You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > So VAR so Good
November 16 2026 5.54am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

So VAR so Good


Page 2 of 2 << First< 1 2
pstrutt Flag Busselton, WA 30 Oct 19 2.56pm

Originally posted by CrazyBadger

aha! the old I'm right and your wrong argument, I was wondering where it had gone!

I guess mine is on the wane as well, as I certainly don't think that fear is a factor in decision making for Referees. Fear of what?

Certainly the Refs are temporarily out of the spotlight, as it not the 'Refs Fault' anymore - it's VARs. But that should not make them void of the same criticism. in fact, If I were a ref it would likely increase my nervousness if VAR kept overriding my decisions - It'd means that the mistake was mine. Id want to make sure that When VAR was called it would back me up, not highlight my mistake.

Referees have a tremendously difficult job to do correctly, which due to the application of rules - in Particular the 'subjective' ones and the invention of the Slow motion replay - means that the scrutiny is based on ten times the amount of data that a Referee has at the time of the decision.

Are they trying to apply the rules to the best of their ability? Yes.
Can they be affected by Media and other 'off the pitch' factors? Yes. They're only human
Does fear come in to it? I don't think so. You're basically calling them out as a cheat..

I am not calling them out as a cheats - quite the opposite. I am saying that no referee has the ability to switch off the media merry-go-round that purports wrong doing by any said referee. Therefore, with their decisions under scrutiny that places a fear in their decision making. VAR enables them to have a more level playing field because they have support.

I disagree that VAR makes it harder. They are supported. If there is anything about VAR for refs to fear is that they are becoming the new factory workers and 'their job is being laid off in favour of computers.'

I was agreeing with Willo (spit) that big club bias is not there, but big club / media frenzy fear is, which makes a difficult job that much harder.

Your (Willo's) age doesn't come into it, I shouldn't have said that. Fear is there, without doubt.

Edited by pstrutt (30 Oct 2019 2.58pm)

 


So I manage a Workshop which provides a safe learning environment for blokes struggling with PTSD and other mental health issues. Being a Palace fan isn't listed yet.

CrazyBadger Flag Ware 30 Oct 19 4.18pm

Originally posted by pstrutt

I am not calling them out as a cheats - quite the opposite. I am saying that no referee has the ability to switch off the media merry-go-round that purports wrong doing by any said referee. Therefore, with their decisions under scrutiny that places a fear in their decision making. VAR enables them to have a more level playing field because they have support.

I disagree that VAR makes it harder. They are supported. If there is anything about VAR for refs to fear is that they are becoming the new factory workers and 'their job is being laid off in favour of computers.'

I was agreeing with Willo (spit) that big club bias is not there, but big club / media frenzy fear is, which makes a difficult job that much harder.

Your (Willo's) age doesn't come into it, I shouldn't have said that. Fear is there, without doubt.

Edited by pstrutt (30 Oct 2019 2.58pm)

Ok, See I agree with That, but would not call it fear. What your describing I would call media/society influence. It's a similiar thing that makes Supermarkets put stuff they want to sell at The end of the aisles; we're being subconsciously controlled by the Marketing departments(or Media in this case). We don't buy these things because we'd be judged poorly if we don't?!
Referees may be influenced by such things (but they shouldn't be), but I don't think they are motivated by Fear.

As for making VAR harder, I guess that's down to the Ego of the Ref. I bet Mike Dean Hates it!! haha


 


"It was a Team effort, I guess it took all players working together to lose this one"

crvenaeagle Flag 31 Oct 19 9.47am

Had VAR not been in place this season we would be in twelfth place with 12 points.
Wolves would be in our current sixth place.

 

braunstoneagle Flag the middle of bumf*** nowhere... 31 Oct 19 6.58pm

i was in favour of VAR coming in, because it is essentially a leveller for a club like palace when it comes to big club bias.

i have never got wound up about dubious decisions as i believe they even themselves out over the space of a season, but this means ut defo evens out over the space of the season.

what i am suprised at is VAR didnt look at the rugby tackle on wilf at the weekend as that was a potential red card offence.

 


‘Football isn’t instant coffee. You have to work at it. You must grow the bean, grind it.’ Ian Holloway


cryrst Flag The garden of England 31 Oct 19 7.27pm

Originally posted by braunstoneagle

i was in favour of VAR coming in, because it is essentially a leveller for a club like palace when it comes to big club bias.

i have never got wound up about dubious decisions as i believe they even themselves out over the space of a season, but this means ut defo evens out over the space of the season.

what i am suprised at is VAR didnt look at the rugby tackle on wilf at the weekend as that was a potential red card offence.

Whilst I think red would be my choice as well I believe it wasnt 'violent' and was in his own half.
If hed have chopped him I think it would be a red.
No guarantee wilf scores either so just seeing the rage of gunners compensates for a single point and a great comeback TBH.

 

kennybrowns leftfoot Flag Reigate 31 Oct 19 8.18pm

I think there needs to be some adjustments even with VAR... Some of the offsides given in games this season have been, in my opinion ridiculous.. in some cases you’re talking the toe of a boot offside... Is that really offside??
Think there needs to be a rule about a certain distance or maybe a certain amount of body part offside.. in my opinion the toe of a boot is ridiculous..

I couldn’t understand Brighton’s penalty against Everton at the weekend either (not just saying this because it’s Brighton!)
Keane never took his eyes off the ball and didn’t even look at Conneley... There has to be some intent to foul for a penalty surely... What happened was a complete accident for me.

 


Don't waste your time with jealousy. Sometimes your ahead, sometimes your behind, the race is long. But in the end it's only with yourself!!

crvenaeagle Flag 31 Oct 19 8.38pm

Originally posted by kennybrowns leftfoot

I think there needs to be some adjustments even with VAR... Some of the offsides given in games this season have been, in my opinion ridiculous.. in some cases you’re talking the toe of a boot offside... Is that really offside??
Think there needs to be a rule about a certain distance or maybe a certain amount of body part offside.. in my opinion the toe of a boot is ridiculous..

I couldn’t understand Brighton’s penalty against Everton at the weekend either (not just saying this because it’s Brighton!)
Keane never took his eyes off the ball and didn’t even look at Conneley... There has to be some intent to foul for a penalty surely... What happened was a complete accident for me.

Agreed on both counts. I envisage future kits being made out of lycra to avoid flapping shorts putting the attacker in an offside position. If they're going to use VAR for offside decisions, or in fact any decision, then the rules need to be rewritten. You can't use a new judging system without writing new rules for it.

As for the Brighton penalty. Haha! If we're going to consider stepping on the toes of other players a foul then we should indeed rewrite the whole game, akin to something like touch rugby.

 

braunstoneagle Flag the middle of bumf*** nowhere... 31 Oct 19 9.00pm

Originally posted by cryrst

Whilst I think red would be my choice as well I believe it wasnt 'violent' and was in his own half.
If hed have chopped him I think it would be a red.
No guarantee wilf scores either so just seeing the rage of gunners compensates for a single point and a great comeback TBH.

i think, regardless of the type of tackle it was...it was stopping a goalscoring opportunity...no player would have caught wilf up and he was effectively through on goal, red didn't even give us the attack and blew as soon as the free kick was played. but he would have allowed that passage of play to continue given the circumstances.

i will also take the point given it boiled the piss of gooners so much!!!

 


‘Football isn’t instant coffee. You have to work at it. You must grow the bean, grind it.’ Ian Holloway


Page 2 of 2 << First< 1 2

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > So VAR so Good