You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Arsenal v Crystal Palace match thread
November 16 2026 5.54am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Arsenal v Crystal Palace match thread


Page 8 of 8 << First< 4 5 6 7 8
Glazier#1 Flag 28 Oct 19 7.53pm

Absolutely.

Kouyate has impressed me when pushing up and around the box this season but the way he turned his back on that shot is unforgivable.

I can take mistakes, everybody makes them, but turning your back on the ball?!
Sorry but anyone who is guilty of that doesn't deserve to wear a Palace shirt.

And he lost his man, allowing a header
for Guendouzi to score.

Originally posted by tonymikejoe

Brilliant point, great comeback etc...but still small details we should improve on.

Watching the goals this morning our Number 8 absolutely bottles closing down their first goal and makes himself as small as possible because he's scared of being hit by a football.

I fully support JA's reaction to being subbed and the joker that replaced him CB, gave Arsenal the ball, which led to a corner and then passed it to them again in our box from which they hit the net.

Fortunately it was ruled out, but come on CB as well as not scoring you have become a 12th man for the opposition.

Edited by Glazier#1 (28 Oct 2019 8.36pm)

 

pompeyeagle Flag Relocated to Shropshire 28 Oct 19 10.19pm

Kouyate has impressed me when pushing up and around the box this season but the way he turned his back on that shot is unforgivable.


I know Max Meyer isn’t everyone’s favourite player but I’d put him in the team ahead of Kouyate every time. At least he has a bit of invention in him and certainly has a goal threat which is more than Kouyate does.

Edited by Glazier#1 (28 Oct 2019 8.36pm)

Edited by pompeyeagle (28 Oct 2019 10.20pm)

 

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 28 Oct 19 11.35pm

Originally posted by pompeyeagle

Kouyate has impressed me when pushing up and around the box this season but the way he turned his back on that shot is unforgivable.


I know Max Meyer isn’t everyone’s favourite player but I’d put him in the team ahead of Kouyate every time. At least he has a bit of invention in him and certainly has a goal threat which is more than Kouyate does.


Edited by Glazier#1 (28 Oct 2019 8.36pm)

Edited by pompeyeagle (28 Oct 2019 10.20pm)

With respect, Meyer has scored 10 goals in his last 114 appearances.
Kouyate over Meyer for me.Meyer just doesn't fit into the Hodgson team organisation.


Edited by Willo (29 Oct 2019 12.16am)

 

kennybrowns leftfoot Flag Reigate 28 Oct 19 11.50pm

Originally posted by YT

I read the comments about the late 'rugby tackle' on Wilf and thought "yeah, yeah". Now I've seen it on MOTD2, I'm incredulous how that wasn't a straight red card. Absolutely outrageous big club bias.

And fair play to Wrighty for calling out Atkinson for his keeness to book Wilf for simulation, without any regard to the facts!

I’m not saying I agree with just a yellow but Wilf still had a long way to go to bear down on goal.. it was probably this factor that made Atkinson decide on only a yellow.

 


Don't waste your time with jealousy. Sometimes your ahead, sometimes your behind, the race is long. But in the end it's only with yourself!!

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 29 Oct 19 12.21am

Originally posted by kennybrowns leftfoot

I’m not saying I agree with just a yellow but Wilf still had a long way to go to bear down on goal.. it was probably this factor that made Atkinson decide on only a yellow.

The distance between the offence and the goal is one of the factors taken into consideration.It was a yellow card offence for me.

 

KLEAGLE2 Flag Shirley 29 Oct 19 1.14am

Wilf would have definitely passed the halfway with the ball first but this is irrelevant.
How can a 'rugby tackle' not be a straight red in a game of football including the last seconds of a game. 'Taking one for the team' usually means a sly trip, tug on shirt or blatent blocking. Players may as well 'rugby tackle' instead if only a yellow.
Straight red all day long.

The distance between the offence and the goal is one of the factors taken into consideration.It was a yellow card offence for me.

 

YT Flag Oxford 29 Oct 19 7.43am

Originally posted by KLEAGLE2

Wilf would have definitely passed the halfway with the ball first but this is irrelevant.
How can a 'rugby tackle' not be a straight red in a game of football including the last seconds of a game. 'Taking one for the team' usually means a sly trip, tug on shirt or blatent blocking. Players may as well 'rugby tackle' instead if only a yellow.
Straight red all day long.

This sums it up in a nutshell. The referee made a mistake. End of.

 


Palace since 19 August 1972. Palace 1 (Tony Taylor) Liverpool 1 (Emlyn Hughes)

jeeagles Flag 29 Oct 19 7.55am

Originally posted by KLEAGLE2

Wilf would have definitely passed the halfway with the ball first but this is irrelevant.
How can a 'rugby tackle' not be a straight red in a game of football including the last seconds of a game. 'Taking one for the team' usually means a sly trip, tug on shirt or blatent blocking. Players may as well 'rugby tackle' instead if only a yellow.
Straight red all day long.

The distance between the offence and the goal is one of the factors taken into consideration.It was a yellow card offence for me.

Arms looked round the neck to me. Definitely a red.

Refereeing in Football is rubbish.

 

eagleman13 Flag On The Road To Hell & Alicante 29 Oct 19 8.17am

Originally posted by KLEAGLE2

Wilf would have definitely passed the halfway with the ball first but this is irrelevant.
How can a 'rugby tackle' not be a straight red in a game of football including the last seconds of a game. 'Taking one for the team' usually means a sly trip, tug on shirt or blatent blocking. Players may as well 'rugby tackle' instead if only a yellow.
Straight red all day long.

The distance between the offence and the goal is one of the factors taken into consideration.It was a yellow card offence for me.

Within the 'Laws' of the game it IS only a caution(yellow), it falls under the heading of 'Professional Foul' As I have highlighted in red. Used to be called 'Ungentlemanly Conduct'

Wilf was in his own half, there was no indication he would have been denied a 'clear goalscoring opportunity'. Guendouzi could've tripped/pulled Wilfs shirt or even blocked his run, it still would've ended up in a caution. As much as we hate it, MA acted within the laws of the game & correctly administered the caution.

Anyhoo, happy with the point. COYP

Edited by eagleman13 (29 Oct 2019 8.19am)

 


This operation, will make the 'Charge Of The Light Brigade' seem like a simple military exercise.

NEILLO Flag Shoreham-by-Sea 29 Oct 19 9.54am

Originally posted by eagleman13

Within the 'Laws' of the game it IS only a caution(yellow), it falls under the heading of 'Professional Foul' As I have highlighted in red. Used to be called 'Ungentlemanly Conduct'

Wilf was in his own half, there was no indication he would have been denied a 'clear goalscoring opportunity'. Guendouzi could've tripped/pulled Wilfs shirt or even blocked his run, it still would've ended up in a caution. As much as we hate it, MA acted within the laws of the game & correctly administered the caution.

Anyhoo, happy with the point. COYP

Edited by eagleman13 (29 Oct 2019 8.19am)

The laws were applied correctly but it was definitely a case of the punishment not fitting the crime.

 


Old, Ungifted and White

dreamwaverider Flag London 29 Oct 19 9.56am

Originally posted by eagleman13

Within the 'Laws' of the game it IS only a caution(yellow), it falls under the heading of 'Professional Foul' As I have highlighted in red. Used to be called 'Ungentlemanly Conduct'

Wilf was in his own half, there was no indication he would have been denied a 'clear goalscoring opportunity'. Guendouzi could've tripped/pulled Wilfs shirt or even blocked his run, it still would've ended up in a caution. As much as we hate it, MA acted within the laws of the game & correctly administered the caution.

Anyhoo, happy with the point. COYP

Edited by eagleman13 (29 Oct 2019 8.19am)

Cant argue with that, but as a paying fan, the rules need looking at otherwise we may as well go to Twickenham to watch rugby. This kind of obvious violation to deny the fans the excitement of Zaha running half the pitch towards goal should be outlawed and given the heaviest penalty, a red card and automatic 3 game ban. That should stop it happening and give us back our moneys worth.

 

ex hibitionist Flag Hastings 29 Oct 19 11.26am

rot, rosso, rouge, rojo, cervena, goch ... alles jour longo per Ich

 

eagleman13 Flag On The Road To Hell & Alicante 29 Oct 19 11.44am

Originally posted by NEILLO

The laws were applied correctly but it was definitely a case of the punishment not fitting the crime.

Agreed.

 


This operation, will make the 'Charge Of The Light Brigade' seem like a simple military exercise.

eagleman13 Flag On The Road To Hell & Alicante 29 Oct 19 11.46am

Originally posted by dreamwaverider

Cant argue with that, but as a paying fan, the rules need looking at otherwise we may as well go to Twickenham to watch rugby. This kind of obvious violation to deny the fans the excitement of Zaha running half the pitch towards goal should be outlawed and given the heaviest penalty, a red card and automatic 3 game ban. That should stop it happening and give us back our moneys worth.

Whilst I do agree with you, since when has the FA/EPL & even clubs themselves ever cared what we the fans think or say?

 


This operation, will make the 'Charge Of The Light Brigade' seem like a simple military exercise.

Sansbup Flag Norfolk 29 Oct 19 11.47am

Rugby tackle = yellow, but effective in stopping Wilf.
Anything stronger would have been violent conduct and got a red.

 

Daddyorc Flag Atlantic Highlands, NJ 29 Oct 19 12.59pm

Originally posted by Sansbup

Rugby tackle = yellow, but effective in stopping Wilf.
Anything stronger would have been violent conduct and got a red.

Agreed, as much as I don't like it, the tackle had almost no chance of causing injury, whereas if he would have slid and taken out his legs, it could have. I'm okay with the yellow, although it does annoy me.

 

eagleman13 Flag On The Road To Hell & Alicante 29 Oct 19 1.32pm

Originally posted by Sansbup

Rugby tackle = yellow, but effective in stopping Wilf.
Anything stronger would have been violent conduct and got a red.

I do wonder, how many players having seen this, will try & copy it this w/e up n down the country?

 


This operation, will make the 'Charge Of The Light Brigade' seem like a simple military exercise.

Phil’s Barber Flag Crowborough 29 Oct 19 8.57pm

Originally posted by eagleman13

I do wonder, how many players having seen this, will try & copy it this w/e up n down the country?


Exactly and why not?!

The rugby tackle is far more effective and more likely to be successful in its aim than a conventional tackle and is far less likely to incur a red card, so it will definitely not have gone unnoticed by players and coaches alike. A sad state of affairs indeed.

 

Tickled pink Flag Cornwall 29 Oct 19 9.51pm

Originally posted by Phil’s Barber


Exactly and why not?!

The rugby tackle is far more effective and more likely to be successful in its aim than a conventional tackle and is far less likely to incur a red card, so it will definitely not have gone unnoticed by players and coaches alike. A sad state of affairs indeed.

Zaha would have been free to run at keeper so should have been red.

 

PALACE FOR EVER Flag London 30 Oct 19 10.10pm

This is never a red card for denying a goal as Wilf is not moving toward's the goal.


 


The pyramid to beat all pyramids!!

[Link]

Find out what team is in which division, eg which division is Coppull United in?

Page 8 of 8 << First< 4 5 6 7 8

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Arsenal v Crystal Palace match thread