You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > The summer in perspective
November 16 2026 5.54am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

The summer in perspective


nead1 Flag 05 Dec 19 10.11pm

Despite all the concerns of so many fans, it seems to be transpiring that the summer was not so bad after all. Luka signed a new 4 year contract, Ayew has proved to be a snip at £2.5m - the reputed fee, Cahill has proved excellent and McCarthy looks a good addition as well. Granted the Camarasa situation has seemed odd and the third goalkeeper has not been required as yet.
Additionally, it appears there is a lot of flexibility within the current squad and both Kelly and Jeff S look perfectly competent full backs - maybe not so surprising as the latter was first choice under Allardyce in that position I seem to recall and Kelly played a lot for Liverpool in that position.
Perhaps of more importance is the obvious togetherness within the squad and you never hear of any discontent getting into the public domain. Roy's man management skills appear to be of the highest order and securing him for a further period seems incredibly important.
Also, of course, Zaha must in retrospect be delighted he didn't join Everton despite the transfer request and the £50m for Wan Bissaka after one season in the PL seems like a sound deal.
All in all, it suggests some steady judgement behind the scenes - whether that be Parish, Freedman or Hodgson or perhaps a combination of all three.
Certainly, another striker option would be helpful in January but even that is not looking as dire as predicted.
Happy times!

 

the.universal 05 Dec 19 10.31pm

Well said. Generally when we spend less it works out better.

 


Vive le Roy!

Law Flag Beckenham 06 Dec 19 12.46am

I agree with many of the points, BUT… let’s be honest. Had we lost Wilf at the end of the window, it’s unlikely that we’d be doing quite as well as we are; and there’s an argument that Everton wouldn’t be as low as they find themselves currently.

Speculation like this means very little. I even argue that Wilf is the kind of player that may well have kept Silva in his job (FTR, I’ve been of the opinion that the man is a fraud after is Hull stint; he most probably would have added nothing to his development. Definitely less than Roy).

We were very lucky to keep hold of Wilf in the summer, but he’ll probably be off this summer coming. He will STILL go with my blessing.

Edited by Law (06 Dec 2019 12.47am)

 

Casual Flag Orpington 06 Dec 19 5.36am

Originally posted by Law

I agree with many of the points, BUT… let’s be honest. Had we lost Wilf at the end of the window, it’s unlikely that we’d be doing quite as well as we are; and there’s an argument that Everton wouldn’t be as low as they find themselves currently.

Speculation like this means very little. I even argue that Wilf is the kind of player that may well have kept Silva in his job (FTR, I’ve been of the opinion that the man is a fraud after is Hull stint; he most probably would have added nothing to his development. Definitely less than Roy).

We were very lucky to keep hold of Wilf in the summer, but he’ll probably be off this summer coming. He will STILL go with my blessing.

Edited by Law (06 Dec 2019 12.47am)

Yep agree, think that Zahas 2 goals in 15 games would have had Everton in a champions league place and Silva would probably be in line for the Real Madrid job

 

Casual Flag Orpington 06 Dec 19 5.40am

Originally posted by nead1

Despite all the concerns of so many fans, it seems to be transpiring that the summer was not so bad after all. Luka signed a new 4 year contract, Ayew has proved to be a snip at £2.5m - the reputed fee, Cahill has proved excellent and McCarthy looks a good addition as well. Granted the Camarasa situation has seemed odd and the third goalkeeper has not been required as yet.
Additionally, it appears there is a lot of flexibility within the current squad and both Kelly and Jeff S look perfectly competent full backs - maybe not so surprising as the latter was first choice under Allardyce in that position I seem to recall and Kelly played a lot for Liverpool in that position.
Perhaps of more importance is the obvious togetherness within the squad and you never hear of any discontent getting into the public domain. Roy's man management skills appear to be of the highest order and securing him for a further period seems incredibly important.
Also, of course, Zaha must in retrospect be delighted he didn't join Everton despite the transfer request and the £50m for Wan Bissaka after one season in the PL seems like a sound deal.
All in all, it suggests some steady judgement behind the scenes - whether that be Parish, Freedman or Hodgson or perhaps a combination of all three.
Certainly, another striker option would be helpful in January but even that is not looking as dire as predicted.
Happy times!

Kelly must be the most underrated player at the club.
Most people’s centre back starters at the beginning of the season would have been Tompkins and Sakho , best this season has been Cahill and Kelly.
Not sure that McCarthy has been any better than average she. He was played though.

 

Badger11 Flag Beckenham 06 Dec 19 7.39am

Originally posted by Casual

Kelly must be the most underrated player at the club.
Most people’s centre back starters at the beginning of the season would have been Tompkins and Sakho , best this season has been Cahill and Kelly.
Not sure that McCarthy has been any better than average she. He was played though.

McCarthy was out injured a long time before we signed him, I doubt we will see the best of him until next season. Still he has done enough for me to be a good squad player with potential if he is now over his injuries. apparently the Everton fans liked him.

 


One more point

Painter Flag Croydon 06 Dec 19 9.16am

Originally posted by Law

I agree with many of the points, BUT… let’s be honest. Had we lost Wilf at the end of the window, it’s unlikely that we’d be doing quite as well as we are; and there’s an argument that Everton wouldn’t be as low as they find themselves currently.

Speculation like this means very little. I even argue that Wilf is the kind of player that may well have kept Silva in his job (FTR, I’ve been of the opinion that the man is a fraud after is Hull stint; he most probably would have added nothing to his development. Definitely less than Roy).

We were very lucky to keep hold of Wilf in the summer, but he’ll probably be off this summer coming. He will STILL go with my blessing.

Edited by Law (06 Dec 2019 12.47am)

Well Zaha didn’t go , so irrelevant point. He is going every window, but never does, getting a bit tedious.

Everton have good players, but an overrated crap manager, Zaha would make no difference at all.

 

Nicholas91 Flag The Democratic Republic of Kent 06 Dec 19 9.23am

Originally posted by Casual

Yep agree, think that Zahas 2 goals in 15 games would have had Everton in a champions league place and Silva would probably be in line for the Real Madrid job

Totally agree and did make me lol.

I think a lot is owed to Roy for this seasons successes. I'm very happy to hold my hands up and say I was very pessimistic, that said there's still surely a lot of frustration and panic to come.

I think the point is that we are all very happy things seem to be working out, and yes Cahill was a great move, we kept Wilf and Ayew scored a few etc. But still, we have no genuine cover at full back, with players covering out of position, no back up wingers and although I am full of praise for Ayew, a genuine goalscorer up front.

My stance would be that in perspective, the summer was still sh!t however I am delighted things seem to be going our way this season, for whatever reason!


 


Now Zaha's got a bit of green grass ahead of him here... and finds Ambrose... not a bad effort!!!!

Painter Flag Croydon 06 Dec 19 9.44am

Originally posted by Nicholas91

Totally agree and did make me lol.

I think a lot is owed to Roy for this seasons successes. I'm very happy to hold my hands up and say I was very pessimistic, that said there's still surely a lot of frustration and panic to come.

I think the point is that we are all very happy things seem to be working out, and yes Cahill was a great move, we kept Wilf and Ayew scored a few etc. But still, we have no genuine cover at full back, with players covering out of position, no back up wingers and although I am full of praise for Ayew, a genuine goalscorer up front.

My stance would be that in perspective, the summer was still sh!t however I am delighted things seem to be going our way this season, for whatever reason!


What is not genuine about a full back that played in that position for Liverpool and England with another that played full back in Premier title winning team?

 

CrazyBadger Flag Ware 06 Dec 19 11.26am

I must say I'm still pessimistic.

- and the window, however you dress it up was still bad.
Selling AWB, and not buying anyone of note was terrible, especially when we were screaming out for a forward, and a CAM. Cahill's turned out to be a good bit of business, and Ayews exceeded everyones expectations(2nd Season Syndrome?) but that's about it. We need so much more.

But whenever I'm pessimistic we do well, and when I'm optimistic, we're sh*t, so what do I know!

 


"It was a Team effort, I guess it took all players working together to lose this one"

Bangell Flag Oxford 06 Dec 19 11.32am

I think the injuries now are showing exactly why we needed two new full-backs. And if something happens to Ayew and we're forced to play Benteke up front...

 

nead1 Flag 06 Dec 19 11.35am

I agree with Painter's analysis re the full backs. Equally, like most of us I expect Zaha to go at some stage but his interests and Palace are much more likely to be met by Chelsea or someone similar.I would guess, on reflection, that Zaha recognises that Palace acted in his and their best interests and that handing in a transfer request was a major error of judgement.Also, to think Arsenal paid £72m for Pepe and offered less than half of that for Zaha. no wonder they are in such a mess!

 

Nicholas91 Flag The Democratic Republic of Kent 06 Dec 19 12.19pm

Originally posted by Painter

What is not genuine about a full back that played in that position for Liverpool and England with another that played full back in Premier title winning team?

Kelly played in that position yes and briefly for England which didn't last long for obvious reasons. As Danny Butterfield played up front for us once and Phil Jagielka has played in goal before. Schlupp wasn't first choice for Leicester and started life out as a striker. Both would now identify with different positions as their default.

That is what I meant by not genuine. I think both have played very well this season but Joel Ward and PVA are first choice full backs with many often arguing we need upgrades on them in the first instance.

I think Kelly and Schlupp have both been fantastic this season and can of course do a job there, but not genuine full backs.

 


Now Zaha's got a bit of green grass ahead of him here... and finds Ambrose... not a bad effort!!!!

Painter Flag Croydon 06 Dec 19 1.09pm

Originally posted by Nicholas91

Kelly played in that position yes and briefly for England which didn't last long for obvious reasons. As Danny Butterfield played up front for us once and Phil Jagielka has played in goal before. Schlupp wasn't first choice for Leicester and started life out as a striker. Both would now identify with different positions as their default.

That is what I meant by not genuine. I think both have played very well this season but Joel Ward and PVA are first choice full backs with many often arguing we need upgrades on them in the first instance.

I think Kelly and Schlupp have both been fantastic this season and can of course do a job there, but not genuine full backs.

The point is we have cover at fullbacks by very able players, who give everything for the team. Both have played in that position at the highest level, so to say we have no cover at fullback is nonsense.
It may now not be their preferred position, but better than an overpriced player brought in, that doesn’t fit into Roy’s work ethic.

 

pstrutt Flag Busselton, WA 06 Dec 19 1.24pm

Originally posted by Nicholas91

Kelly played in that position yes and briefly for England which didn't last long for obvious reasons. As Danny Butterfield played up front for us once and Phil Jagielka has played in goal before. Schlupp wasn't first choice for Leicester and started life out as a striker. Both would now identify with different positions as their default.

Apparently Roy Hodgson wasn't always a manager!


...Oh, hang on now, I've checked and yes he was always a manager.

 


So I manage a Workshop which provides a safe learning environment for blokes struggling with PTSD and other mental health issues. Being a Palace fan isn't listed yet.

jason7 Flag croydon 06 Dec 19 1.50pm

Originally posted by pstrutt

Apparently Roy Hodgson wasn't always a manager!


...Oh, hang on now, I've checked and yes he was always a manager.

Actually he used to be a pe teacher at monks hill school.

 

Nicholas91 Flag The Democratic Republic of Kent 06 Dec 19 7.26pm

Originally posted by Painter

The point is we have cover at fullbacks by very able players, who give everything for the team. Both have played in that position at the highest level, so to say we have no cover at fullback is nonsense.
It may now not be their preferred position, but better than an overpriced player brought in, that doesn’t fit into Roy’s work ethic.

I didn’t make any of the points you seem to be arguing.

I’m very happy with how things are going and think Kelly and schlupp have been excellent, and are both more than able to fill in at fullback, and for that matter I thought Kouyate was our MotM on Tuesday and looks very comfortable at CB.

My original statement was just a slight grumble at a lack of transfer activity which included both full back positions, which Roy has also stated a few times. I was then making the point that neither Kelly nor Schlupp would give their position at full back if you asked them, Kelly is a CB and given Schlupps recent scoring form I would personally like to see him utilised further up the pitch - that is what I meant by ‘not genuine’ full backs, apologies for the mass offence and apparent confusion this seems to have caused.

 


Now Zaha's got a bit of green grass ahead of him here... and finds Ambrose... not a bad effort!!!!

PatrickA Flag London 06 Dec 19 7.41pm

I would be concerned if our recent transfer activity was viewed with rose tinted glasses because of 2 consecutive wins.
It could lead to complacency and not addressing the issues in January.
Today we’re linked with 28 year old Borini who is out of contract at the end of the season.
A decent player but probably only good for at best six goals a season.
Another older experienced player in line with our recent purchases - and probably on high wages.
I’d like us to look at younger players from the Championship with something to prove (e.g Watkins, Bowen).

 

Nicholas91 Flag The Democratic Republic of Kent 06 Dec 19 8.15pm

Originally posted by PatrickA

I would be concerned if our recent transfer activity was viewed with rose tinted glasses because of 2 consecutive wins.
It could lead to complacency and not addressing the issues in January.
Today we’re linked with 28 year old Borini who is out of contract at the end of the season.
A decent player but probably only good for at best six goals a season.
Another older experienced player in line with our recent purchases - and probably on high wages.
I’d like us to look at younger players from the Championship with something to prove (e.g Watkins, Bowen).

Yes, thank you, I’d agree.

We are doing very well atm but I’d suggest that is probably in spite of our transfer activity not because of it.

I think Bowen will have more preferable suitors to us and I fear the same for Watkins, they would also command big fees these days but very much agree with your thinking.

 


Now Zaha's got a bit of green grass ahead of him here... and finds Ambrose... not a bad effort!!!!


You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > The summer in perspective