This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
Palace vs Colchester (Carabao Cup) Match Thread
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
Rachid Rachid Rachid 28 Aug 19 8.56pm |
|
Originally posted by PatrickA
The question needs to be asked why Hodgson continues to b persist with playing players out of position. The squad has gaps but he should still be able to field a balanced team. Skilful players such as Riedewald and Meyer are set up to fail. Hodgson has one way of playing which is sometimes successful but is very dull and he never takes responsibility .
Meyer was played in advanced position against league two opponents last night and was poor yet again. Riedewald isn't a centre back and is hopeless in the air defensively. We have much better in midfield and looked lacking in energy and mobility. Not sure how he would fit into any premier league team.
Edited by Rachid Rachid Rachid (28 Aug 2019 8.56pm)
|
deetee 28 Aug 19 9.00pm |
|
|
Massively disappointing performance - something to prove Vs Villa on Saturday big time!!
|
PatrickA London 28 Aug 19 9.14pm |
|
|
I agree that neither Riedewald or Meyer have impressed under Hodgson and it may be that neither will be able to flourish in the physical nature of the premier league. However, I would question whether they are used as anything other than stopgaps by Hodgson who has a fundamental distrust of flair. Most of Meyer’s appearances have been in a left sided midfield role that he is clearly unsuited to. There seems to be a mindset amongst many fans that we’d be lost without Hodgson’s organisational skills (I.e playing with 9 behind the ball even at home). There is more to football than being set up to defend, and while this may be a valid approach against the top 6 I would like to see us be a bit more adventurous and creative while still remaining solid. I don’t believe that this is an unreasonable aspiration.
|
Rachid Rachid Rachid 28 Aug 19 9.39pm |
|
Originally posted by PatrickA
I agree that neither Riedewald or Meyer have impressed under Hodgson and it may be that neither will be able to flourish in the physical nature of the premier league. However, I would question whether they are used as anything other than stopgaps by Hodgson who has a fundamental distrust of flair. Most of Meyer’s appearances have been in a left sided midfield role that he is clearly unsuited to. There seems to be a mindset amongst many fans that we’d be lost without Hodgson’s organisational skills (I.e playing with 9 behind the ball even at home). There is more to football than being set up to defend, and while this may be a valid approach against the top 6 I would like to see us be a bit more adventurous and creative while still remaining solid. I don’t believe that this is an unreasonable aspiration.
I don't agree with the distrust of flair. We played the best football since we've been back in the Premier League when he had RLC and Cabaye available to him.
Last night against a league two team underlined just how poor our movement is in the final third and how few are able to shrug off or lose a player.
|
Nicholas91 The Democratic Republic of Kent 28 Aug 19 10.19pm |
|
|
Colchester home to Tottenham in next round, have to say I’m happy to have that off the schedule.
Now Zaha's got a bit of green grass ahead of him here... and finds Ambrose... not a bad effort!!!!
|
palace chick South Croydon 28 Aug 19 10.27pm |
|
|
Colchester v Spurs - great 3rd round for them. They deserve that after last nights performance against us.
|
sprites Auckland 28 Aug 19 10.44pm |
|
Originally posted by Rachid Rachid Rachid
Meyer was played in advanced position against league two opponents last night and was poor yet again. Riedewald isn't a centre back and is hopeless in the air defensively. We have much better in midfield and looked lacking in energy and mobility. Not sure how he would fit into any premier league team.
Edited by Rachid Rachid Rachid (28 Aug 2019 8.56pm)
To be honest I'm not sure how you've seen enough of him to make that assessment? Poor guy aint had much opportunity.
|
Rachid Rachid Rachid 28 Aug 19 10.52pm |
|
Originally posted by sprites
To be honest I'm not sure how you've seen enough of him to make that assessment? Poor guy aint had much opportunity.
He's had a few including his debut against Huddersfield where he was badly exposed at centre back.
He played ok centre mid against City at home in the 0-0 but other than that has really struggled and was playing at the back when we got pumped 6-2 by Barnet pre-season IIRC
|
Tickled pink Cornwall 28 Aug 19 10.53pm |
|
Originally posted by palace chick
Colchester v Spurs - great 3rd round for them. They deserve that after last nights performance against us.
I doubt very much Spurs will play a pretty tune either away at Colchester with their second string.
|
Kant exeter 28 Aug 19 11.25pm |
|
Originally posted by Rachid Rachid Rachid
Meyer was played in advanced position against league two opponents last night and was poor yet again. Riedewald isn't a centre back and is hopeless in the air defensively. We have much better in midfield and looked lacking in energy and mobility. Not sure how he would fit into any premier league team.
Edited by Rachid Rachid Rachid (28 Aug 2019 8.56pm)
The voice of reason. Regrettably Meyer, despite his abundant talent, simply isn’t up to it. Nor is Riedewald. Massively disappointing.
|
Daddyorc Atlantic Highlands, NJ 24 Sep 19 9.48pm |
|
|
Killed Spurs chances in the same way as ours.
Gotta hand it to them!
|
kennybrowns leftfoot Reigate 24 Sep 19 11.58pm |
|
Originally posted by Daddyorc
Killed Spurs chances in the same way as ours.
Gotta hand it to them!
Have to admit tonight’s result has pleased me immensely... My business partner is a huge Spurs fan and gave me no end of crap when Colchester knocked us out!!
I’ve sent him a few texts already but strangely enough he hasn’t replied!!... Oh well I speak to him tomorrow!!
Don't waste your time with jealousy. Sometimes your ahead, sometimes your behind, the race is long. But in the end it's only with yourself!!
|
samprior Hamburg 25 Sep 19 6.46am |
|
|
Fair play to Colchester. Well done. Couple of nights that their fans will never forget.
|
cryrst The garden of England 25 Sep 19 10.47am |
|
|
Couple of nights for sure. I still glory in our 4-3 As the song goes That was unforgettable.
|
samprior Hamburg 25 Sep 19 10.09pm |
|
|
After tonights round of results we certainly weren't the only prem side to be embarrassed with an early cup exit this year!
A shame Rochdale couldn't quite do it against United. The mighty Aaron Wilbraham and Calvin Andrew amongst their penalty scorers though.
|