from a former member of the Palace Academy setup pretty much sums up my feelings...
[Link]

 

michaelpearce Flag grays 16 Aug 19 3.52pm

lets look at window once 8 or 9 games have been played then make comments of what they would have done,hind sight is great everyones a winner,thats why your working for 25k a year maybe 35

 

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 16 Aug 19 4.29pm

Originally posted by taylors lovechild

This opinion piece from a former member of the Palace Academy setup pretty much sums up my feelings...
[Link]

I agree with all of it, apart from:

‘How grateful those in the boardroom must be to have super Roy at the helm.

They are going to need all of his tactical nous, organisational skills and know how to navigate the way through what looks like being a tough opening half to the season, while £50m sits gaining interest in the club’s coffers.’

It doubt there will be anything sitting in a bank. Even if not all of it is used to pay off the director loans, I bet our cash flow isn’t the greatest and we’re always waiting for the next tv instalment, what with those Liverpool FC bills and our huge wage bill.

And his maths isn’t great:

‘Having known Wilf since he was a young lad within the academy, I don’t believe that any of the sums mentioned truly reflect anything like his value to Palace – who would lose £100m in the event of relegation. Add in the reported sell-on percentage inserted in the deal when he returned from a brief stay in Manchester and I am closer to £150m.’

 


COYP

Rachid Rachid Rachid Flag 16 Aug 19 9.11pm

Originally posted by Rudi Hedman

I agree with all of it, apart from:

‘How grateful those in the boardroom must be to have super Roy at the helm.

They are going to need all of his tactical nous, organisational skills and know how to navigate the way through what looks like being a tough opening half to the season, while £50m sits gaining interest in the club’s coffers.’

It doubt there will be anything sitting in a bank. Even if not all of it is used to pay off the director loans, I bet our cash flow isn’t the greatest and we’re always waiting for the next tv instalment, what with those Liverpool FC bills and our huge wage bill.

And his maths isn’t great:

‘Having known Wilf since he was a young lad within the academy, I don’t believe that any of the sums mentioned truly reflect anything like his value to Palace – who would lose £100m in the event of relegation. Add in the reported sell-on percentage inserted in the deal when he returned from a brief stay in Manchester and I am closer to £150m.’

I think the maths is bang on personally. We're not going to be able to draw a remotely adequate replacement. Market value is only ever expressed by the popular media in the context of the plastic six.

 

Gary St.Andrews Flag Kenley 17 Aug 19 7.28am

It was a failure, we didn’t strengthen where we needed to. Dougie’s excuse was “we had the money from the AWB deal, but we would have paid over the odds for another right back and striker, because it was common knowledge of the money we had in the bank”.

If that was the case why didn’t he source the buying or loaning of a right back before we sold AWB. I don’t trust the scheming Scottish t***, and if he has ideas about being the manager again I think I will go and watch Whyteleafe Football Club play on Saturdays...

 

Midlands Eagle Flag 17 Aug 19 8.04am

Originally posted by michaelpearce

lets look at window once 8 or 9 games have been played then make comments of what they would have done,hind sight is great everyones a winner,thats why your working for 25k a year maybe 35

Or maybe even considerably more

 

Gary St.Andrews Flag Kenley 17 Aug 19 8.52am

Our squad will have to adapt and players will have to service 2 different positions or maybe 3? I think Cheke has played midfield, centre back and right back in the past for West Ham.

It is incredible when you look at that Man City team and we beat them last season. They had 263 million pounds worth of players sitting on the bench alone for the opening game last weekend.

 

Booted Eagle Flag Bristol 17 Aug 19 9.39am

Originally posted by Gary St.Andrews

It was a failure, we didn’t strengthen where we needed to. Dougie’s excuse was “we had the money from the AWB deal, but we would have paid over the odds for another right back and striker, because it was common knowledge of the money we had in the bank”.

If that was the case why didn’t he source the buying or loaning of a right back before we sold AWB. I don’t trust the scheming Scottish t***, and if he has ideas about being the manager again I think I will go and watch Whyteleafe Football Club play on Saturdays...

Judging by the transfer window and the club are all ready paying him this could well be on the cards as the cheap option if the wheels fall off this season

 


“ [T]here are known knowns; there are things we know that we know.There are known unknowns; that is to say there are things that, we now know we don't know.But there are also unknown unknowns – there are things we do not know we don't know. ”
—United States Secretary of Defense, Donald Rumsfeld

dreamwaverider Flag London 17 Aug 19 10.08am

Unforgivable that we didn't pick up a striker. No direct cover whatsoever for our wing backs. Terrible performance in the window as always by the current runners.

 

CPFCwetrust Flag Maidstone 17 Aug 19 12.15pm

Not a massive fan of DF...but taking his name out the equation, it is fair point that prices have been over inflated because of the windfall. Forwards which may be setting Russia alight but with zero premier league experience being touted for 30 mil as one of many examples... Not disagreeing that we need a forward, RB wise I think Ward will do a good job this season.

I'd rather they thought about getting in the right players rather than spending 50 mil in desperation and getting utter dross.

Edited by CPFCwetrust (17 Aug 2019 12.16pm)

 

pieceofcake Flag Cell 36,HMP Albany 18 Aug 19 6.17pm

I don't think I need to assess the transfer window.

I'll let the performance of 11+ millionaires let you know all you need to know following todays cowardly display.

 

Bangell Flag Oxford 18 Aug 19 6.41pm

Time to drastically re-think the tactics. I hope Roy is thinking to use Camarasa as a link between the midfield and the forwards.

 

iheartcpfc Flag SE25 18 Aug 19 6.53pm

it's a yikes/10 from me

 

craig321 Flag West Wickham 18 Aug 19 7.24pm

Had a sensible window Dougie is right. Why get bent ova for average players coz everyone nows we've got cash on the hip?

That Norich lad is rubbish and ppl on hear wanted us too pay 15 mil for him more like 15p!
23 mil for a unknown Russian? No thanks.

Were b ok, plenty of rubbish in the division sell Zaha in Jan and then rebuild next summer with new manager

 

iheartcpfc Flag SE25 18 Aug 19 9.22pm

Yes, why bother replacing key players

 

Osvaldo Flag Epsom 18 Aug 19 9.48pm

Roy says, no magic wand, no quick fix.
What were the club doing during the summer?
They knew we had a monumental problem up front and did nothing to fix it.
Disgusting display today against SU, they couldn't hit a barn door even it was open!
Why are we not playing some of the new recruits they can't do much worse than this lot!
The quick fix was buying a couple of half decent forwards. Wickham is far better than Benteke up front.
I am appalled by the display today, you pay good money and you get rubbish!
Please CPFC do something and do it quickly otherwise this season will be our last in the Premier!
I wish I had a magic wand that worked!

 

Page 9 of 9 << First< 5 6 7 8 9

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Assess the transfer window